UN vote sends Gaza war report to Security Council
GENEVA — The U.N. Human Rights Council voted Friday to endorse a Gaza war crimes report and send it to the Security Council, possibly setting up international prosecution of Israelis and Palestinians accused of war crimes.
The council approved a Palestinian-backed resolution after two days of debate on the Goldstone report, which it had commissioned following the Dec. 27-Jan. 18 conflict in which almost 1,400 Palestinians and 13 Israelis were killed.
The resolution passed 25-6, with mostly developing countries in favor and the United States and five European countries — Hungary, Italy, Netherlands, Slovakia and Ukraine —opposing.
Eleven mostly European and African countries abstained, while Britain, France and three other members of the 47-nation body declined to vote. Russia and China, two permanent members of the U.N. Security Council, were among those voting yes.
“The clock on the report starts now,” said Ibrahim Khraishi, the Palestinian Authority’s U.N. ambassador in Geneva, adding that he hoped the Security Council in New York would take up the report.
If the report is considered by the 15-member Security Council, the U.S. is likely to use its veto to block any call for getting the International Criminal Court involved in the dispute over Gaza or taking action against Israel.
The 575-page report, compiled by an expert group led by Judge Richard Goldstone, concluded that Israel used disproportionate force, deliberately targeted civilians, used Palestinians as human shields and destroyed civilian infrastructure during its incursion into the Gaza Strip to root out Palestinian rocket squads.
It also accused Palestinian armed groups including Hamas of deliberately targeting civilians and trying to spread terror through rocket attacks on southern Israel.
In Ramallah, a spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, welcomed Friday’s vote.
“What is important now is to translate words into deeds in order to protect our people in the future from any new aggression,” Nabil Abu Rdeneh said.
Israel and the U.S. called the Goldstone report “flawed” because it ignored Israel’s right to defend its people from Palestinian rocket fire. They warned that the vote could jeopardize Middle East peace prospects.
Israel’s foreign minister, Avigdor Lieberman, also said endorsing the report could have far-reaching consequences.
“Whoever votes in favor of endorsing the report must understand that next time it will be the soldiers and officers of NATO in Afghanistan, and then Russian soldiers and officers in Chechnya,” Lieberman said late Thursday.
U.S. diplomat Douglas M. Griffiths told the council that Washington was disappointed with the outcome of the vote.
“We’re focused on moving forward in the peace process and we feel that this is a distraction from that,” Griffiths told The Associated Press.
The resolution — which also condemns recent Israeli actions in the Palestinian territories and East Jerusalem — endorses the report’s recommendation that both sides in the conflict should show the Security Council within six months that they are carrying out credible investigations into alleged Gaza abuses. If they are not, the matter should then be referred to prosecutors at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands.
ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo had no comment Friday on a possible war crimes probe into the Gaza conflict.
Prosecutors are analyzing a declaration in January in which the Palestinian Authority accepted the court’s authority over territory it controls — something only sovereign nations are allowed to do.
Palestinians filed their recognition in the hope that if the court accepts it, Moreno Ocampo would then have jurisdiction to launch an investigation into war crimes committed by both sides during the Gaza conflict even without an order from the Security Council.
Israel does not accept the court’s jurisdiction.
The U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay, urged both sides earlier this week “to carry out impartial, independent, prompt and effective investigations into reported violations of human rights and humanitarian law.”
Associated Press Writer Mike Corder in The Hague and Aron Heller in Jerusalem contributed to this report.
Related News
UN rights council heading for vote on Gaza war crimes reportOctober 16th, 2009 UN rights council heading for vote on Gaza reportGENEVA — The U.N. Human Rights Council is heading for a showdown vote on a report accusing Israeli forces and Palestinian militants of war crimes during their conflict in Gaza last winter.
Israel's Netanyahu calls on UN members to vote against Gaza War crimes resolutionOctober 15th, 2009 Israel seeks UN allies on Gaza War crimes voteJERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday called on members of the U.N.'s Human Rights Council to reject a resolution endorsing a report accusing Israeli forces and their Palestinian opponents of war crimes during the fighting in Gaza last winter. The Geneva-based council is expected to vote Friday on a resolution that would ask the Security Council in New York to determine within six months whether both sides are carrying out credible investigations into alleged abuses or to refer the issue to the International Criminal Court in the Hague, Netherlands.
UN rights chief backs report saying Israel, Palestinians committed war crimes in Gaza conflictOctober 15th, 2009 UN rights chief backs Gaza war crimes reportGENEVA — The U.N.'s top human rights official backed a report Thursday accusing Israeli forces and Palestinian militants of war crimes during their conflict in Gaza last winter. Navi Pillay's endorsement of the report by an expert group led by Judge Richard Goldstone came as Israel warned the U.N.
UN backs report saying Israel, Palestinians committed war crimes in Gaza conflictOctober 15th, 2009 UN says Israel, Palestinians committed war crimesGENEVA — The U.N.'s top human rights official backed a report Thursday accusing Israeli forces and Palestinian militants of war crimes during their conflict in Gaza last winter. Navi Pillay's endorsement of the report by an expert group led by Judge Richard Goldstone came as Israel warned the U.N.
Palestinians, allies force UN rights council to reopen Gaza war crimes debate ThursdayOctober 13th, 2009 Palestinians, allies reopen Gaza war crimes debateGENEVA — The U.N. Human Rights Council will reopen the debate about alleged war crimes in Gaza later this week after Palestinians succeeded in gathering enough support to call a special meeting, officials said Tuesday.
Palestinians drumming up support for emergency UN rights meeting on Gaza report, JerusalemOctober 9th, 2009 Palestinians want urgent UN rights debate on GazaGENEVA — Palestinian diplomats in Geneva said Friday they are pushing to bring forward a U.N. Human Rights Council debate on alleged war crimes committed by Israeli forces and Palestinian militants in Gaza earlier this year.
Palestinian leaders reverse course accusing Hamas of taking advantage of UN reportOctober 8th, 2009 Palestinians accuse Hamas over UN reportUNITED NATIONS — The militant Islamist group Hamas is trying to take cynical advantage of a U.N. report accusing Israel of possible war crimes in Gaza to curry favor back home, Palestinian Foreign Minister Riad Malki told reporters at U.N.
Top official says Palestinian leaders erred in agreeing to shelve UN war crimes report on GazaOctober 7th, 2009 Palestinian official: We erred over Gaza reportRAMALLAH, West Bank — The Palestinian leadership made a mistake by suspending action on a U.N. report on Gaza war crimes, a member of President Mahmoud Abbas' inner circle said Wednesday — the first such acknowledgment after days of protests in the West Bank and Gaza.
UN Security Council agrees to discuss Gaza war crimes report on Oct. 14October 7th, 2009 UN council to discuss Gaza war crimes on Oct. 14UNITED NATIONS — The U.N.
Diplomats say Palestinians want UN rights council resolution on Gaza 'war crimes' postponedOctober 1st, 2009 Diplomats: Palestinians want Gaza resolution delayGENEVA — Diplomats in Geneva say the Palestinian Authority has withdrawn its support for a U.N. resolution endorsing a report on alleged war crimes by Israel and Palestinians in Gaza.
Ahead of Gaza debate, US officials say membership of UN rights body is an 'experiment'September 30th, 2009 US officials: UN rights membership an 'experiment'GENEVA — The United States hopes to use the U.N. Human Rights Council to engage other countries in a dialogue on universal values, senior U.S.
UN investigator defends report accusing Israel, Palestinians of war crimes in Gaza conflictSeptember 30th, 2009 UN expert defends Gaza war crimes reportGENEVA — A U.N. investigator defended a report Tuesday that accuses Israel and Palestinian militants of war crimes during their conflict in Gaza, an allegation Israel condemns and claims is the result of bias against the Jewish state.
Mandate given to UN fact-finding mission in Gaza unacceptable: USSeptember 17th, 2009 NEW YORK - The UN Human Rights Council had given an "unacceptable" mandate to the fact-finding mission in the Gaza Strip led by South African judge Richard Goldstone, a US diplomat said Thursday. Goldstone's findings released this week accused both Israel and Palestinian militant groups of committing war crimes and crimes against humanity during the December-January conflict in Gaza, which the mission said killed at least 1,400 people.
Israel says Goldstone Report supports terrorSeptember 16th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel has described the Goldstone Commission Report as biased and nauseating, and added that it has created an unjust "equivalence of a democratic state with a terror organization". The commission, established by the UN Human Rights Council and led by former South African constitutional court judge Richard Goldstone, concluded that "Israel committed actions amounting to war crimes, possibly crimes against humanity," during Operation Cast Lead from late December to mid-January.
"UN Gaza report written by Palestinians," says Israel's ambassador to UNAugust 16th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel's Ambassador to the United Nations, Aharon Leshno Yaar, has said that the UN Gaza report was written solely "to appease the Arab-controlled Human Rights Council."
Leshno Yaar claimed that the report was "written by Palestinians in Ramallah" and it was "screened by Palestinian lawyers in Geneva in order to satisfy Palestinian diplomats on the Human Rights Council."e said the report was "totally biased" and based on unconfirmed information. "It ignores the facts and the Israeli positions.