NEW DELHI - Ruling out any mediation by a third party, India Monday made it clear that it will not resume the stalled composite dialogue with Pakistan unless there is ‘credible action’ by Islamabad against the perpetrators of the Mumbai attacks and the infrastructure of terrorism on its soil.
India also condemned the terrorist attack in Lahore and described terrorism as ‘a menace’ to the region.
‘There is no point in setting down time-frame or concrete markers. We want to see credible action against terrorism,’ Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon told reporters here.
He was responding to a question on whether India has set any criteria or preconditions before resuming dialogue with Pakistan which paused after the Mumbai terror attacks in November last year.
India suspects the hand of Pakistani nationals and its agencies in the Mumbai terror attack that killed over 170 people, including 22 foreigners.
‘We want to see credible action against the infrastructure of terrorism in Pakistan from where Mumbai attacks and earlier attacks in India were carried out.’
‘We want to see the perpetrators of the Mumbai attacks being brought to justice,’ Menon said when asked to be more specific about the kind of actions India was expecting from Pakistan before it could resume the dialogue process.
‘It’s not a matter of quibbling over markers. The world knows what we mean when we say credible action. We are waiting,’ he said when asked about Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari’s emphasis on the need for early resumption of composite dialogue between the two countries.
Rejecting any external attempt to pressurise India into resuming dialogue with Pakistan, Menon pointed out that the India-Pakistan process has been ‘more successful’ when it’s been on bilateral track.
‘It is hard for any external source to replace’ the bilateral process, he said when asked about US President Barack Obama’s new policy statement on the Afghanistan-Pakistan region that includes using ‘constructive diplomacy’ to resolve tensions between India and Pakistan.
This has been interpreted by some as an attempt to pressurise India into restarting the dialogue process with Pakistan.
‘We need two hands to clap. Third hand will not be helpful,’ Menon stressed.
Menon’s comments are seen as a message to Washington before Prime Minister Manmohan Singh holds his first meeting with the US President on the sidelines of the G20 summit in London Thursday.
The situation in Pakistan and Afghanistan will figure prominently in discussions between the two leaders.
Menon welcomed the new AfPak policy unveiled by Obama last week.
‘We welcome a clear will to control terrorism in the region and its roots in Pakistan. India has direct stakes in the success of the international effort,’ Menon said.
He, however, struck a cautionary note about the $7.5 billion non-military aid the US plans to give to Pakistan over the next five years. The link between extremist elements and the Pakistan establishment is a cause of worry, he said.
‘We are ready to play a constructive role as a responsible power in the region to defeat terrorists and extremists,’ he underlined.
Menon condemned Monday’s terrorist attack in Lahore and described terrorism as ‘a menace’ to the region. He, however, warned against ‘jumping to conclusions’ about the identity of the attackers and the motive behind the terrorist incident.
The Government of India is deeply saddened and shocked by the events in Lahore, he said.
A group of terrorists stormed the police training academy in Pakistan’s Lahore city early Monday, killing at least 22 trainees and injuring dozens. Many trainees were held hostage for hours by the militants, some of whom were wearing police uniforms.
Related News
No talks without action against 26/11 perpetrators: IndiaSeptember 16th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Indian Government has reportedly said that unless Pakistan takes, some sort of action against the 26/11 accused, the possibility of a resumption of dialogue is remote. According to sources, India has provided enough evidence to Pakistan regarding the perpetrators of 26/11 attacks and the need is for Pakistan to act, and then only the dialogue between both the countries can be held.
Pakistan is epicentre of terror in the region: S.M. KrishnaSeptember 5th, 2009 BANGALORE - External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna attacked Pakistan on Saturday by calling it epicentre of terror in this region, and said it's for Islamabad to decide what kind of ties it wants with India.
Manmohan Singh told Pakistan to take credible actions to curb terrorismJuly 17th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said that he has conveyed to the Pakistan's Prime Minister Gilani that sustained, effective and credible action needs to be taken not only to bring the perpetrators of the Mumbai attack to justice, but also to shut down the operations of terrorist groups so as to prevent any future attacks. Singh was making a statement in Lok Sabha on Friday, on his recent dialogue with Pak Premier and his foreign visits.
Dialogue will depend on Pakistan's action against terror: ManmohanJuly 17th, 2009 NEW DELHI - A day after his meeting with Pakistan Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani in Egypt, Prime Minister Mahnmohan Signh Friday made it clear that any "meaningful dialogue" will depend on Islamabad fulfilling its anti-terror pledge "in letter and spirit."
The prime minsiter asked Pakistan to take "sustained, effective and credible action" not only against the perpetrators of the Mumbai carnage, but also against the larger infrastrucure of terrorism on its territory. "I also conveyed to Gilani that sustained, effective and credible action has to be taken not only against the pertpetrators of the Mumbai attacks, but also shut down the operations of terrorist groups to prevent future attacks," Manmohan Singh said in a prepared statement he read out in the Lok Sabha within hours of his return.
India, Pakistan delink terrorism from dialogueJuly 16th, 2009 Sharm-el-SHEIKH - India and Pakistan Thursday said that dialogue was only answer to promote better neighbourly relations and that terrorism should not be linked to their composite dialogue process. A joint statement issued after talks between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh of India and Yousaf Raza Gilani of Pakistan here also agreed that the two countries will share real time credible and actionable information on any future terrorist threat.
India, Pakistan delink terror from talksJuly 16th, 2009 Sharm el-SHEIKH - Nearly eight months after the 26/11 Mumbai attacks, India and Pakistan Thursday sought to put their strained ties back on track by delinking action on terror from the composite dialogue process. Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and his Pakistani counterpart Yousuf Raza Gilani met in the Egyptian resort town of Sharm-el-Sheikh Thursday.
Talks with India unavoidable, says PakistanJune 25th, 2009 ISLAMABAD - Pakistan seriously believes that composite dialogue is in the interest of both India and Pakistan, foreign office spokesman Abdul Basit said here Thursday. "Talks are unavoidable for durable peace and prosperity in the region," Basit said at a weekly press briefing.
Don't resume talks with Pakistan: Kashmiri PanditsJune 21st, 2009 JAMMU - A Kashmiri Pandit group, Panun Kashmir, has warned India against resuming talks with Pakistan under US pressure. "Linking improvement in situation in Pakistan or for that matter in Kashmir as a basis of Kashmir resolution is a suicidal move," said Ajay Charungoo, chairman of the Panun Kashmir, at a seminar here Sunday.
Manmohan to Zardari: Don't allow your territory for anti-India acts (Second Lead)June 16th, 2009 YEKATERINBURG - The territory of Pakistan "should not be used for acts of terrorism against India", Prime Minister Manmohan Singh told President Asif Ali Zardari Tuesday in their first meeting since the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks. The 40-minute meeting of the two leaders began here with Manmohan Singh telling Zardari that he was pleased to meet him but stressing in his opening remark that Pakistani territory "should not be used for acts of terrorism against India".
Take credible action against terror, Manmohan to tell Zardari (Lead)June 15th, 2009 YEKATERINBURG - In the first formal contact between India and Pakistan since the 26/11 Mumbai attacks, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh will hold talks with Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari here Tuesday with a clear message that the resumption of dialogue will depend on Islamabad's "credible action" against terrorism. Manmohan Singh and Zardari will hold a half-an-hour meeting in the Silver Room of Hotel Hyatt Regency in the Russian city of Yekaterinburg, the industrial town located nearly 1,400 km from Moscow and famous as the site of the execution of the last Tsar of Russia and his family.
Act against terror, Manmohan to tell ZardariJune 15th, 2009 YEKATERINBERG - India will convey a clear message to Pakistan to take credible action against terrorism when Prime Minister Manmohan Singh meets Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari here Tuesday for the first time after the Mumbai attacks. The meeting is more of an ice breaker and it will not lead to an immediate resumption of the dialogue between the two countries, stalled since the Mumbai attacks nearly seven months ago.
Pakistan must dismantle terror infrastructure: KrishnaMay 23rd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Pakistan "must take credible action" to dismantle the infrastructure of terrorism on its soil if it wants to resume dialogue with India, new External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna said here Saturday.
India to Pakistan: No talks till credible action against terrorMarch 30th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Underlining its opposition to any external role, India Monday said that it will not resume the stalled dialogue process with Pakistan unless there is 'credible action' by Islamabad against the perpetrators of the Mumbai attacks and the infrastructure of terrorism on its soil. 'There is no point in setting down time-frame or concrete markers.
Diplomacy has prevailed, but Pakistan should take credible action: IndiaFebruary 17th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Nearly a week after Pakistan acknowledged the role of its citizens in the Mumbai terror spree, India Wednesday said diplomacy had 'prevailed' over military options and reminded Islamabad to take 'verifiable and credible action' against the masterminds of the carnage. 'Diplomacy has not failed.
India says Pakistan's probe 'positive', calls for credible actionFebruary 11th, 2009 NEW DELHI - India Thursday welcomed as 'positive' Pakistan's probe into 26/11 which said that elements from Pakistan were involved, but reminded Islamabad to take 'credible action' and 'dismantle the infrastructure of terrorism' in its territory. Breaking repeated patterns of denial and obfuscation in the past, Pakistan for the first time has admitted the involvement of its nationals in the terror attack on India - a step that New Delhi described as 'a positive development'.