Insurance industry assails health care bill
WASHINGTON — Insurance companies aren’t playing nice any more on the health care overhaul. The industry put out a report Monday concluding that the Senate’s health care legislation would drive up costs to consumers, delivering a dire message at a crucial point in the debate and potentially threatening President Barack Obama’s top domestic priority.
The White House and congressional Democrats dismissed the late-in-coming message as a “hatchet job.” But it put them and their allies on the defensive a day ahead of a pivotal vote in the Senate Finance Committee on sweeping legislation that aims to achieve Obama’s goals of extending coverage to the uninsured and curtailing spiraling medical costs.
“I really don’t think it’s worth the paper it’s written on,” AARP Executive Vice President John Rother said Monday of the insurance industry report. “If anyone believes it, that’s a problem.”
The study commissioned by America’s Health Insurance Plans marked a shift in strategy by the industry, which had been working for months behind the scenes to help shape health care legislation. With the Senate panel set to vote on legislation the industry fears could result in a loss of revenue, the insurers went on the attack, in dramatic fashion.
Late Sunday, AHIP sent reporters and its member companies a new accounting firm study that projects the legislation would add $1,700 a year to the cost of family coverage in 2013, when most of the major provisions in the bill would be in effect.
Premiums for a single person would go up by $600 more than would be the case without the legislation, the PricewaterhouseCoopers analysis concluded in the study commissioned by the insurance group.
The study “confirms that the current legislation will make coverage less affordable for individuals, families and employers, and the study shows that costs will go up even faster than they would under the current system,” Karen Ignagni, the top industry lobbyist in Washington, told reporters in a conference call Monday.
The industry said the cost increases would result from new taxes and from a weakening of the penalties for failing to get insurance — a change that would let Americans postpone getting coverage until they get sick.
Ignagni said her group wanted to continue to work with lawmakers to improve the proposals on Capitol Hill, but when questioned she didn’t rule out using the findings from the study in an ad campaign against Obama’s plans.
Democrats and their allies criticized the report as biased. Health economist Len Nichols of the New America Foundation contended that, among other problems, the study failed to take into account the impact of subsidies that would help low- and middle-income people buy coverage. He said it also left out a key expected impact of a proposed new tax on high-value insurance plans, which is a reduction in the use of health services.
“It was paid for by people who are not interested in an objective analysis of the truth but are interested in a particular point of view being inserted into the political process right now,” Nichols said.
Spokesmen for the White House and for Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus, D-Mont., attacked the report along similar lines. “It’s a health insurance company hatchet job, plain and simple,” said Baucus spokesman Scott Mulhauser.
The committee is to vote on its 10-year, $829 billion bill on Tuesday, but more important to the industry are the steps beyond the panel’s decision.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., will be merging the bill with a companion measure from the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, with the goal of a sweeping yet affordable bill. In the House, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and other Democratic leaders have been pulling together legislation from three committees.
Unlike the 1990s, when it contributed to the failure of President Bill Clinton’s health overhaul, the insurance industry has been attracted by the promise of millions more people getting coverage — millions of new consumers buying policies.
The Baucus plan got a boost last week when the Congressional Budget Office estimated it would cover 94 percent of eligible Americans while still reducing the federal deficit. But Ignagni said that number needed to be in the high 90s for the system to work without crushing costs for privately insured individuals.
The PricewaterhouseCoopers analysis attempted to get at that issue, concluding that a combination of factors in the bill — and decisions by lawmakers as they amended it — would raise costs.
The chief reason, said the report, is a decision by lawmakers to weaken proposed penalties for failing to get health insurance. The bill would require insurers to take all applicants, doing away with denials for pre-existing health problems. In return, most Americans would be required to carry coverage, either through an employer or a government program, or by buying it themselves.
But the CBO estimated that even with new federal subsidies, some 17 million Americans would still be unable to afford health insurance. Faced with that affordability problem, senators opted to ease the fines for going without coverage from the levels Baucus originally proposed. The industry says that will only let people postpone getting coverage until they get sick.
On the Net:
America’s Health Insurance Plans: www.ahip.org/
Senate Finance Committee: finance.senate.gov/
Related News
On eve of critical vote, insurance industry group mounts last-minute attack on reform effortOctober 12th, 2009 Insurers mount attack against health reform
WASHINGTON — The health insurance industry is warning that a comprehensive Senate bill would increase the cost of a typical policy by hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars a year after lawmakers eased up on the requirement that all Americans get coverage. The stinging attack came on the eve of a pivotal Senate vote and was a clear message to President Barack Obama and congressional Democratic leaders who have been making headway on overhauling the nation's health care system.
Supporters of health care overhaul push back against insurance industry attackOctober 12th, 2009 Seniors lobby challenges health insurance reportWASHINGTON — Supporters of President Barack Obama's drive to remake health care are pushing back against a dire report from the insurance industry warning of hefty new costs for consumers from the latest legislation. "I really don't think it's worth the paper it's written on," AARP Executive Vice President John Rother told reporters Monday.
On eve of critical vote, insurers say Senate bill would raise cost of premiumsOctober 11th, 2009 Insurers escalate criticism of health overhaulWASHINGTON — The insurance industry sharply escalated its criticism of the Senate health care bill Sunday, charging that the legislation would shift costs to privately insured people, raising the price of a typical policy by hundreds — if not thousands — of dollars annually. A spokesman for Sen.
Health care issues: Are insurance market changes enough to fix the health care system?October 5th, 2009 Health care issues: Insurance market overhaulA look at key issues in the health care debate:
THE ISSUE: Are changes in the insurance industry enough to fix problems in the nation's health care system?
THE POLITICS: To help expand health coverage, President Barack Obama is seeking changes to underwriting practices that can prevent Americans from obtaining affordable insurance. His proposals would ban higher premiums, caps or denial of coverage because of a pre-existing medical condition or when a person gets sick.
Republican says Democrats are ignoring Americans' concerns over health care reformsSeptember 26th, 2009 Republican says Dems ignoring health care concernsWASHINGTON — Republicans say Democrats have ignored the public's concerns in drafting new health care legislation under debate in the Senate Finance Committee. Democrats are giving the public anything but an "open, honest and bipartisan debate," Sen.
GOP: Democratic-run Congress rushing to pass health care overhaul, ignoring public's concernsSeptember 26th, 2009 GOP: Dems ignoring public's health care concernsWASHINGTON — The Democratic-run Congress is ignoring the public's concerns in the rush to pass legislation to overhaul the nation's health care system, Republicans say. "The American people expect us to get this right and to do it in an open, honest and bipartisan debate.
Details on the costs of the Senate Finance Committee chairman's health care billSeptember 16th, 2009 Details on costs of Baucus health care billA rundown of the new spending in Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus' health care overhaul bill, and a look at how it's paid for. The numbers are 10-year totals covering 2010-2019.
Health care issues: The public insurance planSeptember 8th, 2009 Health care issues: The public insurance planA look at key issues in the health care debate:
THE ISSUE: Should Americans have the option of getting health insurance from a government plan that competes with private companies?
THE POLITICS: Many Democrats want to do away with private insurance and replace it with something resembling Medicare coverage for all, but that's not politically feasible. Offering the choice of a government insurance plan was a compromise within the Democratic Party.
Dems want to let people who lose jobs keep employer-covered care until they find new coverageJuly 17th, 2009 House committee agrees to longer COBRA benefitsWASHINGTON — Lawmakers have amended a far-reaching health care overhaul bill to allow workers who lose their jobs to hang onto their employer-provided care until they get new coverage. The measure agreed to by voice vote in the House Education and Labor Committee affects the program known as COBRA.
Obama warns that health costs will keep rising without action as he touts proposal in NJJuly 16th, 2009 Obama says health costs will rise without actionHOLMDEL, N.J. — President Barack Obama says he wants a health care overhaul this year and that costs will continue to rise without action.
A breakdown of the $1.5 trillion cost of the House Democrats' health overhaul billJuly 16th, 2009 A breakdown of the cost of the House health billA trio of House committees began work Thursday on $1.5 trillion, 10-year legislation from the Democrats that would fundamentally reshape the nation's health care system. It would require everyone to have health insurance and make employers provide it or pay a penalty; subsidize the poor to help them buy care; and create a new public insurance plan modeled after Medicare to compete with private insurance companies.
Senators say finding middle ground on a public insurance plan is a key to health care overhaulJuly 5th, 2009 Senators say compromise key to health care billWASHINGTON — It will take a compromise on a government option for insurance if the Senate is to agree on a health care overall before next month's break, two senators said Sunday. President Barack Obama is pushing for an Aug.
Health Secretary Sebelius pitches public health insurance plan, saying it will lower costsJune 14th, 2009 Sebelius says Obama plan would lower health costsWASHINGTON — Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius says the government health insurance plan proposed by the Obama administration would increase competition and drive down costs. Sebelius says President Barack Obama does not want to dismantle privately owned plans and does not want the 180 million people who have employer coverage to lose their insurance.
Health care industry pledge to slow spending leaves questions, criticsMay 12th, 2009 Health care industry makes effort to cut costsWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama praised the health care industry's promise to cut $2 trillion in costs over 10 years, but lawmakers questioned how much it really helps in coming up with a solution for the millions of uninsured. It's "a watershed event in the long and elusive quest for health care reform," Obama said Monday at the White House with representatives of the insurance industry, doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies and a top labor union at his side.
Obama praises health industry figures for offering to slow growth in spending by $2TMay 11th, 2009 Obama lauds industry offer to contain health costsWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama has praised health industry groups for coming forward with an offer to reduce the growth of spending by $2 trillion a year to overhaul the system. Obama appeared at the White House with an array of industry figures, including union representatives, and called it the occasion "historic."
Industry figures pledged that they would voluntarily slow their rate increases over the next 10 years.
Loading ...