Judge overturns Bush administration logging rule
GRANTS PASS, Ore. — A federal judge has struck down the Bush administration’s change to a rule designed to protect the northern spotted owl from logging in national forests.
U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken ruled from Oakland, Calif., on Tuesday that the U.S. Forest Service failed to take a hard look at the environmental impacts of changing the rule to make it easier to cut down forest habitat of species such as the spotted owl and salmon on 193 million acres of national forests.
“I am hopeful that this is the last nail in the coffin to (President George W.) Bush’s assault on our public forests,” said Pete Frost, an attorney for the Western Environmental Law Center in Eugene, which represented plaintiffs in one of two cases challenging the rule.
At stake was a provision of the National Forest Management Act that required maintaining viable populations of species that indicate the health of an ecosystem, such as the spotted owl. The Bush administration changed the rule last year so it required a framework of protection, rather than maintaining viable populations of wildlife.
The ruling marked the third time federal courts have turned back attempts to change the 1984 version of what is known as the viability rule within the National Forest Management Act.
The judge wrote that an environmental impact statement done by the Forest Service “does not evaluate the environmental impacts of the 2008 rule,” and the agency failed to comply with Endangered Species Act requirements to consult with other federal agencies on whether the rule changes would jeopardize the survival of endangered species.
Instead, the Forest Service argued that the rule changes themselves had no direct environmental impact until they were applied to specific projects.
The judge admonished the Forest Service for simply copying legal arguments already rejected in two court rulings into their latest justification for the rule change.
Forest Service spokesman Joe Walsh said in an e-mail that he could not immediately comment on the ruling.
Andy Stahl, director of Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics in Eugene, said until the National Forest Management Act was enacted in 1976, the Forest Service had wide latitude to do as it pleased with little oversight — a situation the Bush administration hoped to recreate.
After President Bush was elected in 2000, his administration systematically worked to increase national forest logging by changing the rules for enforcing environmental laws, but was consistently turned back by federal court rulings.
“This court decision sends the Forest Service back to square zero and upholds the promise … that forest plans be meaningful and they actually protect forests,” he said.
Related News
Agency denies endangered species listing for spotted seals off AlaskaOctober 15th, 2009 US spotted seals denied ESA protectionANCHORAGE, Alaska — A federal agency says it will not list two populations of spotted seals off Alaska's coast as threatened or endangered. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration announced Thursday it will, however, list a population of spotted seals that live off the coasts of Russia and China as threatened.
Federal agency denies endangered listing for spotted seals near AlaskaOctober 15th, 2009 Feds deny protection for spotted seals near AlaskaANCHORAGE, Alaska — Spotted seals off Alaska's coast do not merit endangered species protection despite losses of Arctic sea ice from global warming, a federal agency announced Thursday. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, however, will list as threatened a small population of spotted seals that live off the coasts of Russia and China.
Leatherback sea turtles to get critical habitat in Pacific ocean off Oregon, CaliforniaOctober 8th, 2009 Sea turtles to get critical habitat in PacificFederal fisheries managers have agreed to designate critical habitat for threatened leatherback sea turtles in the Pacific ocean off Oregon and California. NOAA Fisheries officials said Thursday they will have the critical habitat designation done by Dec.
Feds designate southwest Alaska shoreline as protected habitat for threatened sea ottersOctober 7th, 2009 Feds give sea otters habitat protection in AlaskaANCHORAGE, Alaska — Four years after being placed on the Endangered Species List, the dwindling sea otters of southwest Alaska on Wednesday were given an important recovery tool. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service designated nearly 5,900 square miles as critical habitat for sea otters in the Aleutian Islands, Bering Sea and Alaska Peninsula.
Federal judge asks critics to respond to Obama plan for Northwest salmon by Oct. 2September 23rd, 2009 Judge asks responses to Obama salmon planPORTLAND, Ore. — A federal judge has asked critics of the Obama administration's plan for Northwest salmon to file their responses by Oct.
Obama administration submits salmon plan to boost fish protection in Pacific NorthwestSeptember 15th, 2009 Obama administration submits salmon planPORTLAND, Ore. — The Obama administration says it will be more aggressive in protecting declining Pacific Northwest salmon runs and will study breaching some dams as a last resort in a long-awaited management plan.
Labor Department again tries to rollback Bush-era regulation on temporary farm workersSeptember 3rd, 2009 Labor Department proposes new rule on farm workersWASHINGTON — The Labor Department is taking another crack at rolling back a Bush administration regulation that made it easier for farmers to hire temporary foreign farm workers. The agency is proposing a new rule that would boost wages and increase safeguards for thousands of seasonal workers brought in each year to help farmers pick their crops.
Okla. judge overturns state law requiring women to receive an ultrasound before abortionAugust 18th, 2009 OK judge halts abortion law requiring ultrasoundOKLAHOMA CITY — An Oklahoma judge has overturned a law that required women seeking an abortion to receive an ultrasound and a doctor's description of the fetus. Oklahoma County District Judge Vicki Robertson granted a permanent injunction against the law Tuesday afternoon.
Federal judge denies Obama administration attempt to withdraw Bush-era mining ruleAugust 12th, 2009 Judge rebuffs Obama administration on mining ruleCHARLESTON, W.Va. — A federal judge on Wednesday rebuffed the Obama administration's attempt to reverse a last-minute Bush-era rule that allows surface mine waste to be dumped near streams.
Appeals court overturns appointment of guardian to oversee finances of Suleman octupletsAugust 7th, 2009 Appeals court overturns Suleman octuplets guardianSANTA ANA, Calif. — A California appeals court has ruled that Nadya Suleman's octuplets don't have to have a court-appointed guardian to oversee their estate.
Interior finds Bush plan to boost Oregon logging violates Endangered Species ActJuly 16th, 2009 Obama administration scraps Bush logging planGRANTS PASS, Ore. — The Obama administration on Thursday scrapped the Bush administration's last-ditch attempt to boost logging in Northwest forests by scaling back protection for the northern spotted owl.
Study finds Bush owl plan based on false conclusion that fire increasing threat to habitatJuly 7th, 2009 Study: No increased fire threat in owl habitatGRANTS PASS, Ore. — A new study challenges a basic justification about the threat of wildfires that the Bush administration used to make room for more logging in old growth forests that are home to the northern spotted owl.
Main islands of 50th US state eyed as critical habitat for endangered Hawaiian monk sealsJune 13th, 2009 Hawaiian Islands eyed for endangered seal habitatHONOLULU — The federal government said Friday it will revise the critical habitat for endangered Hawaiian monk seals for the first time in 21 years, which is likely to significantly expand the protection area to include beaches and waters of the main Hawaiian Islands. Environmentalists say the added habitat is needed to reverse the plight of the monk seals, which are among the most endangered marine mammals in the world, with fewer than 1,200 remaining.
Obama administration revokes last-minute action by Bush to limit endangered species protectionApril 28th, 2009 Rule limiting species protections revokedWASHINGTON — The Obama administration will again require federal agencies to consult with the government's wildlife experts before taking any actions that could impact threatened or endangered species. The Interior and Commerce departments said Tuesday they have revoked a last-minute rule change by the Bush administration that ended the consultation requirement.
Obama administration revokes last-minute action by Bush to limit endangered species protectionApril 28th, 2009 Gov't revokes rule limiting species protectionsWASHINGTON — Federal agencies again will have to consult with government wildlife experts before taking actions that could have an impact on threatened or endangered species. The Obama administration said Tuesday it was overturning a rule change made in the final weeks of the Bush presidency.
Loading ...