Iran expected to dominate G8 meeting in Italy
TRIESTE, Italy — Foreign ministers of Group of Eight countries are seeking to find a common position on Iran’s violent crackdown on protesters as they open a meeting in this northeastern Italian city.
Italy, the host of the meeting, said Thursday it wanted to send a tough message, but Italian officials in Trieste also stressed the need not to further isolate Iran. The EU commissioner for external relations condemned the use of excessive force, and called for dialogue among battling parties within Iran.
Italy originally invited Iran to attend the three-day gathering as a special guest, arguing that it could play an important role in stabilizing Afghanistan — an important focus of the meeting. But Italy retracted the invitation after Iran failed to respond, and after days of violent clashes with demonstrators protesting Iran’s disputed June 12 elections.
“I think it’s a missed opportunity for the Iranian government,” European Union External Relations Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner said.
Even in Iran’s absence, the country remained at the center of discussions as the delegates converged on this port city.
While several of the G-8’s European members have expressed concern about the postelection violence and urged a recount, it was unclear how strong a condemnation would emerge from the meeting in Trieste.
“Clearly the main point is striking the right balance between the inevitable language of condemnation and worry over violence and, on the other hand, the need not to close the door on Iran and not to accentuate its isolation,” said Maurizio Massari, the Italian Foreign Ministry spokesman. He said Italy did not want to get into the details of whether a re-count or re-election would be necessary.
President Barack Obama condemned the violence against protesters Tuesday and lent his strongest support yet to their accusations the hardline victory was a fraud. But the United States does not want to become a scapegoat for Iran’s cleric-led government.
Russia has said it backs the results that returned President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to power.
Russia’s Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said Wednesday that Russia, which hosted Ahmadinejad at a regional summit a few days after the election, so far had seen no legal violations in Iran’s crackdown. He said no action should be taken that would put lives in danger.
Lavrov said outside the Trieste meeting that “nobody wants to condemn” Tehran, according to the Italian news agency ANSA.
“Isolating Iran is the wrong approach,” Lavrov was quoted as saying by ANSA. “The key word is ‘involvement.’”
Lavrov held talks Thursday with Italian Foreign Minister Franco Frattini, who earlier Thursday had employed some of Italy’s strongest language to date to call for “a tough and clear position before the world” on Iran. Frattini sought to smooth over any differences, saying after the talks that details on the statement on Iran were being worked out.
“We’ll have a good text,” he said.
Frattini also had a meeting with Obama’s U.S. Mideast envoy, former Sen. George Mitchell.
As the delegates started arriving in Trieste amid tight security, dozens of Iranians and Italians gathered in the city in a show of solidarity with protesters in Iran. The demonstrators wore green arm bands and doctor’s masks on their faces. Some carried signs calling Ahmadinejad a “dictator and terrorist.” One sign said “NEDA-Stop the Killing,” in reference to the apparent shooting death of Neda Agha Soltan, a 26-year-old woman who bled to death in a Tehran street and now is a symbol for the demonstrators.
“Mass arbitrary arrests have to stop and crackdown against Iranian and foreign journalists is also unacceptable,” Ferrero-Waldner told reporters. The commissioner said that “we are all deeply concerned about the situation in Iran,” and she condemned “the excessive use of force by the security forces against any peaceful demonstrators, which has already cost quite a number of lives.”
But she also said the crisis should be settled through dialogue between the different forces within Iran.
“We don’t want to interfere in the internal affairs of Iran,” she said, “but I think we want to see them come to a dialogue and sort this very difficult situation out.”
The meeting, which opened with a working dinner, ends at midday Saturday.
On the agenda is a series of global issues, from counterterrorism to organized crime and piracy.
The Afghan conflict will take central stage Friday and Saturday, with U.S. envoy Richard Holbrooke and important regional players — including the foreign ministers of Afghanistan and Pakistan — joining in the discussions on five major points of discussion: border management, drug trafficking, economic development, refugees, and food security.
In all, 44 delegations will participate in the meeting of the eight industrial powers, including representatives from the Islamic Development Bank, the International Organization for Migration and the World Food Program.
On the sidelines of the summit will be a meeting of the Mideast Quartet — the United States, Russia, the European Union and the United Nations — to try to help move the Israeli-Palestinian peace process forward. Mitchell is to attend, as will a range of Arab League nations which will join in a follow-on session Friday afternoon. U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is grounded in Washington with a broken elbow.
Israel was not invited; the Foreign Ministry said that decision was taken by the Quartet, not Italy.
Associated Press Writer Nicole Winfield contributed to this report from Rome.
Related News
Western powers expect 'serious response' from Iran during Oct. 1 meetingSeptember 23rd, 2009 Western powers expect 'serious response' from IranUNITED NATIONS — The international community expects a "serious response" from Iran in discussions about Tehran's nuclear program at a meeting next month, the British foreign secretary said Wednesday. Six global powers are to hold talks with Iranian representatives Oct.
Russian media: Russian delegation official says Moscow does not ruling out new Iran sanctionsSeptember 23rd, 2009 Reports: Moscow not ruling out new Iran sanctionsMOSCOW — Russian news agencies are citing an official in the Russian delegation in New York as saying Moscow does not rule out new sanctions against Iran over its nuclear programs. The reports are the first indication that Russia could support additional measures to punish Iran for its defiance of the international community.
Russian FM says no new sanctions on Iran; comes as Washington shelves missile defense plansSeptember 17th, 2009 Russian FM says no new sanctions on IranMOSCOW — Russia's foreign minister says Moscow firmly opposes any new sanctions against Iran. Sergey Lavrov says new tougher sanctions would ruin hopes for solving the Iranian nuclear program through talks.
G8 deplores detentions of journalists in IranJuly 9th, 2009 L'AQUILA - The Group of Eight (G8) industrialised nations Wednesday criticised the "unjustified" detention of journalists in Iran and condemned Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for denying the Holocaust. In a joint declaration issued at a summit in the central Italian city of L'Aquila, G8 leaders reiterated their "full respect for the sovereignty of Iran".
Italy says on the eve of G-8 summit that world leaders have yet to agree on IranJuly 7th, 2009 Berlusconi: G-8 divided on IranL'AQUILA, Italy — The leaders of Group of Eight countries have yet to forge a common position on Iran's violent crackdown on post-electoral protests, Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi said Tuesday on the eve of the summit. Berlusconi, who chairs the gathering of world leaders opening Wednesday, noted that some countries, such as France, were calling for tougher action against Tehran, while others, such as Russia, favored a softer stance to keep dialogue open.
G8 ministers call for end of violence in Iran, urge Tehran to reflect will of people in voteJune 26th, 2009 G8 to Iran: end violence, reflect will of peopleTRIESTE, Italy — Group of Eight foreign ministers criticized Iran's postelection violence, and urged its ruling clergy on Friday to ensure the outcome of the disputed ballot reflects the will of the Iranian people. A statement by the ministers from the industrialized countries also said the door must remain open to dialogue on Iran's nuclear program but expressed "deep concern" over the proliferation risk.
G8 foreign ministers lament corruption in Afghanistan, call for regional cooperationJune 26th, 2009 G8 foreign ministers lament Afghan corruptionTRIESTE, Italy — Foreign ministers from the Group of Eight countries meeting in Italy lamented corruption and the lack of basic services such as health and water in Afghanistan, saying Friday that better cooperation among countries in the region was needed to promote stability. The foreign ministers from the world's industrialized nations endorsed Pakistan's battle against Taliban insurgents and promised to work more with the country's government "in the face of terrorism, extremism and militancy." They called for better regional cooperation in fighting terrorism and drug trafficking in the region.
World must help ordinary Palestinians: BlairJune 26th, 2009 TRIESTE - The only way to solve the Israel-Palestine conflict is to help ordinary Palestinians rebuild their economy, especially in Gaza, UN Middle East quartet's special envoy to the region Tony Blair said Friday. "We are all worried that we support Gaza and then there's a further outbreak of conflict, but the best way of preventing that ...
G8 gives Iran until September to respond to US offerJune 26th, 2009 TRIESTE - The world's eight most powerful nations have given Iran until September to respond to a US offer of direct talks on Tehran's nuclear programme, G8 foreign ministers agreed Friday. The G8's leaders are to meet in New York in September on the fringes of the United Nations General Assembly, and that will be "an opportunity to verify whether Iran has responded to the international community's negotiation offer," Italy's Foreign Minister Franco Frattini said.
G8 foreign ministers call for end of violence in Iran, urge Tehran to seek peaceful solution.June 26th, 2009 G8 countries urge end of violence in IranTRIESTE, Italy — Foreign ministers from Group of Eight countries meeting in Italy are calling for the immediate end of violence in Iran and are calling on Tehran authorities to seek a peaceful solution. The officials gathering in Trieste have worked to smooth over differences among themselves and address Iran's violent crackdown on protesters following disputed elections.
G8 foreign ministers meeting in Italy at work to hammer out shared document on IranJune 26th, 2009 G8 meeting at work on shared document on IranTRIESTE, Italy — Foreign ministers from Group of Eight countries meeting in Italy were working to smooth over differences and hammer out a joint document Friday addressing Iran's violent crackdown on protesters. French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner said the group was working on a document.
Reports: G8 foreign ministers call for "democratic dialogue" in IranJune 26th, 2009 G8 countries urge 'democratic dialogue' in IranTRIESTE, Italy — Italian news reports say that foreign ministers from Group of Eight countries meeting in Italy have expressed worry over Iran's post-election situation and called for "democratic dialogue."
The officials gathering in Trieste have been working to smooth over differences and hammer out a joint document Friday addressing Iran's violent crackdown on protesters following disputed elections. The ANSA news agency said the final document would say that the Iranian crisis must be resolved through peaceful means and democratic dialogue.
Italy says it considers invitation to Iran for this week's G-8 summit rejectedJune 22nd, 2009 Italy: no response from Iran to G-8 invitationROME — Italy considers its G-8 meeting invitation to Iran rejected since Tehran has not yet responded, the foreign minister said Monday in a sign of Rome's growing impatience. Italy had invited Iran to attend talks on Afghanistan and Pakistan to be held during the Group of Eight foreign ministers' meeting starting Thursday in Trieste.
Report: Italy says Iran should reply to invitation to this week's G8 summitJune 22nd, 2009 Italy presses Iran for response to G-8 invitationROME — Italy will consider its G-8 meeting invitation to Iran rejected unless Tehran replies by the end of the day, the foreign minister said Monday in a sign of Rome's growing impatience. Italy has invited Iran to attend talks on Afghanistan and Pakistan to be held during the Group of Eight foreign ministers' meeting starting Thursday in Trieste.
UN chief: Quartet of key Mideast peacemakers to meet in Italy later this monthJune 12th, 2009 UN chief: key Mideast peacemakers to meetUNITED NATIONS — Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon says that key parties trying to promote Mideast peace will meet in Italy later this month. Ban gave no details on the date and place but said Thursday he expects the Quartet of the United Nations, the United States, the European Union and Russia to discuss the next steps to promote Israeli-Palestinian peace.