House approves defense policy bill over objections
WASHINGTON — Despite a vague veto threat by President Barack Obama, the House on Thursday easily passed a major defense policy bill that calls for continued development of a costly alternative engine for the Pentagon’s next-generation fighter jet.
The bill, passed by a 281-146 vote, also prohibits the Obama administration from transferring any detainees being held at the Guantanamo Bay prison in Cuba to the U.S. until 45 days after the administration submits a comprehensive plan for closing the controversial prison.
The measure, which included a 3.4 percent pay increase for the military that was a half-percentage point more than Obama requested, now goes to the Senate.
While the bill challenges the administration on jet engines and Guantanamo prisoners, Obama and Defense Secretary Robert Gates prevailed in killing the jobs-rich but over-budget F-22 fighter program, which has its origins in the Cold War era and is poorly suited for anti-insurgent battles in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The bill contains unrelated legislation strengthening federal hate crimes laws. That infuriated many Republicans, who said the pro-military measure shouldn’t carry social legislation.
Obama’s veto threat involves a program to develop an alternative engine for the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter, the Air Force’s multimission fighter for the future. The second engine would be built by General Electric Co. and Rolls-Royce in Ohio, Indiana and other states. The main F-35 engine is built in Connecticut by Pratt & Whitney.
The administration promised in June to veto the legislation if it would “seriously disrupt” the F-35 program, a vague threat at best. It says that spending on a second engine is unnecessary and impedes the progress of the Joint Strike Fighter program. The legislation recommends $560 million for the program in 2010.
On Thursday, the administration seemed to backpedal. Obama officials said the Pentagon is evaluating the bill before offering advice to Obama on whether to accept or reject it.
“As was made clear … if the final bill calls for further investment in a second engine, the Defense Department will carefully evaluate the impact of that before making a recommendation to the president about whether or not to veto the legislation,” said Kenneth Baer, a spokesman for the White House budget office.
The Pentagon says the Pratt & Whitney engine is performing well and that the second engine adds unnecessary costs and would delay the program. Supporters of the program say it provides competition that would boost contractors’ performance and tamp down costs.
Lawmakers have parsed the Obama threat and decided not to take it seriously.
“I think if they … were going to carry it out, they would have been more explicit,” said Rep. John Spratt Jr., D-S.C., a senior member of the Armed Services Committee.
“It would be a shock to me” if Obama vetoed the measure, said the panel’s top Republican, Howard “Buck” McKeon of California.
The legislation does, however, accede to Obama’s call to terminate the VH-71 replacement helicopter program for the presidential fleet. The program is six years behind schedule and estimated costs have doubled to more than $13 billion.
The $680 billion measure doesn’t actually fund the Pentagon’s budget but provides policy guidance that is typically followed closely by the appropriations committees. It also approves Obama’s $130 billion request to conduct the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
On Guantanamo, Republicans were on the losing end of a 216-208 vote aimed at blocking any transfer of detainees into the U.S. Thirty-four Democrats broke ranks to support the idea.
Republicans were irate that the so-called hate crimes legislation was attached to the bill. It would give people attacked because of their sexual orientation or gender federal protections and significantly expand the reach of hate crimes law.
The measure also would make it easier for federal prosecutors to step in when state or local authorities are unable or unwilling to pursue hate crimes.
“I’m in a dilemma today,” said Rep. John Carter, R-Texas, adding that enclosing the hate crimes legislation in a bill supporting the U.S. military would force people to vote against their beliefs.
“It is simply inappropriate to use a defense bill as a vehicle for divisive, liberal social policies wholly unrelated to our country’s national security,” said Rep. Mike Pence, R-Ind.
Both Carter and Pence voted against the bill.
Related News
House approves defense policy bill despite vague Obama veto threat over F-35sOctober 8th, 2009 House approves defense policy billWASHINGTON — The House has voted to continue building a costly alternative engine for the Pentagon's next generation fighter jet. The vote came despite a vaguely worded veto threat from President Barack Obama.
House set to approve defense policy bill despite vague Obama veto threat over F-35 programOctober 8th, 2009 House set to approve defense policy billWASHINGTON — Despite a vaguely worded veto threat by President Barack Obama, the House was expected Thursday to easily adopt a major defense policy bill that calls for continued development of a costly alternative engine for the Pentagon's next generation fighter jet. The move comes as the House debated the annual defense authorization bill to guide the Pentagon budget for the fiscal year that began last week.
Defense chief renews threat of White House veto if Congress insists on 2 suppliers for engineAugust 31st, 2009 Gates renews White House veto threat over engineFORT WORTH, Texas — The Obama administration renewed a threat Monday to veto a $680 billion defense spending bill if it includes money for two separate engines for the next-generation jet fighter, a luxury the Pentagon says it cannot afford. Defense Secretary Robert Gates, touring the Lockheed Martin Corp.
US House passes defence bill, kills F-22July 31st, 2009 WASHINGTON - The US House of Representatives passed a $636-billion defence bill Thursday after removing money to continue production of the F-22, meeting a key demand by President Barack Obama. The bill, for fiscal 2010 and including $128 billion for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, passed by a 400-30 vote.
Save for the F-22, Democratic House funds Pentagon programs slated for terminationJuly 30th, 2009 House funds Pentagon programs set for terminationPresident Barack Obama recommended killing several high profile Pentagon programs in his 2010 budget. Here's how he fared in a defense funding bill passed by the House on Thursday:
F-22 fighter jet — After receiving $2.9 billion this year, the F-22 fighter jet was slated for elimination by Obama.
House rejects most Obama weapons cuts, retreats on F-22 fighterJuly 30th, 2009 House rejects most Obama weapons cutsWASHINGTON — The Democratic-controlled House went along with Defense Secretary Robert Gates' plans to kill the over-budget F-22 fighter jet, but has rejected his efforts to cut off several other big ticket items. Despite objections and veto threats from the White House, a $636 billion Pentagon spending bill passed by a 400-30 vote Thursday contains money for a much-criticized new presidential helicopter fleet, cargo jets that Gates says aren't needed, and an alternative engine for the next-generation F-35 Joint Strike Fighter that the Pentagon says is a waste of money.
White House issues veto threats as House fights loom on fighter jets, presidential helicoptersJuly 28th, 2009 White House issues veto threats; House fights loomWASHINGTON — The White House threatened Tuesday to veto a $636 billion spending bill for the Pentagon, citing funding for F-22 fighters and a much-criticized replacement presidential helicopter. President Barack Obama wants to terminate both programs.
Murtha says White House veto threat on F-22 fighter jet funding won't derail spending billJuly 16th, 2009 Dems at odds with White House on F-22 fundingWASHINGTON — Despite adding money for two programs that the White House has said will result in a veto of the defense spending bill, a key House Democrat said Thursday he's confident the legislation will avoid that fate. "We'll work it out," John Murtha, head of the House Appropriations defense subcommittee, told reporters following a markup of the bill.
Key Senate vote postponed to eliminate $1.75 billion in funding for Lockheed F-22 fighter jetsJuly 15th, 2009 Levin says vote postponed on F-22 jet fundingWASHINGTON — A key Senate vote that would eliminate $1.75 billion added to the defense spending bill for more fighter jets from Lockheed Martin has been postponed again. Sen. Carl Levin on Wednesday withdrew the F-22 amendment so the Senate can first address a controversial hate crimes bill.
Democrats say they will work with White House to alter intelligence notification rulesJuly 9th, 2009 House Dems likely to alter intel billWASHINGTON — Stymied by a White House veto threat, House Democrats say they will work with the Obama administration to soften a legislative provision that would broaden access to secret intelligence briefings. Democrats on the intelligence committee say that an intelligence authorization bill containing the controversial provision would likely pass the House intact but would be adjusted in negotiations with the White House and the Senate.
White House threatens to veto bill expanding congressional notification of covert activitiesJuly 8th, 2009 White House threatens to veto intelligence billWASHINGTON — The White House is threatening to veto a bill that would require the president to dramatically increase the number of lawmakers who must be notified about covert CIA activities. The annual intelligence authorization bill the House will consider Thursday contains a provision that would require the president to inform more than 40 members of Congress — rather than eight members currently — about secret actions taken overseas to influence events in other countries.
House passes defence bill despite Obama's veto threatJune 25th, 2009 WASHINGTON - The US House of Representatives passed a $680-billion defence spending bill Thursday despite President Barack Obama's threat to veto the measure. The bill for the fiscal 2010 year, which begins Oct 1, contains $369 million to continue production of the F-22 fighter jet the Obama and Defence Secretary Robert Gates say is not needed.
Senate panel adds $1.75 billion to Pentagon budget for 7 of Lockheed's F-22 fighter jetsJune 25th, 2009 Senators add $1.75B to DOD budget for F-22'sWASHINGTON — Senators on Thursday added $1.75 billion to a Pentagon budget proposal for seven more of Lockheed Martin Corp.'s F-22 fighter jets, setting the stage for a battle with the Obama administration. The Senate Armed Services Committee added the funds in its version of the fiscal 2010 defense spending bill.
Obama administration objects to $369 million in legislation for more F-22 radar-evading jetsJune 24th, 2009 White House threatens defense spending bill vetoWASHINGTON — Preparing for a possible showdown with Congress, the White House has threatened to veto a $680 billion military spending bill if it contains money for jet fighters the Pentagon doesn't want. In a statement of administration policy, President Barack Obama's Office of Management and Budget said the $369 million a House committee added to the bill for 12 additional F-22 fighters runs counter to the "collective judgment" of the military's top leaders.
White House threatens veto over proposed $369 million for more F-22 radar-evading jetsJune 24th, 2009 White House threatens veto over F-22 jet fightersWASHINGTON — Preparing for a possible showdown with Congress, the White House on Wednesday threatened to veto legislation authorizing a $680 billion military budget if it contains money for jet fighters the Pentagon doesn't want. In a statement, the White House Office of Management and Budget said the $369 million that a House committee added to the bill as a downpayment for 12 additional F-22 fighters runs counter to the "collective judgment" of the military's top leaders.
Loading ...