NEW DELHI - A day after Prime Minister Manmohan Singh downplayed reports of increasing Chinese incursions, top Indian officials and the army chief Saturday warned that media “hype” could lead to “unwarranted incident or accident” with Beijing and stressed that the two countries are trying to resolve bilateral issues through dialogue.
Foreign Secretary Nirupama Rao said there was no plan for Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to meet Chinese President Hu Jintao on the sidelines of G-20 Summit in the US next week.
Rao also stressed that there was “no significant increase” in incursions across all sections of the over 4,000 km border between the two countries.
“There is no meeting that has been planned between Singh and the leader of the Chinese delegation to the G20 Summit in Pittsburgh,” Rao told reporters here when asked if Manmohan Singh will take up the issue of incursions with Hu.
“Contrary to popular perception, the situation along the border has remained peaceful for decades,” she said. “That’s because there is no mutually agreed or delineated border. This is not a new phenomenon. It has been going on for years.”
Rao also repudiated a media report that said China had succeeded in blocking a development loan for India in the Asian Development Bank on the ground that a part of it was meant for Arunachal Pradesh, which is claimed by Beijing. “Country partnership strategy has already been endorsed by ADB,” Rao said.
National Security Adviser M.K. Narayanan and army chief Gen. Deepak Kapoor also cautioned against ‘media hype’ and stressed that there was nothing alarming about reported incursions.
“There has not been any more incursions or transgressions. As compared to last year, they are almost at the same level. So there is no cause for worry or concern. I request the media to restrain and not overplay,” Gen. Kapoor told reporters in Chennai.
Narayanan Saturday stoutly maintained there would never be a “repeat” of the 1962 war with China and warned that media hype could lead to “unwarranted incident or accident” and that could create problems with the neighbour.
“The first thing, I would like to sort of wipe out the question of repeat of 1962. India of 2009 isn’t… India of 1962. I want to make this point very clearly,” Narayanan told the news channel CNN-IBN in an interview.
“We are careful. I think we are careful partly because of what happened in 1962 that we should not provoke a situation, which we don’t wish to have. I don’t think anybody in India wishes to have a conflict with China,” said Narayanan, who is also India’s special representative for border talks with China.
“I think that also goes for China. There are issues between the two countries. I don’t think we have all the answers for these issues. But the whole purpose of dialogue is to see where are the congruencies and the differences.”
“In terms of number of incursions, there has been hardly any increase. Occasionally inroads are a little deeper than what might have been in the past. I don’t think there is anything alarming about it,” said Narayanan.
Rao too brushed off the alarming reprots in the Indian media of Chinese intrusions. “There has been a hype and a certain intensification of volume about the manner in which it has been reported.”
Rao said there are established mechanisms like border personnel meetings to address issues relating to intrusions and stressed that they have “worked well”.
India and China have held 13 rounds of talks to resolve the border row albeit with little progress as both sides have reiterated their stated positions.
Underlining the developing nature of relationship between India and China, Rao, a former ambassador to China, said the leadership of the two countries are in regular communication over important bilateral issues.
“We remain in constant touch over all mutual issues. The leadership-level understandings and communication remain open all the time,” she said.
“There is regular communication and a mutual recognition that outstanding issues can be resolved through dialogue and communication between two nations as large as ours with international responsibilities,” she said.
Related News
IAF fleet 'inadequate' compared to China: IAF chiefSeptember 23rd, 2009 GANDHINAGAR - The strength of the Indian Air Force (IAF) is "inadequate", Air Chief Marshal P.V. Naik said Wednesday.
China denies incursions along LACSeptember 22nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - China on Tuesday flatly denied reports of incursions along the Line of Actual Control (LAC). Talking to reporters after meeting with Home Secretary G K Pillai here, Chinese Ambassador Zhang Yan said: "Nothing is happening.
What incursions? Listen to your leaders, Chinese envoy tells mediaSeptember 22nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Days after the Indian government asked the media to eschew "hype" over reported Chinese incursions, China's ambassador Zhang Yan Tuesday met Home Secretary G.K. Pillai here and tried to clarify the picture.
Chinese incursion same as last year, don't worry: Army chiefSeptember 19th, 2009 CHENNAI - A day after Prime Minister Manmohan Singh played down reports of increasing Chinese incursions along the border, Indian Army chief General Deepak Kapoor Saturday also said there has been no increase in infiltration. There has not been any more incursions or transgressions.
India-China border: No question of repeat of 1962, says NSASeptember 19th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Downplaying the recent border intrusions by Chinese troops, National Security Adviser M.K. Narayanan Saturday stoutly maintained there would never be a "repeat of 1962" and there was nothing alarming about the "inroads".
No significant spike in incursions; India, China in touch: RaoSeptember 19th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Seeking to squash the "hype" over recent Chinese incursions, Foreign Secretary Nirupama Rao Saturday said there has been no significant increase in intrusions across all sections of the border and stressed that the leadership of the two countries are in constant touch. "There has been no significant increase in intrusions across all sections of the Line of Actual Control (LAC), Rao told reporters when asked if the external affairs ministry was trying to downplay reported Chinese incursions across the disputed border.
BJP demands white paper on India-China tiesSeptember 18th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Noting an "ominous" rise in Chinese incursions into the Indian territory, the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) Friday asked the government to bring out a white paper on the "ramifications of India-China relationship". "The BJP demands that the government of India should immediately bring out a white paper on the entire ramifications of India-China relationship, including the improvement and the strengthening of the infrastructure of our preparedness at the borders," said party spokesperson Ravi Shankar Prasad.
Chinese envoy meets MEA officialsSeptember 18th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Amid media reports of rising tensions between New Delhi and Beijing, Chinese Ambassador to India Zhang Yan met officials of Ministry of External Affairs in South Block on Thursday, sources have said. The Chinese Ambassador reportedly sought the meeting and no demarche or summon was issued by the Indian Foreign Ministry.
China Study Group meeting postponedSeptember 17th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The China Study Group meeting to discuss the fallout of Chinese incursions into Indian territory, which was to be held on Thursday, has been postponed. No reason was given for the postponement of the meeting.
India gets serious, NSA calls meet over Chinese incursionsSeptember 16th, 2009 NEW DELHI - With recent Chinese incursions creating anxiety in India, National Security Adviser M.K. Narayanan has convened a high-level meeting of top officials Thursday to formulate an appropriate response to what is widely seen as Beijing's hostile posturing.
India denies firing by Chinese troops across LACSeptember 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - India Tuesday denied a media report about two Indian soldiers getting injured in firing by Chinese troops in Sikkim recently. "A media report about two ITBP (Indo-Tibetan Border Police) jawans having been injured due to firing from across the LAC (Line of Actual Control) has come to notice.
India closely monitoring Chinese activities along Arunachal: KrishnaSeptember 10th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Downplaying incursions into Indian territory, External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna Thursday said India was closely monitoring the Chinese build-up along Arunachal Pradesh.
No lowering of defences on Chinese incursions: IndiaSeptember 10th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Cautioning against creating excessive alarm over Chinese incursions into Indian territory, External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna Thursday said India was closely monitoring the situation and assured that there will be no lowering of defenses in this regard.
India downplays Chinese intrusions, says border peacefulSeptember 7th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Downplaying recent Chinese incursions into the Indian territory of Ladakh, External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna Monday said India has one of the most peaceful boundaries with China and added that the issue was being sorted out.
Chinese incursion in Ladakh started in January 2009September 7th, 2009 SRINAGAR - Reports of Chinese incursions in the Ladakh area of Jammu and Kashmir which are now being highlighted by the media are in fact as old as January 2009, according to an official communication sent that month by the district magistrate of Leh to his superiors in the state. According to the contents of a letter sent by Ajeet Kumar Sahu, district magistrate of Leh, to the divisional commissioner of Kashmir on Jan 4 this year, reports of incursions by the Chinese army into the Indian territory had been brought to his notice by shepherds and villagers living close to the international border.