Sick Gazans victims of Hamas-Fatah power struggle
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Hundreds of Palestinian patients have been trapped in the Gaza Strip, unable to travel abroad for crucial treatment for cancer and other diseases, because of political infighting between Gaza’s militant Hamas rulers and their Palestinian rivals.
Eight Gazans who were waiting to travel abroad have died since the crisis began in March, when the dispute shut down a medical referral committee that helps sick residents find treatment outside of Gaza, according to the World Health Organization.
Others are hanging on, waiting. Ten-year-old Ribhi Jindiyeh, a lymphoma patient, lies in bed at home, skinny and jaundiced, too weak to move. He underwent chemotherapy last year in an Israeli hospital, and when he returned home in January, he seemed better. But in March, he began urinating blood.
Gaza doctors can’t find the problem and give him infusions every two days to keep him alive.
“Nobody here knows why he is losing so much blood, but nobody can refer us to a hospital abroad, either,” his mother, Nevine, 38, said.
Another son, 4-year-old Yehia, was diagnosed with lymphoma in March.
“I want everybody to help my son — Israel, Fatah, Hamas, whoever,” Nevine said. “If they can’t help a sick child, who can they help? They should all pack up their bags and go home.”
On Monday, there was hope for a resolution. Hamas health minister Basim Naim announced the restoration of the referral committee, which Hamas’ rival, Fatah, had controlled but Hamas shut down in March.
The committee would resume coordinating medical treatment abroad. But Hamas has reservations and has asked mediating independent health workers to find new committee members both sides can agree on, said senior health official Yousef Mudalal.
That raises the possibility of a new dispute.
The split between Hamas and the Fatah movement of U.S.-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, which controls the West Bank, can have a devastating impact on Gazans’ lives.
Hamas seized control of Gaza in June 2007 after routing forces loyal to Fatah and systematically started taking over government agencies in the tiny Mediterranean territory.
On March 22, Hamas officials took control of the Fatah-run medical committee, which referred about 1,000 patients a month with life-threatening illnesses to Israel and Egypt. Hamas officials said the committee was rife with corruption and needed reform.
In response, the West Bank government, which funds medical treatment for Palestinians abroad, froze most patient transfers.
Gaza patients cannot travel abroad without committee coordination because of a border blockade imposed by Israel and Egypt since the Hamas takeover. The two countries only recognize the West Bank administration as the legitimate Palestinian government.
Rights activists say the political differences are jeopardizing people’s lives.
“They are playing with the lives of people and their pain. There’s a complete absence of responsibility,” said Khalil Shaheen of the Palestinian Center for Human Rights.
The Israeli branch of Physicians for Human Rights, working with the Palestinian Center for Human Rights, has managed to get 35 patients out of Gaza for treatment since the committee collapsed, said Ran Yarom of PHR. But the groups say they don’t have the resources to do the committee’s job.
The crisis compounds the challenges facing Gaza’s medical system. Hospitals use aging equipment and suffer from low medicine supplies.
And in late January, the West Bank government halted payments for medical care in Israel, saying the treatment was too expensive. Fatah health officials said they would only pay for Gaza residents to obtain cheaper medical care in Egypt.
In Gaza City, 12-year-old Mohammed Zibdeh, a brain cancer patient, waits for a permit to travel, breathing with the assistance of a ventilator device in his throat. Last year, doctors in an Israeli hospital worked to shrink his brain tumor with chemotherapy. Now Zibdeh has constant headaches, and his father, Riyad, 48, fears the tumor is growing back.
“I can’t help him, and he might be dying before my own eyes,” he said.
Related News
A look at some of the newly elected Fatah leadersAugust 11th, 2009 A look at some of the newly elected Fatah leadersA look at some of the main figures elected to the 23-member Central Committee of the Western-backed Fatah organization. Marwan Barghouti, 50, a prominent leader of the last Palestinian uprising, is currently serving five life terms in an Israeli prison for his role in deadly shooting attacks.
Rare Fatah convention annoints Palestinian president as party leaderAugust 8th, 2009 Fatah reappoints Palestinian president as its headBETHLEHEM, West Bank —Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas was re-elected to lead his Fatah movement Saturday at its first convention in two decades, giving him a new mandate for peace talks with Israel, if he can also heal divisions among his people. Abbas, who succeeded iconic Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat after his death in 2004, was elected unopposed, but the movement itself has lost its shine over the past five years.
Angry arguments over money and elections erupt at first Fatah conference in 20 yearsAugust 5th, 2009 Angry arguments erupt at Fatah conventionBETHLEHEM, West Bank — Angry arguments over elections and money erupted Wednesday between Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Fatah activists on the second day of the movement's convention. Fatah's first conference in 20 years is meant to elect new leaders, clean up the party's corrupt image and make it more competitive with its bitter rival, the Islamic militant Hamas.
Abbas tells party congress that Palestinians must stick with peace talksAugust 4th, 2009 Abbas: Palestinians must stick with peace talksBETHLEHEM, West Bank — Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas launched his Fatah movement's first conference in two decades Tuesday with a call for his people to limit their resistance to Israel to marches and protests and not to abandon peace talks despite years of setbacks. Abbas spoke at the opening of a convention that marks an attempt by the movement founded by the late Yasser Arafat to rise from division, defeat and failure and to lead the Palestinians to statehood.
Palestinians' Fatah movement seeks renewal, battles chaos in first convention in 20 yearsAugust 4th, 2009 Fatah seeks renewal in first conference since 1989BETHLEHEM, West Bank — The Palestinians' Fatah movement came together Tuesday for its first convention in 20 years, trying to rise from division and defeat with a pragmatic political program and new leaders in what its supporters hope will be the final push toward Palestinian statehood. Fatah's leader, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, expects the three-day convention to boost his standing and strengthen his hand in dealing with his Hamas rivals and with Israel's hawkish prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu.
Fatah holds first conference in 20 yearsAugust 4th, 2009 BETHLEHEM - The Fatah movement of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas began its first party conference in 20 years Tuesday. More than 2,000 delegates gathered in the southern West Bank city of Bethlehem for the three-day event.
Tarnished but still critical to Mideast peace effort, Palestinian party seeks image makeoverAugust 1st, 2009 Fatah, West's hope for peace, faces critical testRAMALLAH, West Bank — Fatah, the divided and demoralized movement of the late Yasser Arafat and the West's best hope for delivering a Mideast peace deal, is trying to stage a comeback. On Tuesday, Fatah is supposed to open its first convention in 20 years, hoping to clean up its corruption-tainted image and transform itself into a vibrant alternative to the Islamic militants of Hamas.
Hamas threatens to derail convention of rival Fatah movement unless its prisoners freedJuly 27th, 2009 Hamas threatens to derail Fatah conferenceRAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian rivals Hamas and Fatah on Monday were locked in a new dispute that threatens to derail next week's Fatah convention, seen as key to rehabilitating the corruption-stained party that has led peace talks with Israel. Officials in Hamas-ruled Gaza said Monday they would only allow Fatah delegates to leave the territory and travel to the conference if Fatah's leader, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, releases hundreds of Hamas detainees in the West Bank, where his Western-backed Palestinian Authority is based.
Palestinian factions arrest rivals to strengthen their grip on the West Bank, GazaJuly 3rd, 2009 Palestinians detain rivals to strengthen gripRAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas' security forces have significantly widened a crackdown on Hamas in the West Bank in the past month. They have doubled the number of detainees and are increasingly targeting the wives of activists, school teachers and others on the fringes of the Islamic militant group, Hamas officials say.
Fatah, Hamas fail to reconcileJuly 1st, 2009 GAZA/CAIRO - Leaders of rival Fatah and Islamic Hamas movement failed to overcome their disputes and reach an agreement by a July 7 deadline set by Cairo, and have agreed to hold a seventh round of dialogue in Cairo July 25, officials said Tuesday. Fatah negotiator Zakareya el-Agha told the Palestinian news agency Wafa of President Mahmoud Abbas that a sixth round of inter-reconciliation dialogue had ended without agreement.
Israel deflects Quartet, G-8 calls for settlement freezeJune 27th, 2009 Israel deflects calls for settlement freezeJERUSALEM — Israel deflected growing international demands for a settlement freeze Saturday, saying the issue should be dealt with in future peace talks with the Palestinians. On Friday, the Quartet of Mideast mediators and foreign ministers from the Group of Eight industrialized nations, meeting in Italy, called for a halt in construction.
6 dead in West Bank flare-up between Hamas, Palestinian policeMay 31st, 2009 6 dead in internal Palestinian fightingQALQILIYA, West Bank — Palestinian security officials say six people have been killed in a firefight between Hamas fighters and Palestinian policemen in the West Bank. The officials say three of the men are Palestinian policemen loyal to President Mahmoud Abbas of Fatah.
Aide: Palestinian president to form new government without Hamas after unity talksMay 8th, 2009 Palestinian president to form new governmentRAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas plans to ask his prime minister within the coming week to form a new government without the Gaza Strip's Hamas rulers, signaling a breakdown in unity talks with the Islamic militant group. Months of power-sharing talks between Abbas' Fatah movement and Hamas have gone nowhere.
Palestinian talks still stalled on unity cabinet platformMarch 19th, 2009 GAZA CITY/CAIRO - Palestinian factions had agreed in Cairo that the unity government they are trying to form will be a transitional one that would prepare for new elections to be held no later than Jan 25, 2010, Hamas has said. But the sides had reached no breakthrough Wednesday on the government's platform, with the main point of disagreement remaining whether it should endorse past interim peace deals signed by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO), expressing recognition of Israel and calling for a two-state solution to the Middle East conflict.
Israel wants open ceasefire without time limit: HamasFebruary 13th, 2009 GAZA CITY - Israel has rejected an 18-month ceasefire with Hamas and wants an open lull without a time-limit, the Islamist Hamas movement said Saturday. Fawzi Barhoum, a Hamas spokesman, said that Egypt, which has mediated between Israel and Hamas, and his movement can't accept such an open lull in accordance with Israel's request.