Britain to back IRA victims’ lawsuit against Libya
DUBLIN — Britain’s sudden decision to support a lawsuit against Libya by Irish Republican Army victims raised hopes Monday that thousands maimed or bereaved by IRA bombs might one day receive compensation.
Libya admits it shipped hundreds of tons of weaponry to the IRA in the mid-1980s, most critically the plastic explosive Semtex at the heart of the outlawed group’s deadliest bombs. Lawyers say they expect the regime of Col. Moammar Gadhafi to pay 10 million pounds ($16 million) to each person on their growing list of IRA victims.
“The fact is, if the Libyans hadn’t provided the IRA with the Semtex, my son would be alive today,” said peace activist Colin Parry, one of more than 150 litigants.
The case was first filed in U.S. courts in 2006 but is currently in limbo. Parry’s 12-year-old son and a 3-year-old boy were killed when the IRA bombed a shopping district in Warrington, northwest England, in February 1993.
British Prime Minister Gordon Brown has endured scathing criticism since Scotland’s Aug. 20 release of the only person convicted of the 1988 Lockerbie bombing. He suffered renewed attacks Sunday, then reversed his government’s hands-off policy toward the lawsuit.
Opposition leaders and IRA victims denounced Brown as weak for failing to tie the Lockerbie prison release to a compensation deal. Within hours, the prime minister announced his government would provide Foreign Office support for IRA victims as they seek meetings with Libyan leaders.
Gadhafi’s son Saif said his government would permit access to Libyan courts — but would mount a stern defense.
“Anyone can knock on our door. You go to the court. They have their lawyers. We have our lawyers,” Saif Gadhafi said in a Sky News interview in the Libyan capital of Tripoli.
Asked if his father’s government would reject compensation demands from IRA victims, Saif Gadhafi responded, “Of course.”
Libya has paid billions to other victims of Libyan-sponsored bloodshed as part of its successful push since 2001 to end its diplomatic isolation and reopen trade with the West.
Libya agreed in 2003 to pay more than $2.1 billion in compensation for the 270 people — including 180 Americans and 52 Britons — killed in the December 1988 destruction of a civilian jet over Lockerbie, Scotland.
And in mid-2008, the Bush administration negotiated a deal that closed all lawsuits by U.S. citizens against Libya for state-sponsored terrorism. In October, Libya paid $1.5 billion into a joint fund to compensate any qualifying U.S. and Libyan citizens for violence, including the 1986 bombing of a Berlin disco frequented by U.S. soldiers; the 1989 downing of a French airliner over Niger that killed 170; and the U.S. air assault on the Libyan cities of Tripoli and Benghazi in 1986.
That fund also covers a handful of Americans wounded or killed in IRA attacks. Their out-of-court payments torpedoed the class-action lawsuit being pursued in the United States chiefly by residents of Northern Ireland and England, because the case needed American plaintiffs to proceed on U.S. soil.
Jason McCue, the London lawyer leading the lawsuit-in-limbo, said Britain’s policy reversal could spur Libya to reach an out-of-court settlement.
McCue said he accepted now that Britain couldn’t negotiate directly with Libya because of earlier agreements that reopened British-Libyan relations.
As part of those talks, Libya accepted responsibility for the Lockerbie attack, agreed to compensate its victims, and gave Britain documents detailing its arms shipments to the IRA from 1984 to 1986.
McCue said he expected thousands more claimants could come forward, given that the IRA killed more than 400 people, wounded thousands more and destroyed billions’ in property following the arrival of the Libyan arsenal.
McCue’s case centers on 10 of the IRA’s biggest bombings from 1987 to 1996, the year before the underground group called a cease-fire. British explosives experts determined that all involved Libyan-supplied Semtex.
The first bombing was a November 1987 attack on a British war memorial service in the Northern Ireland town of Enniskillen that killed 11 Protestant civilians and wounded 63. The most recent was the IRA’s truck-bomb attack in June 1996 in the center of Manchester, northwest England, which wounded about 200 people.
Also Monday, Scotland’s administration denied that it relied on Libyan-commissioned medical assessments when deciding to free convicted Lockerbie bomber Abdel Baset al-Megrahi.
Scottish Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill confirmed he received the assessments Aug. 18, two days before al-Megrahi’s release. But MacAskill said his decision was based solely on evidence from the Scottish Prison Service.
And a Libyan newspaper published a column saying al-Megrahi received a celebratory homecoming “not because he was a freed convict … but because he is an innocent who was taken hostage.”
Related News
Despite Lockerbie bomber's release row, Brown to meet GaddafiSeptember 21st, 2009 LONDON - British Prime Minister Gordon Brown is all set to meet Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi this week. The meeting is likely to add more fuel to Britain's controversial decision to free Lockerbie bomber Abdelbaset Al Megrahi last month.
British Foreign Office denies 'secret deal' with Libya over policewoman's murderSeptember 13th, 2009 British Foreign Office denies 'secret' Libya dealLONDON — Britain's complicated relations with Libya returned to center stage Sunday as Foreign Office diplomats took the unusual step of denying a newspaper report about a secret deal with Moammar Gaddafi's regime. The officials said there was no truth to a front-page Sunday Times article alleging that British diplomats had made a secret deal with Libya three years ago that would prevent the killer of a British policewoman from going on trial in Britain.
Families of 17 sailors killed in USS Cole attack want more compensation from SudanSeptember 11th, 2009 USS Cole sailors' families seek more compensationNORFOLK, Va. — The families of 17 sailors killed in the 2000 attack on the USS Cole are asking to reopen their lawsuit against Sudan in an effort to seek more money.
Brown does a U-turn, vows to support IRA victims suing LibyaSeptember 7th, 2009 LONDON - Hours after refusing to get involved in the issue, British Prime Minister Gordon Brown has vowed to support IRA victims' families in their fight to get compensation from Libya. He declared that he would set up teams of Foreign Office officials dedicated to helping victims and their loved ones sue Libya.
British prime minister faces outrage over refusal to press Libya for terrorism compensationSeptember 6th, 2009 New letters on UK-Libyan ties outrage IRA victimsLONDON — Britain made no demands that Libya offer compensation for Britons killed by Libyan explosives supplied to Irish Republican terrorists for fear it could jeopardize ties with Tripoli, according to new documents released Sunday. The revelation prompted accusations that the British government had acted to protect energy deals, and added to questions about whether trade ties influenced last month's decision to release Lockerbie bomber Abdel Baset al-Megrahi.
Britain's prime minister faces outrage over refusal to press Libya for terrorism compensationSeptember 6th, 2009 Documents on UK-Libyan ties outrage IRA victimsLONDON — Britain made no demands that Libya offer compensation for Britons killed by Libyan explosives supplied to the Irish Republican Army for fear it could jeopardize ties with Tripoli, according to new documents released Sunday. The revelation prompted accusations that Britain had acted to protect energy deals, and added to questions about whether trade ties influenced last month's decision to release Lockerbie bomber Abdel Baset al-Megrahi.
Oil, trade was big part of Lockerbie bombers release deal, admits StrawSeptember 5th, 2009 LONDON - Britain's Justice secretary Jack Straw has admitted for the first time that trade and oil deals with Libya played a very big part in the handling of the Lockerbie bomber's case. He said trade was a major influence on his decision to include Abdelbaset Al Megrahi in a prisoner transfer agreement with Libya signed two years ago, just as BP was seeking a multi-billion pound deal there.
Libya appoints British judge to panel intended to resolve conflict with SwitzerlandSeptember 2nd, 2009 Libya appoints judge to Swiss arbitration panelTRIPOLI, Libya — Libya appointed a British judge to an arbitration panel set up with Switzerland to examine the arrest of Moammar Gadhafi's son in Geneva last year, the Foreign Ministry said Wednesday. The independent panel is meant to defuse tension between the two countries over the arrest of Hannibal Gadhafi and his wife on July 15, 2008, in a luxury hotel for allegedly beating up two of their servants.
NJ lawyer settles lawsuit over solicitations to families of victims of plane that hit NY homeSeptember 1st, 2009 Lawyer settles over NY plane crash solicitationsNEWARK, N.J. — A New Jersey attorney accused of soliciting families of victims of a plane that crashed into a New York home too soon after the accident has settled a lawsuit with the government.
Britain scraps trade trip by Prince Andrew to Libya in wake of Lockerbie bomber controversyAugust 24th, 2009 Britain scraps trip by Prince Andrew to LibyaEDINBURGH, Scotland — Britain has scrapped a visit to Libya by Prince Andrew amid controversy over the release of the Lockerbie bomber. The prince has visited the country several times in his role as a British trade ambassador, and his office said last week that a trip for next month was in the planning stages.
Freed Lockerbie bomber boards plane at Glasgow Airport for flight to LibyaAugust 20th, 2009 Lockerbie bomber boards plane for flight to LibyaGLASGOW, Scotland — Freed Lockerbie bomber Abdel Baset al-Megrahi boarded a plane waiting at Glasgow Airport to take him home to Libya on Thursday. Al-Megrahi walked slowly up the steps of the Airbus operated by Libyan airline Afriqiyah.
Genesee & Wyoming posts 1.2 percent drop in July traffic on lower pulp and paper shipmentsAugust 14th, 2009 Genesee & Wyoming July traffic falls 1.2 percentGREENWICH, Conn. — Regional freight railroad operator Genesee & Wyoming Inc.
9/11 families angered by Justice Dept. brief supporting Saudi royal family in attack lawsuitMay 30th, 2009 9/11 families angered by US support for SaudisNEW YORK — Relatives of Sept. 11 victims say they're angry that the Justice Department is supporting the Saudi royal family's bid to be removed from a 9/11 lawsuit.
US raises American flag over embassy in Libya for first time in 30 yearsMay 13th, 2009 US flag flutters over embassy in LibyaTRIPOLI, Libya — The U.S. has raised the American flag over its embassy in Libya for the first time in about 30 years.
UK ratifies prisoner transfer deal with Libya, could have implications for Lockerbie caseApril 29th, 2009 UK, Libya ratify prisoner transfer dealLONDON — Britain and Libya have ratified a prisoner transfer deal that could potentially allow the man convicted of the Lockerbie bombings to serve out the remainder of his sentence in the North African country. Britain's Foreign Office says the deal was signed in November and ratified Wednesday.