Federal judge shutters Idaho grazing allotment
BOISE, Idaho — A federal judge has ordered a western Idaho rancher to keep his sheep off his family’s traditional grazing ground on public land to protect wild native bighorns. Federal land managers on Monday opted not to fight the ruling.
U.S. District Judge Lynn Winmill ruled last week that a pact between a Salmon River rancher and the state to keep his domestic herd separate from bighorns on a Bureau of Land Management allotment fell short of a 2009 law aimed at helping Idaho’s ranching industry and protecting the native wild sheep.
The Wilderness Society, Western Watersheds Project and Hells Canyon Preservation Council had all contended that a bighorn herd near Riggins was in danger of catching deadly diseases if the allotment near Partridge Creek opened to domestic herds on schedule Thursday.
The number of Idaho bighorns has dwindled by half since 1990 to about 3,500 after several mass die-offs. Wildlife managers believe bighorns can catch diseases such as pneumonia when they come into contact with domestic sheep. Winmill said he was trying to prevent more outbreaks.
“Irreversible damage is possible here,” Winmill wrote in his 17-page ruling. “Bighorns could become infected and roam far up-river in the Salmon River drainage, infecting the other native bighorns along the way, causing large-scale losses.”
This year, Idaho lawmakers passed a plan requiring the state Department of Fish and Game director to certify that the risk of disease transmission between bighorn and domestic sheep was “acceptable for the viability of the bighorn sheep” once ranchers and the state had crafted Best Management Practices, or BMPs, to keep the two species apart.
The state and rancher Mick Carlson, whose family has grazed the Partridge Creek allotment since 1937, negotiated such an agreement in August. Among other things, he agreed to have two herders, three guard dogs and three herding dogs with each band of sheep. He was also allowed to kill bighorns that wandered into his herd.
In his ruling Winmill said that agreement relied on voluntary compliance and could not be enforced by the Bureau of Land Management.
“The director here certified that the risk has been reduced to an acceptable level,” the judge wrote. “Acceptable to who? Acceptable under what standard?
“These questions are not answered,” Winmill added. “There is no certification in this case that upon implementation of the BMPs, the risk of disease transmission will be acceptable for the viability of the bighorn sheep.”
Another hearing on Winmill’s order to close the grazing allotment was planned for Nov. 2. But the Bureau of Land Management on Monday asked the judge to cancel that court date and said it would live by his order until it had a chance to do a new environmental analysis on the effects of grazing at Partridge Creek on wild bighorns.
The judge “found fundamental flaws in (Idaho’s law) that rendered the Idaho Department of Fish and Game’s certification of the Partridge Creek allotment meaningless and irrelevant in this case,” the federal agency’s lawyers wrote in their filing Monday. “For those reasons, the BLM does not oppose imposition of an injunction in this case until such time as an environmental analysis has been completed.”
State Fish and Game officials did not respond to a request for comment.
Jon Marvel, director of Western Watersheds in Hailey, said Winmill’s order underlined the weakness of Idaho’s new law.
“These Best Management Practices are, first of all, voluntary, and second, there is no testimony in the record from any scientist that concludes that they will be effective in protecting bighorn sheep.”
The Nez Perce Tribe, which opposes the grazing on its traditional homeland, called the decision a victory for bighorns.
“The use of BMPs to try and create separation between domestic and bighorn sheep in occupied bighorn sheep habitat is not supported by scientific literature or scientists,” said Brooklyn Baptiste, Vice-Chairman of the Nez Perce Tribal Executive Committee.
Carlson, who has already been barred from grazing on nearby U.S. Forest Service allotments, argued in court that he cannot run his operation in a profitable manner if more than 800 of his sheep are kept away from Partridge Creek.
A phone call to Carlson was not returned, but in court he contended it would cost him about $9,000 if he was forced to restrict his sheep to his private ground along the Salmon River and to the south in Emmett.
Related News
Wild horse defenders criticize plan to manage mustangs, urge removal of cattle in WestOctober 17th, 2009 Wild horse plan rekindles cattle grazing debateRENO, Nev. — A new federal proposal to manage wild horses is rekindling debate over another fixture of the Western range: cattle.
Report: Bus carrying high school marching band tips over on Idaho highway, killing 1October 10th, 2009 Report: High school band's bus crashes in IdahoINKOM, Idaho — An Idaho television station is reporting that a bus carrying members of a high school marching band has tipped over on an Idaho highway, killing one adult. KPVI-TV says that at least three people remained trapped inside the bus Saturday evening.
Feds say ruling that put bears back on threatened list actually puts them in greater dangerOctober 8th, 2009 Feds: Bears in more danger on threatened listBILLINGS, Mont. — Federal officials say a court ruling that returned Yellowstone grizzly bears to the threatened species list has unexpectedly put the animals at increased risk.
Interior Department proposes preserves in Midwest and East to save thousands of wild horsesOctober 7th, 2009 Interior proposes preserves to protect wild horsesWASHINGTON — Interior Secretary Ken Salazar wants to create wild horse preserves in the Midwest and East to protect wild horses and burros that now roam the West. Salazar says his plan will restore the health of America's wild horse herds and the rangelands that support them.
Fla. woman clawed, flown to hospital after trying to take wild emu to animal shelterOctober 5th, 2009 Fla. woman hurt trying to 'save' wild emuMOSSY HEAD, Fla. — A Florida Panhandle woman was flown to the hospital after being clawed by a wild emu she was trying to corral.
Judge hears arguments Friday over defense for Utah man accused of disrupting gas, oil auctionSeptember 25th, 2009 Judge to hear arguments in drilling auction caseSALT LAKE CITY — A federal judge will hear arguments Friday to decide whether a college student charged with disrupting a federal auction for oil and gas drilling leases in Utah can claim he was acting in the interest of the greater good. Tim DeChristopher says he wanted to protect wild lands near Utah's national parks from drilling and call attention to climate change.
Federal judge rules in favor of controversial wolf hunts in Montana, IdahoSeptember 9th, 2009 Federal judge says gray wolf hunts can continueBILLINGS, Mont. — A federal judge said Wednesday that gray wolf hunts in the Northern Rockies can go on, denying a request by environmentalists and animal welfare groups to stop the first organized wolf hunts in decades in Idaho and Montana.
Wild horse roundup in Montona, Wyoming to start Thursday after judge denies effort to block itSeptember 2nd, 2009 Wild horse roundup in Montana, Wyoming plannedBILLINGS, Mont. — A federal judge has rejected a request to halt a roundup of about 190 wild horses in the Pryor Mountains along the Montana-Wyoming border.
Idaho's wolf hunt off to slow start as federal judge eyes request to haltSeptember 1st, 2009 Idaho's wolf hunt on for nowBOISE, Idaho — The first legal wolf hunt in decades in the lower 48 states is off to a slow start. Hunters in Idaho could begin shooting wolves just before sunrise Tuesday in select hunting districts in the central and northern mountains.
Wolf hunts to proceed in Northern Rockies as judge weighs request to stop themAugust 31st, 2009 Wolf hunts are on, but it's uncertain for how longMISSOULA, Mont. — Wolf hunting will begin in the Northern Rockies as a federal judge weighs a request by environmental and animal welfare groups to stop the predators from being killed.
Whoa, Nellie: Spooked horse takes full carriage on a wild ride in downtown Salt Lake CityAugust 30th, 2009 Spooked horse takes family on wild carriage rideSALT LAKE CITY — Talk about a wild ride. A spooked horse pulling a carriage with seven people aboard took off through downtown Salt Lake City and didn't stop until it crashed through a police officer's bicycle and ran into a parked car.
6 juvenile wolves in Idaho found dead just days before start of proposed huntAugust 25th, 2009 6 juvenile wolves found dead in IdahoBOISE, Idaho — Idaho officials say six juvenile wolves were found decomposing on U.S. Forest Service land.
Conservation groups urge federal judge to block next month's wolf hunts in Idaho, MontanaAugust 21st, 2009 Groups try to block Idaho, Montana wolf huntsMISSOULA, Mont. — Conservation groups are asking a federal judge in Missoula to block fall wolf hunts in Idaho and Montana.
Mother's boyfriend arrested in case of Idaho boy found dead in canalAugust 19th, 2009 Mother's boyfriend jailed in death of Idaho boyBOISE, Idaho — An Idaho newspaper is reporting that police have made an arrest in connection with the disappearance and death of 8-year-old Robert Manwill. The Idaho Statesman says Daniel Ehrlick Jr.
Federal judge approves expansion of Smoky Canyon phosphate mine into Idaho roadless areaAugust 6th, 2009 Judge approves phosphate mine expansion in IdahoBOISE, Idaho — A federal judge has given approval for the expansion of the Smoky Canyon phosphate mine into a roadless area near Yellowstone National Park, but an environmental group is already promising to appeal the ruling. In a 53-page decision handed down late Tuesday evening, U.S.
Loading ...