NEW YORK - The Palestinian Authority’s Foreign Minister Riad Al-Malki charged Wednesday that Israel was responsible for the deaths of more than 1,400 Palestinians in Gaza Strip, citing the Goldstone report on the December-January fighting between Israel and Hamas.
Israeli Ambassador Gabriela Shalev countered Al-Malki, rejecting the use of the council meeting by governments to discuss the report as counterproductive to the Middle East peace process. Israel has rejected the report as one-sided and biased.
“The report favours and legitimises terrorism. It is a prize for terrorist organisations,” she said.
“For those of us who seek to resume the peace process in the Middle East, debating the Goldstone Report in the Security Council is but a tale “full of sound and fury, signifying nothing’,” she added, using the famous quote from Shakespeare’s Macbeth.
Arab and Islamic envoys showed up in force in support of the Palestinians before the 15-nation council in New York in a showdown between them and the council in which the US can veto all attacks against its ally Israel.
The Arabs had demanded that the council debate the report of South African Judge Richard Goldstone on the Gaza fighting. The council rejected the demand, but decided to hold its monthly debate on the Middle East situation to allow Arab and Palestinian envoys to speak.
More than 40 speakers have signed up to address the council on the eve of another debate in the UNHRC in Geneva on the Goldstone report, which was drawn from investigations by a three-member panel commissioned by the 47-member council.
Al-Malki rejected assessments by the US and the UN that progress had been made to advance a settlement in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
“No real progress has been made in the peace process,” he said. “The Goldstone report constitutes a wake-up call that cannot be ignored.”
Al-Malki denounced what he called the “savage” killing of Palestinian people by the Israeli Defence Forces during the Gaza fighting with Hamas.
The Goldstone report, published Sep 9, charged both Israel and Hamas with having committed war crimes and acts that amounted to crimes against humanity during the Gaza fighting.
The 547-page report and its findings have infuriated Israel and the US, with the latter trying to bloc discussion in the UNHRC.
The report included recommendations on ways to pursue justice for both sides, including for Israeli and Palestinian authorities to engage in “good faith, independent proceedings” to investigate their own sides within six months.
The report called on the UN Security Council to refer the case to the International Criminal Court’s prosecutor in The Hague.
The fighting in Gaza erupted Dec 27, 2008 and lasted three weeks. The report said about 1,400 Palestinians were killed, mostly civilians. Israel suffered the deaths of three civilians and 10 soldiers.
Israel said Hamas fired hundreds of missiles and rockets at residential areas in Israel, threatening the lives of at least 1 million Jews.
The report said the IDF directed its attacks at Palestinians to punish them. It condemned the Israeli blockade on Gaza, calling it a “collective punishment” to isolate the territory.
Related News
Palestinians urge Israeli punishment for alleged war crimes in Gaza war last winterOctober 14th, 2009 Palestinians urge Israeli punishment over GazaUNITED NATIONS — The Palestinians called Wednesday for global action to punish Israel for alleged war crimes during its military assault on Gaza last winter, warning that the credibility of the United Nations and international human rights law was at stake. The demand was based on the findings of a commission headed by former South African judge Richard Goldstone.
Palestinians, allies force UN rights council to reopen Gaza war crimes debate ThursdayOctober 13th, 2009 Palestinians, allies reopen Gaza war crimes debateGENEVA — The U.N. Human Rights Council will reopen the debate about alleged war crimes in Gaza later this week after Palestinians succeeded in gathering enough support to call a special meeting, officials said Tuesday.
Palestinians: Goldstone report on Gaza war crimes 'remains alive' October 2nd, 2009 Palestinians say Goldstone report 'remains alive'
GENEVA — Palestinian diplomats said Friday they will ensure a United Nations report on war crimes in Gaza "remains alive," despite agreeing to delay a vote in the U.N. Human Rights Council on passing the document to the General Assembly for further action.
UN investigator defends report accusing Israel, Palestinians of war crimes in Gaza conflictSeptember 30th, 2009 UN expert defends Gaza war crimes reportGENEVA — A U.N. investigator defended a report Tuesday that accuses Israel and Palestinian militants of war crimes during their conflict in Gaza, an allegation Israel condemns and claims is the result of bias against the Jewish state.
Israel bombs three Gaza tunnelsSeptember 30th, 2009 TEL AVIV - The Israel Air Force bombed three weapons smuggling tunnels in the southern Gaza Strip border overnight, the military said Wednesday. The triple airstrike in the town of Rafah, on the border with Egypt, came after militants launched two projectiles from Gaza at southern Israel late Tuesday, a spokeswoman said.
US denounces UN Gaza report as biased against Israel, urges world to focus on peaceSeptember 18th, 2009 US raps UN Gaza reportWASHINGTON — The Obama administration on Friday sharply criticized a U.N. report alleging Israeli war crimes in its Gaza war earlier this year, ending nearly a week of muted reaction to findings already rejected by Israel.
Israel PM appeals to world leaders to reject Goldstone findingsSeptember 17th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu has termed the controversial Goldstone report as a "prize for terrorists" and described the commission, headed by South African Constitutional Court Judge Richard Goldstone, as a "kangaroo court" whose conclusions were drawn up before the hearings even started. The Human Rights Council, which mandated Goldstone to "investigate all violations of international human rights law and international humanitarian law by the occupying power, Israel, against the Palestinian people," will review the findings on September 29.
Israel's Netanyahu denounces UN Gaza report, calls on world to back right of self-defenseSeptember 17th, 2009 Netanyahu to world: Back Israeli self-defenseJERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday rejected the U.N. report alleging Israeli war crimes in its Gaza war this year, warning world leaders that they and their anti-terror forces could be targets for similar charges.
Mandate given to UN fact-finding mission in Gaza unacceptable: USSeptember 17th, 2009 NEW YORK - The UN Human Rights Council had given an "unacceptable" mandate to the fact-finding mission in the Gaza Strip led by South African judge Richard Goldstone, a US diplomat said Thursday. Goldstone's findings released this week accused both Israel and Palestinian militant groups of committing war crimes and crimes against humanity during the December-January conflict in Gaza, which the mission said killed at least 1,400 people.
Goldstone rejects Israeli allegations of bias Gaza reportSeptember 16th, 2009 JERUSALEM - The head of the UN fact-finding mission into last winter's Gaza war vehemently rejected Wednesday Israel's allegations against the report he wrote about the three weeks of fighting. Israel has reacted sharply to the critical report by South African justice Richard Goldstone, charging among others that the mission's mandate had been one-sided and its conclusions predetermined.
'We don't need morality lessons from Pak, Bangladesh,' says IsraelSeptember 16th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel has said that it does not need lessons in morality from a committee established by Syria, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Malaysia and Somalia. Responding to the findings of the Goldstone Commission Report with regard to the Israel Defence Force (IDF) aggression in the Gaza Strip earlier this year, Foreign Ministry spokesman Yossi Levy said: "Israel has examined itself in the light of day in innumerable investigations and a robust system of independent courts," said Levy.
Israel says Goldstone Report supports terrorSeptember 16th, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel has described the Goldstone Commission Report as biased and nauseating, and added that it has created an unjust "equivalence of a democratic state with a terror organization". The commission, established by the UN Human Rights Council and led by former South African constitutional court judge Richard Goldstone, concluded that "Israel committed actions amounting to war crimes, possibly crimes against humanity," during Operation Cast Lead from late December to mid-January.
Israel seeks US help to build nuclear power plant!July 31st, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel has sought help from the US to build a nuclear power plant in the country, a media report said Friday. Israel has already conveyed its request to the US, the Ynet news service reported.
Israel, Hamas committed war crimes: AmnestyJuly 2nd, 2009 JERUSALEM - Israel and Palestinian militants committed war crimes during the Gaza war of last winter, Amnesty International said in its first comprehensive report on the 22-day conflict, published Thursday. The London-based human rights groups called for an international arms embargo on both Israel and the radical Islamist Hamas movement ruling Gaza.
Israeli military says its probe shows it operated according to international law in GazaApril 22nd, 2009 Israel military: Probe shows no violations in GazaJERUSALEM — The Israeli military says its internal investigations shows it did not violate international law during its recent war in Gaza. The military says it maintained "high professional and moral level" against an enemy that "aimed to terrorize Israeli civilians while taking cover amid uninvolved civilians in the Gaza Strip and using them as human shields."
A former U.N.
Loading ...