Palestinians say hopes in Obama ‘evaporated’
JERUSALEM — The Palestinian president’s political party says all hopes in the Obama administration have “evaporated,” accusing the White House of caving in to pressure from the pro-Israel lobby and backing off a demand to freeze Jewish settlement.
Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah Party also accused the U.S. of failing to set a clear agenda for a new round of Mideast peace talks, according to an internal memo obtained by The Associated Press on Tuesday.
“All hopes placed in the new U.S. administration and President Obama have evaporated,” the document said. Obama “couldn’t withstand the pressure of the Zionist lobby, which led to a retreat from his previous positions on halting settlement construction and defining an agenda for the negotiations and peace.”
The Palestinians initially greeted Obama’s election with enthusiasm, welcoming his outreach to the Muslim world and hoping he would depart from what they viewed as the pro-Israel bias of his predecessor, George W. Bush. Obama raised Palestinian hopes further with his repeated calls for Israel to halt all construction in Jewish settlements in the West Bank and east Jerusalem — areas the Palestinians claim for a future state.
But in recent weeks, the U.S. appears to have softened its stance on settlements. Washington says it has not abandoned the objective of halting settlement construction, but U.S. officials have indicated they do not see this as a condition for resuming talks.
The memo comes at a time of turmoil within Fatah after Abbas quickly reversed a decision to suspend efforts to bring Israel before a U.N. war crimes tribunal in connection with the Gaza war.
The document, dated Oct. 12, was issued by Fatah’s Office of Mobilization and Organization. The office is headed by the party’s No. 2, Mohammed Ghneim.
It was not immediately clear whether the document reflects Abbas’ views or whether it was leaked to pressure Obama to bear down harder on Israel. Abbas’ aides had no comment and Ghneim could not immediately be reached for comment.
The U.S. Embassy in Israel did not immediately return calls seeking comment.
The document reiterated Fatah’s demand for Israel to freeze settlement construction and agree to a clear agenda for peace talks before negotiations can resume.
The Palestinians want talks to resume from the point they broke down last year under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s predecessor, Ehud Olmert. Netanyahu says he is not bound by any concessions Olmert may have made.
Obama personally intervened last month, when he summoned Abbas and Netanyahu to a three-way meeting in New York. But he failed to break the impasse.
The document echoes sentiments expressed by other Fatah officials. On Sunday, former Fatah strongman Mohammed Dahlan said the party “feels very disappointed and worried by the U.S. administration retreat.”
The last round of Israel-Palestinian negotiations broke down late last year with no breakthroughs on the main issues dividing the two sides: final borders, the status of disputed Jerusalem and a solution for Palestinians who lost homes and other property in Israel after it achieved statehood in 1948.
The dispute over ongoing settlement construction in the West Bank and east Jerusalem has blocked all efforts to get the sides to talk, let alone solve the intractable conflict.
Netanyahu says some settlement construction must continue to accommodate growth of existing settler populations. He also says all of Jerusalem will remain in Israeli hands, although Israel’s annexation of the eastern part of the city and its sensitive holy sites has never been internationally recognized.
The Fatah memo comes at a time when Abbas is under relentless criticism from the rival Hamas group, which rules Gaza. They accused him of betraying the Palestinian cause by suspending efforts to bring Israel before a U.N. war crimes tribunal over the winter offensive on Gaza. Abbas has since reversed himself, and the U.N. Human Rights Council in Geneva, which commissioned the report, is expected to debate the findings on Thursday.
Firing back at his critics Tuesday, Abbas said the Hamas-run Gaza Strip has become an “emirate of darkness.” He also accused Hamas fighters of fleeing during the fighting while they “left their people to be killed in Gaza.”
Tuesday’s speech was Abbas’ harshest so far on his Hamas rivals.
Hamas spokesman Fawzi Barhoum called Abbas’ speech “base and misguided.”
Relations between Abbas’s Fatah government in the West Bank and Hamas collapsed when Hamas seized control of Gaza in 2007. The latest spat has dealt a new blow to reconciliation efforts between the factions.
Related News
Document circulated among Abbas' political party members says hopes in Obama have 'evaporated'October 13th, 2009 Palestinian memo says hopes in Obama 'evaporated'JERUSALEM — An internal document circulated among members of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas' political party says all hopes placed in the Obama administration "have evaporated" because of alleged White House backtracking on key issues to the Palestinians. The Fatah Party memorandum, obtained Tuesday by The Associated Press, accuses the United States of backing off from its demands that Israel freeze settlement construction and failing to set a clear agenda for new Mideast peace talks.
Israel congratulates Obama, hopes prize will boost Mideast peaceOctober 9th, 2009 TEL AVIV - Israeli leaders congratulated US President Barack Obama Friday on winning the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize, saying they hoped it would add force to his efforts to push for peace in the Middle East. President Shimon Peres sent a message to Obama, saying "there are few leaders who succeeded in changing the mood in the world in such a short time", it said, Israel Radio reported.
Diplomats say Palestinians want UN rights council resolution on Gaza 'war crimes' postponedOctober 1st, 2009 Diplomats: Palestinians want Gaza resolution delayGENEVA — Diplomats in Geneva say the Palestinian Authority has withdrawn its support for a U.N. resolution endorsing a report on alleged war crimes by Israel and Palestinians in Gaza.
Israeli FM: Netanyahu talks with Obama, Palestinians was victory for firm stand on settlementsSeptember 23rd, 2009 Israeli FM: US meeting proof firm stand paid offJERUSALEM — Israel's foreign minister says a meeting between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the Palestinian and American leaders was a victory for Israel because it took place even though Israel refused demands to freeze settlement in the West Bank. Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman told Israel Radio Wednesday that the government "kept its promises to the voter" and showed it is not necessary to "surrender and give in."
Israel agreed only to slow settlement construction in the Palestinian territory for a limited time.
2 Palestinians, 2 Israelis wounded in mortar, gunfire on Israel-Gaza borderAugust 24th, 2009 2 Palestinians, 2 Israelis wounded in Gaza clashJERUSALEM — At least two Palestinians and two Israelis have been injured in violence on the Gaza-Israel border. Israeli rescue workers say Palestinians fired two mortar shells from Gaza, slightly wounding two.
Obama: Encouraged on Israel, Palestinian prospects for peace, thanks Mubarak for his roleAugust 18th, 2009 Obama: Encouraged on Israel, Palestinian prospectsWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama said Tuesday he is encouraged by progress in U.S. efforts to bring Israel and the Palestinians back to the negotiating table, thanking his Egyptian counterpart for help in working for a breakthrough.
Clinton meets Egyptian president ahead of White House talks with ObamaAugust 17th, 2009 Clinton sees Mubarak ahead of White House talksWASHINGTON — The Obama administration is hopeful that groundwork can be laid soon to allow the resumption of stalled peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians, the State Department said Monday. "We're trying to work hard to create conditions for negotiation to continue and we hope to have this phase of this process completed in the next few weeks," spokesman P.J.
Obama says Israeli prime minister's speech shows the "possibility we can restart serious talksJune 16th, 2009 Obama welcomes Israeli prime minister's speechWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama on Monday welcomed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's endorsement of Palestinian independence, saying the development shows the "possibility we can restart serious talks."
Bending to U.S. pressure in a speech a day earlier, Netanyahu backed down on decades of opposition to Palestinian statehood by endorsing an independent state beside Israel.
Positive signs from Israel, but settlements must stop: ObamaJune 16th, 2009 WASHINGTON - US President Barack Obama said Monday there was some "positive movement" towards peace after Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu recognised the Palestinians' right to an independent state. But Obama made clear he would not back down from his demand that Israel stop all settlement activity, a key disagreement that remains between the two long-time allies.
President Obama declares two-state solution only answer for violence and bloodshed in MideastJune 4th, 2009 Obama: Two-state solution only answer for MideastCAIRO — President Barack Obama says the Israelis and Palestinians must find a way to live side by side, peacefully as two independent states, arguing that this solution ultimately is the only way to end bloodshed and violence. Obama recognized the long U.S.
Israel must accept Palestinian state: BidenMay 6th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Vice-President Joe Biden has placed America on a collision course with Israel, urging the new government to accept the goal of a Palestinian state and stop expanding Jewish settlements on occupied land. Biden used an address to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee - the leading pro-Israeli lobby group in the United States - to deliver a tough message to Benjamin Netanyahu, the country's new prime minister.
Biden says Israel must back two-state peace deal with PalestiniansMay 5th, 2009 Biden says Israel must back two-state peace dealWASHINGTON — Vice President Joe Biden challenged Israel to back a two-state peace agreement with the Palestinians and urged the Jewish state's new leadership to demonstrate its commitment to such a solution. In a speech Tuesday to the leading pro-Israel lobby in the United States, Biden said Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government should stop constructing new Jewish settlements and ease restrictions on Palestinians.
Netanyahu says Israel wants peace with Palestinians, but won't compromise Israel securityMay 5th, 2009 Israeli PM wants 'triple track' approach to peaceWASHINGTON — Israel's prime minister on Monday outlined a "triple track" approach to peace with the Palestinians, a strategy that emphasizes political, economic and security planks to resolve the decades-long conflict. Benjamin Netanyahu said his government is ready to resume peace negotiations without any delays or preconditions.
Pope hopes Holy Land trip will help Christians, promote peace; urges prayers for PalestiniansMay 3rd, 2009 Pope hopes Holy Land trip will promote peaceVATICAN CITY — Pope Benedict XVI says he hopes his upcoming trip to the Holy Land will give encouragement to Christians there and also promote peace and reconciliation between Israel and the Palestinians. Benedict says he is urging particular prayers for the Palestinians, whom he says have endured "great hardship and suffering."
Benedict travels to Jordan, Israel and the Palestinian territories May 8-15.
Abbas: Palestinians won't be pressured into peace talks if Israel keeps building settlementsApril 27th, 2009 Abbas won't be pressured into talks with IsraelRAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinians won't be pressured into resuming peace talks with Israel as long as construction in Jewish settlements continues, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said Monday. Abbas said a complete construction freeze is a prerequisite for resuming talks.