Undecided Democrat mulls health care options
WASHINGTON — All eyes are on Maine Republican Sen. Olympia Snowe as health care legislation heads for a high-stakes committee vote next week. But she’s not the only senator who is being noncommittal.
Oregon Democrat Ron Wyden isn’t saying how he’ll vote when the Finance Committee takes up Chairman Max Baucus’s 10-year, $829-billion plan next Tuesday.
“I am not going to characterize where I am (on the bill) in any way,” Wyden said Friday as he headed to the airport for a trip back to his state.
“I’m going to be doing everything I can to make sure hardworking Americans aren’t forced to buy unaffordable coverage from monopolies,” he added, making his discomfort clear.
For Wyden to be on the fence is an odd turn of events. He’s been calling for an overhaul of the nation’s health care system for years. He wrote the Healthy Americans Act, a bill that won bipartisan support.
Not only that, his bill got a coveted appraisal from the Congressional Budget Office that it would cover all Americans without adding to the deficit. Instead of creating a new government health plan, it would force private insurers to compete with one another as they’ve never had to before.
While economists judged Wyden’s approach to be an elegant solution, President Barack Obama and Democratic leaders decided that politically, it went too far. It would have loosened the link between health insurance and the workplace, and shifted many Medicaid recipients into private coverage.
Wyden’s plan has been pushed off to the sidelines, and he’s now trying to decide where he belongs. The Baucus bill, as he sees it, limits choice, falls short on cost control, and fails to meet the test of providing affordable coverage for all Americans — particularly solid middle-class families headed by a self-employed person.
Democrats have a 13-10 advantage on the Finance Committee, so Baucus, D-Mont., doesn’t need Wyden’s vote to pass a bill. But Wyden’s dissent would send a message. A liberal on social issues, he’s seen as middle-of-the-road on economic matters.
“It would be both troublesome and ironic if Sen. Wyden voted against this legislation,” said Ron Pollack, executive director of Families USA, a liberal health care advocacy group. “He has been an outspoken leader in promoting the need for health care reform, and a negative vote would defeat the very objectives that the senator has promoted.”
Finance member Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., said Friday in a call with reporters there is only one Democrat who has not indicated how he will vote.
Wyden said his aides will be talking with Baucus’s staff during the weekend. He is positioning himself for a floor debate in which he’s expected to offer a version of his original bill.
“My take is that this cake is far from baked,” Wyden said.
Related News
Climactic Senate Finance committeevote scheduled Tuesday on 10-year, $829B health care billOctober 8th, 2009 After long debate, health care Senate vote TuesdayWASHINGTON — The top Senate Democrat says the final committee vote on health care legislation will take place next week. Nevada Democratic Sen.
Senate health care bill estimated to cost $829 billion, cover 94 percent of AmericansOctober 7th, 2009 Senate health care bill to cost $829 billionWASHINGTON — Health care legislation drafted by a key Senate committee would expand coverage to 94 percent of the eligible population at a 10-year cost of $829 billion, congressional budget experts said Wednesday in a preliminary estimate. The Congressional Budget Office added that the measure would reduce federal deficits by $81 billion over a decade and probably lead to "continued reductions in federal budget deficits" in the years beyond.
Congressional tax experts say industry taxes are $29 billion higher in health billOctober 6th, 2009 Higher taxes in health care billWASHINGTON — Congressional tax experts say Senate health care legislation would impose $29 billion more in taxes on health care industries than originally thought. The Joint Committee on Taxation says drug companies, medical device manufacturers and insurers would pay $121 billion over 10 years as a result of taxes in the Senate Finance Committee bill.
Senate Finance Committee vote slips as lawmakers wait for cost figuresOctober 5th, 2009 Senate committee vote slipsWASHINGTON — It's going to take a little longer for the last congressional committee writing health care legislation to finish its work. Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus of Montana had hoped for a final vote by his panel on Tuesday, but a cost analysis from the Congressional Budget Office isn't ready yet.
Senate Democratic leader has tough task ahead in finalizing health care legislationOctober 5th, 2009 Dem leader faces tough job in crafting health billWASHINGTON — Forget mission accomplished. Try mission seemingly impossible.
Republican says Democrats are ignoring Americans' concerns over health care reformsSeptember 26th, 2009 Republican says Dems ignoring health care concernsWASHINGTON — Republicans say Democrats have ignored the public's concerns in drafting new health care legislation under debate in the Senate Finance Committee. Democrats are giving the public anything but an "open, honest and bipartisan debate," Sen.
Democrats, Republicans ready fresh challenges to far-reaching health care overhaul billSeptember 24th, 2009 Tensions on rise in health care debateWASHINGTON — Tempers are flaring as the Senate Finance Committee starts its third day of exhaustive deliberations on a sweeping overhaul of the health care system. Republican Sen.
Finance Committee adopts amendment to encourage innovative care of ailing seniorsSeptember 22nd, 2009 Measure would encourage innovations for the illWASHINGTON — The Senate Finance Committee has adopted the first amendment to a sweeping health overhaul bill, agreeing to a measure to encourage innovative care for hospitalized Medicare patients. Approval of the amendment by Democratic Senator Kent Conrad of North Dakota came late Tuesday as Democrats struggled to push forward on the first day of debate on the legislation.
Baucus says he expects Republican support for health care bill on final committee voteSeptember 16th, 2009 Baucus calls health care bill commonsense measureWASHINGTON — A prominent Democratic senator is calling his 10-year, $856 billion health care bill a common sense measure that can win broad support. Sen. Max Baucus, chairman of the Finance Committee, unveiled his much-awaited legislation Wednesday after months of bipartisan negotiations that failed to win visible Republican support.
White House Quip: Obama would go to moon in pursuit of deal to overhaul health care system nowAugust 19th, 2009 White House: Obama would go to moon for his goalWASHINGTON — How far is President Barack Obama willing to go for a deal on overhauling the health care system?
Try all the way to the moon. White House spokesman Robert Gibbs joked Wednesday that Obama would orbit the moon if he thought it would help get a deal on a bill Congress can vote on after it returns from summer break.
GOP senator involved in bipartisan talks tamps down expectations for health care billJuly 30th, 2009 GOP senator says health care bill not readyWASHINGTON — A key Republican senator involved in bipartisan talks on health care says there's no way a breakthrough will happen before lawmakers' August recess. Wyoming Sen.
Obama tells Congress he wants health care legislation by August recessJuly 10th, 2009 Obama to Congress: Health care legislation by Aug.L'AQUILA, Italy — Despite snags in Congress, President Barack Obama says his administration is closer to achieving health care reform than at any time in recent history. He says he hopes Congress will pass health care legislation by the August recess but "nothing is do or die."
Obama says he is making health care his "highest legislative priority".
AP sources: Cost of Senate Finance Committee draft health care bill tops $1.6 trillionJune 16th, 2009 AP sources: Senate health overhaul costs top $1.6TWASHINGTON — The latest cost estimates for health care legislation in Congress are around $1.6 trillion over 10 years, two Senate sources said Tuesday as concerns mounted over the price tag for the sweeping overhaul. Two Senate staffers, one Democratic and one Republican, said Congressional Budget Office estimates put the cost of the Finance Committee version of the bill at around $1.6 trillion.
Dodd says taxing benefits to pay for health care overhaul is a bad idea and unnecessaryJune 14th, 2009 Senator says tax on health benefits is unnecessaryWASHINGTON — A leading Democratic senator says the idea of taxing health benefits is a bad one and unnecessary. Sen. Chris Dodd of Connecticut says that people are struggling economically at the moment and don't need a new tax on the health care benefits they receive.
Top Senate Democrats Baucus, Kennedy say they'll work together on health care overhaulMay 30th, 2009 Top Democrats pledge cooperation on health careWASHINGTON — The two Senate Democrats leading the drive to overhaul health care say they will work together to come up with legislation. Sens. Max Baucus and Edward Kennedy said in a joint statement Saturday they intend to cooperate so their committees pass similar bills that can be combined into a single piece of legislation before the Senate leaves for its August recess.
Loading ...