Obama ‘pay czar’ to review compensation plans
WASHINGTON — The Obama administration’s “pay czar” is embarking on a review of proposed compensation packages for the top employees at seven companies that are on government life support, marking the first time a federal official will have veto power over how much private-sector executives are compensated.
Kenneth Feinberg, who ran the government’s fund for families of the victims of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, has 60 days to approve or reject the compensation plans submitted this week from bailout recipients. They include American International Group Inc. and General Motors.
He is expected to complete his review by late October, although Treasury spokesman Andrew Williams said Friday that the 60-day clock will not start until Feinberg makes a determination that a company’s submission is “substantially complete.” He said it could take some days if not weeks for Feinberg to make that determination for each of the seven companies.
Friday was the last day the companies could submit proposed pay packages for their 25 highest earners. Feinberg is expected to negotiate the packages with the companies and will also approve broader compensation formulas that will apply to the 75 next-highest-paid workers at each company.
Feinberg will have a difficult balancing act: He faces pressure to curb diamond-studded compensation packages that have led to public outrage. At the same time, he must ensure that financial institutions and car companies can keep talented executives needed to steer them clear of government assistance. Free market advocates, meanwhile, fault the government’s role in overseeing the private compensation.
“In our country’s heritage, we do not look kindly on the federal government insinuating itself into the private marketplace and micromanaging these companies,” Feinberg told National Public Radio in June. “On the other hand, there’s this populist sentiment today that there was excessive compensation paid to high-level company officials.”
Compensation experts say Feinberg will likely seek changes that would align pay packages with executives’ performance.
The updates could include disbursing executive pay over a few years so the long-term results of their decisions become clear, allowing banks to revoke some of that pay if the bankers’ bets go bad, or having them pay more compensation in restricted stock — which can rise and fall in value based on a company’s performance — and less in cash.
“He needs to find a way to review those executive compensation packages from the perspective of the long-term and this is very, very difficult for an outsider,” said George Tsetsekos, dean of Drexel University’s LeBow College of Business.
Feinberg has been consulting with the companies that have received “exceptional assistance” from the government. Besides AIG and General Motors Co., they include Bank of America Corp., Citigroup Inc., GMAC Inc., Chrysler Group LLC and Chrysler Financial. The companies owe more than $200 billion in federal assistance.
The companies have said little about the process. GM spokeswoman Julie Gibson said the company believes “our compensation is within the rules. We’ve submitted everything they’ve asked for. We’re waiting to get their feedback.”
GMAC said earlier in the week that it was working with Treasury on the compensation proposal and “attracting and retaining key talent is critical toward continuing our efforts to transform the company and restore profitability.”
Congress will be watching. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., told Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner in a letter Wednesday that they were concerned about reports that some bailed-out firms had offered substantial bonuses in 2009.
Pelosi and Frank, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, said the bonuses “appear to foster the same business behavior that created irresponsible risks but insulated executives from the consequences of their bad decisions. This dangerous imbalance between rewarding risk and forgiving mistakes is what Congress and the American people are determined to bring to an end.”
AP Business Writers Daniel Wagner and Kimberly S. Johnson contributed to this report.
Related News
Geithner 'ultimately responsible' for failed AIG oversight, bailout watchdog saysOctober 14th, 2009 Watchdog: Treasury and Fed failed in AIG oversightWASHINGTON — Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner is "ultimately responsible" for regulators' failure to rein in massive bonus payments at American International Group because he led the agencies that provided AIG's lifelines, according to a bailout watchdog. Geithner was president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York before taking over at Treasury in January.
Treasury pay czar asks AIG to withhold millions in bonuses for workers whose bets went badOctober 13th, 2009 Pay czar asks AIG not to pay promised bonusesWASHINGTON — The Obama administration's pay czar has asked American International Group to withhold some of the millions in bonuses promised to its employees. Kenneth Feinberg, the special master for executive compensation, "has informally advised AIG not to pay the full $198 million" employees expect to receive, according to a report Tuesday from the special inspector general overseeing the $700 billion financial bailout.
Awaiting pay czar's rules, largest bailout recipients rework compensation for top earnersOctober 6th, 2009 Bailed-out banks act before pay czar announcementWASHINGTON — Several firms that received large taxpayer bailouts have adjusted executive compensation to trim cash payouts before the Obama administration's pay czar issues new rules. Some fear those rules will go too far, preventing them from attracting the talent they need to remain competitive.
Obama administration's pay czar hopes companies will find his decision fair and reasonableSeptember 30th, 2009 Pay czar hopes companies will find his decision OKCHICAGO — The Obama administration's pay czar says negotiations over executive compensation with seven companies that got the most from the federal bailout pot have been largely consensual, and he hopes they can stay that way. Washington attorney Kenneth Feinberg said Wednesday in a speech to the Chicago Bar Association over a television link that he has been working closely with the companies to make certain the pay levels he sets will keep them competitive and able to hang on to their employees.
Obama administration pay czar says negotiations with 7 companies have been largely consensualSeptember 30th, 2009 Pay czar: Talks with 7 companies are consensualCHICAGO — The Obama administration's pay czar said Wednesday his negotiations over executive compensation with the seven companies that received the biggest helpings from the federal bailout pot have been "a consensual process" and not a matter of forcing decisions on them. "I'm hoping I won't be required to simply make a determination over company objections," veteran Washington attorney Kenneth Feinberg told the Chicago Bar Association in a speech delivered over a television link.
White House OK with $7 million yearly salary for new CEO of bailed-out insurer AIGAugust 18th, 2009 White House OK with $7 million salary for AIG CEOWASHINGTON — The White House is fine with bailed-out insurer AIG's decision to pay its new CEO $7 million a year. Presidential spokesman Robert Gibbs says that's the price of competent leadership to make the company profitable again.
AIG CEO Benmosche to receive $7 million annual salary, could get millions more in incentivesAugust 17th, 2009 New AIG CEO to receive $7 million annual salaryNEW YORK — American International Group Inc.'s new CEO will be paid a yearly salary worth $7 million and could earn millions more in performance-based incentives, the bailed-out insurance giant said Monday. Robert Benmosche will receive $3 million in cash and $4 million in stock under his annual compensation package, AIG said in a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Meltdown 101: How will pay restrictions work for 175 top executives at bailed-out companies?August 12th, 2009 Meltdown 101: How will executive pay curbs work?WASHINGTON — Seven companies on government life support — bailout recipients like General Motors and Citigroup — face a deadline Thursday to propose compensation packages for their highest-paid employees, which will have to get the thumbs-up from the Obama administration's "pay czar."
It's the first time a federal official will have veto power over the how much private-sector executives are compensated. Some fear this new power encroaches on the free market, but Congress decided the government should have a say when it comes to the companies relying most heavily on taxpayer money.
GM provides Obama administration with executive compensation proposalAugust 11th, 2009 GM submits executive compensation planWASHINGTON — General Motors Co. said Tuesday it had submitted its executive compensation proposal to the Obama administration, complying with a requirement for companies bailed out by the federal government.
Citigroup worries pay czar Kenneth Feinberg will balk at energy trader's hefty pay packageJuly 25th, 2009 Citi exec's pay package may spark gov't showdownThe hefty 2009 pay package of Andrew J. Hall, leader of Citigroup Inc.'s lucrative Phibro energy trading unit, may spark a showdown between the New York-based bank and government pay czar Kenneth Feinberg.
Report: Citigroup energy trader wants $100M contract honored, Citi worries pay czar will balkJuly 25th, 2009 Report: Citi energy exec wants $100M deal honoredThe hefty 2009 pay package of Andrew J. Hall, leader of Citigroup Inc.'s lucrative Phibro energy trading unit, may spark a showdown between the New York-based bank and government pay czar Kenneth Feinberg, according to a Wall Street Journal report Saturday.
Report: AIG asking corporate pay czar Kenneth Feinberg to approve next week's bonus paymentsJuly 10th, 2009 Report: AIG asks gov't to approve bonus paymentsAfter its bonus payments ignited a firestorm of criticism earlier this year, American International Group Inc. is asking the federal government to weigh in on the insurer's plan to resume paying millions in promised retention incentives next week, according to media reports.
AP Source: AIG discussing remaining 2008 bonus payouts with Obama's compensation czarJuly 10th, 2009 AP Source: AIG consults administration on bonusesNEW YORK — American International Group Inc. is consulting with the federal government about its plans to pay millions of dollars in retention incentives and bonuses, a person familiar with the situation said.
SEC considers TARP transparency rules, better reporting of executive compensation practicesJuly 1st, 2009 SEC considers rules on pay disclosure, TARP firmsWASHINGTON — The Securities and Exchange Commission is debating proposed rules that would require firms that have received government bailouts to let shareholders vote on executive pay. Congress mandated the rule for participants in the Troubled Asset Relief Program, the $700 billion financial bailout.
Official: Obama to seek legislation giving shareholders a voice on executives' payJune 10th, 2009 Official: Obama wants shareholder say on exec payWASHINGTON — An administration official says President Barack Obama will ask Congress to give shareholders a nonbinding voice in how much corporate executives are paid. It's an effort to link compensation to long-term performance rather than short-term gains.