Judge rules against BU student in downloading case
BOSTON — A federal judge has ruled that a Boston University student violated copyright laws when he swapped music online, paving the way for a jury to begin considering damages Friday.
Joel Tenenbaum, 25, of Providence, R.I., admitted on the witness stand Thursday that he downloaded and shared hundreds of songs by Nirvana, Green Day, The Smashing Pumpkins and other artists. The recording industry focused on only 30 songs in the case, the nation’s second music-downloading lawsuit against an individual to go to trial.
U.S. District Judge Nancy Gertner in Boston ruled late Thursday that the only issue for the jury now is whether his infringement was willful, and how much in damage to award four recording labels that sued him over the illegal file-sharing.
Under federal law, the recording companies are entitled to $750 to $30,000 per infringement but the law allows the jury to raise that to as much as $150,000 per track if it finds the infringements were willful.
Last month, a federal jury in Minneapolis ruled a Minnesota woman must pay $1.92 million, or $80,000 on each of 24 songs, after concluding Jammie Thomas-Rasset, 32, willfully violated the copyrights on those tunes.
The music industry has typically offered to settle such cases for about $5,000, though it has said that it stopped filing such lawsuits last August and is instead working with Internet service providers to fight the worst offenders. Cases already filed, however, are proceeding to trial.
On the witness stand, Tenenbaum acknowledged that he had downloaded more than 800 songs since 1999 and admitted that he lied in pretrial depositions when he said that his two sisters, friends and others may have been responsible for downloading the songs to his computer.
Under questioning from his own lawyer, Harvard Law School professor Charles Nesson, Tenenbaum said he now takes responsibility for the illegal swapping.
“I used the computer. I uploaded, I downloaded music … I did it,” Tenenbaum said.
His testimony contrasted with the tactic used by Thomas-Rasset. Even after the jury’s verdict, she declared, “There’s no way they’re ever going to get that.”
In opening arguments Tuesday, Nesson said Tenenbaum “was a kid who did what kids do” and should not be harshly penalized for technological advances that he said recording companies have been slow to embrace.
But Tim Reynolds, one of the lawyers representing the recording industry, said then that song-swappers like Tenenbaum take a significant toll on the recording industry’s revenues and on backup singers, sound engineers and other people who make a living in music.
Related News
Judge rules city of San Diego not responsible for 2007 landslideOctober 1st, 2009 Judge: City not responsible for Calif. landslideSAN DIEGO — A judge has ruled the city of San Diego is not responsible for a landslide that damaged dozens of homes in a La Jolla neighborhood two years ago.
Supreme Court to decide if federal medical officials can be sued for damagesSeptember 30th, 2009 Court to decide if feds liable for cancer mistakeWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court will decide whether the family of a now-deceased immigrant who was denied medical care for cancer while in custody can sue federal medical officials for damages. The case could have far-reaching implications for doctors, nurses and other medical personnel working for governments.
Judge allows Iraq to argue against paying damages to prisoners held during the Gulf WarSeptember 30th, 2009 Judge gives Iraq second chance in POW suitWASHINGTON — A federal judge is giving Iraq the chance to argue that it shouldn't have to pay damages to U.S. soldiers held as prisoners during the Gulf War in the early 1990s.
Judge says drug bust means no jam band concerts for Pa. 'music church'August 13th, 2009 Pa. 'music church' barred from holding concertsPITTSBURGH — A federal judge says a southwestern Pennsylvania church that claims "jam band" concerts are its services cannot hold four planned concerts this summer. U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose found that evidence of pervasive drug use at a concert on Aug.
Deputies say Fla. man blames cat for downloading child porn by jumping on computer keyboardAugust 7th, 2009 Fla. man blames cat paws for child porn downloadsJENSEN BEACH, Fla. — Florida investigators say a man accused of downloading child pornography is blaming his cat.
A day after bribery conviction, jury rules ex-congressman Jefferson must forfeit $470,000August 6th, 2009 Jury rules ex-congressman must forfeit $470,000ALEXANDRIA, Va. — A federal jury has ruled that a former Louisiana congressman must forfeit roughly $470,000 in bribery receipts.
Jury to decide damages after BU student admits 'I did it' in music-download trialJuly 31st, 2009 Judge in Mass. download case rules for music cos.BOSTON — A federal judge has ruled that a Boston University student violated copyright laws when he swapped music online, paving the way for a jury to begin considering damages Friday.
Pa. high court: Juveniles suing crooked judge who took money can keep their recordsJuly 23rd, 2009 Juveniles suing crooked Pa. judge can keep recordsALLENTOWN, Pa.
NY jury rules against free-speech claims of anti-war demonstrators at West Point gameJuly 22nd, 2009 NY jury: West Point didn't violate free speechWHITE PLAINS, N.Y. — West Point officials who ordered anti-war demonstrators out of an Army-Navy basketball game did not violate their First Amendment rights, a federal jury decided Wednesday.
Minn. woman who owes $1.92M for illegally sharing music asks judge to lower damagesJuly 7th, 2009 Woman seeks to decrease $1.92M fine for downloadsMINNEAPOLIS — A central Minnesota woman ordered to pay $1.92 million for illegally sharing copyright-protected music is asking a federal judge to reduce the damages she must pay or grant a new trial, while the recording industry is taking steps to make sure she doesn't share music again. Last month, a federal jury ruled Jammie Thomas-Rasset, 32, willfully violated the copyrights on 24 songs, and that she must pay $80,000 per song.
Recording industry wants Minn. woman barred from downloading and sharing music in futureJuly 6th, 2009 Industry wants to ban Minn. woman from downloadingMINNEAPOLIS — Just weeks after a federal jury ruled that a Minnesota woman must pay $1.92 million for illegally sharing copyright-protected music, the recording industry wants to make sure she doesn't do it again.
High court rules for injured seaman in dispute with ship owner; OK to sue for punitive damagesJune 25th, 2009 Court rules for seaman in dispute with ship ownerWASHINGTON — The Supreme Court has ruled that seamen injured on the job may sue for punitive damages when employers refuse to pay for medical care and time off. The court, by a 5-4 vote Thursday, decided in favor of Edgar L.
Big fine could be big trouble for both defendants and recording industry in file-sharing caseJune 19th, 2009 Big fine could be big trouble in downloading caseMINNEAPOLIS — The $1.92 million verdict against a Minnesota woman accused of sharing 24 songs over the Internet could ratchet up the pressure on other defendants to settle with the recording industry — if the big fine can withstand an appeal. "Normally in our American legal system, we say the punishment should fit the crime," said Ken Port, director of the Intellectual Property Institute at William Mitchell College of Law in St.
Recording industry vows to prove Minnesota woman illegally shared 24 songsJune 16th, 2009 Music cos. vow to show Minn. woman shared 24 songsMINNEAPOLIS — The recording industry began its second attempt at proving that a Minnesota woman engaged in illegal sharing of copyrighted music on the Internet and should be held accountable.
Suburban NYC family settles music piracy tussle for $7,000 after 4 yearsApril 27th, 2009 Suburban NYC family settles music piracy suitWHITE PLAINS, N.Y. — After battling a suburban family for four years over music downloads, the recording industry has agreed to accept $7,000 — paid in installments — to settle its federal piracy lawsuit.
Loading ...