LONDON - The Disciplinary Committee of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons last week [17 July 2009] postponed its decision on whether to restore a former RCVS member to the Register, having previously struck her off for being unfit to practise.
Miss Judith Kay, of Cambridge Road, Sawbridgeworth, Herts, was removed from the Register in January 2007 following her multiple convictions for drink-driving offences, driving disqualification and four-month imprisonment.
She had applied to be restored to the Register on a previous occasion [January 2008], but the Committee had felt that Miss Kay still did not appreciate the severity of her addiction, which itself was much in evidence, and turned her application down. She had also continued to practise whilst off the Register - a sufficiently serious matter on its own to warrant a refusal.
Last week, the Committee heard new testimony that Miss Kay now recognised the effect of alcohol on her judgement (although she maintained it did not affect her ability to handle animals) and that she had had much closer involvement with the Veterinary Surgeons Health Support Programme (VSHSP) since January 2008.
Whilst the Committee recognised and commended Miss Kay’s commitment to the VSHSP and the “considerable progress” she had made in addressing her addiction, it felt she still had “some way to go” in becoming a “fit and proper person” to resume veterinary practice. It wished to be satisfied with a range of third-party corroborated evidence in support of this, including the results of random blood tests, attendance at AA meetings, and a suitable CPD programme.
Chairman of the Disciplinary Committee, Mrs Alison Bruce, said: “In light of [these requirements], we have concluded that judgment should be postponed for a period of six months, during which time Miss Kay should comply with undertakings [see Notes] designed to ensure her progress towards rehabilitation.
“In particular, we feel that Miss Kay needs to be able to show that she has obtained advice from an experienced practising veterinary surgeon about the requirements of operating and managing a practice in the current market, the difficulties and problems she might face when she is ready to recommence practice, and the appropriate solutions.”
Mrs Bruce concluded: “It is because Miss Kay has agreed to comply with these undertaking that the Committee has been persuaded to follow this course of action.”
Notes For Editors
1.The RCVS is the regulatory body for veterinary surgeons in the UK and deals with issues of professional misconduct, maintaining the register of veterinary surgeons eligible to practise in the UK and assuring standards of veterinary education.
2.RCVS disciplinary powers are exercised through the Preliminary Investigation and Disciplinary Committees, established in accordance with Schedule 2 to the Veterinary Surgeons Act 1966 (the 1966 Act). The RCVS has authority to deal with three types of case:
a)Fraudulent registration
b)Criminal convictions
c)Allegations of disgraceful professional conduct
3.The Disciplinary Committee is a constituted judicial tribunal under the 1966 Act and follows rules of evidence similar to those used in a court of law.
4.The burden of proving an allegation falls upon the RCVS, and the RCVS must prove to the standard that the Committee is sure.
5.A respondent veterinary surgeon may appeal a Disciplinary Committee decision to the Privy Council within 28 days of the date of the decision. If no appeal is received, the Committee’s judgment takes effect after this period.
6.Further information, including the original Inquiry into Miss Kay, her first application for restoration and the undertakings she has now agreed to, can be found at www.rcvs.org.uk/disciplinary.
For more information please contact:
Ian Holloway, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons +44-(0)20-7202-0727 / i.holloway@rcvs.org.uk
Source: Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons
For more information please contact: Ian Holloway, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons +44-(0)20-7202-0727 / i.holloway at rcvs.org.uk
Related Press Releases
Drink-Drive Cambridgeshire Vet Warned as to Future ConductSeptember 20th, 2009 LONDON - Following a two-year postponed judgment, the Disciplinary Committee (DC) of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons last week [17 September 2009] warned a Cambridgeshire veterinary surgeon as to his future conduct, after he had been convicted in 2006 for causing death by careless driving whilst under the influence of alcohol. In September 2007, the Committee heard that Peter Hanlon MRCVS, of Soham in Cambridgeshire, had been involved in a road traffic accident in February 2006.
County Durham Vet Suspended for Practising While not RegisteredSeptember 10th, 2009 LONDON - The Disciplinary Committee (DC) of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons has suspended a veterinary surgeon for a period of three months for practising veterinary surgery while not registered with the College. At a hearing which concluded on 9 September, Silke Birgitt Lindridge, of the Consett Veterinary Centre, Medomsley Road, Consett, County Durham, was found guilty of disgraceful conduct in a professional respect for practising when she ought to have known that her name had been removed from the RCVS Register for non-payment of fees.
House of Lords Upholds Strike out of Claim Brought by Stone & RollsJuly 29th, 2009 LONDON - The House of Lords has delivered judgment in Moore Stephens' application to strike out the legal action brought against them by former client Stone & Rolls Limited (in liquidation). The House of Lords upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal to strike out the claim.
Johal Dairies Refused Permission to Appeal in Case Against J.N.DairiesJuly 20th, 2009 WOLVERHAMPTON, England -
- In relation to the High Court case of J.N.Dairies Ltd (Claimant) v Johal Dairies Ltd (1st Defendant) & Gurbir Singh (2nd Defendant)
- Judgment Laid Down on 12 June 2009, 10:30am at the Royal Courts of Justice (High Court), London
Johal Dairies were yesterday refused permission to appeal against a High Court judgment which found that they had paid an illegal immigrant GBP40,000 to steal confidential customer information from rival dairy supplier J.N.Dairies. Today's hearing followed an extraordinary 8 day trial at Birmingham Civil Justice Centre between 10 and 19 March 2009 at which the Court found that Wolverhampton and Leicester based Johal Dairies had paid an illegal immigrant, Gurbir Singh, GBP40,000 to steal information from J.N.Dairies that contained the volumes, addresses and prices that it was supplying its customers, which Johal Dairies then used in price negotiations to unlawfully win J.N.Dairies' business.
Norwich Vet Suspended for False CertificationJuly 16th, 2009 LONDON -
- The Disciplinary Committee (DC) of the Royal College of Veterinary
Surgeons have suspended a veterinary surgeon for a period of six months for issuing two false horse passports, having found him to have been "consciously dishonest". At a hearing which concluded on 15 July, Andrew Dominic Illing, Director of the Chapelfield Veterinary Partnership, Norwich, admitted charges of backdating the passports of two different horses on 1 May 2008, to indicate that they had been vaccinated on 24 April 2008 against equine influenza and equine influenza and tetanus, when he knew that the vaccinations had not been carried out on that date.
Gwynedd Vet Reprimanded for 'Reckless' CertificationJune 21st, 2009 LONDON - The Disciplinary Committee (DC) of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons last week [18 June 2009] issued a reprimand to a veterinary surgeon for reckless certification of an equine passport, having found her to have been "wholly indifferent" as to whether the horse had been vaccinated properly against equine influenza. Eleri Wyn Jones graduated from the University of Liverpool and qualified as a veterinary surgeon in 2006, before joining The Veterinary Practice on Bala Road in Dolgellau, Gwynedd, where she was also an authorised Local Veterinary Inspector (LVI).
Final Judgment of Hangzhou Intermediate Court: Rejects the Application From DanoneJune 17th, 2009 HANGZHOU, China - Ownership of "Wahaha" Trademark Belongs to Wahaha Group After Danone Suffers 38th Defeat
May 21st, 2009, Hangzhou Intermediate People's Court of Zhejiang Province made the Final judgment to reject the application from Danone on the revocation of No. 207 ruling of Hangzhou Arbitration Commission (2007).
Court of Appeal Upholds Landmark Ruling on Age Discrimination Against Rolls RoyceMay 13th, 2009 LONDON - Unite the Union, Britain's biggest union, has today (14 May 2009) succeeded in securing a landmark judgment from the Court of Appeal against Rolls Royce in one of the first cases on age discrimination to be considered by the higher courts. The Court of Appeal handed down its landmark judgment upholding Unite's resistance to an appeal by Rolls Royce against the decision of the High Court which declared that the use of length of service as one of a number of redundancy selection criteria was not age discrimination.
Disciplinary Committee Accepts 18-Month Undertakings From NE Lincs VetMay 5th, 2009 LONDON - Following two postponed hearings and a stayed Judicial Review, the Disciplinary Committee of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons last week [1 May 2009] accepted a wide-ranging 18-month programme of undertakings from a veterinary surgeon found guilty of serious professional conduct, to address his "serious deficiencies" and "practice failings". In October 2006, Mr Joseph Holmes MRCVS, of the Waltham Veterinary Clinic near Grimsby, was found guilty of serious professional misconduct for performing inappropriate and out-of-date veterinary treatment.
ITV 'Pets Undercover': RCVS ResponseMarch 16th, 2009 LONDON - "The main message that pet owners and veterinary surgeons should take
home from this evening's Tonight programme is the importance of communicating
with each other."
So says RCVS President Jill Nute after watching ITV Tonight presenter
Jonathan Maitland's report - 'Pets undercover' - on the types of treatment
and level of veterinary fees charged by some members of the veterinary
profession. "There is no National Health Service for animals.
Related News
Restoration of sacked judiciary unconstitutional, say most Pak experts?March 17th, 2009 LAHORE - Constitutional experts in Pakistani are divided over the legitimacy of the sacked judges' restoration of sacked judges through an executive order passed by the Prime Minister. Some experts have claimed that the step contradicts an earlier Supreme Court verdict on judges who refused to take the oath under the Provisional Constitutional Order (PCO), while others called the SC ruling 'illegal', the Daily Times reports.
Pakistan court rejects ex-cricketer Ahmed's bail application againApril 22nd, 2009 Court rejects Ahmed's bail applicationLAHORE, Pakistan — A Pakistani court on Wednesday rejected a bail application by former test cricketer Ijaz Ahmed. "We have not received the detailed judgment, but yes our (bail) application was today rejected," Ahmed's lawyer, Kashif Javed, told The Associated Press.
Security Council calls for restoration of Fijian democracyApril 21st, 2009 NEW YORK - The UN Security Council has expressed deep concern over the abrogation of the Fijian constitution and sacking of all judges by the island's military regime. The April 10 declaration also imposed severe press restrictions on the press, broadcaster and website operators.
Court reserves order on Joshi's bail applicationJuly 17th, 2009 MORADABAD - A local court here on Friday reserved its order after an in-camera hearing on the bail application of Uttar Pradesh Congress unit chief Rita Bahuguna Joshi. The order was reserved by Additional District Judge (II) Sudha Sharma.
Pak student reveals his "mental torture" during detention in BritainJune 11th, 2009 ISLAMABAD - Tariqur Rehman, one of the 10 Pakistan students arrested by British officials in a country wide terror crackdown has returned to Pakistan. Talking to media persons upon his arrival in Islamabad, Rehman charged the British officials with treating the students as hardcore criminals during detention.
Titanic-themed five star hotel to be erected in BelfastSeptember 7th, 2009 LONDON - A Titanic-themed boutique hotel is set to be erected at the old headquarters of the Belfast shipyard where the fated Olympic-class passenger liner was built. A planning application has been lodged to turn the former Harland and Wolff HQ into a 90-bedroom hotel, The Telegraph reports.
Tigers at White Sox game postponed by rainMay 8th, 2009 Tigers at White Sox game postponed by rainCHICAGO — The Detroit Tigers at Chicago White Sox game was postponed by rain Wednesday night. The game was called after a delay of 1 hour, 13 minutes.
Sec'y of State Clinton says US working with OAS on restoration of order in troubled HondurasJune 29th, 2009 Clinton urges restoration of order in HondurasWASHINGTON — Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton says the United States believes the unrest in Honduras "has evolved into a coup" and that officials believe the situation needs close watching. Clinton said Monday a delegation from the Organization of American States will be heading to Honduras as early as Tuesday "to begin working with the parties" on the restoration of constitutional government there.
Malaysian Indian Congress delegate suspended over slipper garland for ex-PMSeptember 16th, 2009 KUALA LUMPUR - The Malaysian Indian Congress (MIC) has suspended a delegate who suggested a garland of slippers for former Prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad. The Star quoted MIC President S.
Twins-Red Sox game postponed by rain, makeup set for Wednesday as opener of day-night DHApril 22nd, 2009 Twins-Red Sox game postponed by rainBOSTON — The Minnesota Twins at Boston Red Sox game Tuesday night was postponed because of rain. It was rescheduled as the first game of a day-night doubleheader Wednesday.
