Court rules for defendants on crime lab reports
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court said Thursday that criminal defendants have a constitutional right to cross-examine the forensic analysts who prepare laboratory reports on illegal drugs and other evidence used at trial.
The court ruled 5-4 for a defendant who was convicted of cocaine trafficking, partly because of crime lab analysis.
Luis Melendez-Diaz challenged lab analysis that confirmed cocaine was in plastic bags found in the car he was riding in. Rather than accept the report, Melendez-Diaz said he should be allowed to question the lab analyst about testing methods, how the evidence was preserved and other issues.
Massachusetts courts rejected his arguments.
Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the high court, said Melendez-Diaz has a constitutional right to confront the lab analyst.
Many states had argued that drug prosecutions would be slowed significantly if prosecutors had to make lab analysts available on a routine basis. Crime labs analyzed 1.9 million substances in following drug arrests in 2006, according to a court filing by 35 states.
About 20 states, including California, do give defendants some right to cross-examine lab employees about forensic evidence.
“Perhaps the best indication that the sky will not fall after today’s decision is that it has not done so already,” Scalia said. Many defense lawyers and their clients would just as soon not call added attention to evidence, he said.
But in dissent, Justice Anthony Kennedy said Scalia misunderstood how criminal trials work.
He predicted that criminal defense lawyers will accept the risk that the testimony will prove even more damaging to their clients on the chance the analyst isn’t available to testify “and the government’s case collapses.”
The case produced unusual alliances. Scalia attracted the votes of Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, David Souter, John Paul Stevens and Clarence Thomas.
Joining Kennedy in dissent were Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Samuel Alito and Stephen Breyer.
The case is Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts, 07-591.
Related News
Man convicted in '97 rape, murder of 13-year-old girl loses appeal before Conn. Supreme CourtAugust 24th, 2009 Conn. Supreme Court rejects appeal in 1997 murderNEW HAVEN, Conn. — The Connecticut Supreme Court rejected the appeal Monday of one of eight people convicted in the rape and murder of a 13-year-old New Milford girl.
Honduran top court says ousted president would face trial if he returnsAugust 23rd, 2009 Honduran top court: Ousted president to face trialTEGUCIGALPA, Honduras — Honduras' Supreme Court says ousted President Manuel Zelaya would face trial if he returns to the Central American country. The Honduran top court is giving its opinion on a plan to solve Honduras' political crisis after Zelaya was ousted in a coup.
Calif Supreme Court orders new look at model's lawsuit over Taster's Choice coffee labelAugust 17th, 2009 Court orders new look at Taster's Choice lawsuitSAN FRANCISCO — The California Supreme Court wants a trial court to come back to a long-running dispute over the use of a former model's image on Taster's Choice coffee labels. A Los Angeles County jury awarded Russell Christoff $15.6 million in 2005 after he discovered Nestle USA had been using his image without permission on its freeze-dried coffee.
Guantanamo pretrial hearing in Sept. 11 case stalls when defendants refuse to attend courtJuly 16th, 2009 Sept. 11 defendants no shows at Gitmo hearingGUANTANAMO BAY NAVAL BASE, Cuba — A pretrial hearing in the Sept. 11 war crimes trial was delayed Thursday when none of the five defendants agreed to attend.
Federal judge says he expects lawsuit against Calif gay marriage ban to reach US Supreme CourtJuly 2nd, 2009 Judge eyes quick action on Calif. gay marriage banSAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge in San Francisco said a lawsuit seeking to overturn California's same-sex marriage ban will likely one day reach the U.S.
Ga. death penalty case likely on hold until fall after US Supreme Court recesses for summerJune 29th, 2009 High court puts Georgia death penalty case on holdSAVANNAH, Ga. — The U.S.
Russian Supreme Court overturns not guilty verdict in Politkovskaya killing, orders new trialJune 25th, 2009 Politkovskaya murder acquittal overturnedMOSCOW — Russia's Supreme Court on Thursday overturned the acquittal of three men charged with the murder of Anna Politkovskaya, a journalist whose reporting directly challenged the country's most powerful leaders. A Moscow jury acquitted the defendants — two Chechen brothers and a former policeman — in February after a trial that Politkovskaya's supporters said was undermined by prosecution errors and omissions.
Russian Supreme Court overturns not guilty verdict in Politkovskaya murder, orders new trialJune 25th, 2009 Lawyer: Politkovskaya murder aquittal overturnedMOSCOW — Russia's Supreme Court has thrown out the acquittal of three men tried for the murder of journalist and Kremlin critic Anna Politkovskaya. Defense lawyer Murad Musayev told The Associated Press that the court reached the decision Thursday and ordered a new trial in the case.
Summary of actions by the Supreme Court on ThursdayJune 18th, 2009 Summary of actions by the Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court on Thursday:
— Ruled that school officials violated an Arizona teenage girl's rights by strip-searching her for prescription-strength ibuprofen, saying that U.S. educators hunting for contraband cannot force students to shed their clothes unless student safety is an issue.
Supreme Court will decide battle between Shell Oil and gas station operatorsJune 15th, 2009 Court steps into dispute between Shell, stationsWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court is stepping into a dispute between Shell Oil Co. and gas station operators who claim the oil company tried to drive them out of business.
Supreme Court to weigh in on rights of Fla. beachfront property ownersJune 15th, 2009 High court steps into Fla. beach erosion disputeWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has stepped into a property-rights dispute over plans to rebuild eroded beaches on Florida's Gulf coast.
High court stays out of fight between Ill. casinos and racetracks in case tied to BlagojevichJune 8th, 2009 High court won't hear casinos-racetracks disputeWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court is staying out a fight between Illinois' casinos and horse tracks over a state law that cropped up in the impeachment and indictment of former Gov. Rod Blagojevich.
Apex court order has put Modi government on trial, says CongressMay 2nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Congress party Friday said the Supreme Court order for speedy trial in the 2002 Gujarat riots cases has put the Narendra Modi-led Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government 'on trial'. 'The Gujarat government is on trial,' Congress spokesperson Kapil Sibal told reporters here.
Media reports: Justice David Souter retiring from Supreme CourtMay 1st, 2009 Media reports: Justice Souter retiringWASHINGTON — News media reports say Justice David Souter plans to retire from the Supreme Court at the end of the court's term in June. Speculation that the 69-year-old justice will be stepping down has been fueled by his failure to appoint law clerks from the fall term.
Supreme Court makes it harder for defendants to block testimony of jailhouse informantsApril 29th, 2009 Defendant loses case over jailhouse informantsWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has made it harder for defendants to keep their comments to jailhouse informants from being used against them at trial. The justices, by a 7-2 vote, said a defendant's statement to an informant can be used to poke holes in trial testimony, even if it was elicited in violation of the Constitution.
Loading ...