NEW YORK - More than 100 non-governmental organisations Thursday protested attempts by some governments to push through a UN resolution to save religion from defamation.
Those NGOs said such a move, if it leads to a binding UN resolution, could give states more reasons to adopt new domestic laws clamping down on human rights and freedom of expression.
The UN General Assembly’s human rights committee was considering a draft resolution put forward by Syria, Venezuela and Belarus asking the UN to oppose the “negative stereotyping of religions”.
The draft raises “deep concern” that racial and religious profiling have continued against certain groups of people and that Muslim minorities remain the target of attacks following the Sep 11, 2001 terrorist attacks against the US.
The draft calls on the UN to oppose “manifestations of intolerance and discrimination in matters of religions or belief still evident in the world”.
It would condemn “all acts of psychological and physical violence and assaults” on people on the basis of their religion or belief.
NGOs from 20 countries joined the protest, including Freedom House, the Centre for Democracy and Human Rights in Saudi Arabia, the Anti-Defamation League, UN Watch and the American Jewish Congress.
They said the UN was trying to create a new legal mechanism to fight “incitement to racial and religious hatred” and was making the mechanism binding on states.
Freedom House said such a resolution is “incompatible with the fundamental freedoms of individuals to freely exercise and peacefully express their thoughts, ideas and beliefs”.
Freedom House and the NGOs that signed the petition against the UN debate warned that governments could use the UN resolution to make domestic laws against blasphemy and to punish peaceful expression against political and religious beliefs and ideas.
The NGOs said existing international legal instruments already deal with problems arising from discrimination, personal defamation and incitement in ways that do not violate freedom of expression and of religion.
“It is vitally important for governments to combat violence motivated by bias and hatred and to encourage respectful speech and civil dialogue, while at the same time affirming that freedoms of expression and freedom of thought, conscience and religion, are integral to the health of free societies and the dignity of the human person,” the NGOs said.
The US Commission on International Religious Freedom in Washington called the UN debate a dangerous idea of protecting religions from defamation.
It said the Organisation of Islamic Countries (OIC) has been pushing through the UN system “the problematic idea” of new legislation against “defamation of religion”. It warned it could provide justification for governments to restrict freedoms of religion and expression.
Hillel Heuer, executive director of UN Watch, a Geneva-based human rights group, said the draft is “the latest salvo in a pervasive campaign waged by Islamic states at the UN to declare that the primary victim of the Sep 11, 2001 terrorist attacks was Islam”.
“In fact, the victims were some 3,000 Americans and others, and those who perpetrated the mass murder acted in the name of a radical Islamist ideology,” Neuer said in a statement.
Related News
Civil society groups to protest proposed amendments to RTINovember 10th, 2009 NEW DELHI - The National Campaign for People's Right to Information (NCPRI) along with other civil society groups has charged the government with planning to "emasculate" the Right to Information (RTI) Act by bringing in amendments and is organising a day-long protest here Saturday against the alleged move. RTI activists have alleged that the government is planning to weaken the RTI Act by bringing in amendments such as introduction of an exemption for "vexatious and frivolous" applications and excluding "discussion/ consultations that take place before arriving at a decision.
Tribals demand their rights as PM talks of their developmentNovember 4th, 2009 NEW DELHI - Even as the prime minister Wednesday emphasised on equitable growth and guaranteeing legitimate rights of tribals, members of various tribes staged a protest in the capital demanding their right over forest land. The central government claims that it cares about the rights of adivasis (tribals) and forest dwellers and it wishes to provide them development.
NE Pa. newspaper wins new trial after $3.5M defamation verdict issued by since-arrested judgeNovember 4th, 2009 NE Pa. paper wins new trial in defamation caseHARRISBURG, Pa. — Pennsylvania's high court says the role of two accused judges in a $3.5 million defamation award against The Citizens' Voice of Wilkes-Barre warrants a new trial.
Australian lawmaker for debate on Muslim immigrationOctober 29th, 2009 SYDNEY - Member of Parliament Kevin Andrews Thursday called for a national debate on whether Muslim immigration to Australia should be curbed. Andrews, immigration minister in the conservative government defeated two years ago, said Muslims were the first migrant group not to assimilate and to congregate in certain suburbs of big cities.
PETA activists stage protest against leather fair in DelhiOctober 23rd, 2009 NEW DELHI - Wearing body suits splattered in red and masks of a cow and a horse, activists of an animal rights group painted a gory picture of animal slaughter to protest the international leather fair that begun in the capital Friday. Talking about the protest, Akraprava Bhar, one of the organisers of the protest, said their aim was to sensitise people about animal cruelty and to raise awareness that leather is dead skin.
As Obama weighs immigration overhaul, US and foreign workers agree: guest worker visas abusedOctober 21st, 2009 US workers, immigrants unite vs. work visa programNASHVILLE — A dozen U.S.
Court asks Press Council to frame guidelines for mediaOctober 21st, 2009 NEW DELHI - Taking a serious view of reporting by media in criminal cases, the Delhi High Court Wednesday asked the Press Council of India (PCI) to form guidelines for fair coverage of sensitive issues. The court passed the order on a public interest petition filed by an NGO, Act Now For Harmony and Democracy, seeking action against the police officials for allegedly leaking to the media confessional statements made before them by suspected terrorists in Batla House gun battle case, in which two terrorists and a Delhi Police inspector were killed Sep 19 last year.
Protests mount as BBC invites anti-immigration leaderOctober 21st, 2009 LONDON - Anti-racist campaigners prepared to stage a demonstration outside the television studios of the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) Thursday over its controversial plans to host the leader of an anti-immigration party on a popular current affairs show. Trade unions, Nazi holocaust survivors, politicians, anti-apartheid veterans and students were set to join campaigners against racism and fascism at the BBC's West London television studios to protest the inclusion of British National Party (BNP) leader Nick Griffin on the panel of Question Time.
Future of battle over Google settlement to be mapped out at NY court hearingOctober 7th, 2009 Google book debate back to the drawing boardNEW YORK — Lawyers on both sides are poised to continue their court battle over Google Inc.'s effort to get digital rights to millions of out-of-print books. A hearing is set for Wednesday in Manhattan federal court.
Kerala magistrate issues arrest warrant against CM AcchuthanandanOctober 6th, 2009 CHERTHALA - A judicial court issued an arrest warrant against Kerala Chief Minister V S Achuthanandan on Tuesday in connection with a defamation case filed against the news paper Deshabhimani. Desabhimani is the mouth peace of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) Kerala unit and Achuthnandan, was the editor in chief of the paper in 2004.
Court slaps fine on Medha PatkarSeptember 14th, 2009 NEW DELHI - A city court Monday rejected Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA) leader Medha Patkar's plea to allow her not to appear in the court and also imposed a fine of Rs.500 on her. Patkar is facing two cases of criminal defamation.
Malaysian Indian sues officials over LTTE link chargeSeptember 11th, 2009 KUALA LUMPUR - Firmly denying any links with Sri Lanka's Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), a Malaysian Indian legislator Friday sued senior government officials for defamation. M. Manoharan, a legislator from Kota Alam Shah in Selangor state and a former legal advisor of the now-banned Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) said neither he nor any of the other Hindraf leaders had links with the Tamil Tigers.
Amendment to Goa Panchayati Raj Act to be scrutinised: officialSeptember 10th, 2009 PANAJI - The Goa law commission will study the state government's controversial amendment to the Goa Panchayati Raj Act, which has faced vehement opposition from civil society groups and panchayats throughout the state, an official said Thursday. Commission chairman Ramakant Khalap told IANS that prima facie the amendment's ability to bypass the elected body of the panchayat, allowing a panchayat secretary to execute orders, warranted scrutiny.
Environmental groups say they'll sue to stop uranium mine near Grand Canyon from reopeningSeptember 8th, 2009 Groups say they'll sue to stop Grand Canyon mineFLAGSTAFF, Ariz. — Environmental groups have given notice that they'll sue the federal Bureau of Land Management over its decision to allow a uranium mine to reopen near the Grand Canyon.
Madhya Pradesh's prayer order to be challengedSeptember 5th, 2009 BHOPAL - A group of socio-cultural organisations in Madhya Pradesh Saturday said they would file a petition in the high court demanding that the compulsory recitation of 'bhojan mantra' prayers before the mid-day meal in schools be immediately stopped. The decision came after the groups failed to get an appointment from state Education Minister Archana Chitnis to discuss the issue.