Netanyahu aide: US contrasting with Israel on Iran
JERUSALEM — Comments by President Barack Obama and Vice President Joe Biden about a possible Israeli attack on Iran’s nuclear facilities were directed at Iran and meant to “distinguish” the U.S. from Israel, the Israeli premier’s national security adviser said Wednesday.
Also, American leaders are signaling Iran that the U.S. is still interested in diplomatic engagement, the adviser, Uzi Arad, told The Associated Press.
Speaking to ABC-TV on Sunday, Biden appeared to depart from his previous comment that an Israeli attack on Iran would be ill-advised, saying: “Israel can determine for itself — it’s a sovereign nation — what’s in their interest and what they decide to do relative to Iran and anyone else.”
The following day, Obama in a visit to Moscow was asked by CNN if Biden’s comment’s represented the U.S. giving Israel a “green light” to attack.
“Absolutely not,” the president replied.
The next day, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. Mike Mullen, warned that a military strike to thwart Iran’s nuclear weapons capability could have grave and unpredictable consequences. Iran has denied trying to build nuclear bombs.
Arad said the back-and-forth was an American message toward Iran, rather than Israel, noting that Biden also said in the interview, “If the Iranians respond to the offer of engagement, we will engage.”
“My understanding of what Biden said is that the second part is the interesting part — not that Israel is sovereign to act, but that he said the United States acts differently. Essentially, he distinguished himself” from Israel, Arad said. “What was important for him was to transmit to the Iranians that we, the United States, are different.”
Israel is uncomfortable with the attempt to open talks with Iran, fearing that this would give the Iranians more time to build their weapons. Israel has called for world action to stop the Iranian nuclear program and has not taken its own military options off the table.
Arad said Obama’s quick rebuttal was meant to clarify that the United States was still interested in engagement — despite prospects for dialogue being rattled by Iran’s heavy crackdown on protesters in the country’s disputed presidential election — and was not suggesting that his administration would not stand in the way of an Israeli strike.
“The president felt the need to correct the impression that Biden’s comments made,” he added.
Arad, one of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s top aides, said Israeli officials have often discussed the Iran issue in Washington.
Israel considers Iran a strategic threat because of its nuclear program and missile development, dismissing Iranian denials that it intends to build nuclear weapons.
Israel has been quiet publicly regarding its military intentions but has sent several signals to Iran.
This week an Israeli submarine said by foreign experts to have the capability of carrying nuclear-tipped missiles returned to the Mediterranean after crossing to the Red Sea in the direction of Iran, a mission seen as a warning. Also, Israel has held air force maneuvers that were described unofficially as practicing an attack on Iranian targets.
Arad insisted that Israel’s right to decide its own self defense is a right that “the United States cannot take away from Israel, and doesn’t try to.”
Related News
Obama's deputy national security adviser Mark Lippert leaving to return to active duty NavyOctober 1st, 2009 Obama deputy national security adviser takes leaveWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama's deputy national security adviser is taking a leave of absence. The White House says Mark Lippert is returning to active duty in the U.S.
Israel welcomes Russian stand on Iran sanctions as firm international policy against nukesSeptember 24th, 2009 Israel welcomes Russian stand on Iran sanctionsJERUSALEM — A senior Israeli official welcomes steps by Russia toward endorsing additional sanctions against Iran as a way of stopping its nuclear program. Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Daniel Ayalon said Russian President Dmitry Medvedev opened the door to a firm international stand against Iran.
Israel's military chief says options remain 'on the table' for dealing with IranSeptember 21st, 2009 Israel's army chief: All options on table vs. IranJERUSALEM — Israel's military chief said Monday that all options remain "on the table" in dealing with Iran's nuclear program, indicating that the Jewish state has not abandoned the possibility of a military strike.
Cal State Northridge grad student held for 10 months in Iran returns to Los AngelesAugust 14th, 2009 Iran-American held 10 months in Iran returns to LALOS ANGELES — A graduate student detained for nearly a year in Iran has returned to Los Angeles. Esha Momeni (ESH'-ah moh-men-EE') was detained Oct.
US national security advisor discusses Iran with IsraelisJuly 29th, 2009 JERUSALEM - US National Security Advisor James Jones was in Israel Wednesday for briefings related to Iran's nuclear programme, in the midst of a week of intense US-Israeli diplomacy. General Jones heard updates from senior Israeli security officials, before scheduled meetings with Israel Army Chief of Staff Gaby Ashkenazi and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu later in the day.
Clinton: Israel should give a chance for US policies on Iran's nuclear ambitions time to workJuly 26th, 2009 Clinton says Israel should be patient on IranWASHINGTON — Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton is implicitly urging Israel to give U.S. policy on Iran's nuclear ambitions a chance to work.
Top Iranian general says country has the capability to strike Israel's nuclear facilitiesJuly 25th, 2009 Iran: We can hit Israel's nukesTEHRAN, Iran — The head of Iran's elite Revolutionary Guard said Saturday that his country has the capability to strike Israel's nuclear facilities and wouldn't be afraid to do so if it was attacked. "If the Israeli entity engages in any kind of attack on Iran, we have the capability to strike all targets in occupied Palestine," General Mohammad Ali Jafari told the Arabic-language channel, al-Alam.
Israel calls for 'determined action' against IranJune 7th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel Sunday urged the international community to take determined action to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons. The Israeli foreign ministry also questioned the UN nuclear watchdog's ability to monitor Iran's nuclear programme.
Israeli FM Lieberman says Israel does not intend to bomb IranJune 3rd, 2009 FM says Israel does not intend to bomb IranMOSCOW — Israel's foreign minister says his country does not intend to bomb Iran. Avigdor Lieberman is also telling reporters that other countries in the region and around the world should be concerned about Iran's nuclear program.
Obama understands why Israel considers Iran an existential threatMay 18th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Ahead of his meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, US President Barack Obama has said he understands why Israel considers Iran an existential threat. "I understand very clearly that Israel considers Iran an existential threat, and given some of the statements that have been made by [Iranian] President [Mahmoud] Ahmadinejad, you can understand why," The Jerusalem Post quoted Obama, as saying.
Israeli leader gives cautious backing to Obama overtures to IranMay 5th, 2009 Israeli president: US approach to Iran OK for nowWASHINGTON — Israeli President Shimon Peres offered a cautious endorsement of new U.S. overtures to Iran following a longer-than-expected White House meeting with President Barack Obama.
Israel's postal service issues stamps of Christian holy sites ahead of pope visitMay 1st, 2009 Israel issues special stamps ahead of pope visitJERUSALEM — The Israeli postal service has issued a dozen special stamps marking the upcoming visit of Pope Benedict XVI to the Holy Land. The stamps, which will be made available to the public on Monday, feature 12 Christian holy sites in Israel that the pope will visit during his May 11-15 tour.
Israel's Lieberman says Iran main obstacle to resolving conflict in the Middle EastApril 24th, 2009 Israel's FM: Iran is obstacle to Mideast peaceJERUSALEM — Iran is the main obstacle to peace in the Mideast, Israel's new foreign minister said in an interview published Friday. Avigdor Lieberman told The Jerusalem Post that it will be "impossible to resolve any problem in our region" without dealing with Iran's nuclear program and its support for militant groups opposed to Israel, such as Hezbollah and Hamas.
US bars entry of Israel's new national security aideMarch 17th, 2009 WASHINGTON - The United States has decided to bar the entry of Uzi Arad, who is expected to be Israel's new national security adviser, for nearly two years on the grounds that he is an intelligence risk. According to the Washington Times, Arad, a former member and director of intelligence for the Mossad, Israel's spy service, is mentioned in the indictment of Lawrence Franklin, a former Pentagon analyst who pleaded guilty in 2005 to providing classified information about Iran in a conversation with two employees of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC).
Ceasefire shows Israel's defeat in Gaza, says Iran officialJanuary 17th, 2009 TEHRAN - A senior official at Iran's presidential office Sunday said that the unilateral ceasefire announced by Israel in Gaza was an admission of defeat, IRNA reported. Ali-Reza Zaker Isfahani, chairman of the Strategic Studies, said Israel's unilateral ceasefire indicated its absolute defeat.