CAMBRIDGE, England - Data released today by Cambridge-based broadband comparison website Broadband Genie has revealed the depressing truth that the average consumer is getting less than half of the advertised ‘up to’ speed they think they are paying for. The data also shows long term broadband subscribers are even confused about what package they are on. As ISPs upgrade customers to faster services, while advertising all kinds of other new packages, the message simply isn’t getting across.
Broadband Genie analysed data on the top eight UK broadband suppliers across thousands of speed tests carried out by visitors to its website www.broadbandgenie.co.uk in the first quarter of 2009. The average ratio of download rate received, compared to the customer’s expected ‘up to’ speed claimed by providers, was just 45.8 per cent.
But the ISPs topping the results - Virgin Media (58.8 per cent average) and TalkTalk (52.6 per cent) - had artificially high scores because customers thinking they were on 1Mb and 2Mb packages clearly had better connections. For example, Virgin Media customers who thought they were on 1Mb deals returned an average test speed of 2.9Mb - almost three times what they thought their line was capable of. *
A Virgin Media spokesperson said: “We have been upgrading our cable customers’ speeds regularly to improve the service we provide. For example in 2007 we upgraded 10Mb customers to a super-fast 20Mb, and in 2008 we upgraded our 4Mb customers to 10Mb, both for free. This year we’re upgrading our 2Mb customers to 10Mb, so our entire customer base might actually find themselves on a speed much higher than they originally subscribed to.”
TalkTalk was also quick to defend its position. A spokesperson commented: “We were the first internet service provider to let our customers know what speeds they can receive before they join us, and worked closely with Ofcom to ensure this practice has now became industry standard. We are extending our network to more exchanges, supplying broadband to a huge number of customers in rural areas and optimising line speed for each and every one of them.”
Broadband Genie editor Chris Marling said: “No matter what spin the ISPs put on these results, the underlying truths are there for all to see. Consumers are confused about their broadband connections, and even when they do get a handle on what they should expect, they are only getting half of the ‘up to’ speeds that lead the advertising campaigns.
“This technology is improving all the time - the internet landscape is almost unrecognisable from a decade ago. But the speed of change does not excuse ISPs from the duty they have to their customers. Consumers deserve a more transparent, honest and informative broadband marketplace so they can make correct, informed decisions.”
Virgin Media and O2 recorded the best results on higher speed packages, with customers claiming to be on 20Mb lines recording average speeds above 8Mb. Both ISPs also recorded the best recorded averages on their 8Mb lines, at 3.8Mb and 3.5Mb respectively: 48 and 44 per cent of the advertised ‘up to’ speed.
Commenting on the results, an O2 spokesperson said: “O2’s home broadband packages use the ADSL2+ network which allows for a faster download speed of up to 24Mb. As per our terms and conditions, the speeds customers will receive will vary depending on the distance from the telephone exchange. Speeds may also be slow at peak times and in certain areas with any service provider.
“When connecting a customer we give an initial estimate of the speed they can expect - we then monitor this to make sure it is accurate. If the speed is considerably lower than expected, we will contact the customer to let them know and may also move them to a different package if it’s better suited for them.”
As was the case in tests released by Ofcom and Samknows earlier in the year, Broadband Genie’s overall results on 2Mb lines were generally much closer to the advertised speeds than those on faster lines. The worst test results came from BT, AOL and Orange, with each recording overall actual/expected Mb ratios of around 33 per cent. Even the 2Mb packages from these three providers returned results of around just 60 per cent, with speed tests averaging around 1.15Mb.
The Virgin Media spokesperson concluded: “We’re continuing to invest heavily in our network to ensure customers get the best broadband experience possible. The newly increased capacity of our next generation network is providing benefits to customers on lower speeds - for example, recent independent evidence, from Epitiro demonstrates our ‘up to 10Mb’ fibre optic broadband delivers customers more than double the throughput of similar ‘up to 8Mb’ packages from BT, Tiscali and Orange.” **
The Broadband Genie speed test accurately measures an internet user’s line speed, for both uploads and downloads. It also detects the user’s ISP, but allows the consumer to insert the connection speed they think they should be receiving.
NOTES TO EDITORS
*Virgin Media testers thinking they were on 2Mb connections returned an average download/expected ratio of 109 per cent. Talk Talk customers thinking they were on 2Mb deals recorded an average of 106 per cent.
**According to Virgin Media, Epitiro ISP-I performance stats indicate average throughput performance on comparable services in Q4 2008 was: Virgin Media 10Mb (6.9Mb) vs ‘up to 8Mb’ on BT (3.4Mb), Tiscali (2.5Mb) and Orange (2.1Mb).
1. Visitors to the Broadband Genie website carried out more than 16,000 speed tests in Q1 2009.
2. Broadband Genie is the UK’s leading independent broadband and mobile broadband comparison website, providing consumers with an unbiased source of information on broadband prices and contracts and allowing them to compare broadband providers in an independent environment. Broadband Genie was launched in March 2004 as the first dedicated consumer comparison site for broadband, while Mobile Broadband Genie was the first independent mobile broadband comparison site, launched in October 2007. Both sites are among the most popular sites in their respective fields, and regularly feature in the national press. www.broadbandgenie.co.uk / mobile.broadbandgenie.co.uk
3. All queries and interview requests should be directed to Chris Marling at Broadband Genie:t +44(0)844-415 5531 / f +44(0)871-6618553 / m +44(0)7908-327303 / chris.marling@genieventures.co.uk
Source: Broadband Genie
All queries and interview requests should be directed to Chris Marling at Broadband Genie:t +44(0)844-415 5531 / f +44(0)871-6618553 / m +44(0)7908-327303 / chris.marling at genieventures.co.uk
Related Press Releases
O2 Scoops Top Prize in PC Advisor Broadband Survey, Sponsored by Broadband GenieSeptember 9th, 2009 CAMBRIDGE, England - The 2009 PC Advisor Broadband Survey results have been announced, with O2 taking the 'Best Buy' award despite strong challenges from 'Recommended' internet service providers BE Broadband, PlusNet and Zen Internet. The survey, sponsored by www.broadbandgenie.co.uk and now in its fifth year, asked people to provide feedback on the reliability of their connections, the download speeds they achieve and the customer service they receive.
Alcatel-Lucent Pioneers Live 10G GPON-based LTE BackhaulSeptember 6th, 2009 PARIS, BROADBAND WORLD FORUM EUROPE -
- Next-generation Wireline and Wireless Access Technologies Converge Seamlessly
During this year's Broadband World Forum Europe, Alcatel-Lucent (Euronext Paris and NYSE: ALU) not only shows that it masters next-generation wireline and wireless access. The company also highlights that Long Term Evolution (LTE) and next-generation passive optical networking (PON) technologies converge seamlessly for a smooth delivery of the most demanding, high-speed broadband services.
More Cuts at Lloyds Mean More Confusion and UncertaintyAugust 24th, 2009 LONDON - Unite union has sharply criticised Lloyds Banking Group's (LBG) confused management style today (25th August) as the bank announces over 200 job losses in its general insurance arm, bringing the total job cuts at the bank to 7,500 this year. Only last week LBG decided to abandon the closure of the Cheltenham and Gloucester branches bringing reprieve for 900 staff.
Downloading One TV Show Abroad Could Cost More Than Your Whole HolidayJune 30th, 2009 CAMBRIDGE, England - According to independent consumer website Broadband Genie, downloading one television show via mobile broadband while abroad on holiday could cost more than the rest of the trip combined. As the summer holidays get into full swing, Broadband Genie is keen to remind travellers the cost of using mobile broadband dongles abroad can be incredibly expensive.
DealTaker.com Crosses the Pond to Bring Texas-sized Savings to British ConsumersJune 29th, 2009 PLANO, Texas -
Having saved millions of dollars for American consumers over the past 5 years, DealTaker.com now features deals and vouchers for UK shoppers at DealTaker.com/UK. Consumers visiting the site will have instant access to savings at popular sites like Mothercare, Homebase, Argos, House of Fraser, Laura Ashley and QVC, as well as a host of travel deals from Emirates, Last Minute, Thomson Holidays, Sandals, Beaches, Marriott and more.
Broadband Genie Road Trip Awards Winners UnveiledMay 27th, 2009 CAMBRIDGE, England - The results are now available for the first Mobile Broadband Genie Road Trip Awards. The exercise directly pitted dongles provided by six mobile broadband suppliers (O2, Orange, 3, T-mobile, Virgin Media and Vodafone) against each other on a 350-mile rail journey over two days.
AdvanDx Launches Fast, 90 Minutes Protocol for All CE-IVD Marked PNA FISH(R) Tests in EuropeApril 27th, 2009 WOBURN, Massachusetts and VEDBAEK, Denmark - Pathogen Identification Results in 90 Minutes Direct from Positive Blood Cultures
- Faster Results to Help Clinicians Improve Antibiotic Selection and Outcomes for Critical Infections
AdvanDx today announced that it has launched a fast, 90 minutes protocol for all CE-IVD marked PNA FISH(R) tests in Europe. The fast protocol reduces the PNA FISH turn-around time from the original 2.5 hours to 90 minutes by reducing PNA probe hybridization time from 90 minutes to 30 minutes.
Norwegian Air Shuttle to Provide High-Speed Broadband for its Passengers and CrewApril 26th, 2009 FORNEBU, Norway - Airline will begin outfitting its fleet with in-flight Wi-Fi from Row 44 later this year
Norwegian Air Shuttle ASA, Europe's fifth largest low-cost carrier, announced today that it is equipping its entire fleet with high-speed in-flight broadband. The airline will use a satellite-based broadband solution from Row 44.
Cheapflights Launches Australia /New Zealand Website cheapflights.com.auApril 13th, 2009 LONDON - Cheapflights Ltd, the pioneer and an international leader in independent online flight price comparison announces the launch of its newest travel search website serving Australia and New Zealand, www.cheapflights.com.au. The website is based on the popular search box navigation format that quickly provides users with deals from providers of flights, or packages of flights plus hotel deals by date.
Dreampark Replaces IPTV Middleware Competitor at Ireland's Magnet NetworksMarch 23rd, 2009 NORRKOPING, Sweden - Dreampark, one of the leading IPTV middleware providers on the European
market, today announced its first customer in Ireland as Irish IPTV and ISP
provider Magnet Networks has upgraded their existing middleware solution to
Dreampark's Dreamgallery(TM), further strengthening the company's position as
the leading IPTV middleware provider in Europe. Magnet Networks, the largest provider of broadband and IPTV services on
the Irish market, has chosen to change their current middleware solution to
Dreamgallery after an extensive selection process that tested its speed,
flexibility and user-friendliness.
Related News
Tata Teleservices promises India's fastest broadband serviceJune 17th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Tata Teleservices has teamed up with ECI Telecom, an Israel-based networking infrastructure solutions provider, to offer India's fastest broadband access network till date, the Indian telecom operator said Wednesday. In a statement, Tata Teleservices said ECI's network solution would support a connectivity speed of up to 18 megabit per second (Mbps), a unit to measure broadband speed.
Mont. Public Service Commission leaders say Qwest should reconsider federal broadband moneyAugust 20th, 2009 Mont.: Qwest asked to reconsider Internet grantHELENA, Mont. — Public Service Commission leaders are asking Qwest to take another look at a federal grant aimed at bringing broadband Internet to underserved areas like rural Montana.
Internet service providers asked to ensure minimum bandwidthMarch 3rd, 2009 NEW DELHI - India's telecom watchdog Monday asked internet service providers (ISPs) and telecom operators to ensure availability of the minimum required bandwidth in their networks. 'Operators must ensure availability of the minimum required bandwidth in their network as per the maximum contention ratio suggested by the regulator for different services based on the number of customers,' the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) said in its guidelines issued for the service providers.
Airtel pioneers 16 Mbps broadband in IndiaApril 6th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Bharti Airtel has pioneered 16 Mbps broadband - the fastest wireline broadband on DSL in the country. This service, powered by Airtel's Carrier Ethernet Network, will be initially available in the cities of Delhi NCR, Chennai and Bangalore with phased roll-out to additional cities of Hyderabad, Pune, Mumbai and Kolkata.
Survey: The old and poor sign up for broadband, narrowing gap with young and affluentJune 17th, 2009 Survey: The old and poor sign up for broadbandNEW YORK — Some groups that have lagged in signing up for high-speed Internet service, like the elderly, the poor and rural residents, have started to gain on those who have had a head start, according to a new survey. Those conclusions come as the government is set to decide how to spend $7.2 billion in stimulus money on expanding the availability of broadband.
Many line for broadband stimulus funds: $28B requested vs. $4B availableAugust 27th, 2009 Many interested in broadband stimulus fundsWASHINGTON — "Cash for clunkers" isn't the only economic stimulus program to attract a lot of takers. The U.S. government says it has received requests for a total of $28 billion from groups that want to expand high-speed Internet service in the country.
Biden in W.Pa. to discuss broadband Internet access for rural areas as part of stimulus planJuly 1st, 2009 Biden in W.Pa. to discuss rural broadband accessERIE, Pa.
UTStarcom to support BSNL's IPTV roll-outMay 26th, 2009 NEW DELHI - UTStarcom, a US-based network solutions provider, Tuesday said it will support state-run telecom major Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd (BSNL) to roll out IPTV (Internet protocol television) services. UTStarcom's existing contract with the Indian firm has been extended for this purpose, the company said in a statement.
Calling cards offer flexibility to consumers: ScindiaFebruary 2nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Minister of State for Communications and IT Jyotiraditya Scindia Tuesday said the government has accepted the calling card proposal, which would offer flexibility to consumers to choose their carrier for making long-distance calls. 'The calling cards for both STD and ISD calls have been accepted, making it flexible for consumers to switch their carriers for long distance calls,' Scindia said at a conference here.
Biden announces program to expand broadband Internet access for rural areas at Pa. stopJuly 1st, 2009 Biden announces rural broadband funding in Pa.WATTSBURG, Pa. — Vice President Joe Biden outlined a $4.7 billion loan and grant program Wednesday to develop the infrastructure needed to deliver broadband, or high-speed, Internet access to areas that are underserved or without access.
