SYDNEY - Australia’s booming $12 billion education industry seems to have come under a shadow following a string of attacks on Indian students that has now galvanised the government to act.
At least a score of Indian students have either been attacked in public transport or waylaid near their houses in recent months in both Melbourne and Sydney.
The attacks on students reinforce certain stereotypes. Indians, the police and federal officials say, are hardworking, poor, peaceful and living in the outback that makes them vulnerable.
But do all these attributes of the thousands of Indian students or their failure, conscious or otherwise, to mainstream with Australian society, justify attacks against them?
“There’s a name for this, ‘curry bashing, let’s go curry bashing’,” Yadu Singh, a cardiologist in Sydney, told IANS. “They are not random at all; people are targeting them. They know these students are easy targets.”
There are over 500,000 international students in Australia pursuing university education and vocational studies of which 94,000 are Indians - the second highest after the Chinese. Thousands of Indians are enrolled in vocational courses in government and private Technical and Further Education (TAFE) institutes that act more as visa factories than institutions of learning.
In recent years Australia’s education industry has boomed to become the country’s third-largest foreign currency earner after coal and iron ore, generating about $12 billion in revenue in 2008. Indian students in Australia alone contribute $3.5 billion a year to the economy.
It is well known now that the sector has flourished. Everyone knows there is big money to be made and many of the dodgy institutes hire agents who end up exploiting the ignorance of youth, telling them about dream jobs and a Permanent Residency which can be obtained in two years.
“Indian students in Australia largely fall in two categories. One, those belonging to relatively better economic and educational backgrounds who are pursuing higher education in mainstream universities such as Monash, Victoria, Melbourne, La Trobe, and Deakin,” says Tam Sridhar, a dean in Monash University.
“The others, those enrolled in private TAFE and other such institutes, have been most prone to attacks and are in the news for all the wrong reasons.”
The wave of attacks has now galvanised the Australian government to act. The slew of measures announced include the setting up of a task force appointed by Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, an audit on dubious institutes, improving policing on the transport corridor and seeking ways to find suitable accommodation and more campus-based accommodation for students as well as the need to examine visa rules.
And unless firm steps are initiated, many here within the intelligentsia believe that it could well threaten to undermine efforts to build relations between India and Australia.
As Robin Jeffrey, an emeritus professor of La Trobe University and a member of the Australia-India Council, put it: “When you mess with India, you mess with people who have the professional and financial capacity to pursue you relentlessly through law courts and international forums.
“India exports outstanding lawyers, financiers and IT professionals. Two of the world’s top ten billionaires are Indians, according to the Forbes list. There are no Chinese in the top ten. Or Australians. You want to be friends of India, not antagonists.”
In his reckoning the India-Australia relationship was on the cusp of something good, which was mutually beneficial.
(Murali Krishnan can be contacted at m.krish@ians.in)
Related News
We condemn what is happening against Indians, says Australian envoySeptember 20th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The attack on four Indians in Melbourne last week and a wave of similar violence against students in recent months have had an impact on relations between the two countries, says Australia's envoy who finds it "deeply disappointing" and condemnable that these incidents continue. "You can't go through this kind of phase without it (violence) having a wider impact.
Australia to back foreign students if college shutsJuly 31st, 2009 SYDNEY - Following the closure of a Sydney college where many Indians were studying, the Australian government has assured foreign students that they will be granted "a comparable place to complete their course" or a refund in fees. Financial troubles forced the Sterling College here to suddenly close down, jeopardising the futures of more than 500 people, including many Indians.
Australian police target exploitation of Indian studentsJuly 27th, 2009 SYDNEY - Police Monday raided the Sydney office of a migration agent they believe is exploiting Indians who come to study in Australia. The raid followed claims on national television that a young Indian reporter posing as a student to expose scams had been assaulted in Sydney.
Ahead of Krishna's visit, Australia assures safety of Indian studentsJuly 22nd, 2009 PHUKET - Ahead of Indian External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna's visit to Australia Aug 5, Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith Wednesday assured him that his government was doing everything possible to ensure the safety of nearly 100,000 Indian students in that country.
Australia to counsel Indian students on 'Dos and Don'ts' in higer studiesJuly 8th, 2009 HYDERABAD - Australian authorities will counsel Indian students on the "dos and don'ts" to be kept in mind while pursuing higher studies Down Under following the spate of attacks on students there, Australian High Commissioner John McCarthy announced Wednesday. McCarthy assured the Andhra Pradesh government that his country would take all steps to protect Indian students.
'Cocktail of issues' behind attacks on Indians, says Australian MPJune 30th, 2009 SYDNEY - The disconnect between the "established Indian order" and students was a matter of concern, says a prominent Australian parliamentarian who blames a "cocktail of issues" for the recent attacks on Indian students in his country. Basically it is a cocktail of issues that are affecting Indian students.
Two more Indians assaulted in SydneyJune 28th, 2009 SYDNEY - Two Australian teenagers in Central Sydney reportedly attacked two Indians late on Saturday night. The attack took place on Bathurst Street.
Attacks on Indians in Australia racial outbursts: RaviJune 27th, 2009 CHENNAI - The attacks on Indian students in Australia were racial outbursts by anti-social elements, Overseas Indian Affairs Minister Vayalar Ravi said here Saturday. The minister said the Indian government was in touch with the Australian authorities and expressed confidence that the situation will become normal there.
Australian cop admits of some attacks on Indians being racialJune 9th, 2009 MELBOURNE - The police chief of Australia's Victoria state on Tuesday admitted that some of the attacks on Indian students across the country were racially motivated, as claimed by most of the Indian victims. Victoria's chief commissioner of police Simon Overland said that some of the robbery attacks were racially motivated and others are were opportunistic.
Indian students in Australia urged to be calmJune 9th, 2009 BANGALORE - Spiritual leader Sri Sri Ravi Shankar Tuesday urged Indian students in Australia to stay calm and not to get provoked by attacks on them. Time and again, Indians have demonstrated that peaceful methods of protest have a far greater power in achieving goals than any violent acts, the Art of Living founder said in a statement.
Policy soon to deal with racial discrimination abroad: Preneet KaurJune 6th, 2009 PATIALA - The central government would soon formulate a policy to deal with racial discrimination against Indians abroad, Minister of State for External Affairs Preneet Kaur said here Saturday. Arriving in her hometown Patiala for the first time after being inducted in the government of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, Preneet Kaur expressed concern at the plight of students from India who have been facing racist attacks in Australia for about a month now.
Elements of racism possible in attacks: Australian envoyJune 4th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Australia Thursday admitted that some of the attacks on Indian students in that country may have elements of racism. I think all attacks probably have different motivations.
Outrage in Oxford at attacks in AustraliaJune 1st, 2009 LONDON - Indian students at Oxford University Monday joined in the growing protests over racist attacks on their counterparts in Australia, saying they are baffled by the failure of Australian authorities to take stern measures. Indian students at the University of Oxford strongly deplore the violent attacks on students in Australia.
Indian student attacks: Australia's lucrative education industry could take a hitMay 30th, 2009 MELBOURNE - The recent attacks on Indian students in Melbourne could severely hit Australia's lucrative education industry, agents in India who help arrange student placements have warned. The assaults attracted a blaze of publicity in India for the third consecutive day yesterday, prompting some students and parents to re-evaluate plans to study in Australia.
New Delhi condemns attacks on Indian students in AustraliaMay 27th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Condemning allegedly racist attacks on Indian students in Melbourne, the government Wednesday said it will impress upon the Australian authorities that such attacks should not be permitted and the culprits should be brought to justice. "I have been appalled by the attack on our students in Melbourne.