Federal program misses problem nursing homes
WASHINGTON — A government program that brings extra scrutiny to poorly performing nursing homes leaves out hundreds of troubled facilities, investigators report.
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services identifies up to 136 nursing homes as “special focus facilities” subject to more frequent inspections because of their living conditions. In every state except for Alaska, there are between one and six such facilities. But investigators said four times as many homes, or 580, could be considered among the nation’s worst.
The report from the Government Accountability Office does not identify the homes.
The chairman of the Senate Aging Committee said it indicated to him that the special focus is too limited. At the least, Sen. Herb Kohl, D-Wis., wants more explicit warnings about nursing homes as people study quality ratings on a Medicare Web site, Nursing Home Compare — www.medicare.gov/nhcompare
“If far more than 136 nursing homes boast the bleakest conditions, then perhaps we should consider expanding” the program, said Kohl, who requested the study with Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa.
The GAO said it made just that recommendation two years ago. Federal officials agreed with the concept, but said they didn’t have the resources to do so.
The report being released Monday also suggests adjusting the methods used to identify the worst performing nursing homes. The home now under special attention are the worst performing in their state. But not all states are created equal when it comes to nursing home quality. Comparing the homes nationally would ensure that scarce resources go to inspecting the nursing homes that truly need the most attention, according to the report.
CMS officials told the GAO they disagreed with relying solely on a national comparison. The agency said it would consider an approach that allows for a national comparison to have more weight.
Some states have far more poorly performing nursing homes than are designated as special focus facilities. For example, Indiana had 52 nursing homes listed as among the worst performing, but only four are on the special list; California has 40 considered among the worst performing, but only four are on the list.
Ohio has five nursing homes on the special focus list but only three that investigators considered among the nation’s worst.
Investigators also found that the worst-performing ones tend to be for-profit facilities affiliated with a chain of nursing homes. They are more likely to be a larger facility, averaging 102 residents, while other nursing homes not identified as among the worst had 89 residents on average.
Nationally, there are about 16,000 nursing homes. So the 580 homes that GAO describes as the worst-performing represents almost 4 percent of the nation’s nursing homes.
Grassley urged policymakers and regulators to pay attention to the report, and use the findings to improve quality and better protect nursing home residents.
On the Net:
Government Accountability Office: www.gao.gov
Senate Special Committee on Aging: www.aging.senate.gov
Related News
Task force to address assaults, rapes, murders in Illinois nursing homesOctober 8th, 2009 Task force targets violence in Ill. nursing homesCHICAGO — A pattern of assaults, rapes and murders in Illinois nursing homes has leaders from a half-dozen state agencies promising to come up with recommendations for Gov.
Noncriminal immigrants could be housed in hotels, nursing homes under detention reformsOctober 5th, 2009 Hotels, other sites may house detained immigrantsWASHINGTON — Former hotels, nursing homes and other sites would be used to hold immigrants who are not criminals or violent as part of a larger plan to reform immigration detention proposed by the homeland security secretary, according to documents obtained Monday by The Associated Press. Janet Napolitano is proposing that illegal immigrants awaiting deportation be confined according to the risk they may pose and will detail her plan on Tuesday.
US nursing homes pushed to brink: fund cuts, recession force layoffs, cutbacks, closingsOctober 4th, 2009 Waves of new fund cuts imperil US nursing homesHARTFORD, Conn. — The nation's nursing homes are perilously close to laying off workers, cutting services — possibly even closing — because of a perfect storm wallop from the recession and deep federal and state government spending cuts, industry experts say.
US youth fare poorly in OECD survey of childhood welfare, despite above-average spendingSeptember 1st, 2009 US youth fare poorly in child welfare surveyPARIS — American youths suffer among the industrialized world's worst rates of infant mortality, teenage pregnancy and child poverty, even though the United States spends more per child than better-performing countries such as Switzerland, Japan and the Netherlands, a new survey indicates. The OECD, a Paris-based watchdog of industrialized nations, urged the U.S.
Scary metaphors can affect public healthAugust 9th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Using scary metaphors for any kind of natural disaster or health scare can not only make people notice it, but it can also spread panic or cynicism among populations, according to a study. "Such terms can make people sit up and listen, but they can also lead to panic or cynicism," said Professor Brigitte Nerlich, who led the research.
A look at details of health care bill passed by the Senate health committeeJuly 16th, 2009 A look at the Senate health committee billA look at the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee:
WHO'S COVERED: Aims to cover 97 percent of Americans. COST: About $615 billion over 10 years, but it's only one piece of a larger Senate bill.
Men better than women at hammering nailsJune 29th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Men can hammer a nail with a few, clean sharp strokes and are better at it than women, says a new study. Duncan Irschick and colleagues at the University of Massachusetts in Amherst (U-M) measured hammering performance in men and women.
A look at how much major industries increased spending on lobbying in the past few yearsJune 18th, 2009 Many industries are spending more on lobbyingHere's the rate at which major industries increased spending on lobbying in Washington between 2006 and 2008:
— Oil & Gas: 73 percent
— Air Transport: 59 percent
— Electric Utilities: 43 percent
— Pharmaceuticals/Health Products: 29 percent
— Business Associations: 24 percent
— Misc. Manufacturing & Distributing: 21 percent
— Education: 17 percent
— Hospitals/Nursing Homes: 16 percent
— Insurance: 14 percent
— Computers/Internet: 4 percent
Source: Center for Responsive Politics, disclosure filings with U.S.
Praful Patel says nursing Air India his top priorityMay 28th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Nursing state-run carrier Air India back to financial health will be the top priority for Praful Patel, as he listed his main agenda for the ministry soon after being named minister of state for civil aviation once again. "As soon as I was given aviation (portfolio), I got a call from the Air India chairman and managing director.
Japan's lower house passes record extra budget to finance stimulus measuresMay 13th, 2009 Japan lower house OKs record extra budgetTOKYO — Japan's lower house of parliament approved a record extra budget of nearly 15 trillion yen ($156 billion) Wednesday to finance stimulus measures aimed at lifting the world's second-largest economy out of recession. The extra budget will finance projects to support the unemployed and small businesses, as well as environmental measures.
Hawaii overturns nursing care law that kept couple married 63 years from living togetherApril 23rd, 2009 Hawaii overturns law keeping married couple apartHONOLULU — A couple forced to live apart after more than 60 years of marriage will soon be reunited thanks to a new law changing Hawaii's rules for residential nursing care. Gov. Linda Lingle signed a measure Wednesday that will allow 87-year-old Terry Kaide to move into the same residential care home as her husband Sidney, 89, for the first time in two years.
Our eyes seek new targets while searching for somethingApril 15th, 2009 WASHINGTON - People's attention does not return time and again to the objects they have already seen while searching for something, but they tend to shift their eyes to previously fixated locations when performing other visual tasks, according to a study. Psychologists Michael D.
Heather Schmid targeted by terrorists after performing for Musharraf?March 19th, 2009 WASHINGTON - World-renowned classical singer Heather Schmid has revealed that her private performance for Pakistan's then-President Pervez Musharraf has made her a target for terrorists threats. Schmid had been in Pakistan to perform in a music festival to raise funds for the country after the devastating earthquakes in 2006, and she became so popular there that she was invited to do a private performance at the Governor's Mansion.
Obama for reducing dependence on foreign nursesMarch 7th, 2009 WASHINGTON - President Barack Obama has proposed an increase in the nursing education budget in a bid to end America's dependence on foreign nurses, a large majority of whom come from India, China and the Philippines. 'The notion that we would have to import nurses makes absolutely no sense,' he said at a White House Forum on Health Care Thursday when a lawmaker pointed out that America's huge shortage of nurses may mount to over 500,000 in the next seven years.
ISI could infiltrate through Sri Lanka: ChidambaramFebruary 25th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The government is alive to the threat of Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) attempting to infiltrate its operatives into south India via Sri Lanka and has taken steps to counter this, Home Minister P. Chidambaram said Wednesday.
Loading ...
October 1st, 2009 at 9:29 am
The reason I’ve found the government doesn’t enforce the laws against nursing homes is simple: CORRUPTION
Check out how the State of California DIDN’T enforce a permanent injunction against SUN Healthcare Group Inc. in 2003 and my mother died along with others:
sunhealthcaregroupinc.blogspot.com/
Deborah Calvert
Newport Beach, California