MELBOURNE, Australia - New research released today indicates that the majority of credit statements used around the world mask the true level of debt being racked up by unsuspecting consumers thanks to major design flaws within the documents.
“Consumers have been lulled into a false sense of security, that they are operating their credit card to the best of their ability based on the information they are being given on their statement,” says Professor Sless, Director of the Communication Research Institute, “but the study has found that these statements are virtually incomprehensible. This is frightening news particularly when you consider that globally consumers have accumulated more than $US40 trillion in credit card debt.”
The international study, undertaken by the Communication Research Institute, tested credit statements from Australia, Argentina, Austria, Chile, Netherlands, Portugal, South Africa, UK and the USA and found that the statements could not be used to find out how much credit was run up on the credit card, how long it would take to pay it back, the ‘pay by’ date for each month, how much extra it’s going to cost in interest payments, and what happens if people miss a payment.
Full details of the study will be released by Professor Sless at the Data Designed for Decisions conference (www.DD4D.net) in Paris on Friday 19th June, 2009, held jointly by the IIID and OECD.
“To be easily understood, people should be able to find at least 90% of what they are looking for on a credit card statement and then use appropriately 90% of what they find. The only information that can be found reliably on the statements we tested is the name of the organisation sending it, and the person it is addressed to. Everything else falls well below an acceptable level.”
Final results showing the overall performance of statements from each country, where the minimum acceptable usability target level is 81%:
- Australia 33% - Argentina 75% - Austria 62% - Chile-1 31% - Chile-2 44% - Netherlands 63% - Portugal 41% - South Africa 40% - UK 55% - USA-1 32% - USA-2 60% Tasks which participants were asked to execute included: - identify who the statement is from and who it is for; - find and explain the credit limit and the available credit remaining after purchases; - find and explain the interest that applies to purchases and how much interest has been applied for the statement period; and - find and explain any payment due, and how to make that payment.
Professor Sless suggests that such large scale failure is most likely a symptom of systemic failures across the industry. “The common practices are bad practices” he said. “Getting the credit card providers to design the information to an acceptable standard will require both competitive incentive and regulatory pressure.”
Professor Sless added, “In other industries, such as the pharmaceutical industry, the use of good information design has worked. Easily understood products gain market share, and with well formulated regulation in the background, the majority follow suite.”
The data gathered from the study is already being sought by providers and regulators, and will be used by the Communication Research Institute to inform future redesign projects within the industry. Professor Sless is available for interview ex Australia until the 16th June, 2009 after which time he will be available ex Europe.
Further information and downloadable graphics are available at: communication.org.au/modules/cri_news/item.php?itemid=16
Media Enquiries: Professor David Sless, +61(0)412-356-795 Libby Fordham, Publicist for Prof. Sless +61(0)411-473-928 Alex Tyers, project coordinator/researcher +61(0)3-9521-1641
NOTES TO EDITORS:
- The Communication Research Institute is a worldwide not-for-profit organisation which is carrying out an international communication benchmarking study, with the first international study focusing on credit card statements. The organisation specializes in the design of public documents across a range of industries. Their work has included redesign of high profile public documents such as the Main Economic Indicators for the Australian Bureau of Statistics, and Insurance Policy and Renewal Documents for the Australian Insurance Group. They have also advised the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC); the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) on the regulation of financial and medicines information for consumers; Government regulators and industry in the EU and Mexico on the regulation of consumer information.
- The Institute researches, practices and disseminates knowledge of practical communication to enhance the quality of communication between people and organisations, lending a quiet dignity to ordinary life.
- Professor David Sless will give his presentation of the Communication Benchmarking Study at the DD4D conference in Paris, at 3pm on Friday 19th June, 2009.
Source: Communication Research Institute
Professor David Sless, +61(0)412-356-795, or Alex Tyers, project coordinator/researcher, +61(0)3-9521-1641, or Libby Fordham, Publicist for Prof. Sless, +61(0)411-473-928, all for Communication Research Institute
Related Press Releases
Deutsche Card Services Expands Domestic Services for POS Card Payment SolutionsSeptember 21st, 2009 COLOGNE, Germany - Deutsche Card Services today announced that it is expanding its stationary point-of-sale (POS) card payment solutions. In addition to the existing service of credit card acceptance in stationary POS business, the subsidiary of Deutsche Bank, will, with immediate effect, directly offer payment terminals and the national card payment methods girocard, direct debit and GeldKarte in the German market.
MBNA Launches New No Balance Transfer Fee CardSeptember 1st, 2009 CHESTER, England - MBNA today announced the launch of a new credit card offering no balance transfer handling fee and an introductory rate of 1.9 % p.a. for 12 months on balance transfers.
In Cooperation With Ensan Charity Association Al Rajhi Bank Launches Ensan Credit CardSeptember 1st, 2009 RIYADH - In cooperation with Ensan Charity Association in order to enhance its role in serving the community, Al Rajhi Bank recently launched "Ensan" Credit Card to support social and charity projects, in addition to encouraging charity spending to support key causes in the Saudi community. An agreement has been signed for launching this special product by HRH Prince Faisal bin Salman bin Abdul Aziz, Chairman of Ensan Charity and Mr.
Speed-Trap Launches Analytics for Adobe Air ApplicationsAugust 25th, 2009 NEWBURY, England -
- Speed-Trap Launches Industry-first Online Analytics Software That Captures and Analyses Visitor Interaction With Non-browser-based Adobe AIR and Rich Internet Applications
Speed-Trap www.speed-trap.com the online customer insight software provider, today launches its analytics for adobe air applications, Speed-Trap's unique capability to capture and process detailed data on users' interactions with Adobe AIR applications, despite their being based on the desktop, not in the browser. rich internet applications are no longer solely implemented in browser environments, and with the introduction of Adobe AIR in early 2008, many organisations are starting to implement their rich internet applications as standalone, including companies like the BBC, eBay and PayPal.
Speed-Trap's Mobile Technology Completes the View of Online Customer ExperienceAugust 19th, 2009 NEWBURY, England -
- Speed-Trap Extends the Reach of its Technology to Monitor Visitor Interaction With Websites and Web Applications to Now Include Mobile Customer Experience Measurement by Providing Mobile Internet Analytics of Activity on Mobile Devices From Nokia to Nintendo
Speed-Trap, www.speed-trap.com the online customer insight provider, has extended its Tag-Free(TM) Dynamic Collection(TM) technology to capture data from website visitors accessing sites via almost any mobile device, providing full mobile internet analytics and mobile customer experience measurement. Speed-Trap's mobile internet analytics development allows Speed-Trap customers to build a holistic view of their visitors' online interaction across both traditional Mac/PC and mobile platforms and develop detailed mobile customer experience measurement.
Air China Launches China's First Business Travel CardAugust 6th, 2009 BEIJING -
- Travel card offers business travelers exclusive services and promotions
Air China has launched the 'Air China Business Travel Card', becoming the first airline in China's civil aviation industry to introduce such a service. (Logo: www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20080625/CNW017LOGO )
In order to meet business passengers' needs, Air China has integrated the services offered through e-commerce and frequent flyer programs to launch the 'Air China Business Travel Card'.
EPAY Launches Their EPAY Debit CardJune 8th, 2009 PANAMA CITY - EPAY announces the launch of their newest EPAY debit card, ideal for personal and business usage worldwide. EPAY Inc. is a high performance, online payment platform allowing consumers and small businesses to send and receive money transfers worldwide through epayarea.com debit cards.
CPI Card Group Receives Multiple Elan AwardsApril 30th, 2009 LITTLETON, Colorado - CPI Card Group, a world leader in card manufacturing and related solutions, is pleased to have received two Elan awards and five finalist positions at the 2009 ICMA Annual EXPO. The awards recognize the latest advancements and achievements in card design throughout the industry.
Online Customer Insight Specialist Speed-Trap Launches Rich Media Application Web TrackingMarch 19th, 2009 NEWBURY, England - Unique Online Analytics Software Launched That Captures and Analyses
Visitor Interaction With Multimedia Applications Such as Adobe Flash,
Flex, Windows Media Player, QuickTime or Real Player
Speed-Trap, the online insight software provider
www.speed-trap.com/aboutus.aspx launches a unique capability to
capture detailed data on website visitors' interaction with Multimedia
applications, such as Adobe Flash, Windows Media Player or QuickTime via an
extension to their Patented Dynamic Collection(TM) technology - multimedia
application web tracking. Today's websites are no longer built upon basic HTML - they typically
contain many different active technologies to keep the visitor engaged,
ranging from a simple Flash banner campaign to a streaming movie or
interactive rich media application.
Risk of Non-Payment in Online Retail Lower for Women Than for MenMarch 12th, 2009 COLOGNE, Germany - Pago Retail Report by Deutsche Card Services Gives European Online
Merchants Valuable Information on How to Avoid Non-Payment by Customers
In European online retailing, risks of non-payment are lower for women
than for men. This is indicated by a lower chargeback ratio, which describes
the share of credit card transactions which had to be charged back after the
cardholder's rejection.
Related News
HSBC agrees to nationwide deal to help blind and deaf dispute credit card chargesSeptember 1st, 2009 Deal helps disabled dispute credit card chargesALBANY, N.Y. — New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo says HSBC bank's credit card division is agreeing to a new national standard to serve customers who are blind or deaf.
Summary Box: Indictment in major credit card heists still leaves holes in payment networksAugust 18th, 2009 Summary Box: Indictment of card hackerHACKER CHARGED: This week a man accused of some of the biggest credit card thefts on record was hit with more charges in other prominent cases. WHAT IT MEANS: The indictment illustrates how card numbers can be stolen by exploiting a flaw that still exists in some payment networks and other computer systems.
Obama urges credit-card industry to end unfair practicesApril 24th, 2009 WASHINGTON - US President Barack Obama Thursday met leaders of the credit-card industry, urging them to end unfair practices that are raising costs on indebted consumers, while US lawmakers are considering a wider crackdown on the sector. Obama said he hoped to create a new system that 'eliminates some of the abuses' including sudden interest-rate hikes and late-payment fees, which have added to unmanageable debts for some US consumers.
Credit card industry will have to make major adjustments to new laws, Capital One CFO saysJune 3rd, 2009 Capital One CFO: Industry facing dramatic changesNEW YORK — New credit card legislation is expected to have a dramatic impact on the national lending landscape, the chief financial officer of Capital One Financial Corp. said Wednesday.
Obama signs credit card reform billMay 23rd, 2009 WASHINGTON - US President Barack Obama Friday signed into law a legislation that makes it more difficult for credit card providers to raise fees and interest rates. The credit card reform bill received overwhelming support in Congress this week before landing on Obama's desk for his signature.
12 blind students appear for class 10 exam in JharkhandFebruary 26th, 2009 RANCHI - Twelve blind students are appearing in the ongoing class 10 board examination, an official said here Wednesday. 'This year we have given permission to 12 blind students to appear in the class 10 examination.
'Audio book recorder' made in NagpurMay 20th, 2009 NAGPUR - A unique device called 'Audio book recorder' is made in Nagpur for blind students to help them in their studies. This exceptional audio device was prepared six months back.
Cuba sees boom in blind musiciansJanuary 12th, 2009 HAVANA - Cuba has witnessed an increase in the number of amateur blind musicians as a result of the facilities offered to the visually challenged by the music teaching institutions in the country, the Cuban news agency Prensa Latina reported. Carlos Ramirez, a professor who is himself blind, said that music was among the most practised art by the blind in Cuba, though theatre and literature were not far behind.
Rate of missed credit-card payments up from last year, but better than in 1Q, TransUnion saysAugust 25th, 2009 Data hints consumers handling credit cards betterNEW YORK — The rate at which credit card holders fell behind on their payments was far worse in the second quarter than it was last year, but did improve sharply from the alarming level seen in the first three months of 2009. The shift since the first quarter shows that consumers handled their credit better even as job losses mounted and the recession deepened, according to credit reporting agency TransUnion.
Credit card interest rates change but don't set pattern: average rate rises slightlyJune 15th, 2009 Credit card interest rates waver in past weekNEW YORK — Credit card interest rates wavered in the past week, with the lowest rates holding steady while some higher rates dipped. Overall, the average annual percentage rate charged on variable rate credit cards edged up to 10.88 percent from 10.85 percent last week, according to Bankrate.com.