Australian detained on espionage charge in China
SYDNEY — An Australian who heads Rio Tinto’s iron ore operations in China has been arrested in Shanghai and accused of espionage, Australia’s foreign minister said Wednesday.
The detention of the executive and three Chinese nationals working for Rio comes at a tense period between the Anglo-Australian miner and China due to tough negotiations on iron ore prices and the failed plan for China’s state-owned Chinalco to buy a big stake in Rio Tinto.
Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith said he had seen no evidence the arrests were linked to commercial matters between Rio Tinto and China.
Smith said Chinese officials had confirmed Wednesday the arrest of Stern Hu, the Shanghai-based general manager of Rio’s Chinese iron ore business, and that he was “very surprised” to learn of it.
“Australian officials were advised that the reason for Mr. Hu’s detention was that he was being detained on suspicion of espionage and stealing state secrets,” Smith told reporters in the western city of Perth.
Hu was one of four Rio Tinto workers who were detained in recent days, though the exact timing was not clear. Smith said the three others were not Australian citizens, but few other details have been released.
The Sydney Morning Herald newspaper identified them as Chinese nationals who were also members of Rio Tinto’s iron ore sales team. The company declined to identify any of the workers.
Rio Tinto has been unable to contact the employees, said Ian Head, a company spokesman in Melbourne. Australian diplomats in Shanghai were urgently seeking access to Hu, Smith said.
“Rio Tinto intends to cooperate fully with any investigation the Chinese authorities may wish to undertake and has sought clarification on what has occurred,” the company said in a statement. “Rio Tinto is concerned about the employees’ well-being and is doing everything possible to help them and support their families.”
A spokesman for the Shanghai police, who would give only his surname, Liang, told The Associated Press that he had no information on the case.
Rio Tinto, the world’s third-largest mining company, is acting as lead negotiator for global iron ore suppliers in price talks with Chinese mills.
The two sides failed to reach agreement by the June 30 expiration of previous buying contracts. China’s steel industry association, representing the country’s mills, rejected prices negotiated by Rio Tinto with Japanese and Korean mills.
The other major suppliers are Australia’s BHP Billiton Ltd. and Brazil’s Vale SA.
China criticized Rio Tinto and the Australian government last month after the company abandoned the deal to have state-controlled Aluminum Corp. of China, or Chinalco, invest $19.5 billion in Rio Tinto.
Rio Tinto, which is traded on stock exchanges in London and Sydney, launched a rights issue to raise money instead. Chinalco took up a portion of the $15.2 billion share issue to maintain its 9 percent stake in the company.
The Chinese steel industry group also has criticized Rio Tinto’s plan to form a joint venture with Billiton, combining their mining assets in western Australia. The group said the tie-up might reduce competition, raise prices and hurt customers.
China’s Commerce Ministry said the breakup of the Rio Tinto-Chinalco deal would not harm Beijing’s ties with Australia. But a ministry spokesman warned that the deal with Billiton might face an anti-monopoly investigation by Chinese authorities.
Australia’s foreign minister said he had seen speculation that Hu’s detention could be linked to commercial matters between Rio Tinto and China but added that, “I have no basis for any such speculation.”
Sen. Barnaby Joyce, a right-leaning opposition lawmaker who campaigned against the Rio Tinto-Chinalco deal, said its failure “would appear to have inspired” the arrest of the Rio Tinto workers.
“This should be a clear example to Australia, and other countries around the world, of the extent of the relationship between a 100 percent (state) owned entity … and the actions of the Chinese Government,” he said in a statement.
China’s vague laws on industrial espionage and other spying give authorities wide latitude in deciding what to prosecute. The government treats a sweeping array of economic and other data as state secrets.
In 2002, a Chinese-born American, Fong Fuming, was convicted of paying bribes to help investors obtain secret information to bid on power projects. Fong was sentenced to five years in prison but expelled from China in 2003 after three years in captivity.
Many of those charged with spying in China have been businesspeople from rival Taiwan who are accused of working for the island’s government.
In 2001, a group of Chinese-born academics and others with links to the United States were prosecuted on charges of spying for Taiwan. Most were expelled from China after being convicted and sentenced.
McDonald reported from Beijing. Associated Press researcher Bonnie Cao in Beijing contributed to this report.
Rio Tinto Ltd.: www.riotinto.com
Related News
Rio Tinto 'still unaware' of any evidence to justify China's detention of 4 workersAugust 11th, 2009 Rio Tinto 'still unaware' of China case evidenceSYDNEY — Rio Tinto Ltd. said Tuesday it was still unaware of any evidence to justify China's detention of four employees on spying allegations, as the Australian government urged Beijing to speed up the case.
Oz, China spat over Rio Tinto 'spy' claim may be on the mendAugust 11th, 2009 SHANGHAI - With the Chinese Government backtracking on a website article that accused a British-Australian steel company of industrial espionage costing Beijing 100 billion dollars, and Australian diplomats in Shanghai meeting detained Rio Tinto executive for a second time, it appears as if ties between Beijing and Canberra are on the mend after weeks of tension. Consular staff were last week permitted their second monthly prison visit with Rio Tinto executive Stern Hu since his arrest on July 5.
Mining giant Rio Tinto guilty of commercial espionage worth 100 B dollars: ChinaAugust 10th, 2009 SHANGHAI - Relations between China and Australia are likely to take a turn for the worse with authorities in Beijing accusing the British-Australian mining giant Rio Tinto of engaging in commercial espionage that cost China about 100 billion dollars. The sensational allegation was published on Sunday on a website affiliated with China's State Secrets Bureau, which has detained four Rio Tinto employees - three Chinese citizens and one Australian - in Shanghai last month on suspicions of stealing confidential documents from the country's huge, government-controlled steel industry.
Rio Tinto shares plunge more than 3 percent after China claims a 6-year spying campaignAugust 10th, 2009 Rio Tinto prices plunge on China spy claimsSYDNEY —Rio Tinto Ltd.'s share price plunged more than 3 percent Monday after China accused the Anglo-Australian miner of conducting a six-year spying campaign that it claimed cost Chinese steelmakers billions of dollars in inflated prices for iron ore. Rio Tinto declined to respond to the latest allegations but said in July that bribery allegations against four Rio Tinto employees detained in China were baseless.
Chinese diplomat says Beijing has 'ample evidence' detained Rio employees stole secretsJuly 22nd, 2009 China says 'ample evidence' against Rio employeesBEIJING — China has told Australia it has "ample evidence" a detained Australian manager for miner Rio Tinto Ltd. and three co-workers stole state secrets, a Chinese diplomat said Wednesday.
Australian appeals to China for quick Rio resolution, warns of possible business impactJuly 21st, 2009 Australian asks China for quick Rio resolutionSHANGHAI — A visiting Australian state leader said he appealed to Chinese officials Tuesday to quickly resolve the case of a Rio Tinto Ltd. manager accused of espionage, warning that delays could harm business ties.
Australian foreign minister hopes to talk with Chinese officials about Australian's detentionJuly 21st, 2009 Australian FM hopes to discuss Rio case with ChinaCANBERRA, Australia — Australia's foreign minister said Tuesday he hopes to discuss the detention of an Australian mining executive accused by China of stealing state secrets with his Chinese counterpart this week. Stephen Smith flew to Thailand on Tuesday for an Association of Southeast Asian Nations meeting that China will be participating in.
Rio Tinto says Chinese bribery claims falseJuly 17th, 2009 MELBOURNE - Australian mining giant Rio Tinto has said that the allegations that some of its employees in China have been engaged in bribery are "wholly without foundation". Chinese authorities claim four employees of the world's third-biggest miner bribed Chinese steel mills officials during annual iron ore contract price negotiations.
Now, Oz mining giant Rio Tinto accused of bribing executives of 16 Chinese steel millsJuly 15th, 2009 BEIJING - The staff of Australian miner Rio Tinto bribed executives from all 16 Chinese steel mills participating in this year's iron ore price talks, an industry insider has disclosed. "Rio Tinto got to know the key executives of the 16 steel mills, who have sensitive industry information, when the China Iron and Steel Association (CISA) brought them to the bargaining table," China Daily quoted a senior manager at a large steel company, as saying.
Australian PM warns China that world is watching its handling of detained Rio Tinto employeesJuly 15th, 2009 Australian PM warns China in Rio Tinto caseADELAIDE, Australia — Prime Minister Kevin Rudd on Wednesday warned China that the world is watching how it deals with an investigation into four detained employees of Anglo-Australian mining giant Rio Tinto Ltd. Rudd urged China to consider its economic ties with other countries as it dealt with the men, who have been held since July 5 on espionage charges.
State media alleges widespread bribery in Rio Tinto caseJuly 15th, 2009 Major bribery alleged in Rio Tinto caseBEIJING — A government-owned newspaper alleged Wednesday that executives from all 16 Chinese steel mills participating in iron ore price talks this year were bribed by Rio Tinto employees. The English-language China Daily quoted an unnamed "industry insider" saying that the Anglo-Australian mining giant bribed China's largest steel companies, all members of the China Iron & Steel Association, to get access to industry data.
Rudd Govt. in "worst foreign policy crisis" following China's Rio Tinto GM arrestJuly 11th, 2009 MELBOURNE - The Australian Government's open support to the Shanghai-based Australian general manager of iron ore mining company, Hu Stern, who has been arrested on espionage charges in China, is set to put the Kevin Rudd government in the worst foreign policy crisis since taking office in November 2007. "Frankly, it is difficult for a nation like Australia to see a relationship between espionage and national security and what appeared to be suggestions about commercial or economic negotiations," Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith said in the wake of Australian consular officials gaining access to Hu for the first time since his arrest last Sunday.
Australian diplomats meet executive held in China for spyingJuly 10th, 2009 SYDNEY - Australian diplomats Friday met the Rio Tinto executive held by Chinese authorities since Sunday over spying allegations. Foreign Affairs Minister Stephen Smith would not comment on reports in the Chinese media that Australian citizen Stern Hu stood accused of trying to bribe employees of Chinese steel companies to gather confidential information during iron ore price negotiations.
Four mining firm employees detained in China for spyingJuly 9th, 2009 SHANGHAI - Four employees of the international mining group Rio Tinto Ltd. have been detained on charges of stealing China's state secrets, authorities said Thursday.
Rio Tinto says 4 employees detained in China; Australia seeks access to Australian citizenJuly 8th, 2009 4 Rio Tinto workers detained in ChinaBEIJING — Four employees of Anglo-Australian miner Rio Tinto Ltd., including an Australian man, have been detained in Shanghai for undisclosed reasons, the company and government officials said Wednesday. Rio Tinto has been unable to contact the employees, said Ian Head, a company spokesman in Sydney.
Loading ...