Armenia, Turkey pursue ’soccer diplomacy’
BURSA, Turkey — Turkey defeated longtime foe Armenia on a soccer field Wednesday — an event that had little significance in the world of sports but meant a lot in the arena of international politics.
Armenian President Serge Sarkisian arrived in Turkey to attend the World Cup qualifier after a dinner hosted by Turkish President Abdullah Gul in Bursa, a former Ottoman imperial capital. Gul attended an initial game in Armenia in a goodwill gesture last year, kicking off a round of “football diplomacy” that led to the signing last weekend of an agreement to establish diplomatic ties and open their border within two months.
Turkey’s Halil Altintop scored with a header in the 16th minute, and Servet Cetin fired the ball into the Armenian net in the 28th minute to make it 2-0, a lead that held until the end. After the first goal, Sarkisian shook Gul’s hand to congratulate him.
The game, televised live in both countries, began after Turkish fans booed and whistled as an announcer read out the Armenian lineup, and cheered the Turkish players. Some fans released white doves in a gesture of peace that drew applause in the stadium.
The announcer urged fans to show “traditional Turkish hospitality” to the visiting team and not to jeer or whistle during the playing of the Armenian national anthem. His appeal was mostly ignored. Police in riot gear stood outside the stadium.
A bus taking Armenian journalists to the stadium was pelted with stones by Turkish fans, but there were no injuries or broken windows.
After the game, Sarkisian told reporters: “Both sides have achieved a lot and this is the evidence.”
He also said Armenia was taking all opinions into account but was pressing ahead with its reconciliation agenda. He was referring to fierce opposition from some Armenian groups, including sectors of the powerful Diaspora.
Gul sounded a similar note.
“Try and remember two years ago and you will see the distance that we have covered in relations,” Gul said. “What’s important here is to make the region into a region of cooperation.”
Earlier, Turkish diplomats who attended a meeting between Gul and Sarkisian quoted the Turkish president as saying: “We’re not writing history, we’re making history.”
Foreign Minister Micheline Calmy-Rey of Switzerland, along with the foreign ministers of Turkey and Armenia, also attended the match. All three participated in last weekend’s signing in Switzerland of the agreement, which needs to be approved by the parliaments of both countries.
The deepest dispute is over history and has yet to be resolved: Armenia and many historians allege that Ottoman Turks committed genocide against Armenians early in the last century, a charge that Turkey denies. The countries have agreed to set up a commission to study the issue, though they are unlikely to give much ground on their positions.
Police intensified security ahead of Wednesday night’s match for fear of protests from Turkish nationalists who oppose reconciliation with the country’s eastern neighbor. Both teams have already been knocked out of the World Cup qualifying, so neither can deliver a killer blow to the other’s athletic hopes. Turkey won the first game against Armenia 2-0 in Yerevan in September 2008.
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has warned against “provocations that might come from people who desire to abuse the process between Turkey and Armenia.”
The agreement has strong support in the two countries’ parliaments but faces stiff opposition from nationalists. Turkey has said it would send the agreement to parliament next week. It was signed only after U.S. diplomats helped to resolve a last-minute hitch.
A day after the deal was signed on Saturday, Erdogan repeated a demand that Armenia withdraw from the disputed enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh. Armenia controls the enclave in Azerbaijan, which is inhabited mainly by ethnic Armenians. Turkey, in a show of solidarity with ally Azerbaijan, sealed its border with Armenia in response to the country’s invasion of Nagorno-Karabakh in 1993.
Azerbaijan, a regional oil and gas power, has criticized the Turkish-Armenian deal, saying it aggravates the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. A group of Azeri lawmakers were to meet Erdogan on Wednesday to express their concerns.
Turkish and Azerbaijani flag stickers were pasted on dustbins, electricity poles and billboards surrounding the stadium in Bursa. Street peddlers sold Turkish and Azerbaijani flags.
Virtually all flags inside the stadium were Turkish. One fan unfolded an Azeri flag and briefly held it up.
FIFA — world football’s Zurich-based governing body — earlier contacted Turkey’s Football Association and asked it to ensure that Azeri flags were not flown inside the stadium, in line with FIFA’s stance against political interference and provocative acts.
“The governor was ordered to prevent fans from entering the stadium with Azeri flags,” said Mahmut Ozgener, head of Turkey’s football association. “FIFA is very sensitive about political issues.”
Ozgener also said that football is instrumental in “opening a new era between Turkey and Armenia.”
The Turkish-Armenian deal also faces opposition from groups in the powerful Armenian Diaspora, which insists that Turkey accept that the killing of up to 1.5 million Armenians during the final days of the Ottoman Empire amounts to genocide. Turkey says the number is inflated and that many died on both sides during a chaotic period.
Still, the agreement could benefit Turkey in its long-standing bid to become a member of the European Union.
In its annual progress report on that effort Wednesday, the bloc urged Turkey to boost its chances by speeding up reforms, but EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn welcomed the accord.
“I’m encouraged by the historic steps Turkey and Armenia have just taken toward normalizing their relations. This process should now lead to full normalization as soon as possible,” Rehn said.
Associated Press Writer Avet Demourian in Bursa contributed to this report.
Related News
Turkey: Armenia must withdraw from Nagorno-Karabakh, comes a day after deal to normalize tiesOctober 11th, 2009 Turkey:Armenia must withdraw from Nagorno-KarabakhANKARA, Turkey — Turkey's prime minister says Armenia must withdraw from the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh, a day after the two countries signed a deal to normalize ties. Recep Tayyip Erdogan says Turkey cannot take a "positive step" toward opening the joint border with Armenia until Armenian troops leave the breakaway enclave in Azerbaijan.
Turkey says deal with Armenia not in effect until Armenia withdraws from Nagorno-KarabakhOctober 11th, 2009 Turkey: Armenia must pull out of Nagorno-KarabakhANKARA, Turkey — One day after Turkey signed a deal the U.S. helped salvage to end a century of enmity with Armenia, Turkey's leader set a tough condition for normalizing ties on Sunday: Armenia must withdraw from the disputed enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh.
Turkey and Armenia expected to establish diplmatic ties, despite gulf over bloody pastOctober 10th, 2009 Turkey and Armenia seek diplomatic tiesISTANBUL — Turkey and Armenia plan to sign an agreement Saturday establishing diplomatic ties in hopes of ending a century of acrimony over their bloody past and reopening their border, but nationalists on both sides are seeking to derail its implementation. Better ties between Turkey, a regional heavyweight, and poor, landlocked Armenia are a key goal of President Barack Obama.
Turkey and Armenia sign protocols on tiesOctober 10th, 2009 ZURICH - Turkey and Armenia Saturday signed two protocols that will pave the way for a new era of diplomatic relations, bilateral ties and the opening of their common border after years of hostility. Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu and his Armenian counterpart Eduard Nalbandian signed the documents and exchanged firm handshakes to applause.
Turkey and Armenia try to end enmity, despite gulf over bloody pastOctober 9th, 2009 Turkey and Armenia seek peaceISTANBUL — Enter the "Hall of Armenian Issue with Documents" at the military museum in Istanbul, and you get a very different picture of what many historians view as the first genocide of the 20th century. There, photographs show bodies of Ottoman Turks allegedly slaughtered and mutilated — the term "martyred" appears in the captions — by Armenian gangs.
Armenia's leader in France on tour seeking diaspora's backing for reconciliation with TurkeyOctober 2nd, 2009 Armenia president explains Turkey ties to diasporaPARIS — Armenian President Serge Sarkisian kicked off a tour of influential Armenian communities worldwide with talks in Paris on Friday, as he seeks support for his landmark bid to establish ties with Turkey after a century of enmity. The killing of up to 1.5 million Armenians under the Ottoman Empire has been the main barrier to reconciliation.
US presses Armenia and Turkey to normalize relations after decades of hostilitySeptember 30th, 2009 US prods Armenia, Turkey on diplomatic tiesNEW YORK — Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton on Monday pressed Armenia and Turkey to follow through on their commitment to normalize relations after decades of hostility. In separate meetings on the sidelines of the U.N.
Turkish PM: Turkey, Armenia to sign deal for diplomatic ties on Oct. 10September 30th, 2009 Turkey, Armenia to sign deal for tiesANKARA, Turkey — The Turkish premier says Turkey and Armenia will sign a deal to establish diplomatic ties on Oct. 10. The two had said last month they would conclude discussions to normalize relations by mid-October, though a major dispute remains over the World War I-era massacre of up to 1.5 million Armenians under the Ottoman Empire.
Turkish FM: Turkey, Armenia at start of "long process" toward normalization of tiesSeptember 1st, 2009 Turkish FM: Turkey, Armenia still have far to goANKARA, Turkey — Turkey and Armenia are at the beginning of a "long process" toward normalizing relations, Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu said Tuesday, suggesting the issue surrounding the massacres of Armenians 90 years ago remains tricky. Armenia and Turkey, bitter foes for a century, took a major step toward reconciliation late Tuesday, announcing they were launching final talks aimed at establishing diplomatic ties.
Turkey, Armenia agree to launch final talks aimed at establishing diplomatic tiesSeptember 1st, 2009 Turkey, Armenia to launch talks on diplomatic tiesYEREVAN, Armenia — Armenia and Turkey, bitter foes for a century, took a step toward reconciliation Monday by announcing they would launch final talks aimed at establishing diplomatic ties. But they won't discuss the deepest source of their enmity: the World War I-era massacres of Armenians under Ottoman rule.
A look at issues dividing neighbors Armenia and TurkeyAugust 31st, 2009 Issues dividing neighbors Armenia and TurkeyIssues dividing neighbors Armenia and Turkey, which announced Monday they would establish diplomatic relations for the first time:
GENOCIDE: Bitterly divided by killing of up to 1.5 million Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I, which many scholars consider first genocide of 20th century. Armenia wants it recognized as one of worst humanitarian atrocities.
Turkish official says Turkey and Armenia have agreed to establish diplomatic tiesAugust 31st, 2009 Turkey, Armenia agree to establish diplomatic tiesYEREVAN, Armenia — Armenia and Turkey agreed Monday to final talks aimed at establishing diplomatic relations and resolving a seemingly intractable rift that dates to the massacres of Armenians under Ottoman rule nearly 100 years ago. Both sides said in a joint statement they expected the talks to take six weeks and to end with an agreement setting up and developing ties.
Obama faces dilemma on annual day of remembrance for killings of Armenians by TurksApril 24th, 2009 Obama faces dilemma on Armenian killingsWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama faces a dilemma as he prepares to issue an annual presidential statement on the World War I-era killings of Armenians by Ottoman Turks. Referring to the killings as genocide could upend recent pledges of a closer partnership with Turkey, a vital ally in a critical region.
Thousands of Armenians mark anniversary of WWI-era mass killings; some burn Turkish flagsApril 24th, 2009 Thousands of Armenians mourn WWI-era mass killingsYEREVAN, Armenia — Thousands of Armenians are marking the anniversary of what they call the 1915 genocide despite a diplomatic thaw between Armenia and Turkey. They marched through Armenia's capital of Yerevan on Friday holding torches and candles on the killings' 94th anniversary.
Turkey says agreement reached with Armenia over roadmap to normalize strained tiesApril 22nd, 2009 Turkey says accord reached with Armenia on roadmapANKARA, Turkey — Turkey and Armenia have agreed on a roadmap for normalizing relations and reaching reconciliation, the Turkish Foreign Ministry said Wednesday, but it wasn't immediately clear how they would tackle their bitter dispute over Ottoman-era killings of ethnic Armenians. Turkish officials would not discuss that issue and the ministry statement said only that the two countries had worked out a framework for reaching a solution that would satisfy both sides.