CASTRES, France - The case opposing the French Competition Authority and Pierre Fabre Dermocosmetics (PFDC) came before the Paris Court of Appeal on Thursday, 29 October 2009.
It may be remembered that in this case, the “Conseil de la Concurrence” (now called Autorité de la Concurrence) [Competition Council , now called the Competition Authority] condemned Pierre Fabre Dermocosmetics to pay a fine of EUR17,000 and ordered the company to allow its products to be sold over the Internet.
Pierre Fabre DC appealed against this “Conseil de la Concurrence” Decision on 29 October 2008 and obtained a stay of execution of the injunctions pronounced by the Council from the Paris Court of Appeal in February 2009.
Pierre Fabre maintains that only the physical presence of a graduate pharmacist guarantees that consumers receive the best possible advice from a qualified professional.
In its decision, the Paris Court of Appeal recognized that PFDC had serious grounds for its rationale and decided:
- To put a preliminary question to the CJCE (the Court of Justice of the European Communities) so that this court determines if, by law, “the general and absolute prohibition to sell contract products on the Internet to final users imposed on approved distributors within the framework of a selective distribution network constitutes a hardcore restriction of competition by object”, - To defer ruling pending the decision of the CJCE, - To confirm the stay of execution of the injunctions pronounced by the Competition Authority against PFDC.
In concrete terms, this means that the Internet sales of Pierre Fabre dermocosmetics continue to be prohibited pending the opinion of the CJCE and a final decision by the Paris Court of Appeal.
Pierre Fabre remains opposed to internet sales and to all remote sales of their dermo-cosmetics as this cannot guarantee that customers receive individually tailored advice from qualified professionals, it encourages counterfeiting, and prevents the complete traceability of products which is the only guarantee of good cosmetic vigilance.
Since 2006, Pierre Fabre DermoCosmetics is the only company in its sector of activity that has refused to give into the competition Authority’s injunction, in order to defend the quality and professionalism of the distribution network of its products.
About the Pierre Fabre Group:
The Pierre Fabre group is the second largest independent French pharmaceutical company with a 2008 turnover of EUR1.75 billion. It employs nearly 10,000 people.
The activities of the Pierre Fabre Group are divided between Drugs (sales of EUR552 million ), OTC (EUR352 million ), and dermo-cosmetic (EUR829 million).
The “dermo-cosmetics” activity is splited into 2 divisions: dermatology and dermopharmacy, which safely offers to pharmacists, prescribers and users, effective products which are perfectly well tolerated by the skin, hair and nails, containing mainly active substances of natural origin.
- Dermatology with the brands: Avène, Ducray / A-Derma, Pierre Fabre Dermatologie and Glytone. - Dermopharmacy with the brands: Klorane, Galénic / Elancyl and René Furterer.
The “family health”(OTC) branch, which is divided into 2 departments: Pierre Fabre Santé and Naturactive, provides pharmacists and patients with a wide range of medicines, Over the Counter’s products (OTC) and self medication products for everyday health and well-being. Each of these departments focuses on specialized therapeutic fields: Pierre Fabre Health on immunity, smoking cessation, woman’s health, movement disorders, infectious diseases, skin care, and oral and dental health. Naturactive, a department dedicated to herbal therapy, develops medicines and food supplements containing plants and substances of natural origin.
Source: Laboratoires Pierre Fabre
Contacts presse : Nathalie Barondiot, +33-01-49-10-83-80 / +33-06-18-00-35-59, nathalie.barondiot at pierre-fabre.com; Catherine de Rohan Chabot, +33-01-53-53-20-51 / +33-06-89-45-87-95, catherine.de.rohan.chabot at pierre-fabre.com
Related Press Releases
Occlutech Receives Positive Ruling in German Proceeding Initiated by AGA MedicalSeptember 22nd, 2009 JENA, Germany - Occlutech GmbH, the leading European developer of products for septal closure, today announced that the district court of Frankfurt, Germany reversed an earlier court injunction obtained by AGA Medical against Occlutech's sales and marketing activities relating to the newly launched Figulla Flex ranges of ASD and PFO occluders. The district court of Frankfurt reversed its earlier decision that was based on a request by AGA Medical, relying only on information provided by AGA Medical.
i4i Case Heard in Court of AppealsSeptember 22nd, 2009 WASHINGTON - Today, in the United States Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, in Washington D.C., a panel of three judges heard the appeal of i4i v. Microsoft. This was an appeal from the August 11, 2009 Final Judgment that ruled in favor of i4i and found that Microsoft had willfully infringed i4i's U.S.
Occlutech and IZASA Obtains Favourable Ruling in Proceeding Initiated by AGA Medical in SpainSeptember 20th, 2009 ZURICH - Occlutech AG, the leading European developer of products for septal closure, today announced that, together with its partner in Spain IZASA SA, it defeated a request for an injunction against sales and marketing activities in Spain, launched at the Commercial Court I of Barcelona, Spain by its U.S. competitor AGA Medical.
Microsoft Willfully Infringed i4i Patent Permanent Injunction Against WordSeptember 14th, 2009 TORONTO -
- (i4i v Microsoft - Case Summary)
On August 11, 2009, in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Tyler Division, the Honorable Leonard Davis issued a Final Judgment in i4i v. Microsoft Corporation.
Northern Rock Appeal Process ContinuesJuly 27th, 2009 LONDON - Although the appeal by SRM Global and other former shareholders in the Northern Rock case was today rejected by the Court of Appeal, the litigation continues and may ultimately go to Europe. The shareholders were appealing against the Divisional Court's decision to refuse a judicial review of the fairness of the Government's scheme to compensate former shareholders.
Johal Dairies Refused Permission to Appeal in Case Against J.N.DairiesJuly 20th, 2009 WOLVERHAMPTON, England -
- In relation to the High Court case of J.N.Dairies Ltd (Claimant) v Johal Dairies Ltd (1st Defendant) & Gurbir Singh (2nd Defendant)
- Judgment Laid Down on 12 June 2009, 10:30am at the Royal Courts of Justice (High Court), London
Johal Dairies were yesterday refused permission to appeal against a High Court judgment which found that they had paid an illegal immigrant GBP40,000 to steal confidential customer information from rival dairy supplier J.N.Dairies. Today's hearing followed an extraordinary 8 day trial at Birmingham Civil Justice Centre between 10 and 19 March 2009 at which the Court found that Wolverhampton and Leicester based Johal Dairies had paid an illegal immigrant, Gurbir Singh, GBP40,000 to steal information from J.N.Dairies that contained the volumes, addresses and prices that it was supplying its customers, which Johal Dairies then used in price negotiations to unlawfully win J.N.Dairies' business.
Court in Rotterdam Confirms NMA FineJune 11th, 2009 NIEUWEGEIN, The Netherlands - In the appeal procedure the court in Rotterdam has confirmed the fine of 7,9 million euros for Ballast Nedam as imposed by the NMA (Netherlands Competition Authority). Subject of the appeal procedure was the amount of the fine for summary offences of the competition laws in the period 1998-2000.
Interflora's Case Against M&S Heads to EuropeJune 4th, 2009 LINCOLN, England - Interflora's court case against M&S (Case No: HC08C03440 ) is to be referred to the European Court of Justice. Interflora launched proceedings against M&S in December 2008 to stop M&S bidding on its protected 'INTERFLORA' trade mark as an AdWord on the Google search engine.
L'Oréal Welcomes the UK High Court of Justice's Guiding Comments on Measures to Prevent Trade Mark Infringement on eBay's UK PlatformMay 21st, 2009 CLICHY, France - In a decision passed today by the UK High Court of Justice, the court agreed with the view held from the outset by L'Oréal, that eBay could do more to prevent trade mark infringement and suggested 10 measures:
- filter listings before they are posted on the Site - use additional filters, including filters to detect listings of not-for-sale products and unboxed products - filter descriptions as well as titles - require sellers to disclose their names and addresses when listing items - impose additional restrictions on the volumes of high risk products, such as fragrances and cosmetics, that can be listed at any one time - be more consistent in their policies, for example regarding sales of unboxed products - adopt policies to combat types of infringement which are not presently addressed, and in particular the sale of non-European Economic Area (EEA) goods without the consent of the trade mark owners - take greater account of negative feedback (from site users) - apply sanctions more rigorously - be more rigorous in suspending accounts linked to those of users whose accounts have been suspended
The UK High Court of Justice considered that the relevant European trade mark law and the eCommerce Directive were unclear and referred nearly all the issues to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for further guidance. Since L'Oréal has maintained that eBay cannot benefit from the regime of liability for hosting providers under the eCommerce Directive, it is satisfied to note that the UK Court preferred its view before referring the matter to the ECJ.
Occlutech Obtains Favourable Ruling in Proceedings Initiated by AGA MedicalMarch 18th, 2009 JENA, Germany - Occlutech GmbH today announced that it had defeated a request for
insolvency, launched at the Amtsgericht Gera in Germany by its US competitor
AGA Medical. The request by AGA was based on wrongful assumptions about Occlutech, and
AGA announced that it had started the said request to recover damages.
Related News
Prosecutor won't appeal decision to try ex-French President Chirac in corruption scandalNovember 4th, 2009 Prosecutor won't appeal decision to try ChiracPARIS — The Paris prosecutor's office says it will not appeal a decision by an investigating magistrate to order former French President Jacques Chirac to stand trial on embezzlement charges dating back to his 1977-95 tenure as Paris mayor. The decision, announced Wednesday, means Chirac will be tried for embezzlement and breach of trust in the corruption case.
German court rejects appeal from suspected Nazi death camp guard John DemjanjukMay 6th, 2009 German court rejects Demjanjuk appealBERLIN — A Berlin court has rejected an attempt by suspected Nazi death camp guard John Demjanjuk to block his deportation from the United States. Berlin administrative court spokesman Stephan Groscurth says the court ruled Wednesday there was no case for Demjanjuk to make in Germany.
Five new high court chief justices appointedMarch 5th, 2009 NEW DELHI - President Pratibha Patil Wednesday appointed five chief justices of high courts across the country. 'The president is pleased to appoint Justice Chandramauli Kumar Prasad of the Patna High Court as the chief justice of the Allahabad High Court with effect from the date he assumes charge of his office,' said a statement by the ministry of law and justice here.
Mexico's Supreme Court dismisses appeal of military jurisdiction in crimes against civiliansAugust 11th, 2009 In Mexico, challenge of military courts failsMEXICO CITY — Mexico's Supreme Court has dismissed an appeal against the practice of allowing military courts to judge soldiers involved in crimes against civilians. The court says it rejected an appeal by a woman whose husband was shot by soldiers in northern Sinaloa state in 2008 because she lacks legal standing to file the appeal.
French Senate approves bill to cut off Internet connections of illegal downloadersMay 13th, 2009 French Senate approves Internet piracy lawPARIS — France's Senate has given final approval to a law that would punish people who download music and films illegally by cutting off their Internet connections. The law creates what could be the world's first government agency to punish online pirates.
Court rejects Ansals' plea to get back Uphaar cinema hallMarch 22nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Delhi High Court has rejected the plea of Uphaar Cinema owners and real estate tycoons the Ansal brothers for handing over to them the cinema hall, which was sealed after a fire tragedy that killed 59 people in 1997. In their plea, the Ansals stated that they wanted the cinema hall for its productive use.
Malawi's top judge to hear Madonna's adoption pleaApril 30th, 2009 LONDON - Pop diva Madonna's ongoing bid to adopt a Malawian girl will be heard by the country's top judge May 4. The singer is appealing against a high court judge's April 3 ruling, which rejected her request for the adoption of three-year-old Mercy James, reported femalefirst.com.
EU court voids asset freeze of terrorism suspect in UK; Cites lack of review, allows appealJune 11th, 2009 EU court voids asset freeze of UK terror suspectLUXEMBOURG — An EU court on Thursday voided a 2001 European Union decision to freeze the assets of a suspected Jordanian terrorist held in Britain, saying the case lacked a proper judicial review. The freeze was imposed in accordance with a U.N.
Apex court dismisses plea for caste-based censusApril 9th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Supreme Court Thursday dismissed a plea that sought direction to the government to undertake a caste-based census in 2011. A bench of Chief Justice K.G.
Department of Justice won't appeal shorter sentence for ex-Qwest CEO NacchioAugust 18th, 2009 DOJ won't appeal shorter sentence for ex-Qwest CEODENVER — The Department of Justice will let stand a federal court decision ordering a shorter prison sentence for ex-Qwest CEO Joe Nacchio, sentenced to six years for insider trading. Spokeswoman Laura Sweeney said Monday that the department won't appeal the ruling by a three-judge panel of the Denver-based 10th U.S.
