NEW DELHI - Two Delhi-based advocates have moved the Supreme Court to challenge the international luxury pen manufacturer Mont Blanc that is using Mahatma Gandhi as its poster boy to sell its newly launched “limited edition pens” worth Rs.1.2 million each.
Advocates Harsh Vardhan Surana and Sandeep Singh have moved the apex court to restrain Mont Blanc from commercially exploiting “the most respected face of India, that of the father of the nation”, for a cause linked to “luxury”, which he fought against all his life.
The lawsuit objecting to the commercial exploitation of Gandhi’s visage will be heard by the Supreme Court Dec 7. The lawsuit was filed Monday evening.
Mont Blanc has launched two types of fountain pens — Limited Edition 241 and Limited Edition 3,000. The pens have 18 karat gold nibs and carry the engravings of Mahatma Gandhi walking.
The pens also have a fine gold wire entwined by hand on the middle of their “white gold barrel bodies”, according to a Mont Blanc catalogue annexed to the lawsuit.
The catalogue added that the manufacturer would produce 241 pens under its Limited Edition 241 category. The number 241 symbolises the miles travelled by Gandhi during his famous 1930 Dandi march.
The catalogue said Mont Blanc would produce an additional 3,000 fountain pens and roller ball pens under its Limited Edition 3,000. The catalogue did not explain the symbolism of 3,000 if any.
In their joint lawsuit, Surana and Singh have dubbed the move as an “attempt by some money-minded people to misuse the greatness of the father of the nation by using him as a poster boy for commercial gains under the pretext that they are honouring him”.
The two advocates, in their lawsuit, pointed out that the use of Mahatma Gandhi as a poster boy for commercial gain violates section 3 of the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950, as per which no person for the purpose of any trade or business can use the name or emblem specified in a scheduled list annexed with the 1950 Act.
The lawsuit further pointed out that “entry 9A” mentions the name and picture of Mahatma Gandhi as items, which have been prohibited from use for commercial exploitation.
Accusing the international pen manufacturer of hurting the feelings and emotions of over a billion Indians, the lawsuit said that the firm is using Gandhi’s greatness for its selfish gains.
The lawsuit has also challenged Mahatma Gandhi’s great-grandson Tushar Gandhi’s reported decision to allow Mont Blanc to allegedly use Gandhi’s name.
“Mahatma Gandhi is a symbol of simplicity and making him a poster boy for a lavish and luxurious product is against his very spirit and ideology, which he fought for all his life,” said Singh in the lawsuit.
Citing a May 1931 instance, the two advocates pointed out in the lawsuit that Gandhi himself was against the commercial exploitation of any facet of his personality.
The advocates said Gandhi, in response to a plea by a roof tiles’ manufacturer to use his portrait on the tiles, wrote back in May 1931: “I have no copyrights on my portraits, but I am unable to give the consent you require”.
“Much against his wishes, the same thing is happening now and a move is on to commercially exploit his portrait,” said the lawsuit, pleading to the court to stop Mont Blanc from doing this to Gandhi.
Related News
NYC groups, officials sue state agency to block project that includes Nets basketball arenaNovember 19th, 2009 NYC groups sue to block deal for Nets arenaNEW YORK — Opponents of the Brooklyn arena planned for the New Jersey Nets have filed a lawsuit seeking to overturn a state agency's approval of a modified plan for the project. The lawsuit was filed Thursday in Manhattan state Supreme Court.
Anti-Sikh riots: Court allows examination of Tytler CDOctober 31st, 2009 NEW DELHI - A city court Saturday allowed the counsel of the 1984 anti-Sikh riots victims to examine the CD in which Congress leader Jagdish Tytler has been shown standing next to the body of former prime minister Indira Gandhi. Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Rakesh Pandit asked the counsel for the victims' association to examine the eight CDs in the court Nov 16.
PETA honours Khadi commission for shunning catapult salesOctober 30th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Animal rights group People for Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) Friday announced an award to honour the Khadi and Village Industries Commission that accepted their plea to to stop selling catapaults "used by kids to harm animals". PETA India was delighted to hear that the Khadi has recommended a ban on catapults, or slingshots - which are popular but very destructive weapons.
Northeast students find supporter in Rahul GandhiOctober 29th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Congress general secretary Rahul Gandhi Thursday said he will fully cooperate with the students' union in its efforts to check the rising instances of crime against women and men from the northeastern states. Pali Gongo, co-convener of the Northeast Students Union, said: "We went to meet Rahul Gandhi today (Thursday) to seek his support in fighting the rising crime against the northeastern community.
Bofors case: Court defers order on dropping Quattrocchi's nameOctober 24th, 2009 NEW DELHI - A city court Saturday deferred its order on the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) plea to withdraw italian businessman Ottavio Quattrocchi's name from the Bofors gun deal payoff case. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Kaveri Baweja deferred the order to Nov 6 on whether the CBI's application under section 321 of the criminal procedure code (CrPC) should be accepted.
Verdict in Montana lawsuit against drug maker Zometa could have national significanceOctober 19th, 2009 Trial begins in lawsuit against maker of ZometaMISSOULA, Mont. — A trial is under way in a Montana woman's lawsuit against Swiss drug maker Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp., and attorneys say the verdict could have national significance.
Government faces lawsuit seeking billions in unclaimed bonds dating back to World War IIOctober 18th, 2009 Billions in unclaimed bonds date to World War IIHELENA, Mont. — The federal government is facing a lawsuit over billions in unclaimed bonds that date back to the patriotic fundraising efforts of World War II, leading to a showdown between states who say they should be given the money and a Treasury Department that claims ownership.
Lawyers for Obama poster artist Shepard Fairey say he misled themOctober 16th, 2009 Lawyers for Obama poster artist say he misled themNEW YORK — Attorneys for poster artist Shepard Fairey, who designed the famous Obama "HOPE" image, say he based it on a photograph taken by The Associated Press and not another picture, as the artist had claimed. In papers filed Friday in federal court in Manhattan, Fairey's attorneys said they had amended their lawsuit against the AP, which had alleged copyright infringement.
Court reserves order on CBI's plea on QuattrocchiOctober 9th, 2009 NEW DELHI - A city court Friday reserved its order on the plea of Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) seeking withdrawal of Italian businessman Ottavio Quattrocchi's name from the Bofors gun deal pay off case. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Kaveri Baweja reserved the order for Oct 24 to clear whether CBI's application under Section 321 of Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) should be accepted or not.
Andhra to release 950 lifers on Gandhi JayantiOctober 1st, 2009 HYDERABAD - The Andhra Pradesh government Thursday ordered the release of 950 prisoners who are serving life imprisonment in various jails across the state. State Home Minister P.
Mahatma's dream lives on in NepalOctober 1st, 2009 KATHMANDU - Sixty-one years after he died, Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi's dream of self-reliance lives on in Nepal. The spinning wheel that became one of the integral symbols associated with the man known as the father of the nation in India has created one of Nepal's best known handicraft centres, thronged by foreign tourists for its exquisite pottery, textiles and metal knickknacks.
Rajiv Gandhi assassins continue protest fastSeptember 22nd, 2009 CHENNAI - S. Nalini and Robert Payas, in prison for the 1991 killing of former Indian prime minister Rajiv Gandhi, Tuesday continued their fast demanding their immediate release.
Rajiv Gandhi assassin starts fast to demand releaseSeptember 21st, 2009 CHENNAI - S. Nalini, undergoing life imprisonment in the Vellore jail for her involvement in the assassination of former Indian prime minister Rajiv Gandhi, began an indefinite fast Monday to demand her immediate release, officials said.
Rajiv Gandhi assassin Nalini starts fast to demand releaseSeptember 21st, 2009 CHENNAI - S. Nalini, undergoing life imprisonment in the Vellore jail for her involvement in the assassination of former Indian prime minister Rajiv Gandhi, Monday started a fast to demand her immediate release from jail.
Police register case against Maneka GandhiSeptember 17th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The Delhi Police have booked animal rights activist and Bharatiya Janata Party MP Maneka Gandhi and her NGO for allegedly restraining a pet shop owner from running his business. The Delhi Police have registered a case against Maneka Gandhi and the PFA (People For Animals) under section 451 (trespassing) and 34 (acts done by several people in common intention) of the Indian Penal Code, Imtiaz Ahmed, counsel for the pet shop owner Ashok Pratap Rai, said.