Watchdog: FEMA still lacks housing plan
WASHINGTON — The government could end up repeating mistakes seen after Hurricane Katrina without a better plan for housing people after a catastrophe, the Homeland Security Department’s internal watchdog told lawmakers Wednesday.
Richard Skinner, DHS’s inspector general, said at a House Homeland Security hearing that the agency still relies too heavily on temporary mobile homes, and it doesn’t have a coordinated plan for more quickly getting people into permanent housing.
Craig Fugate, who became the Federal Emergency Management Agency director in May, acknowledged that the agency’s system is flawed but said it is designed by law to be a temporary “bridge” to a more permanent solution. He said FEMA needs help from Congress and state legislatures to fix the problems.
“It’s not a long-term solution,” he said of using trailers and mobile homes as a last resort after widespread displacement. “Our business is sheltering … we do not have the solution for how we re-establish housing stock.”
Skinner said FEMA’s trailers and mobile homes are fine for routine disasters but inadequate to handle the kind of widespread destruction seen after rare catastrophes such as back-to-back hurricanes Katrina and Rita in 2005. Not only does temporary housing leave communities unsettled — thousands of families have been living in limbo along the Gulf Coast for several years — but it is wasteful, he said.
FEMA, for example, sometimes spent more than $100,000 after Katrina to keep a family in a temporary trailer for 18 months and has paid rent for thousands of families for more than three years. But it is restricted from spending significant amounts to repair permanent housing.
Skinner said FEMA is hamstrung by federal laws limiting its role in the broader rebuilding effort. He recommended that FEMA be given more leeway in facilitating permanent housing and that the Housing and Urban Development Department take over responsibility for housing assistance at some point after FEMA’s initial response.
“FEMA needs better alternatives that quickly restore housing stocks,” Skinner said.
Nearly four years after hurricanes Katrina and Rita, about 3,000 households remain in federally supplied trailers and mobile homes in Louisiana and Mississippi. That’s down from a high of 143,000 along the Gulf Coast after the storms.
Some of the trailers were found to have high levels of formaldehyde, a toxic chemical, and are being scrapped after residents complained of feeling sick after living in them.
The Obama administration recently offered to sell other trailers and mobile homes to hurricane victims for $5 or less.
On the Net:
FEMA: tinyurl.com/l6ytvq
(This version CORRECTS that Skinner is DHS inspector general, not FEMA’s.)
Related News
APNewsBreak: FEMA to focus on children's needs in planning for disastersAugust 3rd, 2009 FEMA to focus on children's needs during disastersWASHINGTON — The Federal Emergency Management Agency is going to plan more broadly for children and their needs as the government prepares for disasters. "Children are not small adults," FEMA Administrator Craig Fugate said Monday.
Report: FEMA took too long to react to claims of dangerous formaldehyde levels in trailersJuly 24th, 2009 Report blasts FEMA on storm trailer formaldehydeNEW ORLEANS — The Federal Emergency Management Agency took too long to respond to initial reports of dangerous levels of formaldehyde in trailers delivered to victims of the 2005 hurricanes, exposing people to possible health risks, a report of the Homeland Security Department inspector general said Thursday. "FEMA did not display a degree of urgency in reacting to the reported formaldehyde problem," the report said, "a problem that could pose a significant health risk" to those living in the temporary housing.
Report: FEMA misspent more than $7 million on warehouses built after Hurricane KatrinaJune 25th, 2009 Report: FEMA misspent $7 million on warehousesWASHINGTON — The Federal Emergency Management Agency ignored the law and misused millions of dollars to build two warehouses after hurricanes Katrina and Rita, according to government investigators. Some of the money FEMA misused should have gone toward Katrina victims in Louisiana, according to a Homeland Security Inspector General report obtained by The Associated Press.
Government audit: FEMA must do better job tracking disaster contractsJune 17th, 2009 Audit: FEMA failed to follow contracting rulesWASHINGTON — The Federal Emergency Management Agency failed to follow some federal contracting rules, making it impossible to know whether the agency got its money's worth during disasters, a government audit found. In a report released Tuesday, the inspector general for the Homeland Security Department said that auditors looked at 32 disaster contracts from 2007.
Gov't audit: FEMA must do better job in tracking disaster contractsJune 16th, 2009 Audit: FEMA must do better tracking its contractsWASHINGTON — The Federal Emergency Management Agency failed to follow some federal contracting rules, making it impossible to know whether the agency got its money's worth during disasters, a government audit found. In a report released Tuesday, the inspector general for the Homeland Security Department said that auditors looked at 32 disaster contracts from 2007.
AP Newsbreak: FEMA could put Fla. hurricane victims in foreclosed homesJune 4th, 2009 Foreclosed homes could become hurricane sheltersMIAMI — Trying to make the best of a bad situation, federal officials might use foreclosed homes as temporary housing for hurricane evacuees in Florida as soon as this summer. The proposal would keep people close to their homes and communities instead of scattering them around the country, which happened when Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans nearly four years ago.
AP Newsbreak: FEMA may put Fla. hurricane victims in foreclosed homesJune 3rd, 2009 AP: FEMA may put storm victims in foreclosed homesMIAMI — The federal government is exploring how to put Florida hurricane evacuees in foreclosed homes if a Katrina-like storm devastates the region and shelters, hotels and other housing options are full, The Associated Press has learned. Officials told AP on Tuesday that it is an effort to find some benefit in the foreclosure crisis and keep people close to their homes and communities instead of scattering them around the country, which happened when Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans and other parts of coastal Louisiana and Mississippi almost four years ago.
Obama stresses need for planning, preparation in hurricane-prone areas; gov't there to helpMay 29th, 2009 Obama: Residents must prepare for hurricanesWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama urged residents of hurricane-prone communities on Friday to take responsibility for their own safety and start planning now. Hurricane season officially begins Monday.
2 beds, 1 bath, low formaldehyde: FEMA rolls out the future of emergency housingMay 14th, 2009 FEMA tricks out new trailers for next disasterEMMITSBURG, Md. — They're clean, shutterless and decorated with a rainbow of beige hues.
President approves disaster aid for Ala. counties hit hard by April storms, tornadoes, floodsMay 9th, 2009 President approves disaster aid for Ala. countiesWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama has declared a major disaster for Alabama counties affected by severe storms, flooding, tornadoes and straight-line winds in mid-April.
Louisiana Republican blocking Obama's FEMA nominee over lingering concerns from KatrinaMay 5th, 2009 Senator blocking Obama's FEMA nomineeWASHINGTON — Hurricane season starts in just a few weeks, but the Federal Emergency Management Agency remains without a leader as a Louisiana Republican senator is blocking the White House's nominee over lingering concerns from Hurricane Katrina. Sen. David Vitter said Tuesday he is standing by the hold he placed on President Barack Obama's choice to lead FEMA.
FEMA removes Web site coloring book from 2003 that featured drawings of Sept. 11 attacksMay 1st, 2009 Drawings of 9/11 attacks taken off kids' Web siteWASHINGTON — An online coloring book from 2003 that showed planes crashing into the World Trade Center has been removed from the Federal Emergency Management Agency's Web site. Besides drawings inspired by the Sept.
FEMA nominee promises Senate panel to improve the agency's disaster responseApril 22nd, 2009 FEMA nominee promises to improve agency responseWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama's pick to head FEMA promised senators Wednesday that he would hold the disaster relief agency to a much higher standard than it displayed in the wake of the 2005 Gulf Coast hurricanes. Craig Fugate and John Morton — Obama's choice to lead Immigration and Customs Enforcement — cruised through their Senate hearings Wednesday and appeared on a fast track for confirmation.
FEMA and immigration nominees to testify at Senate confirmation hearingsApril 22nd, 2009 Senate hears from FEMA and immigration nomineesWASHINGTON — The president's nominees to lead the nation's disaster response and immigration enforcement agencies are headed to Capitol Hill for confirmation hearings in the Senate. Federal Emergency Management Agency nominee Craig Fugate faces questions from the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee about hurricane preparedness and response.
FEMA nominee promises Senate panel to improve disaster response at the agencyApril 22nd, 2009 FEMA nominee promises to improve responseWASHINGTON — The president's nominee to lead the nation's disaster response agency said he will hold the agency to a much higher standard than how it demonstrated in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. In testimony prepared for his confirmation hearing Wednesday, Craig Fugate said the 2005 Gulf Coast hurricanes would no longer be the benchmark for performance under his watch at the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
Loading ...