Schumer wants Cayuga land trust review redone
AUBURN, N.Y. — U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer said Tuesday that federal officials must do a more detailed study on how the local economy would be affected if 129 acres of upstate New York land are put into trust for the Cayuga Indian Nation.
At a press conference with business leaders and local elected officials from Cayuga and Seneca counties, Schumer criticized a preliminary assessment made by the federal Bureau of Indian Affairs, which found there would be little or no negative impact.
“They showed no understanding of what’s going on,” Schumer said. “The whole system is out of whack. The only good news about this statement is that it is the draft. We have to make them go back to the drawing board, which is where they should go.
“They’re not dealing with reality,” Schumer said. “To say there would be no effect defies the imagination.”
Schumer said the BIA did not take into account the full economic toll of putting the land into trust, where it would be exempt from state and local laws and taxes. He also said no consideration was given to several pending lawsuits.
“You cannot, in a densely populated county, take various parts of the land and say they’re under a totally different jurisdiction, totally different laws,” Schumer said.
A primary concern is fear the tribe could develop some sort of gaming enterprise that would allow them to buy even more land. The Oneida Indian Nation operates Turning Stone Casino and Resort in nearby Oneida County, and it has reeled in hundreds of millions of dollars in profits since opening in the 1990s.
“They could cherrypick whatever properties they wanted, pay exorbitant prices for them, and then take them off the tax rolls,” said David Dresser, chairman of the Indian affairs committee of Seneca County. “It’s absurd, it is biased and I want to tell you the impact is huge.”
A call seeking comment from Dan French, the lawyer for Cayuga Indian Nation who is handling the tribe’s application to put the land into trust, was not immediately returned.
Schumer noted that the study also did not address how the environment, particularly Cayuga Lake, would be protected without local, county, or state regulation. Trust lands are governed by federal law.
The land is in Cayuga and Seneca counties about 50 miles west of Syracuse. It includes two convenience stores with gas stations operated by the Cayugas.
The federal government holds 66 million acres of land in trust for Indian tribes, mostly in western states.
Related News
Schumer proposes measures to help prevent aircraft crashes over Hudson RiverAugust 31st, 2009 Schumer proposal aims to avert crashes over HudsonNEW YORK — Sen. Charles Schumer is proposing new measures he says would help prevent another crash over the Hudson River like the one that killed nine people this month.
Utah judge authorizes sale of 400 acres of polygamous sect's land in bidding processAugust 24th, 2009 Utah judge orders sale of polygamous sect's landSALT LAKE CITY — A Utah judge has ordered the sale of a 400-acre parcel of land that is part of a trust established by followers of jailed polygamous sect leader Warren Jeffs. In a ruling issued Monday, 3rd District Court Judge Denise Lindberg says a liquidity crisis of the United Effort Plan Trust makes the sale of Berry Knoll necessary.
3,000 Chinese villagers clash with police to protest compensation in land deal, report saysJuly 26th, 2009 Report: 3,000 villagers protest in eastern ChinaBEIJING — More than 3,000 villagers in eastern China blocked a highway and clashed with police while protesting alleged official corruption in a land compensation deal, a human rights monitor and a witness said Sunday. Ten residents of Shipu town, in Zhejiang province, were injured in the clash with more than 300 riot police Saturday, the Hong Kong-based Information Center for Human Rights and Democracy said in a faxed statement.
Utah judge rejects polygamous church trust settlement proposalJuly 23rd, 2009 Judge rejects polygamous church trust settlementSALT LAKE CITY — A judge has rejected a proposed settlement that would have returned control of a state-managed land trust back to followers of polygamous leader Warren Jeffs. The United Effort Plan Trust was formed in 1942 to hold the collective assets of members of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.
Senator says immigration law should require all workers to verify they can hold US jobsJuly 21st, 2009 Senator: All workers should get eligibility checkWASHINGTON — The Senate Democrat leading the push for changes in immigration law says verifying that people are legally employed will require all workers — citizens and immigrants — to prove they are eligible to hold jobs in the U.S. New York Democratic Sen.
Florida cremation company fined over Colorado trust fund totalsJuly 16th, 2009 Fla. cremation company fined in ColoradoDENVER — A cremation provider that turns human remains into an undersea reef and other memorials will pay $1.2 million in fines for violating Colorado insurance laws. Neptune Management Corp.
NY counties plan appeal of court ruling allowing Cayugas to again sell untaxed cigarettesJuly 13th, 2009 NY counties plan to appeal Indian cigarette rulingAUBURN, N.Y. — Local officials said they will file a notice of appeal following a court decision that allows the Cayuga Indian Nation to resume selling untaxed cigarettes at two tribal stores in central New York.
NY's Sen. Schumer prods MTA on wireless Internet access on railsJune 15th, 2009 NY Sen. urges MTA action on wireless InternetGARDEN CITY, N.Y. — Sen. Charles Schumer contends the commuter railroads serving New York City have been slow to implement wireless Internet service.
Officials want a change in law to shut down safe houses used in human-trafficking schemesJune 11th, 2009 Officials want more pressure on human traffickingWASHINGTON — The Obama administration and Sen. Chuck Schumer want to step up pressure on human-trafficking operations by taking away their safe houses.
Sotomayor nomination 'virtually filibuster-proof,' leading Democratic senator saysMay 31st, 2009 Schumer: Sotomayor 'virtually filibuster-proof'WASHINGTON — A leading Democratic senator says that President Barack Obama's Supreme Court nominee is "virtually filibuster-proof" when his colleagues look at her record. Sen. Chuck Schumer of New York said Sunday that Sonia Sotomayor's nomination is heading toward confirmation.
New York's Schumer seeks federal investigation into 'warranty about to expire' phone spamMay 10th, 2009 NY's Schumer asks for probe into phone spamNEW YORK — A New York senator is asking for an investigation into the spam phone calls pitching bogus car warranties that many Americans receive several times a day. Sen. Charles Schumer says the scam artists are using random call generators allowing them to contact people who are on the "do not call" list.
Schumer calling for federal investigation into 'nuisance' vehicle warranty phone spamMay 10th, 2009 Schumer calls for probe into phone spamNEW YORK — Unsolicited calls to home and cell phones warning of a final notice and an expiring vehicle warranty are a nuisance and harassment and should be the subject of a federal investigation, a U.S. senator said Sunday.
NY's Schumer filing legislation making it mandatory for airports to report bird strikesMay 6th, 2009 Schumer: Mandate bird strike reportingWASHINGTON — New York Sen. Chuck Schumer said Wednesday that each time a bird hits an airplane, it should be reported to the Federal Aviation Administration.
Minister concedes 'shortcomings' in Left Front's land reformsMarch 12th, 2009 KOLKATA - Conceding that there were 'shortcomings' in the Left Front government's land reforms programme, West Bengal's Transport and Sports Minister Subhas Chakraborty Wednesday said the front would have to make way for an improved alternative in due course of time. 'There are some shortcomings in our land reforms project.
Despite land row, Tuticorin power project set to go aheadMarch 2nd, 2009 CHENNAI - Neyveli Lignite Corp (NLC) will go ahead with its 1,000-MW power project in Tuticorin in Tamil Nadu despite a legal tussle over part of the project land between SPIC Electric Power Corp and the Tuticorin Port Trust, a top official said. 'NLC or its power subsidiary will not be affected by the land dispute.
Loading ...