Medicare won’t cover ‘virtual colonoscopy’
WASHINGTON — Medicare won’t pay for the so-called virtual colonoscopy procedure, concluding Tuesday that there’s inadequate evidence to support the cheaper, less intrusive alternative to the dreaded colonoscopy.
Some experts had hoped that popularizing the X-ray procedure would boost screening for colon cancer, the country’s second leading cancer killer. Screening to spot early cancer or precancerous growths has resulted in fewer deaths over the last two decades.
But in a decision posted on its Web site, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services said that the test does not qualify for Medicare coverage. The memo noted that the procedure is performed on people without symptoms and cannot, in itself, rid a patient of precancerous growths, like a regular colonoscopy can.
Medicare does cover regular colonoscopies, in which a long, thin tube equipped with a small video camera is snaked through the large intestine to view the lining. Any growth can be removed during the procedure.
CT colonography, also known as virtual colonoscopy, is a super X-ray of the colon that is quicker, cheaper and easier on the patient, but involves radiation. Both procedures involve preparation to clean out the bowels.
The Medicare memo notes that the virtual colonoscopy has shown better precision in detecting larger polyps than smaller ones.
There’s been some division of opinion in the medical community over the virtual colonoscopy. Some doctors question its utility since, if a polyp is found, a regular colonoscopy would typically have to follow, anyway.
Others support it, saying it can result in early cancer detection. The American Cancer Society recommends it as an alternative to a regular colonoscopy.
A concern for Medicare officials, according to their decision Tuesday, was the effectiveness of the procedure for the Medicare population — people 65 and older — as opposed to younger patients. More data is needed to answer that, Medicare said.
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force opted last fall not to give its stamp of approval to the virtual colonoscopy, citing the risk of radiation among other factors. Medicare said it took that decision into account in reaching Tuesday’s determination, which is final.
Some private insurers cover the virtual procedure but others don’t. Colonoscopies cost up to $3,000 while the X-ray test costs $300 to $800.
On the Net:
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services: www.cms.hhs.gov/
Related News
Health care issues: Medicare cutsOctober 6th, 2009 Health care issues: Medicare cutsA look at key issues in the health care debate:
THE ISSUE: Will seniors' Medicare benefits be slashed to pay for health care overhaul?
THE POLITICS: Democrats are proposing to reduce the ballooning costs of Medicare to keep the program solvent. They want to root out waste to find the savings, and to reduce payments to some providers.
Senate health care bill could lead to higher Medicare prescription drug costs for seniorsOctober 2nd, 2009 Health care overhaul could raise Medicare Rx costsWASHINGTON — Medicare recipients could see higher premiums for prescription drug coverage as a result of changes to complex provisions in a Senate health care bill, a senior Republican said Friday. At issue are marching orders for a powerful new commission that would recommend annual Medicare savings to Congress.
STORY REMOVED: US-Medicare-PremiumsSeptember 24th, 2009 STORY REMOVED: US-Medicare-PremiumsWASHINGTON — The Associated Press has withdrawn a story on Medicare premiums. It contained unrelated copy from another story.
Biden reassures Md. seniors: 'Nobody is going to mess with your benefits'September 23rd, 2009 Biden tells Md. seniors reform won't hurt MedicareSILVER SPRING, Md.
Congress' budget chief contradicts Obama, says Medicare benefits would be cut under planSeptember 22nd, 2009 Budget chief contradicts Obama on Medicare costsWASHINGTON — Congress' chief budget officer on Tuesday contradicted President Barack Obama's oft-stated claim that seniors wouldn't see their Medicare benefits cut under a health care overhaul. The head of the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, Douglas Elmendorf, told senators that seniors in Medicare's managed care plans could see reduced benefits under a bill in the Finance Committee.
What will your surgery cost? That depends, and the answer isn't simpleSeptember 18th, 2009 Health care marketplace thrives on secret pricesCHICAGO — Flower shop owner Bob Hausheer would like to know why he can't walk into a doctor's office and see a list of prices. The 45-year-old suburban Chicago man has a $5,000 deductible, meaning he pays for his health care — including a $7,500 back surgery last year — mostly out of his own wallet.
HIV testing proposed to be added to Medicare coverageSeptember 9th, 2009 HIV testing proposed for Medicare coverageWASHINGTON — The government proposed Wednesday to have Medicare cover tests for HIV, the virus that causes AIDS. "This proposal to cover HIV screening for our Medicare population has great potential in terms of saving lives and improving the quality of life for many seniors, as well as beneficiaries under age 65," said Charlene Frizzera, acting administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Obama: Medicare trust fund will not be used to pay for health care overhaulSeptember 9th, 2009 Obama: 'I will protect Medicare'WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama on Wednesday night promised to protect Medicare and reassured the elderly that Medicare funds would not be used to pay for a health care overhaul. The president said the plan would eliminate billions of dollars in waste and fraud and what he called the "unwarranted subsidies" that go to insurance companies.
Federal officials say monthly payments for Medicare drug coverage to rise $2 next yearAugust 14th, 2009 Medicare drug premiums to rise slightly in 2010WASHINGTON — Seniors enrolled in Medicare can expect to see a $2 increase in their monthly payment for prescription drug coverage next year. Medicare officials announced late Thursday that the average monthly premium for the government's drug plan will be $30 next year, up from $28 this year.
AARP says Obama erred in claiming it has endorsed health care legislationAugust 12th, 2009 AARP tells Obama: No health plan endorsement yetWASHINGTON — A group usually seen as one of Barack Obama's allies in the health care debate — AARP — says the president went too far Tuesday when he said the seniors lobby had endorsed the legislation pending in Congress. AARP is sensitive to the issue because polls show that Medicare beneficiaries are worried their health care program will be cut to subsidize coverage for the uninsured.
Obama tries to reassure seniors worried about Medicare cuts in health care overhaulAugust 11th, 2009 Obama seeks to reassure seniors on health carePORTSMOUTH, N.H. — President Barack Obama is seeking to reassure the nation's seniors that health care overhaul won't mean cuts in Medicare.
Cigna discusses Medicare Part D, Medicare Advantage businessJuly 30th, 2009 On the call: Cigna President David CordaniInvestors sent Cigna shares up more than 4 percent in Thursday afternoon trading after the health insurer reported a 60-percent jump in second-quarter profit. But the company saw a 14 percent drop in revenue to $75 million from its Medicare Part D business, and Cigna spent more money on claims than it took in for that part of the business.
Obama says savings in Medicare won't mean cuts in benefits to seniorsJuly 23rd, 2009 Obama says Medicare benefits won't be cutWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama says cutting Medicare costs won't mean cuts in benefits to seniors. He says his goal instead is to change how those benefits are delivered, to make them more efficient.
Over 225 years of Spanish journalism now on the webMarch 8th, 2009 MADRID - Material from 2,000 newspapers published in Spain and Latin America from 1777 up to 2005, amounting to 4.3 million pages, can now be consulted on the Internet. It is available at the site of the Virtual Press History Library (Biblioteca Virtual de Prensa Historica, in Spanish).
Never allow kids to cross roads while using cell phonesJanuary 26th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Children, who tend to cross streets talking on cell phones, stand a higher risk of injury or even death, according to the latest study. 'Cell phones clearly offer convenience and safeguards to families, but they also may pose risks,' said University of Alabama-Birmingham (UAB) researchers, 'particularly when children attempt to multi-task while conversing on the cell phone....'
Researchers used a virtual reality software programme and three screens to display an actual Birmingham area crosswalk with simulated vehicles of different sizes travelling on the virtual street.
Loading ...