Slain Russian activist’s children ask for justice
MOSCOW — Three years after their mother was gunned down in her Moscow apartment building, Anna Politkovskaya’s son and daughter said Tuesday they are losing hope the killers will ever be brought to justice.
Prosecutors are investigating three men accused of helping to set up the journalist’s shooting on Oct. 7, 2006, but they have said little about who might have ordered the contract-style killing while the suspected gunman is believed to be hiding abroad.
Politkovskaya’s editor at Novaya Gazeta said Tuesday the investigators have new suspects “in their field of vision.” Sergei Sokolov, who has worked closely with investigators on the case, refused to identify the new suspects or say how they might have been involved.
Throughout her career, Politkovskaya harshly criticized the Kremlin and exposed widespread rights abuses and corruption in Chechnya, which won her world renown but many enemies at home.
Suspicions arose immediately of possible government involvement in her killing, and the handling of the case so far has done little to dispel them.
Politkovskaya’s daughter expressed concern Tuesday about the government’s willingness to conduct an honest and full investigation.
“An indication that the Kremlin is interested in the case being solved will come when the real people are put on trial,” Vera Politkovskaya told journalists.
“Our family gradually is beginning to lose hope that the whole chain of people who took part in the killing will be found and convicted,” she said, sitting with her brother, Ilya Politkovsky.
The three suspects accused of playing minor roles in the killing were acquitted by a Moscow jury in February. The Supreme Court overturned the acquittal and sent the case back to prosecutors, but then last month changed the scope of the investigation at the family’s request.
The case against the three defendants was merged with the investigation into the suspected gunman and the search for the mastermind. Sokolov said it was doubtful the mastermind would ever be identified.
Alleged gunman Rustam Makhmudov, the brother of two of the defendants, has fled Russia. Although he has moved from one country to another, Sokolov said, there have been missed opportunities to arrest him. The editor would give no specifics, saying only that Makhmudov’s location in a European Union country was known in April.
Ilya Politkovsky said he hopes investigators have been given fresh impetus to find the gunman and mastermind. But as it stands now, the case is only likely to make it back to court in the event Makhmudov is apprehended.
Prosecutors did not respond to a request for information on the status of the investigation.
Since Politkovskaya’s death, several other journalists and human rights activists have been killed in Russia — a trend that has caused alarm in the United States and Europe.
Amnesty International urged Russian President Dmitry Medvedev on Tuesday to take genuine steps to end the attacks and to demonstrate a commitment to bringing perpetrators to justice.
“It is time President Medvedev showed the political will to protect people that stand up for human rights in Russia,” Amnesty secretary general Irene Khan said in a statement.
Two representatives of France-based Reporters Without Borders, including the secretary general, were unable to obtain visas to travel to Moscow to join Politkovskaya’s children at the news conference. The rights organization said it had been tossed from one Russian government department to another after first applying for the visas on Sept. 25.
A spokesman for the Russian Embassy in Paris, Andrei Kleimyonov, said the Reporters Without Borders representatives had filled out the visa application incorrectly, and he denied any political motivation for the decision, the Interfax news agency reported.
Related News
European human rights envoy urges Russia to prosecute killers of NGO in ChechnyaSeptember 10th, 2009 European envoy asks Russia about NGO killingMOSCOW — The Council of Europe's commissioner on human rights says Russia must prosecute the killers of a human rights activist in Chechnya this year, if it is to break a cycle of violence in the region. Thomas Hammarberg said Thursday that bringing the killers of Natalya Estemirova to justice will help dissipate the atmosphere of impunity that pervades Russia's violent southern fringe.
Russian news agencies: Supreme Court orders new investigation of Politkovskaya killingSeptember 3rd, 2009 Report: New probe ordered in Politkovskaya killingMOSCOW — Russian news agencies are reporting that the Supreme Court has ordered a further investigation into the killing of journalist and Kremlin critic Anna Politkovskaya. State-run RIA-Novosti and ITAR-Tass say the court on Thursday reversed the ruling of a lower court that rejected a request by Politkovskaya's children for further investigation.
Russian Supreme Court orders further investigation in killing of investigative reporterSeptember 3rd, 2009 Probe stepped up in killing of Russian reporterMOSCOW — Russia's Supreme Court on Thursday ordered further investigation into the killing of an investigative journalist who was gunned down in an elevator after harshly criticizing Vladimir Putin's Kremlin and human rights abuses in Russia's region of Chechnya. The Supreme Court's military bench returned the case against three suspects accused of involvement in Anna Politkovskaya's 2006 killing to prosecutors, the court's press service said.
Russian rights activist visits slain colleague's Chechnya grave, fears justice won't be doneAugust 30th, 2009 Slain Russian activist's colleague despairsKOSHKELDY, Russia — A leading Russian human rights activist paid an emotional visit Sunday to the cemetery where her slain colleague Natalya Estemirova is buried, weeping at her grave and predicting her killers will never be never be brought to justice. Lyudmila Alexeyeva, the widely respected 82-year-old head of the Moscow Helsinki Group, had a message as she left the plot in Estemirova's ancestral village: "Curse those who are guilty in Natalya's death."
Estemirova worked for the rights group Memorial, and her reports on alleged rights abuses in Chechnya made her unpopular with the region's strongman leader and his government.
Russian human rights activist found dead after going missing, colleague suspects murderJuly 22nd, 2009 Russian activist dead, colleague suspects murderMOSCOW — A Russian human rights activist has been found dead in a sand pit weeks after he went missing, according to police and a colleague who said Wednesday that he suspects the prisoners' rights advocate was murdered. The news of Andrei Kulagin's death came a week after the abduction and killing of Natalya Estemirova, a well-respected human rights activist and critic of the Kremlin-backed leader of Russia's war-scarred Chechnya region.
International reaction to the slaying of Russian activist Natalya EstemirovaJuly 16th, 2009 Comments on slaying of Russian activist Estemirova
International reaction to the kidnapping and murder of Russian human rights activist Natalya Estemirova in the Caucasus. Estemirova, 50, was a leading member of the Chechen branch of the Russian human rights group Memorial.
White House says it's 'disturbed and saddened' by killing of Russian human rights activistJuly 16th, 2009 US 'disturbed and saddened' by Russian killingWASHINGTON — The White House says it's "disturbed and saddened" by the kidnapping and killing of a Russian human rights activist. White House spokesman Bill Burton says the killing is especially shocking because it comes a week after President Barack Obama visited Moscow and met with members of activist Natalya Estemirova's organization.
Lawyers, activists and reporters against the govt are being killed in Russia mysteriouslyJuly 16th, 2009 Some recent high-profile slayings of activists, reporters and lawyers who have challenged Russian authorities in recent years. There have been no convictions in any of the following killings.
Reports: Russian rights activist found dead after being kidnapped in ChechnyaJuly 15th, 2009 Reports: Russian activist found dead in ChechnyaMOSCOW — Russian news agencies are reporting that a prominent rights activist has been found dead, hours after being kidnapped in Chechnya. ITAR-Tass and Interfax quote unidentified police officials as saying that Natalya Estemirova's body was found in Ingushetia, a region that borders Chechnya to the west.
Russian rights group says leading activist kidnapped from her home in ChechnyaJuly 15th, 2009 Russian group says activist abducted in ChechnyaMOSCOW — A prominent Russian human rights group says its leading activist in Chechnya has been kidnapped. Memorial chairman Oleg Orlov says that four men forced Natalya Estemirova into a car in the Chechen capital, Grozny, early Wednesday.
Russian rights activist found dead after being kidnapped in ChechnyaJuly 15th, 2009 Russian activist abducted in Chechnya found deadMOSCOW — A prominent Russian activist who investigated abductions, killings and other rights abuses in Chechnya was found killed Wednesday, hours after being kidnapped in the Chechen capital, police officials and her organization said. Natalya Estemirova's body was found in Ingushetia, which borders Chechnya to the west, Oleg Orlov, the chairman of Memorial, her rights group, told The Associated Press.
Russian human rights activist killed in ChechnyaJuly 15th, 2009 MOSCOW - The head of a prominent Russian human rights organisation was kidnapped and killed in Russia's troubled Caucasus region Wednesday, the Moscow state prosecutor's office confirmed. The body of Natalya Estemirova, head of the group Memorial, was discovered in the Russian republic of Ingushetia with multiple gunshot wounds to the head and chest, reported the Interfax news agency, citing government reports.
US diplomat urges Russia to redouble efforts to bring US journalist's killers to justiceJuly 7th, 2009 US wants justice in journalist's killingMOSCOW — The United States is urging Russia to redouble its efforts to bring an American journalist's killers to justice. Amid a Russian-American summit, a top U.S.
Russian Supreme Court overturns not guilty verdict in Politkovskaya murder, orders new trialJune 25th, 2009 Lawyer: Politkovskaya murder aquittal overturnedMOSCOW — Russia's Supreme Court has thrown out the acquittal of three men tried for the murder of journalist and Kremlin critic Anna Politkovskaya. Defense lawyer Murad Musayev told The Associated Press that the court reached the decision Thursday and ordered a new trial in the case.
Serbia's leading human rights activist quits trial over 1999 murder of 3 Albanian-AmericansJune 11th, 2009 Serb lawyer quits murder trial of 3 AmericansBELGRADE, Serbia — A legal representative of the families of three Albanian-American brothers who were murdered execution-style in Serbia in 1999 says she is quitting the trial of the alleged killers. Serbia's leading human rights activist Natasa Kandic said Thursday she has decided to stop participating in the trial of two Serb policemen because Serb authorities are allegedly protecting the real killers and those who ordered the slaying.