BANGKOK - “Each person is entitled to his fair share of global atmospheric space,” China’s chief climate negotiator Yu Qingtai said Wednesday, publicly placing for the first time Chinese support to this concept formulated by India’s Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.
As the Sep 28-Oct 9 talks here in preparation for this December’s climate summit in Copenhagen threatened to get nowhere due to acrimony between developed and developing countries, Yu said: “The (greenhouse gas) emission aggregate of a country does not stand alone. Each person is entitled to his fair share of global atmospheric space.
“China has 1.3 billion people. It is more appropriate and fair to look at (emissions on) per capita basis. That will give you four tonnes per person per year for China, one third of that of developed countries.”
India’s per capita emission is just over one tonne per year, while it is about 20 tonnes in the US and 12 in the European Union. In 2007, Manmohan Singh had proposed that per capita emissions be equalised, and later committed that India would never exceed the per capita emission in industrialised countries.
But industrialised countries have been insisting on looking at the total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of countries, by which China overtook the US in 2007 to become the world’s worst polluter. India is in fifth place.
However, industrialised countries have emitted almost all the extra GHG - mainly carbon dioxide - now in the atmosphere, over the past two and a half centuries.
Pointing this out, Yu said: “Climate change was created by developed countries. They created the problem and developing countries are the victims. In all fairness we can’t sit here today and say everybody should make an effort. There has to be differentiation between those who created the problem and others.”
Yu was speaking at a media clinic organised by the Climate Change Media Partnership and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). On the same panel, Karl Falkenberg of the European Commission reacted by saying the Chinese proposal would give more people “a right to pollute”, an observation that drew a sharp reaction from Yu.
China’s top climate negotiator pointed out that even today, 20 percent of the world’s population living in industrialised countries contribute 70-80 percent of all the GHG emissions that are leading to climate change - which is already reducing farm output, making droughts, floods and storms more frequent and more severe, and raising the sea level, with developing countries bearing the brunt of the effects.
The panel also showed up the division between developed and developing countries over continuing with the Kyoto Protocol - the current international treaty to fight global warming, under which industrialised countries have to reduce their GHG emissions by over five percent by 2012, compared to 1990, while there is no legal obligation on developing countries to reduce or cap their GHG emissions.
Falkenberg said global warming could be fought “only if we widen participation - with the US on one hand, and emerging large emitters (read China and India) on the other”. Chief US climate negotiator Jonathan Pershing supported him, saying even if all industrialised countries reduced their GHG emissions, it would not solve the global warming problem without action by large developing countries.
While saying that a “legally binding agreement should include action by developing countries”, Pershing acknowledged that major emerging economies such as China, India, Brazil and South Africa were already doing a lot to reduce the rise in their GHG emissions.
“We’re not asking them (the emerging economies) to commit to the outcome, but only to the action, while we have to commit to the outcome,” Pershing said. India’s Minister of State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh has said recently India was willing to report these actions more regularly to the UNFCCC, an offer echoed here Wednesday by the country’s chief climate negotiator Shyam Saran.
Falkenberg said: “It is very unlikely that the US will join the Kyoto Protocol. But we are working very closely with the US to create a legal framework that the US and large developing countries can join.”
But the opposition of developing countries to any attempt to derail the Kyoto Protocol remains as strong as before. As Yu put it: “There are two sets of wheels in this vehicle (UNFCCC and the protocol). Now some people are trying to take away one set of wheels. And you know what happens when that is done.”
Related News
Rich countries framing climate debate to suit themselves: IndiaOctober 6th, 2009 BANGKOK - Rich countries have been framing the climate debate to suit themselves rather than looking at the way global warming affects most of the world, which is why a global treaty is proving elusive, India's top climate negotiator said here Tuesday. "They don't talk about equity, they only talk of how to protect their lifestyles," the Prime Minister's Special Envoy on Climate Change Shyam Saran told a group of Indian NGO representatives.
India for annual climate change dialogues with US, EUOctober 3rd, 2009 WASHINGTON - India has proposed annual bilateral dialogues with the United States and the European Union to exchange notes on the issue of climate change, Minister of State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh has said. The proposed dialogue with the Europeans and the Americans could be on the lines of the first India-China energy dialogue scheduled to take place in New Delhi Oct 21, he said at a press conference here Friday at the end of his US visit.
EU says 'decisive progress' needed at climate talks in BangkokSeptember 25th, 2009 EU calls for urgency at climate talks in BangkokSTOCKHOLM — The European Union is urging wealthy and developing countries to bring more "urgency and ambition" to climate talks in Thailand next week. The Bangkok meeting starting Monday is the penultimate negotiating session before a pivotal U.N.
US says differences in global climate talks narrowingSeptember 18th, 2009 WASHINGTON - The United States' top climate official said there had been a "narrowing of differences" after a meeting of the world's 17 top polluters that are critical to reaching any international deal on curbing climate change. Todd Stern, the US State Department's envoy on climate change, said Friday some "concrete initiatives" that could help broker a deal were considered during two days of talks by the climate officials in Washington.
Danish PM to nudge India on global climate dealSeptember 9th, 2009 NEW DELHI - With less than three months to go for the Copenhagen conference on climate change, Danish Prime Minister Lars Lokke Rasmussen comes here on a day-long visit Friday to enlist India's support for a new global deal to slash carbon emissions. Rasmussen, one of Denmark's youngest prime ministers, will hold talks with his Indian counterpart Manmohan Singh on a wide range of issues, including global financial crisis and issues relating to global warming and green technologies.
Experts say substantive progress in Sino-Indian border talks 'dim'August 8th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The hopes for substantive progress in China-India border talks were "dim" as the two nations began their 13th round of boundary negotiations on Friday, experts in international studies have said. Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo (r), special representative of China in Sino-Indian Boundary Talks, and his Indian counterpart, National Security Advisor M.K.
India, China in talks to monitor Himalayan glaciersAugust 3rd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Setting aside speculation about strains in bilateral ties, India has said it is engaged in talks with China to monitor the glaciers in the Himalayas, a strategic border region, and plans to collaborate in climate change negotiations. "We are talking to the Chinese about monitoring the Himalayan glaciers," Minister for State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh told Britain's Financial Times.
China most important ally in combatting global warming- Indian Environment MinistryJuly 31st, 2009 NEW DELHI - "India considers China its most important ally in Copenhagen negotiations," Minister of State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh said here Friday. Negotiations for the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) summit in Copenhagen this December have often been fractious, with developed and major developing countries like India and China often taking opposing stands on who should do more to combat global warming.
UN chief says China wants to seal a deal on a new UN climate treaty in Copenhagen in DecemberJuly 30th, 2009 UN chief says China wants climate dealUNITED NATIONS — Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon says China's leaders have assured him they want to seal a deal on a new U.N. climate treaty at a conference in Copenhagen, Denmark, in December.
Clinton: US and China agree to cooperate on foreign challengesJuly 28th, 2009 Clinton: U.S.-China to cooperate on challengesWASHINGTON — Secretary of State Hillary Clinton says the United States and China have agreed to cooperate on difficult foreign policy challenges such as North Korea and Iran as well as counterterrorism and climate change. Clinton described as unparalleled the range of issues discussed between U.S.
India, China have to resist pressure on climate change: PMJuly 11th, 2009 ON BOARD AIR INDIA ONE - India and China need to resist pressure from industrialised countries on the issue of climate change, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said Saturday. The developed countries are by far the biggest polluters of the environment since the start of the Industrial Age.
India, US to hold bilateral talks on climate changeJune 12th, 2009 BONN - Climate negotiators from the Obama administration will be in New Delhi to hold bilateral talks on what India is ready to do to tackle global warming, the leader of the US delegation to a UN conclave said here Friday. Jonathan Pershing, who led the US delegation at these preparatory talks of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) for the December summit in Copenhagen, said he had met the leader of the Indian delegation Shyam Saran on the sidelines of the talks here.
Long hard way to global climate deal: UNJune 8th, 2009 BONN - The world needs clarity on the extent industrialised countries are going to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gas (GHG) that are changing the climate and what "nationally appropriate mitigation action" large developing countries like India will take, UN climate chief Yvo de Boer said here Monday. Speaking at the mid-point of a June 1-12 conference to prepare for this December's summit in Copenhagen where a climate agreement is scheduled to be inked, de Boer said negotiators from 182 countries gathered here should also provide clarity on "how to generate support for mitigation and adaptation (to climate change) in developing countries" through financing from industrialised countries.
India wants to meet China, Brazil, Russia over climate pactMay 14th, 2009 NEW DELHI - There should be high level talks between Brazil, Russia, India and China on a global pact to combat climate change before the first BRIC summit in Russia next month, India's top climate negotiator Shyam Saran said here Thursday. The talks should be at the level of either politicians or senior officials, Prime Minister's Special Envoy on Climate Change Saran told delegates from all BRIC countries at a summit preparatory meeting organised by the Observer Research Foundation (ORF).
Manmohan, Obama hold first bilateral talksApril 2nd, 2009 LONDON - Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and US President Barack Obama held their first bilateral talks here Thursday and discussed new paths of collaboration in fighting terrorism and climate change. 'We held fruitful talks,' Manmohan Singh said after his meeting with Obama.
Loading ...