Afghan runner-up has faith in election fraud panel
KABUL — President Hamid Karzai’s top challenger in Afghanistan’s intensely contested presidential election said Thursday he had faith that a U.N.-backed commission working to root out fraudulent votes would announce a fair decision within days.
Former Foreign Minister Abdullah Abdullah stopped short of saying he would accept its results, however, and expressed concern over the commission’s methodology. But “we have to have faith in something,” he said.
The U.N.-backed Electoral Complaints Commission, which is tasked with determining how many fraudulent votes to toss out, could release its finding as early as Saturday. The nation’s main electoral body would then announce whether Abdullah will face Karzai in a runoff, which would have to be held within two weeks.
Uncertainty over the election outcome has eaten away at Karzai’s legitimacy, leaving Afghanistan in limbo as the Taliban-led insurgency in the countryside deepens and the Obama administration debates its strategy in a war that has become increasingly unpopular in the U.S.
“While the international community is reviewing its policy, it’s crucial that the process end with an outcome which leads to a legitimate government which could be a partner for the international community … and deal with the challenges which are ahead of it,” Abdullah told reporters on the lawn of his home in Kabul.
Abdullah’s camp believes a runoff is imminent. Karzai spokesman Waheed Omar said Thursday he expected otherwise.
“If that process remains technical, remains transparent and remains accountable, we do not see a chance for the elections to go to a second round,” Omar said. He said he based his comment on reports from Karzai representatives who observed the opening and examining of ballot boxes.
Preliminary results show Karzai won re-election with about 54.6 percent of the vote, but the commission could discard enough fraudulent ballots to drop his tally below 50 percent and force a second round.
Both candidates rejected rumors that they might agree to some sort of power-sharing deal or coalition government rather than risk a runoff that will likely be plagued by more violence and could be hampered in the north by winter snow that cuts off mountain villages.
A U.N. spokesman in Kabul also dismissed the idea that alternatives to a runoff were being pushed by the international community.
“We are meeting with the candidates and their campaign teams regularly, but this is part of our efforts to keep them updated on progress with the elections, and any future government will be decided by the winning candidates and not anybody from the international community,” Aleem Siddique said.
The top U.N. official in Afghanistan has acknowledged “widespread fraud” occurred in the Aug. 20 poll. On Monday, the Canadian head of the complaints commission, Grant Kippen, said his panel had misinterpreted the statistical analysis used to determine what percentage of votes would be voided if fraudulent, but said the confusion had not affected the process, only “people’s perception” of it.
“That formula has come under a lot of question,” Abdullah said. But “in spite of all this we still have faith.”
The election dispute is taking place against the backdrop of rising violence.
On Thursday, Afghan and NATO forces clashed with militants in eastern Afghanistan, killing several insurgents, U.S. military and provincial officials said.
The Zabul provincial police chief, Abdul Rahman Surjung, said 14 militants were killed in Zabul province’s Bahar district and another eight in Argandab district overnight.
A U.S. forces spokeswoman confirmed the Bahar fighting and another battle in Wardak province, both sparked when the joint Afghan-NATO forces came under fire while searching for Taliban commanders. Capt. Regina Gillis said fewer than 10 militants were killed in the two operations.
An Italian soldier died Thursday from wounds sustained when his vehicle tipped over while traveling on an unstable road, the Italian military said. Two other soldiers on board were bruised in the accident near Herat in the west.
Meanwhile, Italy and NATO on Thursday denied a newspaper report that Italian intelligence secretly paid the Taliban thousands of dollars to maintain peace in an area in Afghanistan that was under Italian control.
Premier Silvio Berlusconi’s office called the report in the Times of London “completely groundless.” The Italian defense minister denounced it as “rubbish” and said he wanted to sue the newspaper.
In Kabul, a U.S. spokesman for NATO forces in Afghanistan denied the allegations. “We don’t do bribes,” Col. Wayne Shanks said. “We don’t pay the insurgents.”
The Times reported that Italy had paid “tens of thousands of dollars” to Taliban commanders and warlords in the Surobi district, east of the capital, Kabul. The newspaper cited Western military officials, including high-ranking officers at NATO, speaking on condition of anonymity.
Associated Press writers Rahim Faiez and Heidi Vogt in Kabul and Noor Khan in Kandahar, and Alessandra Rizzo in Rome contributed to this report.
Related News
Afghan candidate Abdullah says he has faith in UN-backed fraud panelOctober 15th, 2009 Afghan candidate says he has faith in fraud panelKABUL — The runner-up in Afghanistan's unsettled presidential election said Thursday that he has faith in a U.N.-backed panel that is trying to determine whether there are enough fraudulent votes to force a runoff. But Abdullah Abdullah stopped short of saying he would accept its results.
Karzai questions credibility of UN vote fraud panelOctober 14th, 2009 KABUL - Afghanistan President Hamid Karzai has expressed concern about the investigation into election fraud in Afghanistan. In an interview on US TV, the BBC quoted Karzai, as saying that the resignation of an Afghan member of the UN-backed panel "cast serious doubt" on its work.
Afghan president rejects resignation of fraud investigator in disputed voteOctober 14th, 2009 Afghan election official blocked from resigningKABUL — The Afghan president says he has rejected the resignation of a top fraud investigator in the country's disputed August election. The official said Monday that he was leaving because foreigners were making all the decisions on the U.N.-backed panel.
Member of UN-backed panel investigating Afghan election resignsOctober 12th, 2009 Afghanistan: UN-backed fraud panel member resignsKABUL — A member of a U.N.-backed panel set up to investigate fraud complaints in Afghanistan's presidential election resigned Monday, blaming what he called "the interference of foreigners" and dealing another blow to a vote already mired in controversy. The fraud panel is expected to decide this week whether to throw out enough votes to force a runoff between President Hamid Karzai and his top challenger, Abdullah Abdullah.
Afghan fraud investigators to recount only a sample of suspect ballots to speed processSeptember 21st, 2009 Afghan fraud panel to use sampling in recountsKABUL — The U.N.-backed panel investigating fraud in Afghanistan's presidential vote has agreed to allow a recount of just a sampling of hundreds of thousands of suspect ballots to speed a process some fear could stretch into spring, an official said Monday. Preliminary results from the Aug.
CIA director tells Voice of America: Karzai appears to have won Afghan electionSeptember 18th, 2009 CIA director: Karzai appears to have wonWASHINGTON — CIA Director Leon Panetta says Afghan President Hamid Karzai appears to have won re-election despite charges of fraud and corruption in the vote. Panetta said in an interview with Voice of America radio taped Wednesday that Karzai appears to have enough votes to carry the election even after fraudulent votes are eliminated.
EU renews call for Afghan vote fraud probeSeptember 10th, 2009 STOCKHOLM - The European Union Thursday said it backed a complete investigation into "allegations of fraud" in connection with the recent presidential elections in Afghanistan. The EU said it supported the work by the UN-backed Election Complaints Commission ECC to "safeguard the credibility of the elections," the statement issued by Sweden, which currently holds the EU's rotating presidency, said.
AP Interview: Abdullah says scale of fraud in Afghan election only now becoming clearSeptember 10th, 2009 Abdullah: Afghan vote "state-engineered" fraudKABUL — The top challenger to President Hamid Karzai told The Associated Press on Thursday that the scale of cheating in Afghanistan's Aug. 20 election is only now becoming clear, and that he expects enough fraudulent Karzai votes to be thrown out to trigger a runoff.
Afghan election commission favours Karzai, says AbdullahSeptember 10th, 2009 KABUL - Abdullah Abdullah, the main challenger to President Hamid Karzai in the Afghan presidential election, Thursday accused the country's election commission of corruption and bias towards the incumbent. In an interview with the BBC, the former foreign minister accused Karzai of fraud, saying the election was stolen from the Afghan people.
Karzai hails Afghan election resultsSeptember 9th, 2009 KABUL - Afghan President Hamid Karzai Wednesday welcomed the partial election results announced by the Independent Elections Commission, ignoring reports of "clear proof" of fraud by a UN-backed commission. Karzai congratulated Afghan voters for going to the polls despite Taliban intimidation.
Karzai has 54 pct in Afghan vote, passing threshold for outright victory, amid fraud claimsSeptember 8th, 2009 Karzai has 54 pct in Afghan of fraud-tainted voteKABUL — President Hamid Karzai surpassed for the first time the 50 percent threshold needed to avoid a run-off in Afghanistan's presidential election, according to preliminary results released Tuesday, but with fraud allegations rising, a U.N.-backed commission ordered a re-count of tainted ballots. The chief electoral officer of the Afghan-run Independent Election Commission, Daoud Ali Najafi, said that recounting votes could take "two or three months," meaning the already over-extended election is likely far from over.
Karzai has 54 pct in Afghan vote, passing key threshold, but concerns grow over fraudSeptember 8th, 2009 Karzai has 54 pct of Afghan vote amid fraud claimsKABUL — President Hamid Karzai surpassed for the first time the 50 percent threshold needed to avoid a run-off in Afghanistan's presidential election, according to preliminary results released Tuesday, but with fraud allegations rising, a U.N.-backed commission ordered a re-count of tainted ballots. The chief electoral officer of the Afghan-run Independent Election Commission, Daoud Ali Najafi, said that recounting votes could take "two or three months," meaning the already over-extended election is likely far from over.
Karzai creeps closer to 50 percent in Afghan vote; Abdullah far behind at 30 percentSeptember 6th, 2009 Karzai edges closer to 50 percent in Afghan voteKABUL — President Hamid Karzai nudged closer to the 50 percent threshold needed to avoid a runoff in Afghanistan's election, according to the latest results released Sunday. The Aug. 20 ballot has been marred by accusations of vote-rigging and election officials said they threw out results from 447 out of more than 26,000 polling sites because of fraud allegations.
Votes thrown out at 447 Afghan polling sites; Karzai closer to 50 percent in election tallySeptember 6th, 2009 Votes thrown out at 447 Afghan polling sitesKABUL — Afghan election officials say they have thrown out votes at 447 voting sites across the country because of fraud allegations. The head of the Independent Election Commission Daoud Ali Najafi couldn't say how many votes are affected.
Karzai increases lead to 46 percent in Afghan vote countAugust 29th, 2009 Karzai increases lead to 46 pct in Afghan electionKABUL — President Hamid Karzai widened his lead in Afghanistan's presidential race as new vote tallies were released Saturday, inching closer to the 50 percent threshold of votes he needs to avoid a run-off. As Afghanistan's Independent Election Commission slowly releases partial results from the Aug.