Air France crash inquiry needs more money
PARIS — Investigators looking for the Air France plane that disappeared into the Atlantic Ocean in June still cannot explain the crash and need more money and resources to search for the aircraft’s data recorders, the man leading the probe said Monday.
“At the moment, we can’t explain the accident,” said Paul-Louis Arslanian, head of France’s Bureau of Investigation and Analysis, or BEA.
He said a third, more meticulous search for plane debris and the flight recorders, should begin before the end of the year, but could cost tens of millions of euros (dollars).
“We are making progress and will make progress and I’m optimistic, but this will take time,” he told journalists in Paris. “It takes a year and a half, being responsible and reasonable, in order to make progress and ensure that we’ve run through all of the questions.”
Investigators still don’t know exactly where the Airbus A330 flying from Rio to Paris crashed, killing all 228 people aboard, or what caused the June 1 accident, Arslanian told a gathering of aerospace journalists in Paris.
The search has so far failed to locate the plane’s data recorders, without which the full causes of the crash may never be fully known — but investigators don’t want to give up.
Arslanian said planemaker Airbus has offered to help fund the efforts, but more commitments are needed.
“We have to mobilize resources. It’s not only having promises for money, we need to know who will contribute financially and how,” he said.
Arslanian said around 1,000 parts of the plane have so far been recovered from the Atlantic Ocean — including a nearly intact tail, an engine cover, uninflated life jackets, seats and kitchen items.
The BEA, together with an international team of experts, has been studying the data gathered from two phases of research to decide what a third search phase would cost and require. The second phase of the search began after the black boxes stopped emitting signals, about a month after the crash.
The crash site is more than 900 miles (1,450 kilometers) off Brazil’s northeastern coast.
A preliminary report into the crash said the plane hit the ocean intact and belly first at a high rate of speed. Investigators have announced no signs of explosion or terrorism.
The Brazilian authorities have yet to send detailed information about the autopsies on the 50 bodies that have been recovered, although the BEA is working with general information obtained from French authorities, Arslanian said.
He said the agency has not issued a recommendation to airlines over speed measuring equipment because he doesn’t have the evidence to justify it.
Since the accident, European air safety regulators have told world airlines to replace hundreds of air speed sensors of the type fitted to the crashed plane.
A series of automatic messages sent by the plane point to a malfunction of the external speed monitors, known as Pitot tubes, which some experts think may have iced over and given false speed readings to the Air France plane’s computers as it ran into a turbulent thunderstorm.
“If I had thought it was important to make a recommendation, I would have done it,” Arslanian said.
Problems with Pitots are not unusual, but the malfunction doesn’t normally last longer than a few seconds, he said.
The BEA is also working with authorities from Yemen and Comoros to find the causes of the Yemenia Airways crash last June, which killed 152 people.
The recently recovered black boxes from that crash should arrive in France on Monday with the Comoran investigators and will be examined by the BEA, Arslanian said.
Related News
French family sues Air France over plane crash investigationAugust 21st, 2009 Air France sued over plane crash investigationPARIS — A lawyer says the family of a French flight attendant who perished in an Air France plane crash on June 1 over the Atlantic Ocean is suing the airline to force it to release information on what caused the tragedy. The Airbus jet went down while flying from Rio de Janeiro to Paris.
Underwater robots reach site of Yemen plane's crash in Indian Ocean nation of ComorosAugust 20th, 2009 Underwater robots reach site of Indian Ocean crashPARIS — France says a ship carrying an underwater robot has arrived at the Indian Ocean nation of Comoros to retrieve the flight recorders from the Yemenia Airways plane crash. One girl survived the June 30 ocean crash and the other 152 people aboard the Comoros-bound flight were killed.
French investigators halt underwater search in Atlantic for black boxes of Flight 447August 20th, 2009 French end search for Flight 447 black boxesPARIS — French investigators said Thursday they have abandoned a second round of search efforts for the black box flight recorders from Air France Flight 447, believed to be resting in the depths of the Atlantic. The Airbus jet crashed into the ocean June 1 en route from Rio de Janeiro to Paris, killing all 228 people aboard.
French ship scans Atlantic seafloor in hunt for Air France Flight 447's black boxesJuly 30th, 2009 French begin new search for Air France black boxesPARIS — A French oceanographic survey ship has begun scanning the Atlantic Ocean floor, a new phase in the hunt for Air France Flight 447's black boxes now that they are no longer emitting signals, investigators said Thursday. The Airbus 330 crashed into the Atlantic en route from Rio de Janeiro to Paris on June 1, killing all 228 people onboard.
Air France Flight 447 debris arrives in France for further examination by crash investigatorsJuly 15th, 2009 Flight 447 debris returned to FrancePARIS — Debris from Air France Flight 447 has been brought to France for further examination, the agency investigating the crash said Wednesday. Flight 447 crashed into the Atlantic Ocean, more than 900 miles (1,450 kilometers) off Brazil's northeastern coast, on June 1 as it flew from Rio de Janeiro to Paris.
2 ships ending search for Air France black boxes; French submarine continuesJuly 10th, 2009 Ships ending search for Air France black boxesRIO DE JANEIRO — Two ships using U.S. listening devices to search for the black boxes of Air France Flight 447 were ending their hunt Friday, an American commander said.
Wreckage of Air France Flight 447 en route from Brazil to France for further investigationJuly 9th, 2009 Remains of Flight 447 en route to France for probePARIS — More than 600 pieces of Air France Flight 447 are being sent from Brazil to France by ship to be studied further for clues into the June 1 crash, Airbus said Thursday. The disaster overshadowed a meeting of Air France-KLM shareholders on Thursday, with pilots saying the company didn't do enough to prevent the plane from crashing into the Atlantic Ocean.
French divers, aviation investigators in the Comoros search for crashed planeJuly 7th, 2009 Divers, investigators in Comoros search for planeNAIROBI, Kenya — A Comoran official says little debris and no bodies from the crashed Yemenia Airways plane have been found, but predicts that will change once the exact location of the plane's black boxes are pinpointed. One 12-year-old girl survived by clinging to floating debris for up to 13 hours after the June 30 plane crash, but 152 other passengers and crew are still missing from Flight 626.
Air France says the bodies of the pilot and a crew member of Flight 447 retrieved in AtlanticJune 25th, 2009 Air France: Flight 447 pilot's body retrievedPARIS — Search crews in the mid-Atlantic have retrieved the bodies of the chief pilot of Flight 447 and a flight attendant, Air France said Thursday. The two are among 50 bodies pulled out of the ocean in the international search for remains of the 228 victims and wreckage of the May 31 crash.
Air France flight recorders located in AtlanticJune 23rd, 2009 MOSCOW - Signals from the flight data recorders of the Air France jet that crashed into the Atlantic killing all 228 people on board have been located, a media report said Tuesday. The Le Monde newspaper said French naval vessels had picked up a weak signal from the flight recorders at the site of the June 1 crash.
Air France crash: 'black box signals located'June 23rd, 2009 PARIS - Signals from the flight data recorder, or the black boxes of the Air France flight that crashed into the Atlantic ocean killing all 228 passengers onboard, has been located. "A French naval vessel has detected a weak signal from the flight data recorders, and a mini submarine was dispatched on Monday to try and find the black boxes at the bottom of the ocean floor," The Telegraph quoted a French newspaper Le Monde.
Report: Signals detected from Air France flight 447 black boxes in Atlantic OceanJune 23rd, 2009 Report: Signals heard from Flight 447 black boxesPARIS — The French newspaper Le Monde reported Tuesday that French military ships have detected a signal from the black boxes of Flight 447 in the Atlantic depths. The report says a mini research submarine, the Nautile, dived Monday to search for the boxes based on a "very weak signal" from the flight recorders picked up by the French ships.
13 more bodies found at Air France crash siteJune 11th, 2009 RIO DE JANEIRO - Thirteen more bodies have been recovered from an area in the Atlantic Ocean where a France jet crashed last week, bringing the total number of bodies found to 41, officials said. The Brazilian Air Force said 41 bodies have been recovered from the crash site so far, including 13 bodies found Tuesday.
Air France jetliner goes missing over Atlantic OceanJune 1st, 2009 PARIS - Air France has lost contact with a jetliner carrying 228 people. The flight bound from Rio de Janeiro to Paris went missing over the Atlantic Ocean.
Brazil's Air Force says an Air France jetliner disappeared over the Atlantic OceanJune 1st, 2009 Brazil: Air France jet missing over AtlanticSAO PAULO, Brazil — Brazil's Air Force says an Air France jet bound from Rio de Janeiro to Paris disappeared over the Atlantic Ocean and a search is under way near the Brazilian island of Fernando de Noronha. An Air Force spokesman says the search and rescue mission was mounted Monday morning after the jet failed to make regular radio contact.