Traditional growth models are the legacy of the industrialization era that started a couple of centuries ago. The approach meant leveraging lowest cost resources with an aim of maximizing benefits to the owners of the enterprise. It is apparent now that pursuing a growth model that brings prosperity to a few while leaving the majority out of the ambit of its benefits is only furthering the gap between the haves and have not. There is a need to change that for inclusive growth, and the ‘Anand experience’ provides an excellent model.
Verghese Kurien, the father of the ‘white revolution’ in India, innovated the concept of social business in this country through the ‘Anand Model’, a vertically integrated three-tier self-generative system for cooperative dairy development. He successfully established a commodity like milk as an instrument for socio-economic development. The impact that Anand Model was able to make is very similar to the economic theory canvassed by economist Jeffrey Sachs three decades later.
Sachs, professor of Sustainable Development at Columbia’s School of International and Public Affairs, authored a seminal work “The End of Poverty” in 2005 in which he claimed the right policies and key interventions can eradicate extreme poverty (living on less than $1 per day) in 20 years. He suggests that an improved input significantly increases the income of subsistence farmers, thereby reducing poverty. He does not believe that increased aid is the only solution; he supports establishing credit and micro loan programmes that are lacking in impoverished areas.
Across the globe there is a realization that consistent economic growth has done precious little to reduce the actual extent of deprivation in the world. World Development Report 2008 mentions 850 million people as undernourished and chronically food insecure; leading to death of 2.8 million children and three million women annually in the developing world. The recent financial meltdown too has added about 200 million to the list of poor globally.
These facts highlight the need for a greater inclusiveness in the determination of growth processes to combat the increasing global poverty levels. No wonder that global leaders are refocusing their efforts to create a participatory base, encompassing every section of the society in the growth process. Inclusive growth implies an equitable distribution of resources and its accruing benefits for every section of the society.
Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel laureate from Bangladesh, purported the need for business models that recognize the multidimensional nature of human beings; ‘Social Business’ as he terms it provides everyone with a fair chance to unleash their energy and creativity. Designed to operate as a normal business enterprise with the exception of the principal of profit maximization, which is replaced with the principal of social benefit, he set about to make a change. He believes once a social objective driven project overcomes the gravitation of financial dependency, it is ready for space flight.
The success of an inclusive growth model in a developing economy will depend much on growth in the rural areas, especially in the agriculture sector. If you look at the agricultural sector in India, the conventional output in relation to the human resources deployed is actually reducing dramatically. In large parts the ailment to this section of our society can be addressed by enabling micro enterprises and businesses that create value added products and services. It is important to provision necessary inputs to the marginalized populace in the rural areas such as access to banking, micro credit and suitable technologies.
The Indian government had consistently provided policy support to agriculture and its sub-sectors, including recently while formulating the eleventh plan. Poor execution of public delivery models have seriously impaired the impact that these policies could have made. The Indian farmer seeks empowerment, access to right inputs and not merely largesse. If inclusive growth in India is to succeed there is a dire need to revisit the operating models at the lowest levels.
The classical intervention for inclusive growth has come through NGOs or through the corporate world itself. While the NGOs have been stymied by unavailability of adequate infrastructure the corporate intervention through Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is usually limited to its area of operation or in conflict with the overall goal of the business to maximize profit.
There is a case to consider the Anand Model as an operating national model due to its proven record. The approach provides for action at the grassroot levels as well as coalesces the inputs into capacities to provide global scale finished products, effectively providing an opportunity to create economic value at all the three levels of value chain.
However the Anand Model too has its limitations, those that have impaired its ability to emerge as an instrument of change across the nation. These are largely structural as well as political. The cooperative framework imposes limitations as it necessitates these entities to be administered by bureaucracy and state controlled archaic act and rules that impairs functional autonomy. Given its potential impact the guiding structure for the cooperatives shall need to be reviewed and structured to allow them to play the role of catalysts of inclusive growth.
Technology is driving mass awareness and exposing systemic inefficacy and socio-economic inequalities, in turn influencing public opinion. India today has a wonderful opportunity to lead the world in inclusive growth. Better infrastructure in conjunction with an inclusive growth enabled by all-pervasive technology has the potential to transform the lives of a billion people. But we need to act decisively and now. Napoleon Bonaparte had said, at a critical juncture: “Take time to deliberate but when the time for action arrives stop thinking and go for it; otherwise defeat is inevitable.”
(30.06.2009- The author is former executive director, National Dairy Development Board and past president Indian Dairy Association, who works for rural empowerment. He can be reached at banerjeeanimesh@rediffmail.com)
Related News
Too early to comment on impact of drought, floods: PMOctober 9th, 2009 HYDERABAD - Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Friday said it was to too early to comment on what would be the impact of drought and floods on the country's economy. "It is too early to comment," he said when a journalist wanted to know the impact the drought in some parts of the country and floods in others would have on the economic growth.
Infrastructure sector could attract $1.5 tn: MinisterOctober 5th, 2009 NEW DELHI - India's infrastructure sector has the potential to attract investments worth $1.5 trillion (Rs.75 lakh crore) over the coming decade, Commerce and Industry Minister Anand Sharma said here Monday. The 11th Five-Year Plan envisages an outlay of over $500 billion of investment for infrastructure.
Stimulus helped infrastructure sector revive: MinisterJuly 23rd, 2009 NEW DELHI - The timely release of stimulus packages has helped the infrastructure sector post a good growth rate last month despite the economic slowdown, Commerce and Industry Minister Anand Sharma claimed here Thursday. Referring to the 6.5 percent growth rate achieved by the six core infrastructure sectors in June, Sharma said: "It's clear that the government's stimulus packages and the budgetary proposals have had a positive impact.
Delhi Metro official sent back to Indian RailwaysJuly 15th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Delhi Metro chief E. Sreedharan Wednesday gave marching orders to Vijay Anand, director in charge of the Central Secretariat-Badarpur metro line where an accident Sunday left six people dead.
Three challenges before Indian economyJuly 6th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Indian economy faces primarily three challenges, according to Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee's budget speech. They are:
-- "The first challenge is to lead the economy back to the high GDP growth rate of 9 percent per annum at the earliest.
High GDP growth, inclusive development to be key challenges: Finance MinisterJuly 6th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Presenting the General Budget 2009-10 in Lok Sabha today, Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee said that the Government has clearly recognized and identified the challenges to boost Indian economy specially at a time when the world is still struggling with an unprecedented financial crisis and an economic slowdown. Elaborating on challenges, the Minister pointed out that the first challenge is to lead the economy back to the high GDP growth rate of nine percent per annum at the earliest.
Infosys' Murthy wants budget to focus on inclusive growthJune 20th, 2009 BANGALORE - Infosys Technologies Ltd chairman and chief mentor N.R. Narayana Murthy Saturday hoped the union budget for 2009-10 would focus on inclusive growth, which he termed as "the need of the country".
Anand Sharma keen to stabilise industrial productionMay 29th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Commerce and Industry Minister Anand Sharma today said that the Government would take every possible step to stabilise industrial production. Talking to reporters here, Sharma said, "In the present climate, when economies across the world have been adversely affected and there is continuous fall in demand, we would like to ensure that every possible step is taken to ensure that industrial output remains stable."
Sharma is taking charge of the trade ministry at a time when India's exports have suffered a severe setback due to the global downturn.
Govt. to ensure Indian economy returns to high trajectory growthMay 29th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Minister for Commerce (trade) and Industry, Anand Sharma on Friday said that the Government would take all possible steps to stabilise Indian economy in times of global recession. Addressing media after taking charge of his office, Minister for Commerce and Industry said the government will take every possible step to ensure a steady Indian economy, particularly at a time when recessionary trends have upset overall industry and trade around the globe.
First priority restoring economy : Manmohan SinghMay 22nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Friday said the new government's focus will be on restoring the economy and ensure inclusive growth. 'Our first priority is to restore the economy, especially keeping the global recession (in mind),' the prime minister told reporters after assuming office for a second term after his Congress party's sweeping win in the general election.
More jobs, revival of growth are priorities: ManmohanMay 19th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Tuesday said the priority of the new Congress-led government was the revival of economic growth and creating new employment opportunities that had been slowed down by the global recession. Addressing the newly-elected party MPs after being named the prime minister by the Congress Parliamentary Party, Manmohan Singh said: 'There is some slowing down of investment and employment generation.
Food prices will come down: PMMay 9th, 2009 CHENNAI - Admitting that foodgrain prices had remained high even as the inflation rate came down, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said here Saturday that the common man will have relief soon. 'It is true that the consumer prices of food grains haven't come down when inflation rates came down.
Manmohan Singh sees growth falling below 7 percentApril 13th, 2009 MUMBAI - Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Monday admitted the economic growth India experienced during 2008-2009 has slowed down, and that it was likely to be a little less than 7 percent now. 'It (the slowdown) is a matter of concern, but our situation is very different from the deep recession being experienced elsewhere, like in the US, where several companies closed down,' Manmohan Singh told a news conference here.
CII to work for integrated growth in northern regionMarch 19th, 2009 CHANDIGARH - The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) Wednesday called for comprehensive growth of the entire northern region and urged consistency in subsidies and incentives for all states. 'Our motto for the year 2009-10 is 'Building North for Tomorrow'.
Suzuki India targets 10 percent share in 150cc segmentFebruary 16th, 2009 CHENNAI - Japanese two-wheeler manufacturer Suzuki's Indian subsidiary hopes to capture a 10 percent market share in the growing 150cc motorbike segment with its new model GS150R, said a company official. Launching the model here Tuesday, Anand Singh Thakur, Suzuki Motorcycle India senior sales manager told reporters: 'The 150cc bike category logs around 45,000 unit sales per month.