NEW DELHI - The 34 percent hike in the defence budget for 2009-10 is driven more by the increased salaries granted to government employees on a pay panel’s recommendations than by the armed forces’ need for capacity building, experts say.
The hike of 34 percent over last year is misleading. This is principally meant to pay for the increased salaries recommended by the Sixth Pay Commission,” Commodore (retd) Uday Bhaskar, the director of the National Maritime Foundation, told IANS.
“The real challenge is to convert fiscal allocations into appropriate capacity building,” Bhaskar maintained, pointing out that the armed forces had returned Rs.7,000 crore of the Rs.48,007 crore allocated for the purchase of military hardware during 2008-09.
“If we do not address this, we cannot pre-empt another (1999) Kargil (conflict with Pakistan) or (the 26/11) Mumbai (terror attacks), Bhaskar, a former deputy director of defence ministry-sponsored think tank Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, contended.
Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee presented the budget for 2009-10 in the Lok Sabha Monday, leaving defence expenditure for the fiscal unchanged from the Rs.141,703 crore ($28 billion) allocated in the interim budget earlier this year - which was a hike of 34 percent over the previous year.
Of the total defence budget, the operating expenditure of the three services and other departments has been pegged at Rs.86,879 crore. This leaves just Rs.54,824 crore for capital expenditure on modernising the military.
Of the two heads, the operating expenditure has been increased - in comparison to last hike of less than 7 per cent - by a whopping 50.85 per cent or Rs.29,286 crore largely due the hike in salaries and allowances.
At the same time, capital expenditure has declined 14.20 percent or by Rs.6,817 crore, leading to analysts sounding alarm bells.
This in a situation in which the armed forces are on a modernisation drive. The shopping list includes a variety of weapons and systems that include combat jets, heavy artillery guns, armoured vehicles, radars, missiles and naval vessels. Thus, the requirement for new equipment is on the rise while less money is available for this. More worrisome is the return of money allocated for purchases.
This (returning of money) represents a serious systemic problem as the finance ministry allocates but the defence ministry is unable to spend it. This is a very serious trend and can erode the capacities of the armed forces, Bhaskar pointed out.
As for the ex-servicemen, they are extremely upset at the government’s response to their “one-rank-one-pension” (OROP) demand.
We are happy the pension for jawans (soldiers) and junior commissioned officers (JCOs) has been increased but it is nowhere close to our demand as retired officers have been ignored,” said Commodore (retd) Lokesh Batra, a member of the Indian Ex-servicemen’s Movement.
“If it has not been announced in the budget, it means the OROP demand for officers has been ignored,” Batra added.
Around 13,000 armed forces veterans have returned their medals this year protesting against the government’s apathy to their OROP demand that irrespective of the date on which an officer or soldier retires, he or she should get the same pension as those who had earlier retired in the same rank.
Mukherjee, in his budget speech, said: The government has decided to substantially improve the pension of pre-1.1.2006 defence pensioners below officer rank (PBOR) and bring pre-10.10.1997 pensioners on par with post 10.10.1997 pensioners. Both these decisions will be implemented from 1st July 2009, resulting in enhanced pension for more than 12 lakh jawans and JCOs.
Related News
Russia's defence budget to be $36 bn in 2010September 22nd, 2009 MOSCOW - Russia's defence budget will rise by 8 percent in 2010 to reach $36 billion, Deputy Prime Minister Sergei Ivanov said Tuesday. The defence allocation in 2009 is expected to fetch $33 billion, with $10.9 billion being spent on purchases and maintenance of military equipment.
Boeing cuts 1,000 jobs in defence branchJuly 15th, 2009 WASHINGTON/CHICAGO - Boeing's Integrated Defence Systems said Wednesday it is cutting 1,000 jobs to accommodate the drop in demand in the federal defence budget. The lost jobs represent about 1.5 percent of the 70,000 employees in the defence branch.
Global Inc. may get larger share of Indian defence pieJuly 14th, 2009 NEW DELHI - India is expected to issue by the end of this year a notification to increase foreign equity in defence production to 49 percent from the current 26 percent, a senior official said. This follows the Economic Survey for 2008-09 tabled in parliament July 2 that said that 100 percent foreign direct investment (FDI) should be permitted for high-technology defence equipment.
India's defence budget stays at Rs.141,703 crore (Second Lead)July 6th, 2009 NEW DELHI - India's defence expenditure during 2009-10 remains unchanged from Rs.141,703 crore ($28 billion) allocated in the interim budget earlier this year - which was a hike of 34 percent over the previous year. Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, while presenting the budget in the Lok Sabha, had a word of cheer for soldiers and junior commissioned officers (JCOs), saying their pensions would be enhanced.
People react angrily as fuel price gets a steep hike all over IndiaJuly 2nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Petrol and diesel prices rise by as much as 10 percent in India, on Wednesday, the first increase this year and one of the steepest ever. Petrol prices rose by four rupees a litre, while diesel rates were hiked by two rupees a litre.
Budget session begins on stormy noteJuly 2nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - The budget session of parliament began on a stormy note Thursday as almost the entire opposition staged angry protests over the hike in petrol and diesel prices, forcing the speaker to adjourn the Lok Sabha. The protest, led by the Left parties, started soon after Speaker Meira Kumar concluded reading obituary references to two former members minutes after the house assembled.
Budget session of parliament starts with two stopsJuly 2nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - The budget session of parliament began on a stormy note Thursday with opposition members staging angry protests over the hike in petrol and diesel prices, forcing the speaker to adjourn the Lok Sabha twice. Minutes after the house assembled, almost all the opposition members led by the Left parties were on their feet, demanding that the hike in petrol and diesel prices be withdrawn immediately.
Pakistan hikes defence spending 15 percent to Rs.347 bnJune 13th, 2009 ISLAMABAD - Pakistan has hiked its defence spending for fiscal 2009-10 to Rs.347 billion ($4 billion) in the budget presented in parliament Saturday. Of this, Rs.343 billion has been allocated for the armed forces, Rs.463 million for defence production and Rs.840 million for the defence division, Minister of State for Finance Hina Rabbani Khar said while delivering the first budget speech by a woman in Pakistan's history.
China's defence budget to grow 14.9 percent in 2009March 4th, 2009 BEIJING - China plans to increase its defence budget by 14.9 percent in 2009, a parliament spokesman said here Wednesday. The planned defence budget is 480.686 billion yuan ($70 billion), Li Zhaoxing, spokesman for the annual session of the National People's Congress (NPC), told a press conference.
Indian Army gets lion's share of Rs.1.417 trillion defence budgetFebruary 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Saying a 'threshold has been crossed' with the Mumbai terror attacks, External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee hiked the allocation for defence by 34 percent to Rs.141,703 crore (Rs.1.417 trillion) in the interim budget for 2009-10 he presented in the Lok Sabha Monday. The allocation is nearly 15 percent of the total interim budget of Rs.953,231 crore for the fiscal beginning April 1.
Increase in defence allocation marginal: ExpertsFebruary 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Security experts have viewed as marginal the 34 percent hike in the defence allocation in the interim budget for 2009-10 presented in the Lok Sabha Monday, pointing to the armed forces returning Rs.7,000 crore from what had been earmarked for arms purchases during the fiscal ending Mar 31. 'On the face of it they are talking about an increase of 25 percent (in real terms) but much of it is going to be used to pay arrears to the armed forces personnel after the (hikes recommended by the) Sixth Pay Commission,' defence analyst Commodore (retd) C.
Mumbai attacks trigger 34 percent hike in defence allocationFebruary 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Holding a 'threshold has been crossed' with the Mumbai terror attacks, the Indian government hiked the allocation for defence by 34 percent to Rs.141,703 crore (Rs.1.417 trillion) in the interim budget for 2009-10 External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee presented in the Lok Sabha Monday. The allocation is nearly 15 percent of the total interim budget of Rs.953,231 crore for the fiscal beginning April 1.
Post-Mumbai 'threshold', defence outlay hiked 34 percentFebruary 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Maintaining a 'threshold has been crossed' with the Mumbai terror attacks, the Indian government hiked the allocation for defence by 34 percent to Rs.141,703 crore (Rs.1.417 trillion) in the interim budget for 2009-10 that External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee presented in the Lok Sabha Monday. 'We welcome the budget,' Defence Minister A.K.
Antony hopes for hike in 2009-10 defence budgetFebruary 10th, 2009 BANGALORE - Defence Minister A.K. Antony Wednesday hoped that the defence budget for fiscal 2009-10 beginning April 1 would rise despite the recession the Indian economy was going through.
Chhattisgarh police get Rs.9.4 billion to counter MaoistsFebruary 8th, 2009 RAIPUR - The Chhattisgarh government Monday allocated Rs.9.41 billion (Rs.941 crore), a hike of 22 percent from last year's allocations, for the police force to counter Leftist insurgency in the state. Chief Minister Raman Singh, who also holds the finance portfolio, presented a Rs.222.11 billion budget that levies no new taxes for the fiscal 2009-10.