Raphael G. Satter
Lawmakers urge UK to drop Afghan drugs mission
LONDON — Britain should abandon its anti-drug role in Afghanistan and focus on securing the country against the Taliban insurgency, a prominent group of U.K. lawmakers said Sunday.
Britain, along with the United States, is one of the leading contributors to the international campaign to eradicate Afghanistan’s opium crop. But nearly 160 million pounds ($267 million) were spent on its counter-narcotics role between 2004 and 2008, to little effect.
The U.K. also supplies the second-highest number of troops to NATO’s military campaign against the Taliban. Its 9,000-strong contingent has taken heavy casualties in the past month.
Lawmakers on the House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee say Britain does not have the resources to shoulder both burdens at once.
“We recommend that in the immediate future the government should refocus its efforts to concentrate its limited resources on one priority, namely security,” the committee said in a published report.
Questions about Britain’s role in Afghanistan have come to the fore as U.K. and U.S. forces take the offensive against a resurgent Taliban, sparking intense fighting.
The British military suffered 22 fatalities in July, its bloodiest month since the invasion of Afghanistan in the aftermath of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. July was also the deadliest month for U.S. forces there.
Britain’s political opposition has accused the government of sending troops into combat without proper equipment and air support. Others have questioned whether the U.K. even belongs in Afghanistan at all.
The Foreign Affairs Committee said there could be “no question” of abandoning Afghanistan. Its chairman, Mike Gapes, said the international community needed to show “that it intends to outlast the insurgency and remain in Afghanistan until the Afghan authorities are able take control of their own security.”
But the report said the international effort to put Afghanistan back on its feet had faltered.
Progress on police reform has been “disappointingly slow,” the effort to create an independent judiciary was a failure and there has been “virtually no tangible progress” on tackling corruption, according to the report.
Lawmakers also had some harsh words for what they called the “unilateralist tendencies” of the U.S. under George W. Bush.
“Some, though certainly not all, of the responsibility for problems in Afghanistan since 2001 must be attributed to the direction of U.S. policy in the years immediately after the military intervention,” the report said, explaining that the Bush administration’s “focus on military goals to the exclusion of many other strategically important issues set the tone for the international community’s early presence in Afghanistan.”
The Foreign Affairs Committee is made up of 14 lawmakers drawn from Britain’s three major parties. Although its recommendations are not binding, they are generally taken into account by policy-makers.
Britain’s foreign ministry said it welcomed the report and would study it closely before submitting a response to lawmakers in the coming months.
www.parliament.uk/facom/
Related News
EU observers say Afghan elections 'largely positive'August 22nd, 2009 KABUL - Election monitors from the European Union Saturday described the Afghan presidential elections as "largely positive". Two days after the elections, the European Union Election Observation Mission to Afghanistan, in a statement, welcomed the elections "as a victory against those who wanted to prevent the Afghan people from deciding their own future".
Afghan mission is war of necessity, says ObamaAugust 18th, 2009 - US President Barack Obama said the mission in Afghanistan was "a war of necessity" as Al Qaeda was still plotting against the US. However, he said the Iraq mission -- which he has repeatedly criticised as "a war of choice" -- will end in 2011.
5 rockets slam into Kabul, Afghan police say 1 child hurtAugust 4th, 2009 5 rockets fired on KabulKABUL — Police say five rockets have slammed into Kabul, injuring at least one child. The explosions were heard by AP reporters at daybreak Tuesday in the Afghan capital.
British soldier condemns Afghan warJuly 31st, 2009 LONDON - A British soldier is facing court martial after refusing to return to Afghanistan, claiming the British mission there is doomed to failure. Lance Corporal Joe Glenton, from the northern city of York, handed Prime Minister Gordon Brown a letter Thursday condemning the Afghan war and demanding the withdrawal of British troops.
British foreign secretary defends Afghan mission after heavy losses in fightingJuly 11th, 2009 British foreign secretary defends Afghan missionLONDON — Foreign Secretary David Miliband defended Britain's role in Afghanistan on Saturday after fighting claimed eight soldiers' lives in 24 hours. The deaths pushed Britain's overall toll in Afghanistan to 184 — five more than the total British deaths in the Iraq war.
Help Afghan police, NATO chief urges membersJune 12th, 2009 BRUSSELS - NATO members states must give the Afghan police more training and better equipment to help them fight off insurgent attacks, the alliance's top official said Friday. Two-thirds of all the uniformed personnel killed in Afghanistan are police officers, and there is an "urgent need to provide them with better training, infrastructure and equipment", NATO Secretary General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer told alliance defence ministers.
Romania's military ends Iraq deployment, reducing US-led coalition to 3 countriesJune 4th, 2009 Romanian contingent ends Iraq deploymentBAGHDAD — Romania's small military contingent ended its deployment in Iraq on Thursday, reducing the U.S.-led coalition to three countries. In Iraq's north, another U.S.
Murrya will become first Brit since Fred Perry to win a Grand Slam: HenmanMay 13th, 2009 LONDON - Wimbledon legend Tim Henman insists Andy Murray will become the first Briton since Fred Perry to win a Grand Slam. Henman, who lost four Wimbledon semi-finals, declared: "Andy Murray is still only 21, yet will go on to far bigger and better things than I achieved.
Syria criticizes renewal of US sanctions, urges Washington to abandon 'foolish policies'May 10th, 2009 Syria criticizes renewal of US sanctionsDAMASCUS, Syria — Syria rejected the Obama administration's decision to renew economic and diplomatic sanctions against Damascus and urged Washington to abandon "foolish policies," a state-run newspaper reported Sunday. The State Department announced Friday that President Barack Obama felt compelled to renew the sanctions, which were first imposed by George W.
Ryan Howard hits 7th career grand slam, ties Mike Schmidt for Phillies recordMay 5th, 2009 Ryan Howard's 7th grand slam ties Phillies recordST. LOUIS — Ryan Howard has hit his seventh career grand slam, tying Hall of Famer Mike Schmidt for the Philadelphia Phillies record.
Serena Williams aims verbal serve at No. 1 Dinara Safina by claiming to be the world's bestMay 4th, 2009 Serena Williams: I am the real No. 1 _ not SafinaROME — Serena Williams says she's No.
Hot-hitting Longoria's grand slam helps Sonnanstine beat Red Sox 6-2May 2nd, 2009 Longoria grand slam powers RaysST. PETERSBURG, Fla.
Cash believes Murray can be first Brit to win Wimbledon since PerryApril 22nd, 2009 LONDON - Former Wimbledon champion Pat Cash believes Andy Murray can become the first Brit since Fred Perry to win Wimbledon. Australian Cash, who won the men's title himself in 1987, admits he would be surprised if Murray fails to lift a Grand Slam at some point in the near future.
UN says war on drugs has failed, calls for softer approach in dealing with addictsApril 21st, 2009 UN official says war on drugs has failedBANGKOK — The war on drugs has been a failure and nations should take a softer approach in dealing with addicts by providing them with access to treatment and respecting their human rights, a top U.N. rights official said Tuesday.
Brit schoolboy breaks world record with seven-metre slam-dunkApril 19th, 2009 LONDON - A 13-year-old Brit boy has entered record books after slam-dunking a basketball from seven metres away. Gymnast Jordan Ramos, from Sheffield, made it to the Guinness Book of World Record with a seven-metre jump - shattering the previous record of 6.3 metres, reports News of the World.