Palestinians change course on UN report
UNITED NATIONS — The Palestinian leadership has quickly backtracked in its approach to a U.N. report accusing Israel of possible war crimes in Gaza, in what its top diplomat acknowledged Thursday is erupting into a “clear crisis” for its people.
Palestinian Foreign Minister Riad Malki didn’t say who was responsible for the crisis, but told reporters at U.N. headquarters that the militant Islamist group Hamas is trying to take cynical advantage of the report, to court favor with the Palestinians.
“This clear crisis about the report proves that the Hamas position is really trying to exploit it, to its own favor, trying to take advantage of it, and really score points, rather than having a genuine principled position regarding the report,” Malki said.
The report also accuses Palestinian armed groups of possible war crimes in the Israeli-Hamas conflict last winter. Hamas, the Palestinian Authority’s main rival, controls Gaza.
The Palestinian Authority initially pushed for the U.N. Human Rights Council to forward its commissioned Sept. 15 report to the Security Council.
Then it agreed last week under U.S. pressure not to push the issue at the United Nations. That brought harsh criticism, including angry protests at home and condemnation around the Arab world.
Finally, on Wednesday, the Palestinian leadership again switched gears. It reversed itself by strongly backing Security Council member Libya’s push to hold the 15-nation council’s monthly debate on the Middle East a week earlier than planned and provide a high-profile forum for the explosive report to be discussed.
Malki said Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah movement — which lost power in Gaza when it was overrun by Hamas militants in 2007 — remains “far apart” in any potential deal with Hamas to reconcile and hold Palestinian elections. The Egyptians hope to broker a deal in Cairo this month.
“Frankly saying, and this is the first time I say it: When it comes to the principal issues, we feel that we are close to reaching an agreement between the Palestinian Authority, between Fatah and Hamas, and that’s why everybody talks about the possibility of signing that agreement in the next couple days,” Malki said.
“But when we start looking deeper into the details, and the positions of each party regarding the different issues, we discover we are very far apart,” he added.
Malki said the Palestinian leadership supports “all the recommendations” contained in the U.N. report on Gaza and had dispatched him to New York to press the case on Thursday for having the Security Council or other arms of the United Nations take up the findings. He left the U.N. on Thursday but plans to return for the May 14 debate, originally scheduled for May 20.
Malki held a strategy session with U.N. General Assembly President Ali Treki, a former Libyan foreign minister, and said he also met to “coordinate efforts” with Libyan Ambassador Abdurrahman Mohamed Shalgham. At a meeting with U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, Malki said he pressed for the U.N.’s “immediate intervention.”
Malki said he also was assured by this month’s Security Council president, Vietnamese Ambassador Le Luong Minh, that the “emphasis” of next week’s debate will be on the U.N. report written by a panel of experts led by respected South African jurist Richard Goldstone.
The 575-page Goldstone report accused Israel of using disproportionate force and failing to protect civilians while calling Hamas’ firing of rockets at civilian areas in southern Israel a war crime.
Related News
Israeli aircraft strike Gaza smuggling tunnels along border in response to rocket fireOctober 14th, 2009 Israeli aircraft strike Gaza smuggling tunnelsJERUSALEM — The Israeli military says its aircraft struck two smuggling tunnels along the Gaza Strip border after a rocket fired by Palestinian militants hit southern Israel. Gaza health officials say four people were slightly injured in the attack early Wednesday.
Palestinian leaders reverse course accusing Hamas of taking advantage of UN reportOctober 8th, 2009 Palestinians accuse Hamas over UN reportUNITED NATIONS — The militant Islamist group Hamas is trying to take cynical advantage of a U.N. report accusing Israel of possible war crimes in Gaza to curry favor back home, Palestinian Foreign Minister Riad Malki told reporters at U.N.
Israeli army carries out airstrikes on Gaza weapons workshop, no injuries reportedOctober 3rd, 2009 Israeli army strikes Gaza weapons workshopGAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The Israeli army says it carried out airstrikes on a weapons workshop east of Gaza City and two weapons smuggling tunnels under the Gaza-Egypt border. Palestinian health officials reported no injuries.
Diplomats say Palestinians want UN rights council resolution on Gaza 'war crimes' postponedOctober 1st, 2009 Diplomats: Palestinians want Gaza resolution delayGENEVA — Diplomats in Geneva say the Palestinian Authority has withdrawn its support for a U.N. resolution endorsing a report on alleged war crimes by Israel and Palestinians in Gaza.
Israeli troops shoot dead 2 Palestinian militants on Gaza-Israel borderSeptember 20th, 2009 Israeli troops kill 2 Palestinians on Gaza borderJERUSALEM — A Palestinian Health Ministry official says Israeli forces have killed two Palestinian militants and wounded three in an incident along the Gaza border. Dr. Moaiya Hassanain said the men were hit by tank fire.
Palestinian official says 3 dead, 7 hurt in Israeli air strike on Gaza tunnelAugust 25th, 2009 Gaza official: 3 dead, 7 hurt in Israel air strikeGAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — An Israeli air strike on a smuggling tunnel between the Gaza Strip and Egypt on Tuesday killed three Palestinians and wounded seven, a Palestinian Health Ministry official said. The official, Dr.
2 Palestinians, 2 Israelis wounded in mortar, gunfire on Israel-Gaza borderAugust 24th, 2009 2 Palestinians, 2 Israelis wounded in Gaza clashJERUSALEM — At least two Palestinians and two Israelis have been injured in violence on the Gaza-Israel border. Israeli rescue workers say Palestinians fired two mortar shells from Gaza, slightly wounding two.
"UN Gaza report written by Palestinians," says Israel's ambassador to UNAugust 16th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel's Ambassador to the United Nations, Aharon Leshno Yaar, has said that the UN Gaza report was written solely "to appease the Arab-controlled Human Rights Council."
Leshno Yaar claimed that the report was "written by Palestinians in Ramallah" and it was "screened by Palestinian lawyers in Geneva in order to satisfy Palestinian diplomats on the Human Rights Council."e said the report was "totally biased" and based on unconfirmed information. "It ignores the facts and the Israeli positions.
End the Gaza blockade, Hamas tells NAM summitJuly 15th, 2009 GAZA CITY/CAIRO - Hamas Wednesday called on world leaders gathered in Egypt for the 15th summit of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) to take "all necessary measures" to end the blockade of the Gaza Strip. Hamas, which has controlled the Gaza Strip since 2007, called on more than 50 world leaders gathered in the Sinai resort city of Sharm el-Sheikh, to "take clear decisions toward ending the siege on the Gaza Strip".
Amnesty blames Israel for collapse of truce with HamasMay 28th, 2009 JERUSALEM - In its 2009 annual report, formally released on Thursday, Amnesty International places sole blame on Israel for the breakdown in the cease-fire between Israel and Hamas that led to Operation Cast Lead. The London-based organization accuses Israel of breaking the six-month cease-fire on November 4, 2008, when "Israeli forces killed six Palestinian militants."
Jerusalem-based research organization NGO Monitor said the report ignored Hamas violations.
Blair hails Egypt's role in Gaza truceJanuary 27th, 2009 CAIRO - International Quartet's envoy for the Middle East and former British prime minister Tony Blair Wednesday praised the ongoing Egyptian efforts to consolidate a ceasefire in the Gaza Strip. Following talks with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak in Cairo, Blair said it's the most important move to stabilize the fragile truce in Gaza, Egpyt's MENA news agency reported.
Israel to leave Gaza once ceasefire is stable: OlmertJanuary 18th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel has no intention of keeping its troops in the Gaza Strip following a 22-day-long campaign against Hamas and will leave the salient once it is satisfied a ceasefire implemented Sunday is holding, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said Sunday night. 'Israel has no intention of staying in the Gaza Strip.
Blair optimistic on Gaza ceasefireJanuary 11th, 2009 CAIRO - Former British prime minister and Middle East special envoy Tony Blair Monday said 'elements were in place' for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas. Speaking after a meeting with Egyptian President Hosny Mubarak in Cairo, Blair stressed that any agreement must be predicated on an end to weapons smuggling into Gaza and an end to the blockade of the territory.
Israel announces 'humanitarian corridor' for Gaza StripJanuary 6th, 2009 TEL AVIV - Israel plans to establish a 'humanitarian corridor' to get needed supplies to Palestinian civilians in the embattled Gaza Strip, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert announced overnight Tuesday. The plan would allow limited time windows to get humanitarian supplies into parts of the Palestinian territory, Ynetnews reported online, citing the prime minister's office.
Gaza will not surrender to Israeli ground troops: HaniyaJanuary 6th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Hamas leader and de-facto Palestinian prime minister in Gaza Ismail Haniya Tuesday issued a statement from his hideout, seeking to boost morale in Gaza and vowing its people would not 'surrender' to the Israeli ground troops operating in the Strip. 'The ground aggression on the Gaza Strip is proof that the Occupation (Israel) has failed to force the population of the Gaza Strip to surrender,' he said in the statement sent to reporters.