TORONTO -
- (i4i v Microsoft - Case Summary)
On August 11, 2009, in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Tyler Division, the Honorable Leonard Davis issued a Final Judgment in i4i v. Microsoft Corporation. The Final Judgment included an award in excess of $290 million USD in favor of i4i and a Permanent Injunction against Defendant Microsoft selling its flagship Word product in the USA unless it removes custom XML which infringes i4i’s U.S. Patent No. 5,787,449.
Subsequent to the Final Judgment, Microsoft filed an Emergency Motion that claimed it may have to stop selling not only Word but also its entire software suite of programs called Office in the USA until it could redesign its products to remove custom XML. It further stated that its distributors, which include retailers such as Best Buy and OEM’s such as HP and Dell, face the imminent possibility of a massive disruption in their sales. Each of Dell and HP also claimed a heavy burden if the injunction proceeded and filed amicus briefs with the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals granted a stay of the injunction pending appeal. In addition, the Court of Appeals scheduled the appeal to be heard in Washington D.C. on September 23, 2009.
Loudon Owen, Chairman of i4i, says, “We firmly believe that the U. S. District Court made the right decision on the merits of the case, and we are confident that i4i will prevail on the appeal by Defendant Microsoft. This is a vital case for inventors and entrepreneurial companies who, like i4i, are damaged by the willful infringement of their patents by competitors; particularly competitors as large and powerful as Microsoft.”
Mr. Owen continues, “We do not have the gargantuan financial resources of Microsoft, but i4i has the protection of fairness under the U.S. justice system. Microsoft is not above the law. It cannot privately expropriate i4i’s patented invention.”
i4i is a global technology company headquartered in Toronto, Canada. i4i LP is a licensing entity, affiliated with i4i Inc., which owns patent #5,787,449 issued by the United States Patent Office in 1998.
For more information, selected court documents in i4i v. Microsoft can be found on www.i4ilp.com or other public record websites.
For further information, please contact:
Loudon Owen - lowen@mcleanwatson.com or +1-416-307-3271
Melony Jamieson - melony@getitdone.ca or +1-416-518-6355
Source: McLean Watson and i4i
For further information, please contact: Loudon Owen - lowen at mcleanwatson.com or, +1-416-307-3271; Melony Jamieson - melony at getitdone.ca or +1-416-518-6355
Related Press Releases
Occlutech Receives Positive Ruling in German Proceeding Initiated by AGA MedicalSeptember 22nd, 2009 JENA, Germany - Occlutech GmbH, the leading European developer of products for septal closure, today announced that the district court of Frankfurt, Germany reversed an earlier court injunction obtained by AGA Medical against Occlutech's sales and marketing activities relating to the newly launched Figulla Flex ranges of ASD and PFO occluders. The district court of Frankfurt reversed its earlier decision that was based on a request by AGA Medical, relying only on information provided by AGA Medical.
i4i Case Heard in Court of AppealsSeptember 22nd, 2009 WASHINGTON - Today, in the United States Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, in Washington D.C., a panel of three judges heard the appeal of i4i v. Microsoft. This was an appeal from the August 11, 2009 Final Judgment that ruled in favor of i4i and found that Microsoft had willfully infringed i4i's U.S.
Occlutech and IZASA Obtains Favourable Ruling in Proceeding Initiated by AGA Medical in SpainSeptember 20th, 2009 ZURICH - Occlutech AG, the leading European developer of products for septal closure, today announced that, together with its partner in Spain IZASA SA, it defeated a request for an injunction against sales and marketing activities in Spain, launched at the Commercial Court I of Barcelona, Spain by its U.S. competitor AGA Medical.
AnyBizSoft Announces Release of the First PDF to Word Converter for Office 2010 and Windows 7September 12th, 2009 AnyBizSoft Studio, a blooming company focused on PDF solution, today announced the release of new PDF to Word Converter that can convert PDF to Word 2010 and operate smoothly in Windows 7 OS. So far it is the first PDF to Word Converter which supports both Word 2010 and Windows 7 worldwide.
US Court Grants Finjan a Permanent Injunction for Infringing Technology Found in the WebWasher and TSP Products and Enhances the Jury's Damage AwardAugust 19th, 2009 SAN-JOSE, California -
- Injunctions and Extended Damages Were Granted on McAfee's Webwasher and TSP Products
Finjan Inc., a leader in secure web gateway products and the provider of unified web security solutions for the enterprise market, is proud to announce that the US District Court in Delaware has ruled in favor of Finjan, affirming a jury verdict against Secure Computing Corporation currently owned by McAfee. The Court issued a permanent injunction against the sale of the WebWasher and TSP Products for infringement of Finjan's U.S.
Trademark Infringement Case of Nude Skincare and Stella Nude by Stella McCartney Ltd.August 19th, 2009 LONDON - There has been significant public interest and media coverage around this case over the last few days. For legal reasons, Nude has been unable to comment or make any statement until today.
Easily Use Office 2007 and Office 2010 Technical Preview with Addintools' Classic MenuAugust 3rd, 2009 HAINAN, China -
Addintools Technology Ltd. is delighted to announce the releases of Classic Menu for Office 2007 v4.50 and Classic Menu and Toolbar for Microsoft Office 2010 Technical Preview.
New Online Courses Cut Education Costs for Patent ProfessionalsMay 18th, 2009 ALEXANDRIA, Virginia - Patent Resources Group (PRG), the nation's leading patent educator, has launched a Video on Demand program that allows legal and business professionals to access patent courses and earn continuing legal education (CLE) or continuing professional development (CPD) credits online. (Logo: www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20090413/PRGLOGO )
Video on Demand customers can take PRG's high-quality patent education courses at their own pace from any computer with Internet access, while eliminating the travel and hotel expenses associated with attending a classroom course.
Addintools Launches Classic Menu for MS Office 2007 V4.01aMay 6th, 2009 HAINAN, China - Addintools Technology LTD is delighted to announce the release of Classic Menu for MS Office 2007 V4.01a, an updated version for the popular tool that bridges the two different interfaces of Office 2003 and 2007. Classic Menu brings back the classic menus and toolbars of Office 2003 to help users enjoy the benefits of Office 2007 under a familiar environment.
Microsoft and TomTom Settle Patent Infringement CasesMarch 29th, 2009 REDMOND, Washington - Microsoft Corp. and TomTom N.V.
Related News
Texas judge OKs patent judgment against Microsoft, tells it to stop selling Word in 60 daysAugust 13th, 2009 Microsoft ordered to pay $290M in patent rulingSEATTLE — A federal judge in Texas has ordered Microsoft Corp. to stop selling some versions of its Word software in the U.S.
Dish to pay TiVo $200 mln for violating injunction on technology that rewinds, pauses live TVSeptember 4th, 2009 Dish to pay TiVo $200 mln for injunction violationA federal judge on Friday ordered Dish Network Corp. and sister firm EchoStar Corp.
RI judge tosses $388 million patent infringement verdict against MicrosoftSeptember 30th, 2009 RI judge tosses patent verdict against MicrosoftSEATTLE — A federal judge in Rhode Island threw out a $388 million patent infringement jury verdict against Microsoft Corp., the latest move in a six-year legal skirmish. In April, a jury found that the world's largest software maker had infringed on a patent owned by Uniloc Inc.
Serverside Group granted second patent on core card customization architectureMay 21st, 2009 LONDON - Global technology provider, Serverside Group, announced that the Indian Patent Office has granted a patent directed to its core card customization architecture, thus establishing an international trend. Since the Indian filing was part of an international strategy, the grant of the Indian patent, which follows the grant of a European Patent, not only enhances Serverside's competitive position in India but indicates the likely outcome in other territories yet to come to grant.
Judge rules Tessera miniaturization patents valid but says they weren't infringedAugust 29th, 2009 Judge: Tessera patents valid but not infringedSAN JOSE, Calif. — The U.S.
Judge rejects plaintiff's lawsuit against cup maker in first-of-its-kind patent caseJuly 8th, 2009 Judge closes door on legal quirk in patent lawALEXANDRIA, Va. — A federal judge has turned away a first-of-its-kind lawsuit filed by an attorney seeking to exploit a quirk in federal patent law that had been dormant for more than a century.
Judge dismisses Guardian Media's patent-infringement claim against NintendoJune 12th, 2009 Judge tosses patent claim against NintendoREDMOND, Wash. — A judge has dismissed a patent-infringement lawsuit against Nintendo over the company's Wii video game machine.
Microsoft to invest in Gujarat's education sectorJanuary 14th, 2009 AHMEDABAD - Global software giant Microsoft will invest in training teachers in Gujarat and enhance the use of IT in the education sector. Microsoft India Pvt Ltd signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the Gujarat government at the Vibrant Gujarat Global Investors' Summit this week.
Supreme Court to decide whether to limit 'business method' patentsJune 1st, 2009 Court to decide whether to limit patentsWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has decided to take on an appeal that could decide whether someone can get a patent for a complex business idea. The high court on Monday decided to hear an appeal from Bernard Bilski and Rand Warsaw, who attempted to patent a method for managing weather-related risk having to do with trading in commodities.
Google, Microsoft chairmen share laugh together as battle for tech supremacy intensifiesJuly 9th, 2009 Google, Microsoft chairmen share laugh togetherSUN VALLEY, Idaho — The escalating tension between Google and Microsoft didn't prevent the companies' chairmen from sharing a moment of levity Thursday at an exclusive media conference in the Idaho mountains. As he headed out the door to lunch, Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates paused to consider a question about Google's plans to develop a computer operating system that will rival Microsoft's Windows.