Australia: Rio detention could hurt China business
BEIJING — Australian officials said Sunday that China has not given them any evidence to support its detention of an Australian mining executive on spying charges and warned that the affair could discourage foreign companies from doing business there.
Foreign Minister Stephen Smith told reporters in western Australia that officials will seek information Monday on the detention of Rio Tinto employee Stern Hu. Hu was detained with three of Rio Tinto’s Chinese employees in Shanghai on July 5.
Beijing hasn’t provided evidence to support its allegations that Hu spied for Rio Tinto — the world’s third-largest mining company — to gain an edge in iron ore price talks with Chinese steel mills, Smith said.
“We may well be in for a long haul here,” he said. “Which is why we are urging the Chinese authorities — and officials will take this up in Canberra and Beijing tomorrow — that this matter be dealt with expeditiously.”
Smith warned Hu’s detention may discourage foreign companies from doing business in China.
“China needs to think very carefully what implications, if any, this has for the international business community and the international network’s view of China,” Smith said.
Financial Services Minister Chris Bowen told Network Ten television in Australia: “The Chinese government will be very aware that it is not good for business certainty if there’s a regular pattern of foreign businesspeople being incarcerated.”
The Rio employees were detained as the company negotiated on behalf of global iron ore producers in price talks with Chinese steel mills. Hu manages Rio’s Chinese iron ore business. The other detainees are Chinese.
The Rio employees are accused of bribing Chinese steel company personnel to obtain summaries of the Chinese negotiators’ meetings and gain an edge in price talks, according to Chinese news reports. The maximum penalty for an espionage conviction is life in prison.
Australian diplomats visited Hu on Friday, and Smith said Saturday that he appeared to be well and raised no health or welfare concerns.
But Australian officials have to wait another month to visit Hu again, Smith said Sunday.
On Saturday, Australian trade minister Simon Crean met with Chinese officials during a trade mission in Shanghai and said his government was “deeply concerned” about Hu.
China, the world’s biggest steel producer, has criticized iron ore suppliers for repeated price hikes and is pressing for reductions. The other major suppliers are Australia’s BHP Billiton Ltd. and Brazil’s Vale SA.
Information on Chinese steel company ore costs, profit margins and technology spending all are considered official secrets, according to news reports.
The accusations reflect the communist government’s sensitivity about fields such as steel and energy that it deems strategic and its intense secrecy about a wide array of economic and industrial information.
Rio expressed surprise at the spying allegations and said Friday it is “committed to high standards and business integrity.” It said Chinese authorities have not given the company any details about the case.
Employees of the China Iron & Steel Association, the iron ore price negotiator for Chinese steel mills, are also under investigation, the newspaper 21st Century Business Herald reported. It said an executive who oversaw iron ore purchases for one of China’s biggest steel producers, Shougang Group, was detained last week.
Associated Press writer Kristen Gelineau in Sydney contributed to this report.
On the Net:
Rio Tinto Ltd.: www.riotinto.com
Related News
China charges Rio Tinto Australia executive of commercial briberyAugust 12th, 2009 BEIJING - Chinese prosecutors have charged Australian executive Stern Hu with commercial bribery, which means he could be facing up to seven years jail if found guilty by Beijing. China's official news agency Xinhua said Hu and three Rio Tinto Chinese colleagues were charged late on Tuesday, six days after being detained in Shanghai.
Rio Tinto 'still unaware' of any evidence to justify China's detention of 4 workersAugust 11th, 2009 Rio Tinto 'still unaware' of China case evidenceSYDNEY — Rio Tinto Ltd. said Tuesday it was still unaware of any evidence to justify China's detention of four employees on spying allegations, as the Australian government urged Beijing to speed up the case.
Rio Tinto shares plunge more than 3 percent after China claims a 6-year spying campaignAugust 10th, 2009 Rio Tinto prices plunge on China spy claimsSYDNEY —Rio Tinto Ltd.'s share price plunged more than 3 percent Monday after China accused the Anglo-Australian miner of conducting a six-year spying campaign that it claimed cost Chinese steelmakers billions of dollars in inflated prices for iron ore. Rio Tinto declined to respond to the latest allegations but said in July that bribery allegations against four Rio Tinto employees detained in China were baseless.
Australia FM meets with Chinese counterpart over Rio Tinto spying case, fails to resolve issueJuly 23rd, 2009 Australia, China FMs discuss Rio Tinto spying casePHUKET, Thailand — Australia's Foreign Minister Stephen Smith met with his Chinese counterpart Thursday over the case of a Rio Tinto Ltd. manager accused of espionage in China but made no progress resolving the issue.
Chinese diplomat says Beijing has 'ample evidence' detained Rio employees stole secretsJuly 22nd, 2009 China says 'ample evidence' against Rio employeesBEIJING — China has told Australia it has "ample evidence" a detained Australian manager for miner Rio Tinto Ltd. and three co-workers stole state secrets, a Chinese diplomat said Wednesday.
Australian FM says detention of Rio Tinto employees in China will not be resolved quicklyJuly 22nd, 2009 Australia FM: Rio case won't be resolved quicklyPHUKET, Thailand — Australia pressed China again Wednesday for a quick resolution to the case of a Rio Tinto manager accused of espionage while acknowledging it will not be settled with one meeting of the two sides. Speaking on the sidelines of a regional conference, the Australian foreign minister Stephen Smith said he still hoped to meet his Chinese counterpart Yang Jiechi about the matter in the next day.
China tells Oz that it has sufficient evidence against Rio Tinto staffJuly 22nd, 2009 BEIJING - China has told Australia that it has sufficient evidence to prove Rio Tinto staff's involvement in espionage and bribery case. "I've introduced the information about the case to him (Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith) and stressed we have sufficient evidence to show that people involved in the case have obtained our state secrets through illegal means," The Australian quoted He Yafei, as saying.
Australian appeals to China for quick Rio resolution, warns of possible business impactJuly 21st, 2009 Australian asks China for quick Rio resolutionSHANGHAI — A visiting Australian state leader said he appealed to Chinese officials Tuesday to quickly resolve the case of a Rio Tinto Ltd. manager accused of espionage, warning that delays could harm business ties.
Australian foreign minister hopes to talk with Chinese officials about Australian's detentionJuly 21st, 2009 Australian FM hopes to discuss Rio case with ChinaCANBERRA, Australia — Australia's foreign minister said Tuesday he hopes to discuss the detention of an Australian mining executive accused by China of stealing state secrets with his Chinese counterpart this week. Stephen Smith flew to Thailand on Tuesday for an Association of Southeast Asian Nations meeting that China will be participating in.
Australia: Detention of Rio employee on spy charges could hurt foreign business in ChinaJuly 12th, 2009 Australia: Employee detention could hurt China bizBEIJING — The detention of an Australian Rio Tinto Ltd. employee on spying charges could damage the business environment for foreign companies wanting to work in China, an Australian cabinet minister said Sunday.
Australia says spy arrest could affect China's businessJuly 12th, 2009 MELBOURNE - Australia's Financial Services Minister Chris Bowen has warned that the country's business people may not want to work in China in the wake of Australian origin Rio Tinto executive Stern Hu being arrested in the country on espionage charges. "The Chinese Government will be very aware that it is not good for business certainty if there's a regular pattern of foreign business people being incarcerated," news.co.au quoted Brown, as saying.
Australian diplomats meet executive held in China for spyingJuly 10th, 2009 SYDNEY - Australian diplomats Friday met the Rio Tinto executive held by Chinese authorities since Sunday over spying allegations. Foreign Affairs Minister Stephen Smith would not comment on reports in the Chinese media that Australian citizen Stern Hu stood accused of trying to bribe employees of Chinese steel companies to gather confidential information during iron ore price negotiations.
Rio Tinto says 4 employees detained in China; Australia seeks access to Australian citizenJuly 8th, 2009 4 Rio Tinto workers detained in ChinaBEIJING — Four employees of Anglo-Australian miner Rio Tinto Ltd., including an Australian man, have been detained in Shanghai for undisclosed reasons, the company and government officials said Wednesday. Rio Tinto has been unable to contact the employees, said Ian Head, a company spokesman in Sydney.
Australian Rio Tinto worker detained in China on espionage chargeJuly 8th, 2009 Australian detained on espionage charge in ChinaSYDNEY — An Australian who heads Rio Tinto's iron ore operations in China has been arrested in Shanghai and accused of espionage, Australia's foreign minister said Wednesday. The detention of the executive and three Chinese nationals working for Rio comes at a tense period between the Anglo-Australian miner and China due to tough negotiations on iron ore prices and the failed plan for China's state-owned Chinalco to buy a big stake in Rio Tinto.
Chinalco maintains 9.3 percent stake in Rio Tinto through $15.2 billion rights issueJuly 2nd, 2009 Chinalco maintains 9.3 percent stake in Rio TintoMELBOURNE, Australia — State-controlled Aluminum Corp. of China said Thursday it took up its full entitlement in Rio Tinto's $15.2 billion share issue to maintain a 9.3 percent stake in the Anglo-Australian miner.
Loading ...