Ontario files suit against tobacco industry
TORONTO — The Canadian province of Ontario said Tuesday it is suing the tobacco industry in a bid to recover billions of dollars in smoking-related health care costs.
The lawsuit seeks 50 billion Canadian dollars ($46 billion) from a dozen Canadian companies and their corporate parents.
Ontario Attorney General Chris Bentley said the figure represents an estimate of the costs of treating illnesses directly tied to tobacco from 1955 until now.
The claim follows similar actions by the provinces of British Columbia and New Brunswick, as well as in the U.S. and elsewhere.
Among those named in the suit is Canada’s largest tobacco manufacturer, Imperial Tobacco Co., a unit of British American Tobacco of London that sells cigarettes under brands including du Maurier and Player’s.
Imperial spokesman Eric Gagnon suggested the Ontario government was being hypocritical.
“They’re collecting billions of dollars in taxes (on tobacco products), and right now they are turning and suing the tobacco companies,” Gagnon said. “This is a legal product and we do it in the way the government dictates us to do it.”
The lawsuit alleges the companies have long known cigarettes are addictive, and that active and passive smoking can cause diseases such as lung cancer. It also accuses the companies of conspiring to mislead the public about the dangers of smoking, suppressing evidence of its risks, and failing to take proper care to stop adolescents from smoking.
Ontario, Canada’s most populous province with over 12 million residents, says tobacco-related illnesses cost the health care system more than 1.6 billion Canadian dollars per year. Tobacco use accounts for the deaths of about 13,000 Ontario residents each year, or 36 deaths per day, and almost 500,000 hospital days annually, it says.
In 1998, 46 U.S. states settled a lawsuit against the tobacco industry for $206 billion, payable over 25 years, for health care costs and anti-smoking campaigns. Four other states settled separately for a total of $40 billion.
Last month, a Los Angeles jury recommended that Philip Morris USA pay $13.8 million in punitive damages to the daughter of a longtime smoker who died of lung cancer.
Related News
Northeast dairy farmers sue milk handlers over "monopolization, price-fixing"October 9th, 2009 Northeast dairy farmers sue milk handlersMONTPELIER, Vt. — A group of dairy farmers is suing four milk marketing firms, saying they've engaged in monopolizing the market into which farmers have had to sell milk, fixed prices and created an economic crisis in the Northeast dairy industry.
NJ man sues PNC Bank citing 'abusive' overdraft fee policyOctober 9th, 2009 PNC Bank sued over overdraft fee policyTRENTON, N.J. — A New Jersey man is suing PNC Bank, accusing it of violating the state's consumer fraud act by using abusive overdraft policies.
La. jury rules in favor of plaintiff in Electrochem suit, awards $21.7 million in damagesOctober 8th, 2009 Plaintiff wins Electrochem suit, awarded damagesCLARENCE, N.Y. — Electrochem Solutions Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of medical components maker Greatbatch Inc., said Thursday a Louisiana jury found in favor of a plaintiff in a suit against the unit and awarded damages of $21.7 million for lost profit.
Wisc. woman settles suit against companies over 2006 spinach outbreak that almost killed herOctober 7th, 2009 Wisc. woman settles suit in 2006 spinach outbreakSALINAS, Calif. — An 85-year-old woman who fell sick after eating E.
55 members, associates of Pagans Motorcycle Club accused of plotting to kill, extort rivalsOctober 6th, 2009 Feds: Biker gang plotted to kill, extort rivalsCHARLESTON, W.Va. — National Pagans Motorcycle Club leaders and more than 50 members and associates of the outlaw biker gang are accused of plotting to kill and extort rivals to consolidate the club's power in the eastern U.S., according to an indictment unsealed Tuesday.
Madoff trustee seeks $7B from Fla. philanthropist, accuses him of trying to avoid blameOctober 1st, 2009 Madoff trustee seeks $7B from Fla. philanthropistNEW YORK — A trustee recovering Bernard Madoff's assets for jilted investors has labeled a Florida philanthropist as the biggest beneficiary of Madoff's multibillion-dollar fraud and demanded he return more than $7 billion in bogus profits, his lawyers say.
Ontario files suit against tobacco manufacturersSeptember 30th, 2009 Ontario files suit against tobaccoTORONTO — The Canadian province of Ontario has become the latest jurisdiction to launch a lawsuit to recover smoking-related health costs from the tobacco industry. The suit seeks $50 billion Canadian (US$46 billion) from a dozen Canadian firms and their parent companies.
Boston Scientific will pay $716.3M to J&J in settlement that resolves 14 patent lawsuitsSeptember 30th, 2009 Boston Scientific will pay J&J $716M in stent suitNEW YORK — Boston Scientific Corp. said Tuesday it will pay Johnson & Johnson $716.3 million to settle 14 patent infringement lawsuits related to the use of stents in treating heart disease.
Marine widow cleared of murdering husband files federal civil lawsuitSeptember 24th, 2009 Marine widow cleared of killing husband files suitSAN DIEGO — A widow cleared of murdering her Marine husband has filed a $20 million lawsuit in San Diego, alleging her constitutional and civil rights were violated. The suit, filed Thursday in U.S.
Int'l Trade Commission to stop illegal Internet imports of counterfeit Marlboro cigarettesSeptember 24th, 2009 Int'l Trade Comm. stops import of fake cigarettesRICHMOND, Va.
Skype founders file another suit that could complicate eBay's plans to sell Web phone serviceSeptember 18th, 2009 Skype founders file suit against Skype buyerSAN FRANCISCO — The founders of Internet phone service Skype have filed another lawsuit that may put a wrench in eBay Inc.'s plan to sell Skype for $2 billion to a private investor group. In a lawsuit filed Friday in a Delaware state court, Joost N.V.
Maker's Mark: Seeing red over red wax seal on tequila bottles, claims trademark infringementSeptember 11th, 2009 Maker's Mark: Seeing red over wax seal on tequilaLOUISVILLE, Ky. — Maker's Mark Distillery, famous for the distinctive wax seal atop its Kentucky bourbon, is seeing red over what it considers a trademark infringement by some liquor competitors.
Canadian politician behind road-rage death banned from drivingSeptember 5th, 2009 TORONTO - A top Canadian politician, who was charged in the killing of a cyclist in road rage in the heart of Toronto, has been banned from driving and ordered to deposit his passport with the police. Michael Bryant, who till May served as the attorney-general in Canada's most powerful province of Ontario, spent Monday night in police custody after causing the death of 33-year-old cyclist Darcy Allan Sheppard.
Jail term for not showing pictorial warnings on cigarette packsSeptember 2nd, 2009 NEW DELHI - The union health ministry Wednesday warned tobacco producers that they could face jail terms up to two years for the fist offence and for up to five years subsequently if their cigarette packs do not carry pictorial warning or have it in less than the prescribed 40 percent of space. It may also be brought to notice of the public that violation of the law by the tobacco manufacturers is a punishable offence with imprisonment which may extend to two years or with fine which may extend to Rs.5,000, or with both, a ministry statement said.
Facebook gets notice for tobacco promotionSeptember 1st, 2009 CHANDIGARH - Popular social networking website Facebook has been caught in a 'smoky' row. An anti-tobacco activist here has served a notice to the website, accusing it of "promotion of smoking culture" through its web pages.
