RI judge tosses patent verdict against Microsoft
SEATTLE — A federal judge in Rhode Island threw out a $388 million patent infringement jury verdict against Microsoft Corp., the latest move in a six-year legal skirmish.
In April, a jury found that the world’s largest software maker had infringed on a patent owned by Uniloc Inc.
Irvine, Calif.-based Uniloc makes software that prevents people from illegally installing software on multiple computers. Uniloc had argued Microsoft’s “product activation” system used in Windows XP, Office XP and Office 2003 programs infringed on several parts of a related patent, and that the software maker had copied Uniloc’s technology rather than developed similar work on its own.
Uniloc’s original lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Rhode Island in 2003. Microsoft won summary judgment in 2007, and Uniloc appealed. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit sent a much narrower version of the case back to district court, which ruled in Uniloc’s favor earlier this year. Microsoft asked the judge to reconsider.
U.S. District Judge William Smith dismissed the jury verdict in a decision made public late Tuesday.
“The Court has reviewed the transcripts and evidence with painstaking detail in the light most favorable to Uniloc, careful not to act as the eleventh juror. What remains is a firm belief (indeed a certitude) that the jury ‘lacked a grasp of the issues before it’ and reached a finding without a legally sufficient basis,” Smith wrote, finding once again that Microsoft did not infringe on the patent.
Smith also said the jury’s method of deciding how much Microsoft owed Uniloc, based on total sales of Windows XP and Office, was flawed.
Uniloc said it plans to appeal the judge’s latest decision.
“We believe that the jury’s verdict in April was thoughtful, well reasoned and supported by the evidence presented,” said Brad Davis, Uniloc’s CEO, in a statement.
Microsoft, based in Redmond, Wash., said in a statement that is pleased with the outcome.
__
Associated Press Writer Eric Tucker in Providence, R.I., contributed to this report.
Related News
NY judge: 400 voices in Google book dispute means speakers at public hearing may be limitedSeptember 16th, 2009 Judge may limit speakers in Google books hearingNEW YORK — A New York judge says about 400 submissions were filed with his chambers prior to a hearing on a hotly disputed class-action settlement that would give Google Inc. the digital rights to millions of out-of-print books.
Dish to pay TiVo $200 mln for violating injunction on technology that rewinds, pauses live TVSeptember 4th, 2009 Dish to pay TiVo $200 mln for injunction violationA federal judge on Friday ordered Dish Network Corp. and sister firm EchoStar Corp.
Texas judge OKs patent judgment against Microsoft, tells it to stop selling Word in 60 daysAugust 13th, 2009 Microsoft ordered to pay $290M in patent rulingSEATTLE — A federal judge in Texas has ordered Microsoft Corp. to stop selling some versions of its Word software in the U.S.
Judge tosses lawsuit against ordinance that would require Philly tour guides to be licensedAugust 6th, 2009 Judge tosses lawsuit against Philly tour guide lawPHILADELPHIA — A federal judge has dismissed a free-speech lawsuit in which Philadelphia tour guides challenged an ordinance that would require them to take tests and be licensed. The Philadelphia City Council passed the ordinance last year hoping to ensure tourists aren't misinformed by poorly trained guides.
EU says Microsoft has offered concessions to settle Internet Explorer antitrust actionJuly 24th, 2009 EU: Microsoft trying to settle browser caseBRUSSELS — Microsoft Corp. will offer computer users a choice of Web browsers to ward off new European Union antitrust fines, EU regulators said Friday.
Judge rejects plaintiff's lawsuit against cup maker in first-of-its-kind patent caseJuly 8th, 2009 Judge closes door on legal quirk in patent lawALEXANDRIA, Va. — A federal judge has turned away a first-of-its-kind lawsuit filed by an attorney seeking to exploit a quirk in federal patent law that had been dormant for more than a century.
Big fine could be big trouble for both defendants and recording industry in file-sharing caseJune 19th, 2009 Big fine could be big trouble in downloading caseMINNEAPOLIS — The $1.92 million verdict against a Minnesota woman accused of sharing 24 songs over the Internet could ratchet up the pressure on other defendants to settle with the recording industry — if the big fine can withstand an appeal. "Normally in our American legal system, we say the punishment should fit the crime," said Ken Port, director of the Intellectual Property Institute at William Mitchell College of Law in St.
Judge upholds $4 million verdict in "Flip This House" lawsuit in SC by creator against A&EJune 18th, 2009 Judge upholds $4M verdict in "Flip" lawsuit in SCCHARLESTON, S.C. — A federal judge in South Carolina has upheld a $4 million verdict for the creator and one-time host of cable television's "Flip This House".
Judge tosses lawsuit against Oracle dating from dot-com eraJune 17th, 2009 Judge tosses long-running lawsuit against OracleSAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge has thrown out a long-running lawsuit accusing Oracle Corp. of misleading investors about the company's health before the tech meltdown of 2001 whacked its sales and stock price.
Judge dismisses Guardian Media's patent-infringement claim against NintendoJune 12th, 2009 Judge tosses patent claim against NintendoREDMOND, Wash. — A judge has dismissed a patent-infringement lawsuit against Nintendo over the company's Wii video game machine.
Verdict for Georgia terror suspect to be announced by federal judge in AtlantaJune 10th, 2009 Judge's verdict for Ga. terror suspect expectedATLANTA — A federal judge is soon expected to announce his verdict in the case of a former Georgia Tech student charged with plotting to aid a terrorist group.
Supreme Court to decide whether to limit 'business method' patentsJune 1st, 2009 Court to decide whether to limit patentsWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has decided to take on an appeal that could decide whether someone can get a patent for a complex business idea. The high court on Monday decided to hear an appeal from Bernard Bilski and Rand Warsaw, who attempted to patent a method for managing weather-related risk having to do with trading in commodities.
Serverside Group granted second patent on core card customization architectureMay 21st, 2009 LONDON - Global technology provider, Serverside Group, announced that the Indian Patent Office has granted a patent directed to its core card customization architecture, thus establishing an international trend. Since the Indian filing was part of an international strategy, the grant of the Indian patent, which follows the grant of a European Patent, not only enhances Serverside's competitive position in India but indicates the likely outcome in other territories yet to come to grant.
Federal judge upholds $100M Mattel verdict over Bratz dolls, appoints receiver for MGAApril 28th, 2009 Judge upholds $100M Mattel verdict over BratzRIVERSIDE, Calif. — A federal judge upheld a $100 million jury verdict Monday for Mattel Inc.
Microsoft to invest in Gujarat's education sectorJanuary 14th, 2009 AHMEDABAD - Global software giant Microsoft will invest in training teachers in Gujarat and enhance the use of IT in the education sector. Microsoft India Pvt Ltd signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the Gujarat government at the Vibrant Gujarat Global Investors' Summit this week.
Loading ...