No deal on crucial issues as UN climate talks end
BANGKOK — The United States was heavily criticized Friday at the U.N. climate talks in Bangkok for failing to offer emission cuts or financing for developing countries — both considered crucial to reaching a global warming pact this year.
The Bangkok talks ended just as it was announced that President Barack Obama had won the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize, for among other things strengthening the U.S. role in combatting climate change. U.N. climate chief Yvo de Boer said he hoped the award would spur progress when the U.S. delegation arrives in Copenhagen in December for crucial climate negotiations.
Obama is set to received his award in Oslo on Dec. 10 — just days after the climate talks start.
“I hope this encourages him to come to Copenhagen with an ambitious target,” de Boer said. “We need that.”
Earlier, the Americans took a beating from environmentalists and poor nations for failing to commit to deep emissions cuts and to provide financial aid to poorer nations.
“The developing nations are justifiably angry at the lack of progress, about the lack of credible offers by the United States, by the European Union and by Japan,” said Alden Meyer, director of strategy and policy for the Union of Concerned Scientists.
Jonathan Pershing, the head of the American delegation, said the United States wanted a deal in Copenhagen but he admitted “it would be extremely difficult for the U.S. to commit to specific numbers in the absence of legislation from Congress.”
In the U.S., which rejected the Kyoto Protocol because it exempted countries such as India and China from obligations, a bill that passed the House of Representatives would reduce emissions by 17 percent from 2005 levels — about 4 percent below 1990 levels — by 2020. The Senate is considering its own bill that would cut emissions 20 percent.
Negotiations have been deadlocked for months and delegates have raised doubts whether a new climate pact to rein in greenhouse gases can be reached by the time world leaders gather in Copenhagen. The pact would replace the Kyoto Protocol, which expires in 2012.
Shayam Saran, India’s special envoy for climate change, told reporters said he was “dismayed” that developed nations hadn’t announced plans for deep emissions cuts at the Bangkok meeting, as he had been expecting.
Most countries want a new climate pact that includes measures limiting temperature increases to 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) above preindustrial levels, a level necessary to avoid the worst impacts of climate change. But so far, there is no consensus on how to reach that goal.
Industrialized nations have pledged emission cuts of up to 23 percent below 1990 levels by 2020 — far short of the 25 to 40 percent cuts scientists and activists say are needed to keep temperature increases below 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit).
Only Norway announced a new target at the Bangkok meeting, saying it would reduce by 40 percent, up from a previous commitment of 30 percent, by 2020.
Developing countries have said they want to do their part but have refused to agree on binding targets and want to see more ambitious cuts by the industrialized nations. They won’t sign any deal until the West guarantees tens of billions of dollars in financial assistance.
“This week has witnessed a very regretful and unfortunate development which has demonstrated without a doubt the lack of seriousness of the developed countries,” Lumumba Di-Aping, chairman of the developing block of nations known as the G-77 and China, told reporters. “We have witnessed one developed country after another making pronouncements that literally amount to the discarding and killing the Kyoto Protocol.”
Related News
Environmentalists criticize UN climate talks for lack of progress on emission targets, financeOctober 8th, 2009 UN talks to end without deal on crucial issuesBANGKOK — U.N. climate talks ended in a whimper Friday without progress on the pressing issues of emission cuts for wealthy nations or financing for the developing ones, both of which are crucial to reaching a global warming pact.
Why she doesn't want to date a guy from a developed countryOctober 8th, 2009 BANGKOK - Tired of the way industrialised countries are dragging their feet on a global agreement to tackle global warming, young Indian climate activist Leela Raina has found a new way to express her frustration. She has written a blog with 11 reasons on why she will not date a man from a developed country.
Stay with Kyoto protocol, urges UN climate chiefOctober 7th, 2009 BANGKOK - "When I have only one pair of shoes, it makes sense to stay with that pair." With these words, UN climate chief Yvo de Boer Wednesday came out clearly in favour of retaining the Kyoto Protocol to tackle global warming, despite strong efforts by many industrialised countries to dump it. The issue has become the main point of contention in the Sep 28-Oct 9 talks here in preparation for the climate summit in Copenhagen this December.
Climate talks still stuck on key issues: IndiaOctober 7th, 2009 BANGKOK - Talks to finalise a climate treaty in time for December's Copenhagen summit are still stuck over key issues of the extent to which industrialised countries will reduce their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and how much they will pay developing countries to deal with global warming, India's top climate negotiator said here Wednesday. As the Sep 28-Oct 9 preparatory talks here neared their final phase, Prime Minister's Special Envoy on Climate Change Shyam Saran said: "There is no agreement on the most difficult issues - mitigation (of GHG emissions) and financing."
"We need an early decision on significant (GHG) emission reduction targets during the second commitment period of the Kyoto Protocol (2013-2020), but there's virtually no progress."
India and 36 other developing countries have proposed that industrialised countries -- which have emitted almost all the excess GHG that is leading to climate change -- reduce their emissions by at least 40 percent by 2020, compared to 1990.
Rich countries framing climate debate to suit themselves: IndiaOctober 6th, 2009 BANGKOK - Rich countries have been framing the climate debate to suit themselves rather than looking at the way global warming affects most of the world, which is why a global treaty is proving elusive, India's top climate negotiator said here Tuesday. "They don't talk about equity, they only talk of how to protect their lifestyles," the Prime Minister's Special Envoy on Climate Change Shyam Saran told a group of Indian NGO representatives.
US says its climate bill unlikely to pass before global conference on cutting greenhouse gasesSeptember 30th, 2009 US says climate bill might not pass in timeBANGKOK — The fate of U.S. legislation capping carbon emissions weighed heavily on delegates at U.N.
UN climate talks kick off in Bangkok with calls to reach deal, avert catastropheSeptember 30th, 2009 Leaders warn time running out for climate dealBANGKOK — U.N. climate talks kicked off Monday in Bangkok with leaders calling for delegates to break the deadlock over a global warming deal and warning that failure to act would leave future generations fighting for survival.
WWF: Saving forests 20 percent of climate-change challengeSeptember 29th, 2009 BANGKOK - Saving the world's remaining native forests must be a big part of any new climate deal as about 20 percent of global carbon emissions are due to deforestation and forest degradation, the World Wildlife Fund for Nature (WWF) said Tuesday. The WWF's Forest Carbon Initiative seeks to achieve zero net greenhouse gas emission from deforestation and degradation by 2020.
India among countries leading fight against climate change: WWFSeptember 28th, 2009 BANGKOK - India, China and Japan are now leading the world to reach a deal this December that will be effective in tackling climate change while EU and the US are proving major stumbling blocks, international NGO WWF has said. As delegates from 177 countries gathered here Monday for the start of a two-week preparatory meet for December's climate summit in Copenhagen, WWF applauded Japan, China and India for outlining concrete action to mitigate emissions of greenhouse gases.
On climate, leadership in Asia, rhetoric in the West: WWFSeptember 28th, 2009 BANGKOK - International NGO WWF is "worried about a mismatch between credible leadership in Asia and empty rhetoric in Europe and the US" on ways to tackle climate change. "While key Asian countries are offering concrete contributions to reach a deal in December, EU and US are emerging as major stumbling blocks."
As delegates from 177 countries gathered here Monday for the start of a two-week preparatory meet for December's climate summit in Copenhagen, WWF applauded Japan, China and India for outlining concrete action to mitigate emissions of greenhouse gases.
EU says 'decisive progress' needed at climate talks in BangkokSeptember 25th, 2009 EU calls for urgency at climate talks in BangkokSTOCKHOLM — The European Union is urging wealthy and developing countries to bring more "urgency and ambition" to climate talks in Thailand next week. The Bangkok meeting starting Monday is the penultimate negotiating session before a pivotal U.N.
EU to press for climate change dealJuly 25th, 2009 ARE - The European Union (EU) is hoping for progress in the run-up to a global climate change summit in December, Swedish Environment Minister Andreas Carlgren said Saturday. "We expect the negotiations to speed up," Carlgren said at the end of a two-day informal meeting of EU environment ministers in Are, 630 km northwest of Stockholm.
India, US to hold bilateral talks on climate changeJune 12th, 2009 BONN - Climate negotiators from the Obama administration will be in New Delhi to hold bilateral talks on what India is ready to do to tackle global warming, the leader of the US delegation to a UN conclave said here Friday. Jonathan Pershing, who led the US delegation at these preparatory talks of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) for the December summit in Copenhagen, said he had met the leader of the Indian delegation Shyam Saran on the sidelines of the talks here.
No detailed deal in Copenhagen: UN climate chief (Repeating for all needing)June 11th, 2009 BONN - It will be "physically impossible" to have a detailed deal to tackle climate change by this December's summit in Copenhagen, UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) Executive Secretary Yvo de Boer said here Wednesday. However, he hoped, the "Copenhagen (summit) will deliver clarity on key political issues in this debate, that there will be clarity on the extent industrialised countries will reduce their (GHG) emissions, and clarity on what major developing countries (including India) are willing to do to mitigate their emissions."
He also hoped that there would be "clarity on financing developing countries" to help them mitigate their emissions and adapt to climate change, and that there would "clarity on the governance structure" to administer these funds.
Rich nations should pay for pollution from exports: ChinaMarch 17th, 2009 WASHINGTON - The world's wealthiest nations should be responsible for China's pollution coming from exports, Chinese officials said amid talks with the US on how to combat global warming. China, the world's largest polluter together with the US, has a plan in place to reduce greenhouse gas emissions blamed for global warming even as its economy grows rapidly, said Li Gao, director of China's department of climate change.