Chimp owner: Conn. woman was mauled on the job
NEW HAVEN, Conn. — An attorney representing the owner of a chimpanzee that mauled and blinded a woman is calling the attack a work-related incident and said her family’s case should be treated like a workers’ compensation claim.
The strategy, if successful, would severely limit potential damages in the case and insulate the chimp owner from personal liability.
The 200-pound chimpanzee named Travis went berserk in February when his owner, Sandra Herold, asked her friend and employee Charla Nash to help lure him back into her house in Stamford. The animal ripped off Nash’s hands, nose, lips and eyelids, and she remains in stable condition at the Cleveland Clinic.
Nash’s family filed a $50 million lawsuit against Herold, saying she was negligent and reckless for lacking the ability to control “a wild animal with violent propensities.”
But Herold’s attorney, Robert Golger, says in recent court papers that Nash was working as an employee of Herold’s tow truck company, Desire Me Motors, at the time of the attack. He argues that Travis was an integral part of the business, saying his picture was on the wrecker, he appeared at the garage daily and he attended numerous promotional events.
The house where the attack occurred is a business office of the company, Golger said. Nash fed Travis, cleaned his play area and purchased his supplies as an employee, Golger contends.
“It’s an unfortunate and tragic accident that happened in the workplace and should be subject to the provisions of the Connecticut workers’ compensation statutes,” Golger said Wednesday.
Matt Newman, attorney for Nash’s family, said he disagrees with the argument but declined further comment.
Under workers’ compensation, Nash would have her medical bills paid for by the employer’s insurance and would receive partial wage replacement, but would not get any money for pain and suffering that makes up a large part of jury awards in civil cases. Workers typically receive 65 to 75 percent of their wages.
“It’s a steady smaller income that would be enormously dwarfed by a successful civil suit,” John Mastropietro, chairman of the Connecticut Workers Compensation Commission, said Wednesday.
Paul Slager, an attorney in Stamford not involved in the case, says Golger is making “a pretty creative argument.”
To win the argument, Herold will need to prove there was an employer-employee relationship and that Nash’s injuries were work-related.
Nathan Shafner, a workers’ compensation attorney in Connecticut, called the tactic “a very sellable argument” and thinks it could prevail.
The strategy leaves Nash’s side in a quandary because they only have one year to file a workers’ compensation claim, Shafner said. If they fail to file that claim and lose the civil case, they could be left with no remedy, he said.
The 14-year-old chimp was shot and killed by police when he tried to attack a police officer responding to the assault on Nash. Test results showed that Travis had the anti-anxiety drug Xanax in his system at the time of the attack, but investigators don’t know whether the drug played a role.
Related News
Connecticut chimp owner seeking to limit mauled woman's claim to workers compensationOctober 14th, 2009 Chimp owner seeks to limit mauled woman's claimNEW HAVEN, Conn. — An attorney for the owner of a chimpanzee that mauled a Connecticut woman in February is arguing that the attack should be treated like a worker's compensation claim.
Woman killed, 12 injured in mudslideOctober 6th, 2009 NOIDA - A 25-year-old woman labourer was killed and 12 workers were injured when tonnes of mud fell on them at a construction site here Tuesday, police said. Over a dozen workers were digging away in Sector 63 in Noida when the mudslide occurred, trapping them.
Calgary Zoo says tiger mauled man who broke into zoo overnightOctober 5th, 2009 Canadian man mauled by tigerTORONTO — A man who broke into the Calgary Zoo overnight and scaled a fence around a tiger exhibit is hospitalized with serious injuries to his arms after he was attacked by a tiger. Zoo spokesman Grahame Newton says two men, both 27, broke into the zoo at around 1 a.m.
Woman named as a suspect in 6 New England bank robberies last week is taken into custodySeptember 30th, 2009 Female suspect in 6 bank robberies is arrestedHARTFORD, Conn. — A woman suspected in six bank robberies last week in southern New England has been arrested.
Connecticut woman suspected of robbing 6 banks in 6 days is ordered held on $1 million bondSeptember 30th, 2009 $1M bond set for woman suspected in bank robberiesNORWICH, Conn. — A 34-year-old woman suspected of robbing six southern New England banks in six days has been ordered held on $1 million bond.
Woman accused of attempted murder after alleged car theft with owner clinging to hoodAugust 14th, 2009 Colo. woman allegedly stole car with owner on hoodDENVER — Prosecutors are accusing a Denver woman of attempted first-degree murder for allegedly stealing a car and fleeing at speeds up to 50 mph — even after the owner hopped on the car's hood in a bid to stop her. Ryan Calles had stopped at a sandwich shop in Denver on Wednesday, and left his keys inside.
Hartford Financial Services will refund $48.2M in excess profit from Florida businessAugust 12th, 2009 Hartford will refund $48M in workers' comp profitHARTFORD, Conn. — Insurer Hartford Financial Services Group Inc.
New Zealand woman jogger seriously hurt in mauling by 8 hunting dogsAugust 3rd, 2009 NZ woman jogger mauled by 8 hunting dogsWELLINGTON, New Zealand — A New Zealand woman jogger "looked like a blob of blood" from multiple bite wounds after eight pig hunting dogs attacked her as she ran past a rural property on North Island, her husband said Tuesday. Margit Christensen, 36, suffered scores of bites to her scalp, arms and legs before the dogs ran off.
Mob lynches bear after it mauls woman to deathJuly 13th, 2009 BHUBANESWAR - A group of villagers lynched a bear after it mauled a woman to death in Orissas Ganjam district, police said Monday. Khali Behera, 55, resident of Badamahuri village under Kabisuryanagar police station, some 250 km from here, had gone to a forest near her village to collect firewood when the bear attacked her, A.C.
Brothers of Connecticut chimp victim say she thought primate might hurt someoneJune 28th, 2009 Brothers: Victim of chimp attack feared animalNEW HAVEN, Conn. — The brothers of a Connecticut woman mauled and blinded by a chimpanzee say she feared the animal might hurt someone and described him as mean and so strong that she had to repair his cage several times.
Conn. trucking co. owner gets 6 years for fatal crash;accused of rigging truck with bad brakesJune 24th, 2009 Conn. trucking co. owner gets 6 years in prisonHARTFORD, Conn.
AP: Conn. officials were warned about chimp danger before attack but failed to take actionJune 20th, 2009 AP: Conn. officials were warned about attack chimpNEW HAVEN, Conn. — Connecticut officials were repeatedly warned about the dangers posed by a chimpanzee who later mauled and blinded a woman and were urged — more than three years before the attack — to take action, but failed to do so, according to records obtained by The Associated Press.
Bear kills woman in Himachal PradeshJune 7th, 2009 SHIMLA - A bear mauled to death a woman in a Himachal Pradesh village, police said Sunday. The victim, Devki Devi, 60, was grazing livestock when she was attacked by the bear near Nerwa village of Shimla district Saturday, police said.
Costs for keeping a chimpMay 14th, 2009 Costs for keeping a chimpCaring for a chimpanzee costs about $15,000 annually at any of the nation's dozen chimpanzee sanctuaries. Here's a breakdown of the cost:
— $2,500: food
— $8,000: caregiver/staff salaries
— $1,000: medicine
— $3,500: facilities, including caging, maintenance, equipment and security
Source: Chimpanzee Sanctuary Northwest
Prosecutor: Conn. chimp that mauled woman had Xanax in system, but unclear if it played roleMay 13th, 2009 Conn. chimp that mauled woman had Xanax in systemNEW HAVEN, Conn. — A chimpanzee that mauled a Connecticut woman had the anti-anxiety drug Xanax in its system, according to toxicology tests, but investigators haven't determined whether the drug played a role in the attack, a prosecutor said Wednesday.
Loading ...