DOT report warned about lax safety oversight
WASHINGTON —Less than a month before the deadly midair collision involving a private plane and a sightseeing helicopter over New York’s Hudson River, a federal watchdog warned about the lax safety oversight of the for-hire flight business.
A report issued by the Department of Transportation’s inspector general criticized the Federal Aviation Administration for providing significantly weaker oversight of the “on-demand” flight industry — companies hired to fly aircraft, both helicopters and planes, that seat less than 30 people — than it does of the commercial airline industry.
National Transportation Safety Board Chairman Debbie Hersman, in an interview with The Associated Press before Saturday’s accident, said the report makes it clear “that there is disparate level of oversight.”
The accident across from Manhattan’s West Side near the Hoboken, N.J., waterfront occurred around noon on an otherwise idyllic summer day when a small private plane with three people aboard collided with a for-hire sightseeing helicopter carrying the pilot and five Italian tourists.
The impact scattered debris over the water and forced people on shore to flee for cover. Everyone aboard the two aircraft were presumed dead.
Criticism of the FAA’s oversight of the on-demand flight industry is nothing new. Since 2002, the NTSB has made 16 recommendations related to safety of the on-demand flight industry. The FAA has not implemented any of them.
An FAA advisory committee spent two years examining on-demand flight industry safety, issuing 124 recommendations in September 2005. Nearly four years later, none of those recommendations — many of which paralleled the NTSB recommendations — have been implemented.
The report noted that FAA is developing a new approach to safety oversight for for-hire operators that would target the most risky operations. However, it said the new system isn’t scheduled for full deployment for at least four years.
FAA officials have said they agree with recommendations in the inspector general’s report and are implementing them.
There are over 2,300 on-demand operators in the U.S., flying more than 9,000 aircraft. In 2007 and 2008, a period in which there were no deaths due to commercial airline accidents, there were 33 fatal on-demand aircraft accidents in which 109 people were killed.
Many of the regulations governing the industry haven’t been updated since 1978. Since that time technology has changed. The use of jets by for-hire companies is now common, for example. Operators also fly more complex types of flights and more international flights.
On-demand flight operations are inspected far less frequently than commercial airliners even though they often operate under riskier conditions. For instance, they typically fly into small airports without control towers or take off and land in remote locations, from Rocky Mountain ski slopes to the red rock canyons of the desert Southwest.
The inspector general’s report cited as an example an on-demand operator that flies dozens of flight a day taking tourists to glaciers where the planes land and take off on skis. The operator has 17 planes and was inspected eight times by FAA in 2008. By contrast, a commercial airline with 10 planes overseen by the same FAA office received 199 inspections the same year.
For-hire industry pilots are required to have a minimum of 500 hours of flight experience and a commercial license, while a commercial airline captain is required to have 1,500 hours of flight experience and needs to obtain the more difficult air transport license.
On-demand companies are also not required to employ an FAA-licensed dispatcher, and their aircraft don’t have to be equipped with warnings systems that alert pilots when they are in danger of colliding with another aircraft or flying into the ground. Nor do they have to have cockpit voice or data recorders or in-flight radar systems. There are also less stringent maintenance requirements.
On the Net:
DOT inspector general report: www.oig.dot.gov/item.jsp?id=2511
Related News
Treasury IG responds to request for ACORN probe by examining oversight of tax-exempt groupsSeptember 24th, 2009 Oversight of tax-exempt groups like ACORN examinedWASHINGTON — The Treasury Department's inspector general is looking into the government's oversight of tax-exempt organizations like ACORN when they engage in political activities. The office of Rep.
Inspector general criticizes Los Alamos firefighters' ability to respond to nuclear lab firesSeptember 16th, 2009 Audit: Firefighters not ready for nuclear lab fireALBUQUERQUE, N.M. — The U.S.
Investigator: Some safety checks still lacking for US road travel of Mexican trucks, busesSeptember 2nd, 2009 Auditor: Mexican truck safety rules still unmetWASHINGTON — Some Mexican passenger buses are not being inspected when they enter the U.S. because they cross the border on evenings and weekends, there are no inspectors or the crossings lack safe places for inspections, according to a government audit made public Wednesday.
NTSB recommends separation of planes, choppers over Hudson, slams air controller complacencyAugust 28th, 2009 NTSB: Controller didn't warn plane in midair crashNEWARK, N.J. — An air traffic controller should have warned the pilot of a small plane about aircraft in its path before it collided with a sightseeing helicopter over New York's Hudson River in a crash that claimed nine lives, federal officials said Thursday in making safety recommendations.
VA investigator says oversight lacking in $70M program to replace hospital appointment systemAugust 27th, 2009 Report: No oversight for $70M program at the VAWASHINGTON — Managers at the Veterans Affairs Department were aware of serious problems with a $70 million project to replace its hospital appointment system several years before the VA dropped the program, the agency's inspector general says in a new report. The VA announced the project in 2000 following complaints from veterans about long waits to make appointments.
Government watchdog, safety board have warned of lax oversight of for-hire flight industryAugust 9th, 2009 Collision turns attention to for-hire flightsWASHINGTON —The collision that sent a sightseeing helicopter full of tourists and a small plane into the Hudson River on Saturday comes less than a month after a federal watchdog warned that safety oversight of sightseeing and other for-hire flights is too lax. A small plane collided with a New York City sightseeing helicopter carrying Italian tourists on Saturday around noon.
House fails to give speedy passage to bill establishing greater food safety oversightJuly 29th, 2009 Food safety bill denied quick passage in HouseWASHINGTON — A sweeping food safety bill has failed to pass in the House after criticism that it was being pushed through too quickly. The legislation would require more government inspections and oversight of food manufacturers in the wake of a massive salmonella outbreak in peanuts.
Inspector general: Treasury has not adopted accountability measures for bailout programJuly 20th, 2009 Watchdog: Treasury bailout disclosure falls shortWASHINGTON — The government's main watchdog over the federal financial bailout says the Treasury Department has repeatedly failed to adopt recommendations aimed at making the $700 billion program more accountable and transparent. Neil Barofsky (buh-RAHF'-skee), the inspector general for the Troubled Asset Relief Program, says in a report to Congress that Treasury's inaction means taxpayers have not been told what the financial institutions that have received assistance are doing with the money.
Watchdog: FAA safety oversight of 'on-demand' flight operators lax, recommendations ignoredJuly 16th, 2009 FAA safety oversight of small operators criticizedWASHINGTON — There is less safety oversight of "on-demand" flight operators than commercial airlines even though those smaller operations are often riskier, a federal watchdog said Thursday. A report by the Transportation Department's inspector general said the Federal Aviation Administration conducts far fewer safety inspections of on-demand operators than commercial airlines and doesn't effectively target the inspections it does make to the highest-risk operations.
India upgrades aviation security, safety standardsJune 25th, 2009 NEW DELHI - India Thursday said it has developed an effective strategy to strengthen its regulatory mechanism and safety system for its aviation sector following recommendations from international authorities. "The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA - India's aviation regulator) has developed an effective strategy to strengthen and develop a robust regulatory mechanism and a safety oversight system.
Senators tell FAA to adopt 2005 safety recommendation on pilot background checksJune 10th, 2009 Senators urge FAA to adopt safety recommendationWASHINGTON — Senators on Wednesday urged the Federal Aviation Administration to implement a 2005 recommendation that airlines be required to check the training histories of pilots they hire, an issue in a February air crash near Buffalo, N.Y. Mark Rosenker, the acting chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board, told a Senate committee probing safety issues related to FAA's oversight of regional airlines that the board urged three years ago that airlines be required to request a pilot's complete training history from the agency.
Inspector general: Congress needs to keep closer watch on FAA safety oversight of airlinesJune 10th, 2009 Investigator: FAA missing inspections at airlinesWASHINGTON — A government watchdog says the Federal Aviation Administration is missing safety inspections at major airlines. The Transportation Department's inspector general, Calvin Scovel, said Wednesday that the cozy relationship between FAA inspectors and Southwest Airlines that he warned Congress about last year extends to more offices within the agency and more airlines than previously known.
Despite Pentagon claims military in charge, report says security firm oversees for-hire guardsJune 10th, 2009 Contractor oversees security guards in AfghanistanWASHINGTON — A major security contractor is running an office overseeing armed guards in Afghanistan, a situation at odds with the Pentagon's claim that military officers would be in charge of such sensitive work. A new report on wartime spending to be made public Wednesday at a congressional hearing says the contractor, Aegis Defense Services, has operated with limited U.S.
Mexican airline Aviacsa resumes flights after winning court decisionJune 6th, 2009 Mexico's Aviacsa wins court ruling, starts flightsMEXICO CITY — Mexican airline Aviacsa has resumed flights after winning a court ruling against a government order grounding its fleet over safety concerns. An Aviacsa statement says it resumed operations Saturday after a judge struck down the government order.
Gov't watchdogs say some audits delayed, shelved over examining failed financial institutionsMay 5th, 2009 Watchdogs: Failed-bank reviews stop some auditsWASHINGTON — U.S. efforts to trace terrorist financing and money laundering are receiving less scrutiny by government watchdog offices because of the unprecedented need to monitor failed financial institutions, the Treasury Department's inspector general said Tuesday.
Loading ...