Obama EPA releases Bush-era global warming finding
WASHINGTON — A controversial e-mail message buried by the Bush administration because of its conclusions on global warming surfaced Tuesday, nearly two years after it was first sent to the White House and never opened.
The e-mail and the 28-page document attached to it, released Tuesday by the Environmental Protection Agency, show that back in December of 2007 the agency concluded that six gases linked to global warming pose dangers to public welfare, and wanted to take steps to regulate their release from automobiles and the burning of gasoline.
The document specifically cites global warming’s effects on air quality, agriculture, forestry, water resources and coastal areas as endangering public welfare.
That finding was rejected by the Bush White House, which strongly opposed using the Clean Air Act to address climate change and stalled on producing a so-called “endangerment finding” that had been ordered by the Supreme Court in 2007.
As a result, the Dec. 5 e-mail sent by the agency to Susan Dudley, who headed the regulatory division at the Office of Management and Budget was never opened, according to Jason Burnett, the former EPA official that wrote it.
The Bush administration, and then EPA administrator Stephen Johnson, also refused to release the document, which is labeled “deliberative, do not distribute” to Democratic lawmakers. The White House instead allowed three senators to review it in July 2008, when excerpts were released.
The Obama administration in April made a similar determination, but also concluded that greenhouse gases endanger public health. The EPA is currently drafting the first greenhouse gas standards for automobiles, and recently signaled it would attempt to reduce climate-altering pollution from refineries, factories and other large industrial sources.
In response, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Republican lawmakers have criticized the EPA’s reasoning and called for a more thorough vetting of the science. An internal review by a dozen federal agencies released in May also raised questions about the EPA’s conclusion, saying the agency could have been more balanced and raising questions about the difficulty in linking global warming to health effects.
The agency released the e-mail and documents after receiving requests under the Freedom of Information Act.
Adora Andy, a spokeswoman for EPA administrator Lisa Jackson, said Tuesday that the draft shows the science in 2007 was as clear as it is today.
“The conclusions reached then by the EPA scientists should have been made public and should have been considered,” she said.
On the Net:
EPA FOIA Reading Room: www.epa.gov/foia/frequent.html
Related News
Texas activists sue state over lack of greenhouse gas restrictions for new power plantsOctober 6th, 2009 Activists sue Texas to restrict greenhouse gasesDALLAS — Environmental activists sued the Texas environmental agency Tuesday in an effort to force the state to regulate greenhouse gases, asking that coal-fired power plant projects be halted until that happens. The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality issues air pollution permits that set limits on toxic releases, but the agency says there is no need to regulate carbon dioxide.
Obama directs government to lead by example on global warming, oil useOctober 6th, 2009 Obama: Government to set global warming exampleWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama wants the federal government to set the example when it comes to global warming. In an executive order signed Monday, Obama required all agencies to do what he wants companies operating power plants, running refineries and making automobiles to do: reduce heat-trapping gases.
Obama directs federal agencies to set targets to reduce their global warming pollutionOctober 5th, 2009 Obama puts government on greenhouse-gas dietWASHINGTON — President Barack Obama is putting the federal government on a greenhouse-gas diet. In an executive order signed Monday, Obama directed all agencies to set the first-ever targets for reducing climate-altering pollution from government buildings, fleets and federal workers' commutes.
Denver released largest amount of greenhouse gases this yearSeptember 24th, 2009 WASHINGTON - A new study has determined that Denver, US, released the largest amount of greenhouse gases (GHG) and Barcelona, Spain, the smallest amount this year. The study documented how differences in climate, population density and other factors affect GHG emissions in global cities.
"Supervillain" CO2 has "henchmen" like NO2 and methane to amplify global warmingSeptember 9th, 2009 WASHINGTON - Scientists have said that in the fight against global warming, "supervillain" carbon dioxide (CO2) should not be solely targeted, as there are harmful greenhouse gases like nitrous oxide (N2O) and methane, which are the "henchmen" of CO2. According to a report in National Geographic News, several "henchmen" gases-some even more potent than CO2-have also been building up in Earth's atmosphere.
Bush releases final lists of White House, Camp David overnight guestsJuly 13th, 2009 Bush releases White House, Camp David guest listsWASHINGTON — Former President George W. Bush's overnight guests shortly before he left office included Republican Sen.
Obama administration agrees that industrialized nations should reduce greenhouse gas emissionsJuly 8th, 2009 Obama administration agrees on greenhouse gas cutsL'AQUILA, Italy — The Obama administration says it agrees that industrialized nations should sharply reduce their greenhouse gas emissions over the next four decades. White House officials said Wednesday that the administration supports a goal of an 80 percent greenhouse gas reduction from industrialized nations by 2050.
House rejects GOP energy alternatives, sets stage for OK of bill to combat climate changeJune 27th, 2009 House rejects GOP energy alternativeWASHINGTON — The House has rejected a Republican alternative to a Democratic climate bill. The vote set the stage for passage of a bill that for the first time would limit U.S.
3.6 trillion metric tons and rising: NYers can now track greenhouse gases on big billboardJune 18th, 2009 NYC billboard monitors rising greenhouse gasesNEW YORK — New Yorkers have long been able to keep tabs on the national debt, but they now have a highly visible counter to track greenhouse gas emissions. A 70-foot-high billboard outside Madison Square Garden and Pennsylvania Station, not far from the Empire State Building, features a carbon counter.
New York City billboard, Internet widget help the public monitor greenhouse gasesJune 18th, 2009 New York City billboard monitors greenhouse gasesNEW YORK — How are those greenhouse gases doing?
New York City residents and visitors will be able to monitor the situation, thanks to a giant billboard in Manhattan. A widget also will be provided to Web sites and blogs around the world.
GOP blasts plan to limit climate-changing gases and calls for nuclear plants, oil drillingJune 13th, 2009 GOP says Democrats' climate bill is another taxWASHINGTON — Republicans on Saturday slammed a Democratic bill before the House that seeks to address climate change, arguing that it amounts to an energy tax on consumers. In the GOP's weekly radio and Internet address, Indiana Rep.
US says it won't 'race forward' on new treaty to reduce greenhouse gases without ChinaJune 3rd, 2009 US role in new climate treaty hinges on ChinaWASHINGTON — The United States is not likely to enter into a new international treaty to reduce the emissions blamed for global warming without China and other major greenhouse-gas emitters on board, the Obama administration's chief climate negotiator said Wednesday. U.S. climate envoy Todd Stern told reporters in a conference call that China and other major developing countries are critical to making any international agreement work, and there is not going to be a new treaty to curb greenhouse gases without them.
White House document says EPA regulation of greenhouse gases will have serious economic costsMay 12th, 2009 White House memo challenges EPA finding on warmingWASHINGTON — An Environmental Protection Agency proposal that could lead to regulating the gases blamed for global warming will prove costly for factories, small businesses and other institutions, according to a White House document. The nine-page memo is a compilation of opinions made by a dozen federal agencies and departments during an internal review before the EPA issued a finding in April that greenhouse gases pose dangers to public health and welfare.
On second day of hearings on global warming bill, Obama administration could take heatApril 22nd, 2009 House climate hearings put Obama team on hot seatWASHINGTON — Top members of President Barack Obama's energy and environmental team are weighing in on a bill that would curb the emissions blamed for global warming and transform how the nation produces and uses energy. Energy Secretary Steven Chu and Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa Jackson, along with Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, were to spend part of their Earth Day before a House energy panel Wednesday.
Bush to host Obama, former presidents at White House lunchJanuary 6th, 2009 WASHINGTON - US President George W. Bush will host former presidents and his successor, Barack Obama, at the White House for a private meeting during lunch Wednesday, the White House said.
Loading ...