WASHINGTON - Even conspiracy theories must sometimes be taken seriously.
Every week Roger Launius, chief historian at the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum in Washington, devotes his time to debunking one of history’s favourite such theories: That astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin never landed on the moon.
The entire July 20, 1969, landing and the spacewalk several hours later was just a show, all lies, filmed in a Hollywood studio or in a desert, the sceptics say.
Few other conspiracy theories have proven so popular or long-lived.
“We Americans love that sort of thing,” Launius said as he stood before a lunar lander like the Eagle that took Armstrong and Aldrin to the moon’s surface.
In fact, conspiracy theories abound in the US: the Sep 11, 2001, terrorist attacks were planned by the government; President Barack Obama is not really a US citizen; and various false hypotheses about the assassination of president John F. Kennedy.
It didn’t take long after the moon landing for wild speculation to surface. Then the 1976 book, “We Never Went to the Moon - America’s 30 Billion Dollar Swindle”, by Bill Kaysing really got things going. It was the era of Watergate and the Vietnam War, and the theories played off the resulting distrust of the government.
At one time, up to 10 percent of Americans may have believed the conspiracy theories about the moon. On average, it has dropped to about six percent of Americans, Launius said.
The arguments of the critics include the “waving flag”, the “missing stars” and “false shadows” in television images. But at the root of the idea is that the country was not yet technologically advanced enough to make the trip. The US was in a space race with the Soviet Union during the Cold War and could not hand a win to the communists. As a last resort they reached for fabrication, the disbelievers say.
As evidence, a favourite of the doubters is the waving flag that Armstrong and Aldrin planted in the moon’s surface. How was it waving if there is no air on the moon? In actuality, the flag was equipped with a bar to keep it extended rather than hanging limp and the ripples in the cloth were due to its folding in the packaging.
Additionally, a shot of the flag actually moving was caused by an astronaut letting go of the cloth.
Then there is the issue of missing stars. Why were there no stars visible in the television pictures? The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) has responded that starlight is too weak to appear in photos under normal lighting conditions on the moon — a phenomenon also well known to every photographer on Earth.
As for the “false shadows” in NASA pictures, objects and people appeared to cast shadows in different directions rather than in parallel directions. Because the sun is the only light source on the moon, sceptics have used this as evidence that it was all filmed in a Hollywood studio with multiple lights. The experts’ answer: The moon is not flat, meaning there is no 100 percent “correct” shadow. This can even happen on Earth.
Launius calls the theories “silly”, but admits they aren’t going away any time soon.
“It would be the coolest thing on Earth to go back to the moon - just to prove that we have been there before,” he said.
Related News
Chandrayaan images debunk Apollo 15 conspiracy theory: ScientistSeptember 2nd, 2009 PANAJI - In a considerable downer for space conspiracy theorists, Chandrayaan-1's terrain-mapper camera has recorded images of the landing site of US spaceship Apollo 15 and tracks of its lunar rovers that were used by astronauts to travel on moon's surface nearly four decades ago, a scientist said Wednesday. Prakash Chauhan of the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) said the images captured by the hyper-spectral camera on board Chandrayaan-1 debunked conspiracy theories that have claimed that the Apollo 15, the fourth US mission to land on the moon was a hoax.
5 little-known facts about the Moon landingJuly 22nd, 2009 WASHINGTON - In a new report, National Geographic News has outlined 5 little-known facts about the Moon landing. So, 40 years after the Apollo 11 moon landing, here are some of the facts that you probably didn't know about the historic event:
1.
Apollo 11: 40th anniversary moon landingJuly 21st, 2009 Forty years back this day that is July 20, 1969 Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin stepped on moon. US President Obama celebrates the 40 anniversary moon landing by paying tribute to the astronauts of Apollo 11.
Apollo astronauts dream of trip to MarsJuly 20th, 2009 WASHINGTON - It's been decades since they set foot on the moon, but the pioneers of the Apollo programme remain committed to exploring space with the goal of sending a human to Mars. Seven astronauts from the Apollo programme talked with journalists Monday to mark the 40th anniversary of the Apollo 11 landing on the moon.
Google offers 'guided tour' of the moon, 40 years after the first Apollo landingJuly 20th, 2009 Google offers 'guided tour' of the moonNEW YORK — Google Inc. is offering a more wide-ranging view of the Moon, 40 years after humans first landed there.
Doesn't matter who was first on moon, says "Buzz" AldrinJuly 20th, 2009 CANBERRA - Edwin "buzz" Aldrin, the second man on the moon, has said that it doesn't matter who was the first on the Moon, as the landing was more important than walking on the lunar surface. According to a report in The News, Aldrin made the statement at a book-signing recently, arguing that being second man on the moon behind Neil Armstrong was "just as significant".
Moon landing still fascinates 40 years after `one small step'July 19th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Forty years ago, millions gathered around grainy black and white television images as the first man set foot on the moon in what remains for many the pinnacle of manned spaceflight. That moon landing July 20, 1969, was the first of just six times that any human being has visited the Earth's nearest celestial neighbour, and it has been more than 30 years since any person has been there.
Ahead of 40th anniversary of moon landing, Aldrin reflects on apex of his lifeJuly 18th, 2009 Aldrin reflects on first moon landingDAYTON, Ohio — Buzz Aldrin still has the felt-tipped pen he used as a makeshift switch needed to fire up the engines that lifted him and fellow Apollo 11 astronaut Neil Armstrong off the moon and started their safe return to Earth nearly 40 years ago. "The pen and the circuit breaker (switch) are in my possession because we do get a few memorabilia to kind of symbolize things that happened," Aldrin told reporters Friday.
25pct Brits think 1969 moon landing was hoaxJuly 18th, 2009 LONDON - One fourth of Britons believe that the 1969 Apollo 11 mission moon landings were nothing but a hoax, according to a survey. A total of 1009 people participated in the survey for E andT magazine, published by the Institution of Engineering and Technology.
Ahead of 40th anniversary of the moon landing, Aldrin reflects on 'the climax of my life'July 17th, 2009 Aldrin reflects on 'the climax of my life'DAYTON, Ohio — Buzz Aldrin still has the felt-tipped pen he used as a makeshift switch needed to fire up the engines that lifted him and fellow Apollo 11 astronaut Neil Armstrong off the moon and started their safe return to Earth nearly 40 years ago. "The pen and the circuit breaker (switch) are in my possession because we do get a few memorabilia to kind of symbolize things that happened," Aldrin told reporters Friday.
As 40th anniversary of first moon landing looms, Aldrin says moon desolate, but magnificentJuly 17th, 2009 Aldrin: moon desolate, but magnificentDAYTON, Ohio — Buzz Aldrin still has the felt-tipped pen he used as a makeshift switch needed to fire up the engines that lifted him and fellow Apollo 11 astronaut Neil Armstrong off the moon and started their safe return to Earth nearly 40 years ago. "The pen and the circuit breaker (switch) are in my possession because we do get a few memorabilia to kind of symbolize things that happened," Aldrin told reporters Friday.
Buzz Lightyear believed by some to be 'first man on Moon', says surveyJuly 8th, 2009 LONDON - Buzz Lightyear, the fictional cartoon character from the film 'Toy Story', is believed by some people to have been the first man on the Moon, revealed a survey. The survey revealed "deeply worrying" levels of ignorance about the Apollo space programme, which sent three men to the moon 40 years ago this month.
Buzz Aldrin calls for human settlement on MarsJuly 4th, 2009 LONDON - The NASA astronaut Buzz Aldrin has said that humans should create a settlement on Mars to provide much-needed objectives to the younger generation. Aldrin, the second man to set his foot on the Moon, has claimed that setting up habitation on the surface of the red planet is a "wonderful objective" for humanity.
Lunar science probe sends back moon shots less than week after launch, another orbiting moonJune 24th, 2009 NASA's new moon probe sends back moon shotsCAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — NASA's new lunar probe launched less than a week ago has already sent back some shots of the moon.
Space was hardly romantic, says Apollo astronaut Buzz AldrinJune 5th, 2009 NEW YORK - Buzz Aldrin has revealed that not all memories of the historic landing on the Moon 40 years ago were as romantic as portrayed. The second man to set foot on the moon said the July 20, 1969 landing bore another side of reality that the video archives could not translate.