Feds set to say which banks can repay bailout cash
NEW YORK — The government is set to announce as early as Tuesday morning which of the country’s biggest banks will be able to repay billions in federal bailout dollars in a decision that risks creating a two-tier banking system — winners and losers.
Congress approved the $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Program eight months ago as financial markets teetered on collapse. Almost ever since, banks have been eager to pay back bailout money and cut the federal strings that come with it.
Combined, the repayments could exceed $50 billion. Experts say that figure reflects a measure of stability that has returned to the banking system but caution that the crisis isn’t over. Some worry the repayments could widen the gap between healthy and weak banks.
“We’re going to find out who are the strongest kids on the block and who are not,” said Bert Ely, a longtime banking analyst.
Banks started railing against the TARP almost immediately after they accepted the help. One CEO, Jamie Dimon of JPMorgan Chase & Co., called the money a “scarlet letter,” referring to the public backlash and federal scrutiny that came with it.
Banks that are expected to get a green light to repay bailout funds include JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and American Express Co. They would be free of federal rules ranging from caps on executive pay to restrictions on dividend payments.
But weaker banks such as Citigroup Inc. and Bank of America Corp. would remain tethered to the government and face a problem — how to compete for business and top workers against rivals operating more freely.
“Banks had been at an equal disadvantage,” said Jack A. Ablin, chief investment officer at Harris Private Bank in Chicago. “Now you’ll have some that are unfettered and others that are constrained. That will affect the ability to attract customers and talent.”
Investors are also keeping score. Stock in Citigroup and Bank of America, which received a combined $90 billion in TARP money, has plunged. Investors will probably keep favoring firms that show they can stand without federal help, Ablin said.
“If you can decide between a weak player and a strong player, just about every advantage goes to the strong,” he said.
The push to repay TARP money comes a month after “stress tests” of the nation’s 19 largest financial firms found that 10 needed to raise $75 billion more to protect against future losses. All 10 had submitted plans by late Monday, the Federal Reserve said. The Fed said Monday that plans submitted by 10 banks to bolster their capital cushions are enough to help them survive a deeper recession.
The remaining nine institutions received a combined $56 billion in TARP money. They had to prove they could raise enough private capital without federal guarantees before they could return the money.
So far, 16 of the 19 banks have raised $75.2 billion, mostly by selling common stock. Meanwhile, about a dozen smaller banks have already repaid TARP money.
Regulators want to avoid letting a bank repay its TARP money only to have it return months later in worse shape, seeking another handout.
That’s why regulators say they need to determine which banks are truly stable enough to repay their TARP money. Their decisions depend on how accurate the tests were in calculating the banks’ capital needs.
“You could easily be off by $300 billion on how much capital these 19 banks needed,” said Douglas Elliott, a fellow at the Brookings Institution and a former investment banker. “Maybe we’ll get lucky and everything will be fine, but I wouldn’t count on it. There are a lot of dangers still out there.”
Industry insiders say a big worry is that banks stuck with limits on how much they can pay executives will watch star performers flee to other companies.
Federal rules imposed by Congress limit executive bonuses at banks that receive bailout money and cap total compensation of top executives at $400,000 a year. Administration officials are set to outline stricter rules later this week.
Much of the revenue at banks like Citigroup comes from a relatively small number of trading desks. So losing a few key traders could be a serious drag on the banks’ bottom lines as they strive to right themselves.
Scott Talbott, top lobbyist with the Financial Services Roundtable, which represents the largest financial firms, said top salespeople and producers were already leaving banks for hedge funds and foreign firms. The growing gulf between TARP and non-TARP banks could speed that process, he said.
“It will impact sales people, and sales people are the life of the company,” Talbott said. “If you can’t make sales, you can’t improve revenue. If you can’t improve revenue, you can’t improve your stock price. If you can’t improve your stock price, you can’t return the government’s money. And that will just maintain the competitive disadvantage.”
That’s lost on the banks most heavily indebted to the bailout. Bank of America wants to repay the money “soon as possible, but the timing is up to the government,” spokesman Scott Silvestri said.
A spokesman said Citigroup hasn’t applied to repay TARP funds.
Simon Johnson, a former chief economist at the International Monetary Fund, said putting Citigroup and Bank of America at a disadvantage might be part of the government’s plan.
“Both banks need to downsize, so this is going to cause them to lose talent if the constraints are effective,” said Johnson, now at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Sloan School of Business. “That may be, given the political constraints, the most effective way to reduce systemic risk.”
The Treasury declined to comment on whether it was concerned that bailout paybacks might increase strain on weaker banks.
One person who says he isn’t worried: Rep. Barney Frank, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee.
“Do you think there are people who don’t already know that there are strong banks and weak banks? We don’t need TARP repayments to figure that out,” Frank, D-Mass., said in an interview.
Wagner reported from Washington. AP Business Writers Madlen Read in New York and Jeannine Aversa in Washington contributed to this report.
Related News
Report: US makes $4 billion in profits from large banks in federal bailoutAugust 31st, 2009 Report: US makes $4 billion from bailout banksWASHINGTON — The U.S. government has hauled in about $4 billion in profits from large banks that have repaid their obligations from last year's federal bailout, The New York Times reported Sunday.
Person familiar with situation says Morgan Stanley to repay bailout money WednesdayJune 17th, 2009 AP Source: Morgan Stanley to repay TARP WednesdayNEW YORK — Morgan Stanley is expected to repay its government bailout money on Wednesday, according to a person familiar with the talks between the bank and the government. The investment bank will return all of the $10 billion in loans it received last fall during the height of the credit crisis, said the person, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he is not authorized to speak publicly about the bank's plans.
10 large US banks to repay government $68 billion in bailout funds, industry officials sayJune 17th, 2009 10 large US banks to repay $68B in TARP fundsWASHINGTON — Ten large U.S. banks are planning to repay the government about $68 billion in bailout money Wednesday, a pair of industry officials say.
Bailout overseer says Bush administration initially underestimated banks' struggles last yearJune 10th, 2009 Bailout overseer: Bank repayments sign of progressWASHINGTON — The head of a congressional panel overseeing the federal financial system bailout fund says Washington initially underestimated how much banks in America were struggling to stay afloat. Elizabeth Warren says the approval of a repayment to the government of $68 billion by several of the banks receiving taxpayer assistance amounts to "phase two of the economic recovery" in the system.
List of 10 banks that got Treasury approval to pay back their bailout moneyJune 9th, 2009 List of 10 banks that will repay bailout moneyThe Treasury has given 10 banks permission pay back a total of $68 billion in government bailout money. The banks include the eight recipients of bailout money that passed regulators' stress test last month, plus the investment bank Morgan Stanley and Chicago-based custody bank Northern Trust Corp.
Obama calls $68B bank repayments to government 'an initial return' on taxpayer investmentsJune 9th, 2009 Obama hails bank repayments of $68B to TreasuryWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama is complimenting banks that are reimbursing taxpayers to the tune of $68 billion in federal bailout assistance. Appearing at a White House event to call attention to slow the pace of government spending, Obama stressed that the deal to repay this sum "is not a sign that our troubles are over — far from it."
But he did call it a "positive sign" and said he is happy that people are beginning to see "an initial return on a few of these investments."
The Treasury Department did not identify the banks involved in the repayment.
Stocks nudge higher as investors await word on bank loan repayments; Fiat sticks by ChryslerJune 9th, 2009 Stocks edge higher as investors look to banksNEW YORK — Investors are showing little reaction to word that 10 of nation's largest banks can repay $68 billion in bailout money. Stocks are moderately higher but traders are reacting coolly to the Treasury Department's announcement that the banks, which were not named, will be allowed to repay the money they received from the $700 billion emergency rescue fund created by Congress at the height of the financial crisis in October.
16 of 19 stress-tested banks raise $75.2B in capital since early May, mostly by selling stockJune 8th, 2009 Stress-tested banks raise $75.2 billion in capitalSixteen of the 19 large banks that underwent government stress tests last month have raised more than $75 billion in capital, either because regulators required it or because the banks want to return federal bailout funds. Banks have also been issuing debt to prove to officials that they can finance operations on their own.
Fed issues guidelines for banks to repay bailouts; JPMorgan & Amex to sell stock to repay aidJune 2nd, 2009 JPMorgan, Amex launch stock offers to repay TARPWASHINGTON — JPMorgan Chase & Co. and American Express Co.
Goldman Sachs sells part of its stake in China bank ICBC for $1.9 billionJune 2nd, 2009 Goldman Sachs sells $1.9B stake in China's ICBCHONG KONG — Goldman Sachs has raised more than $1.9 billion after selling part of its stake in Industrial & Commercial Bank of China as the U.S. investment firm seeks to repay government bailout funds.
JPMorgan Chase seeks to raise $5 billion in bid to repay government's TARP programJune 1st, 2009 JPMorgan Chase to raise $5 billion to repay TARPNEW YORK — JPMorgan Chase & Co. said Monday it plans to raise $5 billion through a common stock offering as it seeks to repay the $25 billion that the bank was awarded in the government's troubled asset relief program.
Fed issues guidelines for big banks to repay bailouts; must 'reduce reliance' on governmentJune 1st, 2009 Fed outlines rules for repaying bailout moneyWASHINGTON — The Federal Reserve on Monday laid out rules for banks seeking to repay taxpayer bailout funds, clearing the way for the 19 largest financial institutions to wind down their reliance on government support. The rules apply to the nation's 19 largest banks, which have assets of more than $100 billion and were subjected to "stress tests" to determine their financial strength.
Official: Banks must shed FDIC guarantees if they want to return bailout fundsMay 6th, 2009 Official: Bailout returns will have conditionsWASHINGTON — The government will require banks seeking to return federal bailout money to prove they don't need other special federal assistance, a condition that will make it harder for some institutions to escape restrictions on executive compensation. The new requirement represents another shift in a changing landscape for banks.
Treasury selects 3 asset management firms for bailout program that buys bank stockApril 22nd, 2009 Treasury picks asset management firms for bailoutWASHINGTON — The Treasury Department on Wednesday selected three management firms to handle bank assets obtained as part of the $700 billion financial rescue program. The assets include stock warrants that Treasury has received as part of its program to buy nearly $200 billion in preferred shares in banks to help bolster their capital reserves and resume more normal lending to consumers and businesses.
Pandit, other top US bankers to defend use of bailout fundsFebruary 10th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Vikram Pandit, Indian American chief executive of CitiBank, and the heads of seven other major American banks will defend the use of hundreds of billions of dollars in bailout money to lawmakers on Capitol Hill Wednesday. 'American people are right to expect that we use funds responsibly, quickly and transparently to help American families, businesses and communities,' Pandit is expected to say before the House Financial Services committee, according to prepared remarks.
Loading ...