Health care issues: Using parliamentary maneuvers
A look at key issues in the health care debate:
THE ISSUE: If congressional Republicans continue to oppose Democratic plans to overhaul the nation’s health care system, should majority Democrats employ a process called reconciliation to pass parts of it without Republican support?
THE POLITICS: Reconciliation is a procedure used to protect bills from being filibustered to death. It effectively lowers the threshold for Senate passage from 60 votes to a simple majority of 51. Both parties have used the procedure to override objections from the minority, but doing so carries the risk of alienating anyone with concerns about the policy being forced through. Democrats who support using reconciliation say it’s necessary to enact health care overhaul that has eluded every president and Congress for decades. Republicans say that the use of reconciliation for health care would validate their warnings about the Democrats having too much control of the levers of government — and taxpayer money.
WHAT IT MEANS: Deploying reconciliation would strip health care overhaul of any patina of the bipartisan consensus all sides say such a sweeping policy change would need to be effective. It would mean that Democrats did a difficult cost-benefit analysis and determined that passing some type of overhaul was worth the risk of alienating large segments of voters on the eve of the 2010 elections.
— Laurie Kellman
Related News
Democratic senators cite savings and effect on jobs in supporting health care overhaulNovember 22nd, 2009 Democrats: Health care bill saves money and jobsWASHINGTON — Two Democratic senators say the health care overhaul bill now going to the Senate floor for debate is a key to saving jobs and reducing the spiraling American budget deficit. Democratic Sen.
Nebraska's moderate Sen. Ben Nelson to vote 'yes' on crucial health care test vote SaturdayNovember 20th, 2009 Sen. Nelson a 'yes' on health care test voteWASHINGTON — Democratic Sen. Ben Nelson of Nebraska is a "yes" in a crucial weekend test vote on health care.
Senate to hold first health care vote on Saturday nightNovember 19th, 2009 Saturday night set for initial health care voteWASHINGTON — The Senate will hold its first vote on health care legislation on Saturday night and Democrats will need 60 votes to prevail. Majority Leader Harry Reid announced the schedule on the Senate floor, one day after unveiling a nearly $1 trillion bill to expand health coverage.
Health care issues: Proposed drug industry savingsNovember 18th, 2009 Health care issues: Proposed drug industry savingsA look at key issues in the health care debate:
THE ISSUE: Is the pharmaceutical industry's agreement to lower drug costs by $80 billion over the next decade fair?
THE POLITICS: The industry's trade group, the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, agreed to contribute those savings to help pay for Democrats' proposed $1 trillion health care overhaul. That deal was struck with the White House and the chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, Democrat Max Baucus of Montana.
Health care issues: What's the best treatment?November 17th, 2009 Health care issues: What's the best treatment?A look at key issues in the health care debate:
THE ISSUE: Researching which treatments work best and how much they cost, and how doctors and patients should use that information. THE POLITICS: On the surface, it seems like common sense: How different health conditions are treated — whether with surgery, drugs or managing diet and exercise, for example — should depend on what works best and costs least.
December 1st, 2009 at 2:16 am
It is clear that the Republicans have no intentions of voting for the health care bill with a public option. Not having a public option takes the engine out of health care reform. Bipartisanship has to work both way’s. The Democrats have compromised on many aspects of the health care bill. If there was ever a time for the Democrats to use reconciliation, the time is now. Pass the health care bill!