STIMULUS WATCH: Obama announces job-counting rules
WASHINGTON — Attention workers: If you’re getting federal stimulus money, stand up and prepare to be counted. And no cheating.
The Obama administration issued its long-awaited rules for tallying jobs Monday and warned that local politicians trying to inflate their numbers would surely be caught.
As part of the $787 billion stimulus law, governors, mayors and contractors must begin reporting job numbers to the federal government in October. The data collected could provide the most accurate count of workers employed by stimulus money, a number that is expected to be far more precise than the murky and unverifiable promise that 3.5 million jobs will be created by the end of next year.
But for months, there has been confusion over what the rules would be. What’s a created job? A saved job? Could a construction worker be counted twice if he worked two part-time contracts? On highway jobs, do you count just the laborers, or also the extra wait staff at the nearby lunch spot?
Under the rules released Monday, the White House told governors, mayors and contractors to keep it simple.
“Just count the people being paid out of Recovery Act dollars,” said Rob Nabors, deputy director at the White House budget office.
To avoid double-counting, a job means a full-time, full-year job. So a student working a 9-to-5 job for his three-month summer vacation will be counted as one-fourth of a job. The part-time teacher who works all year is half a job. And the full-time highway contractor who works all year is one job.
As the figures are released every three months, the data will represent the closest to a stimulus head count as any information available in real time. The number is expected to fall well short of the 3.5 million mark. That’s because there’s no way to reliably tally jobs created by Obama’s $288 billion tax cuts. And the count will not include jobs created by the ripple effect of business spending.
The White House will issue those estimates based on the head count.
“This whole thing is tricky. I’m not going to pretend it’s not,” Nabors said. “This whole effort is virtually unprecedented.”
If the numbers are to be reliable, however, states, cities and contractors must report honestly. White House officials know there are political and financial incentive to cheat: Contractors can use job-creation data as a public relations ploy. Local politicians can turn job numbers into campaign literature. And states that use the money well could be in line to get more of it.
In the absence of these rules, some states have announced jobs based on out-of-date formulas, leading to implausible estimates. Ohio officials, for instance, have estimated that a $20 million bridge construction project will create or save 10,500 jobs.
Nabors said officials will analyze the data for signs of inflation.
“If governors or mayors or contractors make up numbers, it’s not going to take long for that to come to light,” he said.
Since Obama signed the stimulus bill, the nation has shed more than 1.6 million jobs. The president says the stimulus has created or saved 150,000 jobs, but White House advisers acknowledge the estimate is based on a formula that was never intended to count jobs.
On the Net:
American Recovery and Reinvestment Act: www.recovery.gov
Related News
Why doesn't cheating pay in the amoeba worldOctober 12th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Cheaters may prosper in the short term, but they are doomed to fail, at least in the microscopic world of amoebas, say researchers. But why? Shouldn't "survival of the fittest" give the sneaky cheaters an edge? Not necessarily, say researchers.
EU warns action will be taken against protectionism in GM's sale of car unit OpelSeptember 12th, 2009 EU warns against protectionism in GM sale of OpelBRUSSELS — The European Union's competition commissioner has warned she will take action if there is any protectionism in the sale of General Motors Co.'s European unit Opel. The Belgian government says it wants the EU Commission to investigate the Opel deal amid concern that Germany allegedly sought to protect its own plants at the cost of others.
Obama says $787 billion stimulus program is reason economy beginning to turn itself aroundJuly 31st, 2009 Obama credits stimulus for economy's progressWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama says the $787 billion economic stimulus program he enacted within weeks of taking office is helping the economy begin to pull itself out of the recession. The Commerce Department reported Friday that the economy contracted at a pace of just 1 percent in the second quarter.
Pa. bank robbery suspect nabbed while counting loot after handing smiley-face note to tellerJuly 30th, 2009 W. Pa. bank robbery suspect nabbed counting moneyGREENSBURG, Pa. — Police said they caught a bank robbery suspect who was counting the loot as he walked away from a western Pennsylvania heist in which he had handed a teller a polite demand note, complete with a smiley face.
Obama says he will hold off on seeking a second stimulus program for beleaguered economyJune 23rd, 2009 Obama: No new stimulus needed, but quicker resultsWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama says he is not ready to offer a second stimulus plan even though the economy continues to struggle. The president said Tuesday that more time is needed to assess the effectiveness of the $787 billion economic stimulus plan enacted early this year.
Stimulus Watch: Follow along from home as Obama counts jobs toward 3.5 million stimulus goalJune 18th, 2009 Stimulus Watch: Follow along as Obama counts jobsWASHINGTON — Few things in President Barack Obama's economic stimulus plan have engendered as much skepticism or criticism as his oft-repeated promise to create or save 3.5 million jobs by the end of next year. Republicans in Congress have labeled it fuzzy math.
Counting begins in Andhra PradeshMay 16th, 2009 HYDERABAD - The counting of votes polled in the state assembly and Lok Sabha elections in Andhra Pradesh began Saturday amid tight security and high expectations by candidates. The initial trends show ruling Congress party and the main opposition Telugu Desam Party (TDP) leading in one assembly constituency each after the first round of counting.
Obama to keep military tribunals at GuantanamoMay 15th, 2009 WASHINGTON - US President Barack Obama announced Friday that he would keep the Guantanamo military tribunals for trying terror suspects but would enact new rules to enhance their rights. Obama suspended the proceedings shortly after taking office in January pending a review of the process.
Arrangements for vote countMay 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - All eyes are on Saturday's vote count. A glance at the arrangements the Election Commission has made for the mammoth exercise across the country:
* Total counting centres: 1,080
* Total counting halls: 4,260
* Counting staff deployed: approximately 60,000
* Secure arrangements for counting agents of candidates to witness the counting procedure.
Vote counting: Gangtok makes it live and bigMay 13th, 2009 NEW DELHI - For the first time, residents of Sikkim capital Gangtok will watch a live telecast of poll results in the state May 16. That's the day when counting will take place at TNA auditorium.
SPIN METER: Politicians announcing stimulus jobs faster than stimulus can (maybe) create themApril 29th, 2009 SPIN METER: Counting jobs a political numbers gameSILVER SPRING, Md. — When Ed Pegler was laid off from his highway construction job four months ago, the 47-year-old father of two didn't know when he'd be back to work.
SPIN METER: White House announcing stimulus jobs faster than stimulus can (maybe) create themApril 29th, 2009 SPIN METER: The politics of counting stimulus jobsSILVER SPRING, Md. — When Ed Pegler was laid off from his highway construction job four months ago, the 47-year-old father of two didn't know when he'd be back to work.
Lobbyists, allies meet with White House officials to seek end to stimulus lobbying limitsApril 23rd, 2009 Lobbyists ask White House to ease lobbying rulesWASHINGTON — Lobbyists and leaders of public interest groups will meet with White House officials on Friday to seek a roll back of the ban on lobbyists discussing economic stimulus projects with federal officials. President Barack Obama imposed the prohibition last month in hopes of reducing the influence lobbyists might have over how the $787 billion economic stimulus package will be doled out.
US releases stimulus fundsMarch 4th, 2009 WASHINGTON - US Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke Tuesday warned there was 'considerable uncertainty' over how quickly the United States can recover from a deep recession, even as funds from a massive government stimulus package were being released into the economy. While President Barack Obama announced that new infrastructure projects would begin Tuesday and help spur job growth, Bernanke told a Senate hearing that it was difficult to measure the impact of Obama's $787-billion plan.
Obama warns of 'catastrophe' as stimulus debate stalls in CongressFebruary 4th, 2009 WASHINGTON - US President Barack Obama warned of an economic 'catastrophe' if lawmakers were unable to pass an unprecedented economic stimulus package and slammed Republicans for failing to recognise the outcome of the country's general election last year. 'A failure to act, and act now, will turn crisis into a catastrophe and guarantee a longer recession,' Obama warned Wednesday at the White House.